Off Topic

Racism in NZ.

111 replies · 3,592 views
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Yet we still have a Maori only national rugby team?
although some of the "maoris" who have participated are from dubious backgrounds.UberGunner2010-05-12 09:48:41
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Hard News wrote:
Children.  Behave.  Or take it to stormfront.
 
I learn so much from these forums (& thanks to goggle)... Now I know what Stormfront means and the other day I discovered the lovely meaning behind don't eat the biscuit lol
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
stealthkiwi wrote:
lol I just took offence to Buffy belittling Robb's opinion simply because he is a supposed uncultured ozzie wether he drinks xxxx or not  normally I'd be quite happy to make digs at australians myself but seemed wrong in a thread about racist behaviour
I'm from NSW, I'd be shot for drinking XXXX  I usually go for Cascade Lager myself.
 
I personally didn't take Buffy's comments as belittling, just a mix of a different opinion and the usual pisstaking.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Yeah, except this time i wasn't taking the piss. If i was i would of left my original comment there and not returned to the thread.

Three for me, and two for them.

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Buffon II wrote:
Yeah, except this time i wasn't taking the piss. If i was i would of left my original comment there and not returned to the thread.
 
ok... but Buffy you haven't actually said what you think should be changed to ensure a more ethnic mix on the team. And apolagies but I have zero idea of what ethnic makeup/nationality you yourself are. I still get confused by wether the countries in people's headers mean that where they are from or where they currently are. I still like my original suggestions months back about it reading Stealthkiwi - F - NZ - Wlg
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
I'm Maori and European.

Three for me, and two for them.

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Well as everyone knows I'm totally lacking in knowledge about football in NZ so have no idea wether there are now more maori kids playing than ten or twenty years ago but hopefully it is evolving and not too far way it will be reflected in national selections
 
Changes do happen. I briefly played football in the late seventies in Hawkes Bay and there were no other females of any age playing at that time but my mother made a huge stink till they let me join a boys team and I played for 2 years and never saw another female player in that time. The same with rowing... whn I started at school there was no female school teams or Mardi Cup but these days both sports have huge female participation
 
Within NZ the small towns with a majority made up of non-whites are likely going to be the last places to switch codes from the traditional rugby. places like Wairoa, Levin and Turangi - I once lived in Turangi for a year and ended up playing rugby myself simply because my first choices of rowing, hockey, football were all unavailable and you cdn't pay me to play netball
stealthkiwi2010-05-12 10:18:39
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Robb wrote:
stealthkiwi wrote:
lol I just took offence to Buffy belittling Robb's opinion simply because he is a supposed uncultured ozzie wether he drinks xxxx or not  normally I'd be quite happy to make digs at australians myself but seemed wrong in a thread about racist behaviour
I'm from NSW, I'd be shot for drinking XXXX  I usually go for Cascade Lager myself.
 
I personally didn't take Buffy's comments as belittling, just a mix of a different opinion and the usual pisstaking.
Tassie beer ftw.


Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Vaguely related to our Boy discussion earlier in the thread this in the herald cracked me up - my breakdancing skills suck jst like the authors
 
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
stealthkiwi wrote:
Hard News wrote:
Children.  Behave.  Or take it to stormfront.
 
I learn so much from these forums (& thanks to goggle)... Now I know what Stormfront means and the other day I discovered the lovely meaning behind don't eat the biscuit lol
Better than learning from experience im sure

Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Buffon II wrote:
It's not racist it's just fact. They have no history of a culture or system of shared beliefs or traditions within their race. Jandals and barbies don't come close to counting as tradition. It's the same with white New Zealanders.


So what's tradition? When does something become tradition? Is there a time limit?
dairyflat2010-05-12 13:49:07
Profile pic. Should you be interested. Lakhsen, on the right, lost touch with him.
Mohammed, on the left, I'm still in touch with. He's now living in Agadez, Niger. More focused on his animals now as tourism has dried up. Is active with a co-op promoting local goods, leather work and bijouterie, into Europe. 
20/5/20

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Tegal wrote:
stealthkiwi wrote:
Hard News wrote:
Children.  Behave.  Or take it to stormfront.
 
I learn so much from these forums (& thanks to goggle)... Now I know what Stormfront means and the other day I discovered the lovely meaning behind don't eat the biscuit lol
Better than learning from experience im sure
 
bugger... now you've got me wondering if I got the correct meaning cause funnily enough I'm not likely to have to learn frm experience as woman don't tend to sit around doing competative jerking where the one with the most staying power ends up losing lol
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
dairyflat wrote:
Buffon II wrote:
It's not racist it's just fact. They have no history of a culture or system of shared beliefs or traditions within their race. Jandals and barbies don't come close to counting as tradition. It's the same with white New Zealanders.


So what's tradition? When does something become tradition? Is there a time limit?
 
Another white NZer? I wouldn't worry about it then, you don't have it.

Three for me, and two for them.

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Buffon II wrote:
dairyflat wrote:
Buffon II wrote:
It's not racist it's just fact. They have no history of a culture or system of shared beliefs or traditions within their race. Jandals and barbies don't come close to counting as tradition. It's the same with white New Zealanders.


So what's tradition? When does something become tradition? Is there a time limit?
 
Another white NZer? I wouldn't worry about it then, you don't have it.

Coming from such an expert.

Immigrating from South Africa to New Zealand you do notice cultural differences, not many and small but there are differences. There would be even more if I was brought up in an Afrikaans family.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Buffon II wrote:
dairyflat wrote:
Buffon II wrote:
It's not racist it's just fact. They have no history of a culture or system of shared beliefs or traditions within their race. Jandals and barbies don't come close to counting as tradition. It's the same with white New Zealanders.


So what's tradition? When does something become tradition? Is there a time limit?
 
Another white NZer? I wouldn't worry about it then, you don't have it.


Better to be (supposedly) lacking tradition than to be a reverse racist...

Buffy I'm quite disappointed in you. Blindly slagging off european/caucasian kiwis is exactly why some of them can't be bothered learning or caring about your own traditions/culture etc and the racism/dislike jst feeds itself back and forth
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Buffon II wrote:
dairyflat wrote:
Buffon II wrote:
It's not racist it's just fact. They have no history of a culture or system of shared beliefs or traditions within their race. Jandals and barbies don't come close to counting as tradition. It's the same with white New Zealanders.


So what's tradition? When does something become tradition? Is there a time limit?
 
Another white NZer? I wouldn't worry about it then, you don't have it.


He's not worried, he's just asking a question. I'd also like to know your answer to it tbh.
 
And yes I'm white, but I'm all right.
kiwi pie2010-05-12 17:37:36
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
White NZ has a very general culture as well as individual ones for the Irish, Welsh, Germans etc who have immigrated.  I'd agree with UG that going to the pub and sports has become a part of our culture.  It's very much different to other cultures where, say, you can't touch a persons head, but it's culture regardless.

Also could you not say that certain things we, as a group, don't do also comes down to culture?
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Buffy, I think that comments like yours are often why Caucasian society can be so cold towards our ethnic minorities - in particular Polynesian and Maori. 
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Buffy, I think that comments like yours are often why Caucasian society can be so cold towards our ethnic minorities - in particular Polynesian and Maori. 


That wouldn't be anything new would it Mr Inc. Pakeha have downtrodden on the Maori people for generations. Only recently has that started to change for the better. When my grandmother was at school she would get the cane for speaking Maori. In her own country, speaking her own language, she got the cane.

But keep being cold, it's not like you owe us anything.

Three for me, and two for them.

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Buffy, I don't disagree with anything you've just said, more the way you've said it.

The way European's have treated Maori has been disgrace. But you don't exactly endear people to you when you treat them the way you are now.

What you've got to remember is that while my ancestors f**ked your people over, that doesn't mean I want to or am going to. So don't treat me like sh*t.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
I'm not treating you like sh*t. I'd rather not speak about it with my white friends as it can only cause disruption and trouble.

I'll probably leave it there then.

Three for me, and two for them.

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Buffon II wrote:
  When my grandmother was at school she would get the cane for speaking Maori. In her own country, speaking her own language, she got the cane.

 
Do you yourself speak maori Buffy? It's been pretty widely available for 30 years now and I'm curious wether you took advantage of the oppurtunities she never had. Even tho I was 100% 'white' I was already fairly fluent by the time I was 10 and I'm only a cpl of years older than you. I lost it in my early twenties and having never much used it since only have basic skills these days
 
 
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
I'm not fluent. I know most common words and phrases. I can comfortably tell people who i am, where i am from, and what my heritage is (family, mountain, river etc). Apart from that i would probably struggle unfortunately.

Three for me, and two for them.

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Buffon II wrote:
I'm not fluent. I know most common words and phrases. I can comfortably tell people who i am, where i am from, and what my heritage is (family, mountain, river etc). Apart from that i would probably struggle unfortunately.
 
Well truthfully thats what I expected. I gave up maori studies at school because was getting A's (as my mother had immersed me in the culture cause she'd gone all femanist/radical) and most maori students at the school didn't speak it at all or bother to take it when available and they resented me and I used to get threatened & just cdn't be bothered putting up with all the wah wah wah woe is me bullsh*t when they were too lazy to correct it
 
The great majority of ethnic races have rights to be aggrieved about incidences from their past. From the scottish and irish to rwandians. Personally I've heard way worse first hand stories about things in the last 20 years done to Serbians and Croats than were done to maori 200 years ago
 
women were once treated like chattel and had zero rights (in their own countries) yet as a female I believe that in this country at least while not yet 100% equal its almost there and I personaly don't believe in things like woman's gym or the Ministry of Womans affairs - i find them sexist and think people who live on the past generations greviances cause themselves more harm than anyone else does
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Hard News wrote:
Buffy's age is a little misleading:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gianluigi_Buffon
 
ok well if he was in his fifties or more than I might think he had a reasonable excuse why he never learnt (not that I think that one has to know the language of ones previous generations). but anything younger esp in the 15-30 age range well immersion schools have been around since the ninties and most state schools have taught it as a subject since the eighties.
 
and since he's often yabbering on about chicks and strippers I always figured him for about 18
stealthkiwi2010-05-13 09:28:06
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
stealthkiwi wrote:
Personally I've heard way worse first hand stories about things in the last 20 years done to Serbians and Croats than were done to maori 200 years ago



Pfft.

Bunch of boxheads.el grapadura2010-05-13 09:57:16
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Buffon II wrote:
I'd rather not speak about it with my white friends as it can only cause disruption and trouble.
You'd rather just bottle it up? Sounds like you've got some sh*t to get off your chest, why not talk to your white mates about it?
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
kiwi pie wrote:
Buffon II wrote:
I'd rather not speak about it with my white friends as it can only cause disruption and trouble.
You'd rather just bottle it up? Sounds like you've got some sh*t to get off your chest, why not talk to your white mates about it?


I don't like arguing with people i care about. It reminds me of the fights my mum and dad used to have.

Three for me, and two for them.

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
You'd rather resent them secretly? Bit unfair imo. Seems you're comfortable to vent at total strangers (I find that helpful sometimes too), but these are your friends, Buff, you should be straight up with them. Maybe they'll surprise you.
That sucks about your Grandmother btw, i think we'd all agree about that. But don't forget - kids also got caned for using their left hand to write!
 
People were just idiots back then.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
I don't resent them. I'd just rather not argue with people i feel close to. My parents used to have terrible arguments and say the worst things to each other, they're supposed to love each other more than anyone else in the world and yet they would scream at each other and call each other terribly derogatory names. I don't want to become that.

I'd just rather i left it all alone now.

Three for me, and two for them.

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
No worries dude.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
This sh*t got deep

Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Experienced some (more) racism in Christchurch today. Not directed at me, but.

Was visiting my grandparents and they had some of there friends come over halfway thru. Somehow I mentioned that I was applying at Massey and would probably want to go to either there Wellington or Auckland campus.

One of my Grandparents friends said that they would never want to live in Auckland, I asked why and there answer was "well, for starters there are all the stupid Samoans there - they are brainless." She then proceeded to say the typical misinformed old people bullsh*t.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
thats not a chch thing tho... many white kiwis 60 or up have never even met a pacific islander and get much of their info from the media and the media tends to mention Akld/Porirua samoans in the context of burglaries, gangs, inter - pacific islander fighting and their own clergy ripping them off by tithing. And many islanders in NZ weren't born here and have a diff way of doing things that many older people in particular find strange.

My grandparents often say stuff that makes me cringe but I know there is no malice behind it - simply ignorance and the fact they just don't understand
stealthkiwi2010-05-13 19:35:41
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Tegal wrote:
This sh*t got deep

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Buffon II wrote:
That doesn't change the fact that no culture exists within white New Zealand.[/QUOTE]

Hmmm, not sure about that Buffy. Take that great European import Christianity as just one example. Now you could split hairs and argue that there's a difference between religion and culture but the impact Christianity has on all our daily lives - whether Christian or not - is definitely cultural.

Think about something as fundamental as the way we measure time using the Gregorian calendar. All the important holidays we take are Christian celebrations (don't try and tell me that Christmas isn't a major cultural event for everyone in NZ regardless of religious persuasion). Our national anthem is God Defend NZ. Christian teachings also underpin most of our morals, values and our legal system. I could go on.

Not only does white New Zealand (as you put it) have a culture, as you point out yourself it has had a massive impact on Maori culture over the last 150 years. As Michael King says in the conclusion to his Penguin History of NZ:

[QUOTE]The Maori culture of of the 21st century is not Maori culture frozen at 1769, nor at 1840. Nor should it be. It changed and grew dynamically according to changing needs and circumstances prior to the 18th century, and it continues to do so in the 21st century.

Similarly, Pakeha culture continues to borrow and to learn from Maori. That was one of the features that made it different from its European cultures of origin.


NZ is a true bicultural society.


Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Buffon II wrote:
Buffy, I think that comments like yours are often why Caucasian society can be so cold towards our ethnic minorities - in particular Polynesian and Maori. 


That wouldn't be anything new would it Mr Inc. Pakeha have downtrodden on the Maori people for generations. Only recently has that started to change for the better. When my grandmother was at school she would get the cane for speaking Maori. In her own country, speaking her own language, she got the cane.

But keep being cold, it's not like you owe us anything.
a lot of maoris still often get caned

Founder

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
stealthkiwi wrote:

My grandparents often say stuff that makes me cringe but I know there is no malice behind it - simply ignorance and the fact they just don't understand


Older people do seem to be intolerant more often than the rest, in my experience of them at least.  Though, again in my experience of it, they've tended to have a reason.  While this doesn't justify their intolerance you can kind of see why they think the way they do.  I may've used the example of my grandmother before who didn't like the Japanese.  That was because her cousin was beheaded by a group of them.  Now, I see Japanese people and some are good, some are bad, and to think all Japanese people go around beheading people is ridiculous and so I'd like to think that if I had an experience like that I wouldn't hold a grudge against the Japanese as a whole.  But you can still understand why they think the way they do, and who knows, if something like that happened to someone I was close too maybe I would end up having a few prejudices as well.
Permalink Permalink