Closed for new posts
Legend
2.2K
·
16K
·
over 17 years

2ndBest wrote:
Not sure what you expect because we can only sign amateurs or free agents now the window is closed.

probably not getting ourselves into this postition

Appiah without the pace
6.8K
·
19K
·
about 17 years

You mean relying on NZF to complete one of their core tasks?

Legend
2.2K
·
16K
·
over 17 years

2ndBest wrote:

You mean relying on NZF to complete one of their core tasks?

maybe Nix need to buy a calendar.

I don't think we would have sat on our arses during the window if they have relo in HAL

Early retirement
3.2K
·
34K
·
over 17 years

I don't think we'd have sat on our arses if we had a licence beyond May.

Legend
2.2K
·
16K
·
over 17 years

Hard News wrote:

I don't think we'd have sat on our arses if we had a licence beyond May.

but we can sign a four year licence whenever we want...

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
about 15 years

chopah wrote:

el grapadura wrote:

valeo wrote:

When will NZF be held accountable? Sack the lot of them. 

The problem is that after you do that, the new lot invariably turns out to be even more incompetent.

It's the kind of thing that almost makes you wanna become a rugby fan.

sack Fred - oh wait that's been done already... things don't seem to have got any better.

I have to give you that one. We got the blood we wanted and you are right - nothing has improved and you could actually argue have gotten worse
Early retirement
3.2K
·
34K
·
over 17 years

Fred was always a scpegoat for the endemic incompetence in the organisation.

RR
·
Bossi Insider
11K
·
35K
·
about 16 years

Jeff Vader wrote:

valeo wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

So we have Logan Rogerson on the books but we are starting Stevens and signed Watson. What?

From everything i've heard, Rogerson isn't ready yet.

Ok I have only seen about 30 mins of him.

If this is the case, why sign him to pro papers then? Why not offer that to Joel Stevens, whom seems to have the goods, and leave Rogerson in the Weenix off contract (ala Blake and Dimairo)?

I just find it odd that the Phoenix sign a player that is not up to it and the player that it, is playing more and they probably shoulda signed.

Rogerson is on a Wee Nix deal.
RR
·
Bossi Insider
11K
·
35K
·
about 16 years

2ndBest wrote:
Not sure what you expect because we can only sign amateurs or free agents now the window is closed.
Also doubt ACFC would have let us have De Vries with the O-League coming up.
First Team Squad
280
·
1.6K
·
over 12 years

RR wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

valeo wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

So we have Logan Rogerson on the books but we are starting Stevens and signed Watson. What?

From everything i've heard, Rogerson isn't ready yet.

Ok I have only seen about 30 mins of him.

If this is the case, why sign him to pro papers then? Why not offer that to Joel Stevens, whom seems to have the goods, and leave Rogerson in the Weenix off contract (ala Blake and Dimairo)?

I just find it odd that the Phoenix sign a player that is not up to it and the player that it, is playing more and they probably shoulda signed.

Rogerson is on a Wee Nix deal.

No, he's pro.

RR
·
Bossi Insider
11K
·
35K
·
about 16 years

yellowsite wrote:

RR wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

valeo wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

So we have Logan Rogerson on the books but we are starting Stevens and signed Watson. What?

From everything i've heard, Rogerson isn't ready yet.

Ok I have only seen about 30 mins of him.

If this is the case, why sign him to pro papers then? Why not offer that to Joel Stevens, whom seems to have the goods, and leave Rogerson in the Weenix off contract (ala Blake and Dimairo)?

I just find it odd that the Phoenix sign a player that is not up to it and the player that it, is playing more and they probably shoulda signed.

Rogerson is on a Wee Nix deal.

No, he's pro.

He is one of our 3 contracted youth players outside the 23 man squad limit. It isn't a senior deal.
Marquee
4.5K
·
6.8K
·
about 14 years

Ryan wrote:

Why did the Phoenix submit the paperwork on a Saturday? Surely they knew for a week that Alex was coming. Does he have to be in the country before he is cleared? Also the fact that its a loan and not a transfer isn't taken into account?

WelNix are in Wellington - I guess they did not click that Auckland (where NZF is) is closed down on Monday 1st February.

But they should have checked with NZF anyway - because you owe that much to a player wanting to come over to the bottom of the world to play for you. And this is where our corporate culture fails - we are just not sharp enough and not good enough.

Truly, "The Team That Could Not Shoot Straight".

Starting XI
1.6K
·
2.6K
·
about 17 years

FFS

So, we all know NZF is hopeless. You presume the Nix know they are hopeless. When dealing with the hopeless what do you do?

Were there not phone calls from Nix to NZF the week before the transfer paper work was sent through, to make sure NZF knew it was coming and would be urgent, and to organise who their contact point at NZF was to check that all was going smoothly?

Were there no phone calls and requests for confirmation from NZF on the Tuesday that the papers had been received and processed?

Why were we not escalating this all the way to the NZF CEO and Board if we could get no response?

This all seems un-fudging-believable, and not just from NZF imo.  Maybe not from NZF at all.

Lawyerish
2.1K
·
5.1K
·
over 13 years

Everydays a holiday for those who are lucky enough to be employed by NZ football

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
almost 13 years

I don't think anyone ever thought Fred was the only issue with NZF, but there was a general consensus that he had failed in his role, which was meant to be High Performance Director IIRC. So I don't get why people are implying he was hard done by because the shambles has continued. Also, surely lodging player transfers with FIFA would be an administration/support officer role, not something the High Performance Director was doing. Its a bit different to establishing player eligibility - just fill in a form and hit send.

So basically, why is this about Fred all of a sudden? Or do we think he took the fax machine manual with him when he left?

Marquee
4.5K
·
6.8K
·
about 14 years

I don't think anyone ever thought Fred was the only issue with NZF, but there was a general consensus that he had failed in his role, which was meant to be High Performance Director IIRC. So I don't get why people are implying he was hard done by because the shambles has continued. Also, surely lodging player transfers with FIFA would be an administration/support officer role, not something the High Performance Director was doing. Its a bit different to establishing player eligibility - just fill in a form and hit send.

So basically, why is this about Fred all of a sudden? Or do we think he took the fax machine manual with him when he left?

It is not about Fred. It is about what I call a "Fred Syndrome", which is that NZF seems to be about as competent as EQC.

Football seems to be peripheral issue of interest to NZF, much like earthquakes are of passing interest to EQC.

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
almost 13 years

Mainland FC wrote:

I don't think anyone ever thought Fred was the only issue with NZF, but there was a general consensus that he had failed in his role, which was meant to be High Performance Director IIRC. So I don't get why people are implying he was hard done by because the shambles has continued. Also, surely lodging player transfers with FIFA would be an administration/support officer role, not something the High Performance Director was doing. Its a bit different to establishing player eligibility - just fill in a form and hit send.

So basically, why is this about Fred all of a sudden? Or do we think he took the fax machine manual with him when he left?

It is not about Fred. It is about what I call a "Fred Syndrome", which is that NZF seems to be about as competent as EQC.

Football seems to be peripheral issue of interest to NZF, much like earthquakes are of passing interest to EQC.

I agree it's not about Fred, but it seemed like a few posts up there were implying he was hard done by because the incompetence continued without him
Marquee
740
·
5.2K
·
about 17 years

There's a striker called Jiang Chen without a club according to wikki.

Marquee
7.8K
·
9.7K
·
almost 14 years

Mainland FC wrote:

Ryan wrote:

Why did the Phoenix submit the paperwork on a Saturday? Surely they knew for a week that Alex was coming. Does he have to be in the country before he is cleared? Also the fact that its a loan and not a transfer isn't taken into account?

WelNix are in Wellington - I guess they did not click that Auckland (where NZF is) is closed down on Monday 1st February.

But they should have checked with NZF anyway - because you owe that much to a player wanting to come over to the bottom of the world to play for you. And this is where our corporate culture fails - we are just not sharp enough and not good enough.

Truly, "The Team That Could Not Shoot Straight".

yeah, it figures that it was submitted as soon it was sorted. They are saying it was partially completed in FIFA's system so we don't know if the Phoenix chased them up or not.
Legend
2.2K
·
16K
·
over 17 years

RR wrote:

yellowsite wrote:

RR wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

valeo wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

So we have Logan Rogerson on the books but we are starting Stevens and signed Watson. What?

From everything i've heard, Rogerson isn't ready yet.

Ok I have only seen about 30 mins of him.

If this is the case, why sign him to pro papers then? Why not offer that to Joel Stevens, whom seems to have the goods, and leave Rogerson in the Weenix off contract (ala Blake and Dimairo)?

I just find it odd that the Phoenix sign a player that is not up to it and the player that it, is playing more and they probably shoulda signed.

Rogerson is on a Wee Nix deal.

No, he's pro.

He is one of our 3 contracted youth players outside the 23 man squad limit. It isn't a senior deal.

He's a pro. What's your point? Wee Nix is not an actual thing

Appiah without the pace
6.8K
·
19K
·
about 17 years
Phoenix Academy
130
·
260
·
almost 14 years

chopah wrote:

el grapadura wrote:

valeo wrote:

When will NZF be held accountable? Sack the lot of them. 

The problem is that after you do that, the new lot invariably turns out to be even more incompetent.

It's the kind of thing that almost makes you wanna become a rugby fan.

sack De Jonkey - oh wait that's been done already... things don't seem to have got any better.

Fixed

Starting XI
920
·
2.5K
·
over 12 years

Mainland FC wrote:

I don't think anyone ever thought Fred was the only issue with NZF, but there was a general consensus that he had failed in his role, which was meant to be High Performance Director IIRC. So I don't get why people are implying he was hard done by because the shambles has continued. Also, surely lodging player transfers with FIFA would be an administration/support officer role, not something the High Performance Director was doing. Its a bit different to establishing player eligibility - just fill in a form and hit send.

So basically, why is this about Fred all of a sudden? Or do we think he took the fax machine manual with him when he left?

It is not about Fred. It is about what I call a "Fred Syndrome", which is that NZF seems to be about as competent as EQC.

Football seems to be peripheral issue of interest to NZF, much like earthquakes are of passing interest to EQC.

I agree it's not about Fred, but it seemed like a few posts up there were implying he was hard done by because the incompetence continued without him

it was just a tongue in cheek joke mate - so don't worry.

I know just as much as everyone else in football that NZF were a shambles BF (before fred) and will continue to be one AF.

Trialist
6
·
60
·
over 8 years

After tonight - how has Harris from Team Wellington not been given a shot with the Phoenix? Any ideas? I just don't understand it - but don't much when it comes to the Phoenix these days...

One in a million
4.4K
·
9.7K
·
over 17 years

And how much do our clubs pay the NZF every bleeding year to do their job.? Are none of them actual Phoenix fans and might be looking out for the paperwork to help get him on the pitch?

LG
Legend
5.9K
·
24K
·
about 17 years

I am amazed that tyhe guy dealing with the paper work so to speak just happened to be in an area where there was no internet coverage. I didn't think Jafas could exist without at least one avenue of access to the Net. If only to keep up with the Kardashians, Sally Ridge or Max Key.

Appiah without the pace
6.8K
·
19K
·
about 17 years

shearer9 wrote:

After tonight - how has Harris from Team Wellington not been given a shot with the Phoenix? Any ideas? I just don't understand it - but don't much when it comes to the Phoenix these days...

As mentioned a few pages back, he only trains once a week  at TeeDubs because he has dodgy knees

WeeNix
300
·
570
·
almost 11 years

The comments in stuff on this saga are gold, NZF getting a good kicking from Nix fans. Lovin it.

http://i.stuff.co.nz/sport/football/a-league/76786352/NZ-Football-and-Phoenix-working-hard-to-save-Alex-Jones-loan-deal

LG
Legend
5.9K
·
24K
·
about 17 years

Just got another kick from me too!

Marquee
3.8K
·
5.9K
·
over 17 years

I fail to see how some seem to be turning a blind eye to the part the Phoenix have played in this shambles seems they dropped the ball big time despite what is claimed by some. Given its mostly no comment from the both of them seems both might have to admit they made mistakes.

Trialist
6
·
60
·
over 8 years

The lads goal scoring record speaks for itself. He appears to be settled in Wellington. Its not like they are offering up a 3 year contact. Its a 10 game emergency deal. Seems like a decent option to me - but they go for somebody they have already had then released - essentially deciding that he not good enough? Phoenix are a shambles.

Appiah without the pace
6.8K
·
19K
·
about 17 years

shearer9 wrote:

The lads goal scoring record speaks for itself. He appears to be settled in Wellington. Its not like they are offering up a 3 year contact. Its a 10 game emergency deal. Seems like a decent option to me - but they go for somebody they have already had then released - essentially deciding that he not good enough? Phoenix are a shambles.

You're obviously his friend/relative given all four of your posts are about him. Don't worry, you're not the first person to do that here.

If they signed Harris, they wouldn't then be able to sign Jones if the transfer eventually goes through.  We'd be over the foreign quota number. 

Marquee
7.8K
·
9.7K
·
almost 14 years

ballane wrote:

I fail to see how some seem to be turning a blind eye to the part the Phoenix have played in this shambles seems they dropped the ball big time despite what is claimed by some. Given its mostly no comment from the both of them seems both might have to admit they made mistakes.

according to Simon Hampton the Phoenix are furious in private but towing the line in public. The only information that we have is that the nix submitted their paperwork in time and that the process was started in the FIFA system but for whatever reason was not completed. Any blame going towards the club is just based on guesses ATM.
Marquee
3.8K
·
5.9K
·
over 17 years

Ryan wrote:

ballane wrote:

I fail to see how some seem to be turning a blind eye to the part the Phoenix have played in this shambles seems they dropped the ball big time despite what is claimed by some. Given its mostly no comment from the both of them seems both might have to admit they made mistakes.

according to Simon Hampton the Phoenix are furious in private but towing the line in public. The only information that we have is that the nix submitted their paperwork in time and that the process was started in the FIFA system but for whatever reason was not completed. Any blame going towards the club is just based on guesses ATM.

Yeah thats fine apart from the fact that the Phoenix are well aware of the issues NZF have had and if they fired it off and didnt follow up then im afraid yes they do have to take some of the blame.Dosnt really matter if NZF has dropped the ball the Phoenix should have been on their backs making sure the paper work was being done.

Its all assumption any way isnt it as they are all keeping pretty quiet.

Chant Savant
2.5K
·
12K
·
over 17 years

My Greek mate Con Spirocy-Theory reckons that the FFA attempted to pay off NZF off to look incompetent and accept blame for the transfer documents not being processed on time.

NZF said keep your money...

Starting XI
920
·
2.5K
·
over 12 years

ballane wrote:

Ryan wrote:

ballane wrote:

I fail to see how some seem to be turning a blind eye to the part the Phoenix have played in this shambles seems they dropped the ball big time despite what is claimed by some. Given its mostly no comment from the both of them seems both might have to admit they made mistakes.

according to Simon Hampton the Phoenix are furious in private but towing the line in public. The only information that we have is that the nix submitted their paperwork in time and that the process was started in the FIFA system but for whatever reason was not completed. Any blame going towards the club is just based on guesses ATM.

Yeah thats fine apart from the fact that the Phoenix are well aware of the issues NZF have had and if they fired it off and didnt follow up then im afraid yes they do have to take some of the blame.Dosnt really matter if NZF has dropped the ball the Phoenix should have been on their backs making sure the paper work was being done.

Its all assumption any way isnt it as they are all keeping pretty quiet.

yeah I get that you want some accountability from the nix - you have pushed this barrow three or four times.  Bottom line is we should still expect NZF to do this mundane task.  If your an international business dealing across multiple countries then you shouldn't even be closed for NZ public holidays, do FIFA give a shark about Auckland Anniversary?  To also remain closed with a transfer window closure looming is just idiotic, not to mention someone letting the person looking after the transfers be out of the office over this period - it's horrible management.

Should the nix have followed up - probably (they may have tried?) but that doesn't take anything away from how piss poor the grassroot football funded NZF are.

and 2 others
Marquee
7.8K
·
9.7K
·
almost 14 years

The press release said that they had started the process of the transfer but it was never completed, it could very well be that NZF filled in some of the information but the person who needed to sign off on it couldn't be reached. In this made up scenario the Phoenix may have called, multiple times, and NZF may have told them that they were processing it and it would be done.

We have no idea.

The truth is that NZF knew that the transfer window was closing and that their only professional club was on the look out for players, hopefully the nix gave them a heads up that they were about to sign someone, but even so it was a critical time and one that happens only twice a year so they should have been on the alert.

The nix should have followed up, and for all we know they did. Heck, with hindsight, they probably should have flown up to Auckland and sat behind the person who was entering the data into FIFA's system and not left NZF's office until it was done. But the fact is that the Phoenix has transferred dozens of players in the past and haven't had a issue like this before with NZF, so why would they start to worry?

Woof Woof
2.7K
·
19K
·
about 17 years

ballane wrote:

Ryan wrote:

ballane wrote:

I fail to see how some seem to be turning a blind eye to the part the Phoenix have played in this shambles seems they dropped the ball big time despite what is claimed by some. Given its mostly no comment from the both of them seems both might have to admit they made mistakes.

according to Simon Hampton the Phoenix are furious in private but towing the line in public. The only information that we have is that the nix submitted their paperwork in time and that the process was started in the FIFA system but for whatever reason was not completed. Any blame going towards the club is just based on guesses ATM.

Yeah thats fine apart from the fact that the Phoenix are well aware of the issues NZF have had and if they fired it off and didnt follow up then im afraid yes they do have to take some of the blame.Dosnt really matter if NZF has dropped the ball the Phoenix should have been on their backs making sure the paper work was being done.

Its all assumption any way isnt it as they are all keeping pretty quiet.

If the person you need to be following up with is uncontactable, what do you do?

Starting XI
1.6K
·
2.6K
·
about 17 years

el grapadura wrote:

ballane wrote:

Ryan wrote:

ballane wrote:

I fail to see how some seem to be turning a blind eye to the part the Phoenix have played in this shambles seems they dropped the ball big time despite what is claimed by some. Given its mostly no comment from the both of them seems both might have to admit they made mistakes.

according to Simon Hampton the Phoenix are furious in private but towing the line in public. The only information that we have is that the nix submitted their paperwork in time and that the process was started in the FIFA system but for whatever reason was not completed. Any blame going towards the club is just based on guesses ATM.

Yeah thats fine apart from the fact that the Phoenix are well aware of the issues NZF have had and if they fired it off and didnt follow up then im afraid yes they do have to take some of the blame.Dosnt really matter if NZF has dropped the ball the Phoenix should have been on their backs making sure the paper work was being done.

Its all assumption any way isnt it as they are all keeping pretty quiet.

If the person you need to be following up with is uncontactable, what do you do?

you ring the fudging CEO

then the Chairman

but the truth is we have no idea what happened and who did what

the only thing we know for a fact is that this is total incompetence, wherever it occurred

Early retirement
3.2K
·
34K
·
over 17 years

If you have done hundreds of these over 9 years you probably expect the people responsible for the single click to have performing that action under control.

Closed for new posts