Elliot is clearly a RB first and foremost in our squad, don't think that's really up for debate?
Better than TAHW there anyway, based on Wednesday. Neither were great defensively, but Elliot was far more likely to commit and then go past a defender. His movement was more dynamic in general, but it was clear he has work to do to transition from playing as RWB in a back 5 to RB in a back 4 - was noticeable how deep especially Devlin was dropping to mark the Striker's advanced fullbacks. Big adjustment to go from being the widest player in a defensive line to having someone outside you.
I've watched Callan play since he was 5, he's more than up to this.
Fair enough. From what I've seen, Elliot doesn't have the recovery pace when he gets beaten. He's decent as a winger as he's quite tricky and has a low centre of gravity.
TAHW struggled because Devlin didn't track runners properly and their communication wasn't really there.
You've seen him play more, though, so will trust your judgment. Just based on his appearances for us, I can't see him quite working as a RB in the A-League.
I see TAHW as the more defensive option, though not sure how comfortable he really is there.