It is really hard to nail down a best XI.
Right now, I think you have to start Payne, Boxall, Cacace, Stamenic, Bell, Singh, Wood & Garbett.
You then add one of Crocombe/Paulsen and one of Bindon/Surman.
That leaves one spot, which you could make a case for any of McCowatt, Old, Kosta, Waine & Just (with Rojas almost certain to be added to this conversation in June). For me it's a toss-up between McCowatt, Kosta & Old right now.
What is interesting to me is there is only one player who is undisputedly in our best starting XI & will be for years to come and that's Cacace. Wood & Boxall would be but for their advanced age, fingers crossed but you just don't know when they'll start to lose the battle against time. Bell has been in an extended form slump, maybe he never gets out of it? He along with Stamenic, Garbett & Singh could be nailed on starters for years to come but they haven't quite established themselves properly at club level. Payne needs to do well to keep the likes of Kirwan & Elliot at bay (I don't see Ingham as genuine competition and while Roux should be in the conversation it seems Bazeley just doesn't like him).
In short there is going to be no shortage of discussion on this topic in coming years.