Is he eligible?
Yes he has already played 1 game for NZ a 2-0 loss to Fiji in 2008
Sure - and that's long enough ago that there may have been different regulations in place, but as far as I'm aware, he doesn't meet any of the 4 questions.
except he has played a competition game for NZ so that's it, he can't play or anyone else, doesn't matter what the regs are now
I think it's more the fact that he hasn't been anywhere near the NZ team since 2008, even when Hudson was doing his scattergun selecting and that he's only playing in the Welsh league, which is probably on a par with the SSpremiership, that he shouldn't be selected - just because a player plays outside New Zealand it doesn't make them International quality
sure, but it's not that simple is it, otherwise deklan wynne would have been fine, 'because he'd played for NZ'