All Whites V South Africa | 30 May 7:30pm | The Zookeeper's Son | SS3

Marquee
740
·
5.2K
·
almost 17 years
Buffon II wrote:
Lonegunmen wrote:

In Rubgy Union's case there's about 24 countries involved at decent standard and that's not bad but a long way off what football has.


Name these mythical 24 countries you speak of.



IRB World Rankings

Rank Change* Team Points 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Top 25 Rankings as 2 June 2014[1]
New Zealand 93.81
South Africa 89.34
Australia 86.88
England 85.68
Ireland 82.13
Wales 80.70
France 80.07
1 Argentina 76.44
1 Samoa 75.49
Scotland 75.16
Fiji 74.21
1 Japan 73.90
1 Tonga 73.21
Italy 72.05
Canada 70.75
Georgia 70.46
Romania 68.08
United States 67.21
Russia 63.43
Uruguay 61.86
Spain 60.65
Namibia 58.79
Hong Kong 58.47
Portugal 57.73
1 South Korea 57.22


And if you say South Korea or Portugal don't count then you could argue that NZ in football, don't either.
Legend
2.5K
·
17K
·
over 17 years

New Zealand (ranked 1) would put 100 points on anyone from Canada (ranked 15) down.

I doubt you can say the same would happen in football. Nice try, but come back with a different angle.


Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
over 12 years


NZ as a rank outsider and either worst or second worst ranked team at the 2010 WC (I can't remember which) managed a draw against the defending champions. What's the closest a country like Romania, Russia, Georgia, etc has got to beating one of the big boys at the RWC?

 

Marquee
740
·
5.2K
·
almost 17 years
Buffon II wrote:

New Zealand (ranked 1) would put 100 points on anyone from Canada (ranked 15) down.

I doubt you can say the same would happen in football. Nice try, but come back with a different angle.




Sorry I don't see what your argument is? So by your logic with 207 teams ranked in Football, Spain wouldn't comfortably put away Burkina Faso at rank 61? A similar comparison to NZ and Canada in Rugby world rankings.

Who outside of the top twenty of Football would at a tournament put away Spain, Germany or Brazil?

Football is bigger we are all agreed. But Rugby Union for a world sport is hardly a poor one and 4 and a half million people estimated to play club rugby is hardly shabby.
Marquee
740
·
5.2K
·
almost 17 years


NZ as a rank outsider and either worst or second worst ranked team at the 2010 WC (I can't remember which) managed a draw against the defending champions. What's the closest a country like Romania, Russia, Georgia, etc has got to beating one of the big boys at the RWC?

 



You could have said that about Italy a few years ago or Argentina - OK not there yet but certainly getting there.

Or Wales 15 years ago - rubbish. They can compete with most teams these days.
WeeNix
150
·
950
·
about 13 years

So we complain about NZ Football not getting enough media attention......

Open this thread and see the last  3 pages are mainly about Rugby.


Mods take control.

Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
about 17 years

Since the 1987 RWC the following teams have made the semifinals of the tournament: NZ, Australia, Wales, France, Scotland, England, South Africa, Argentina (8 teams in 7 tournaments)

Since the 1986 football WC the following teams have made the semifinals of the tournament: Argentina, Belgium, France, (West) Germany, Italy, England, Bulgaria, Italy, Sweden, Brazil, Netherlands, Croatia, South Korea, Turkey, Portugal, Uruguay, Spain (17 teams in 7 tournaments, or 18 if you consider West Germany and Germany separately)

I think that says something about the relative depth of teams at the tournaments

I like this. 
Also, 25 teams have qualified for the World Cup in its history (there are 20 spots available). Compared with 76 to the football World Cup. 

Marquee
740
·
5.2K
·
almost 17 years

So Rugby Union shouldn't bother having a world tournament then because there are only 5 teams in it? 


Since 1987 the Rugby world cup has been won by 4 teams.

Since 1986 the Football world cup has been won by 6 teams.

Hardly a gulf between the codes. 


Christ If I never had to watch Rugby again it would be no loss but I don't have an issue with other people watching it. 


You never hear of cricket or that god awful Formula 1 being compared to football so whats the problem?

Legend
1.8K
·
22K
·
over 15 years

No one's got an issue with anyone watching eggball.

The issue is that either code struggle to get meaningful world-scale competitions.  13-man egg ball is a farce. 15-man egg ball is so lopsided.

The reason there isn't so much skewness at FIFA WC is that the likes of American Samoa and Myanmar get eliminated in the regional qualifiers early on.

15-man egg ball doesn't have the depth and breadth to do this does it?


Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
over 12 years

There's basically a rivalry between football and rugby in NZ and that's where these squabbles come from. Cricket and F1 fans don't see football as a threat. Football fans don't get harassed by cricket and F1 fans for the sport they follow.

 

edit: not that I really care. It is fun to have a silly pointless rivalry sometimes - kinda like the Nix and ACFC

 

Marquee
970
·
6.5K
·
over 11 years

There's basically a rivalry between football and rugby in NZ and that's where these squabbles come from.

"No soccer fags gonna kick their pill on our footie paddock!"

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
almost 15 years

Pretty much and the reason being is because they don't like that no one gives a shit about rugby anywhere else in the world and that 'soccer' is played by fairy boy poofs.

Marquee
740
·
5.2K
·
almost 17 years

There's basically a rivalry between football and rugby in NZ and that's where these squabbles come from. Cricket and F1 fans don't see football as a threat. Football fans don't get harassed by cricket and F1 fans for the sport they follow.

 

edit: not that I really care. It is fun to have a silly pointless rivalry sometimes - kinda like the Nix and ACFC

 



We have a rivalry between us and ACFC?? That's like Peterboro United being the Rivals of Man City.

Wow with those last few posts you could feel the resentment of the bullied draining away....
Legend
2.5K
·
17K
·
over 17 years
Jeff Vader wrote:

Pretty much and the reason being is because they don't like that no one gives a shit about rugby anywhere else in the world and that 'soccer' is played by fairy boy poofs.


Nah it's taken seriously in 24 countries mate. Show some respect!
Marquee
970
·
6.5K
·
over 11 years

More like between Man U and FC Utd of Manchester.

Marquee
740
·
5.2K
·
almost 17 years
Junior82 wrote:

No one's got an issue with anyone watching eggball.

The issue is that either code struggle to get meaningful world-scale competitions.  13-man egg ball is a farce. 15-man egg ball is so lopsided.

The reason there isn't so much skewness at FIFA WC is that the likes of American Samoa and Myanmar get eliminated in the regional qualifiers early on.

15-man egg ball doesn't have the depth and breadth to do this does it?




But its practically a matter of what 20 years, which is no time in sport, for at least another 4 or 5 teams to become competitive. Also football success is far from Global with it being divvied up between South America and Europe. I think it's still really sad that we've not to seen an African nation lifting the world cup yet.

And you could promote football in say the middle east, somewhere sensible like Qatar maybe.
LG
Legend
5.8K
·
24K
·
almost 17 years
Oska wrote:
Lonegunmen wrote:

Well Junior, if they made the qualifying standard then you have to rightly assume that they indeed were. Sure we know the reality of the situation - again, regardless of the sport, but there are standards that are measured and accepted. Especially with Olympic qualifying. At the end of the day, they appeared.

Chompingchange, in support of yur argument, Kenya springs to mind. They are doing alright on the 7's front.


So why doesn't this logic of yours apply to league?

Because in 7s kenya have achievved notable success as such where as when was the lasrt ti e Feance or Papua New Guinea beaten anyone?
Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
about 17 years
Lonegunmen wrote:
Oska wrote:
Lonegunmen wrote:

Well Junior, if they made the qualifying standard then you have to rightly assume that they indeed were. Sure we know the reality of the situation - again, regardless of the sport, but there are standards that are measured and accepted. Especially with Olympic qualifying. At the end of the day, they appeared.

Chompingchange, in support of yur argument, Kenya springs to mind. They are doing alright on the 7's front.


So why doesn't this logic of yours apply to league?

Because in 7s kenya have achievved notable success as such where as when was the lasrt ti e Feance or Papua New Guinea beaten anyone?

7s isn't rugby. In the same way Futsal isn't football. 
LG
Legend
5.8K
·
24K
·
almost 17 years


NZ as a rank outsider and either worst or second worst ranked team at the 2010 WC (I can't remember which) managed a draw against the defending champions. What's the closest a country like Romania, Russia, Georgia, etc has got to beating one of the big boys at the RWC?

 

in 1981 the All Blacks beat Romania 14-6 and the Romanians had 2 tries disallowed. They have competed in all 7 world cups, won their group at one.


However this now difressed from the original thread but then if someone hadn't questioned me, perhaps it would not have been sidetracked. Job well done by one person.

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
over 12 years
Lonegunmen wrote:


NZ as a rank outsider and either worst or second worst ranked team at the 2010 WC (I can't remember which) managed a draw against the defending champions. What's the closest a country like Romania, Russia, Georgia, etc has got to beating one of the big boys at the RWC?

 

in 1981 the All Blacks beat Romania 14-6 and the Romanians had 2 tries disallowed. They have competed in all 7 world cups, won their group at one.


However this now difressed from the original thread but then if someone hadn't questioned me, perhaps it would not have been sidetracked. Job well done by one person.

Interesting, I had no idea about that! Well-played sir

 

LG
Legend
5.8K
·
24K
·
almost 17 years

Thanks. Someone else suggested earlier about having a triangular tournament like the rugby every season. Us, Aussie and SA. I myself would like to see this. It would help with our gloabl rankings and give our players regular international level football. Other thsn the travel, what other obsticles would there be? Using the international windows would make it feasable surely?

Listen here Fudgeface
3.7K
·
15K
·
over 14 years

Biggest obstacle is there isn't really much benefit to Australia, they are better off playing games against other Asian opponents or against teams ranked higher than them. 

LG
Legend
5.8K
·
24K
·
almost 17 years

Arnt SA ranked up there with them though? Also it gives them game time too.

Starting XI
1K
·
2.3K
·
about 12 years
Lonegunmen wrote:

Arnt SA ranked up there with them though? Also it gives them game time too.

SA are 50-something iirc and from what I've read many people seem to consider that a bit flattering.

 

Legend
2.5K
·
17K
·
over 17 years
Lonegunmen wrote:


NZ as a rank outsider and either worst or second worst ranked team at the 2010 WC (I can't remember which) managed a draw against the defending champions. What's the closest a country like Romania, Russia, Georgia, etc has got to beating one of the big boys at the RWC?

 

in 1981 the All Blacks beat Romania 14-6 and the Romanians had 2 tries disallowed. They have competed in all 7 world cups, won their group at one.


However this now difressed from the original thread but then if someone hadn't questioned me, perhaps it would not have been sidetracked. Job well done by one person.


Romania have never won their group. What utter lies.
Marquee
380
·
9.6K
·
over 17 years

If you did it every year you would get even less than 6,000 people turning up in Auckland. 

LG
Legend
5.8K
·
24K
·
almost 17 years

Sorry, was reading the european nations cup stuff. Nice of you to constantly go after me. Makes me wonder if you are stalking me or not. Still I am sure the big green bunny will tell you to carry on. 

But just to help your general knowledge, did you know that Romania have won 218 of their 377 test played? They have beaten France, Wales and Scotland. Now come on Buffon, come back with another smart remark. I know you actually like me. I find you kind of amusing too. ;) I am sorry I am only human, I know you know everything but one day I may catch you out too.

WeeNix
150
·
950
·
about 13 years

Guys its really important that I am right on the internet.

Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
about 17 years
LG
Legend
5.8K
·
24K
·
almost 17 years

Cheers Tegal. We know France can blow hot and cold but any result against them is surely notable? They also beat Wales.

Phoenix Academy
240
·
360
·
over 10 years
Lonegunmen wrote:

Cheers Tegal. We know France can blow hot and cold but any result against them is surely notable? They also beat Wales.

Just when did this become a rugby forum?

LG
Legend
5.8K
·
24K
·
almost 17 years

Since someone called me up on a point I had made. Sorry about that, I tried to get it back on track until said person started to digress again. 

Legend
1.8K
·
22K
·
over 15 years
ForteanTimes wrote:
Junior82 wrote:

No one's got an issue with anyone watching eggball.

The issue is that either code struggle to get meaningful world-scale competitions.  13-man egg ball is a farce. 15-man egg ball is so lopsided.

The reason there isn't so much skewness at FIFA WC is that the likes of American Samoa and Myanmar get eliminated in the regional qualifiers early on.

15-man egg ball doesn't have the depth and breadth to do this does it?




But its practically a matter of what 20 years, which is no time in sport, for at least another 4 or 5 teams to become competitive. Also football success is far from Global with it being divvied up between South America and Europe. I think it's still really sad that we've not to seen an African nation lifting the world cup yet.

And you could promote football in say the middle east, somewhere sensible like Qatar maybe.
I would say that football success is global. Sth Korea and Japan, Cameroon, Sth Africa all have come a long way in the last couple of decades. Maybe more so than Romania in egg ball union.
LG
Legend
5.8K
·
24K
·
almost 17 years

I agree, so e of the so called lesser count ries have really come on in leaps and bounds. I wonder if any of this is through players running various clinics during their season breaks.

Legend
1.8K
·
22K
·
over 15 years

I think it is because football is better than egg ball.

LG
Legend
5.8K
·
24K
·
almost 17 years

Sorry, I wws referring soley to the improvements within football. 

Legend
1.8K
·
22K
·
over 15 years

I'm just baiting.

#offseason

#sigh

TV
On probation
250
·
4.2K
·
over 13 years
Sydney 'til they fold
31
·
1.8K
·
almost 17 years

Enjoyed the last couple of pages, smurf mirth.

Watched most of the Internet coverage of last week's game & I agree with Smithy's appraisl.


Has Emblen got the job?



Starting XI
2.3K
·
5K
·
about 17 years
MetalLegNZ wrote:

so after the game are we:

A) feeling better about the direction of NZF

B) as pessimistic as ever

C) Just glad Herberts gone.

And the final question, who out of the youner brigade do we think we have the biggest impact on NZ's future fortunes

Rojas Thomas Wood Payne Tuiloma Roux Howieson Ridenton


1st: Wood
2nd: Thomas
3rd: Ridenton

You’ll need an account to join the conversation!

Sign in Sign up