My thoughts
**Disclaimer** I didn't see anything after the goal.
I thought it was good that Ricki played the formation he did. I don't think he would have gotten the answers from the midfield he was looking for but then thats what this is about. At times, they looked mobile, quick, nice passes and at other times, all at sea and I guess thats what comes when you have not played together in how long.
I think if he is looking at a back 3 and front 3, at the very least, the pieces he has should show him that is not the way to the play. The 4-2-3-1 looked more comfortable for us than the 3-4-3. I think had we played a 3-4-3 today, we might have been on the other end of a scoreline because I think we would have been split open a lot easier. When you have that front 4 of Kosta, Wee Mac and Rojas and you can pick a striker from Wood or Smeltz then that looks much better than what we have in Saudi and at the very least, makes Brockie redundant and the need for wingbacks. I think the other two midfield spots in front of the back 4 are still very open. I don't think this performance needs to have wrist slitting because of players coming back in and also the fact we won and are (still) experimenting but we also can't slap each other on the back and say we have it sussed. If that was Honduras, we might have been punished more severely.
Players
I thought Winston Reid played like he thought he was the best player on the park, rather than actually being the best player on the park. For a guy that gets talked about as being one of the better CBs in the EPL and looking to be signed by Arsenal, he certainly is not Ryan Nelsen. He looked his usual casual composed self but I think he gets involved in things where as Nelsen was a master of trying not to be involved and even then when he did, he was all about getting others in there and touches here and there when needed. I think while there is no doubt about his talent, his onfield marshalling needs a lot of work and thats the big difference between the former skipper and the current.
Tommy Smith I thought took some odd options and played more long ball than I thought he would. The axis between him and Winston was rusty but to be expected so can't really hang them for that.
Lochhead looked rusty. I think he was better for not having to get forward as much as he had to previously but he needs to get more game time than this. He will still be the best LB in the country if he never plays again for the next 3 months.
Sigmund I thought was not too bad at RB. I'm not a fan of his at all and while he is effective for club, an international footballer I believe he is not. Having said that, I thought he played better at RB today than he has at any other time I have seen him play in that postion. Needs a bit of positional help and is always going to be a long ball merchant, but it was ok compared to other times. That's no to say he is the answer at RB but I'll give him credit for playing better there than any other time he has.
Butler well I don't think he was terrbile, but he is not the answer. He can leave his feet at ASBP level and get away with it. International football will not allow you to do that and everything will be fine. He didn't cough possession up but he also never made a pass forward. Playing back to Winston and Tommy is the wrong choice when he should have been looking to hit James. At least Clapham looks to play forward so I do give AC that much.
Durante got up and down the pitch a lot including covering the Saudi counters. Its harsh to judge him on one game in that position. He made a better fist of it than Killen but I think he got dragged about a bit where as I thought Butler was not dragged about as much. Those two need to slide laterally in front of the back 4 as a unit of 2 and the was not done at all. The Saudis were able to make 30 passes through the space that they should have been patrolling. In that respects, when you see Manny do it for the Nix, thats how it should be done.
Chris James I thought did ok with what he had. I think he probably did not press himself on the game as much as I thought that AM/10 role dictates but then I read an article on the front page where he sees himself as a ball playing holding midfielder now. He had a cracking free kick and I think he can feel satisfied with what he put in.
Jeremy Brockie I thought was a bit invisible but then how often do we say that?
Kosta I thought was industrious although there were times when I was chastising him for taking the option he did. Smarter options would have seen him being the best player on the park.
Chris Wood I have to say I was disapointed with and I am not sure if that is because of the way he played or the expectation of the way I thought he would play.
I think if I was Ricki, for the next game I would want to try this.
Moss
Sigmund, Durante, Reid, Smith
Ivan, James
Kosta Howieson/Clapham Brockie
Wood
(although I expect to see Dura in the holding role again)
I know there are other players in the team but he needs to look at his best players in their best position for the up coming crucial games. If the likes of Bright, Clapham, Bertos don't get a run, I'm not fussed
A win is a win and they can take something from that, but you would hope we see an improvement in the next game.