Phoenix 2011-12 Members' Player of the year

Phoenix 2011-12 Members' Player of the year

http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/membersplayer2012 You'll need your membership number.

I just used my name.

Pavs. Ward. Tsatallios.

Lindsay Downey Griffiths


Edit - for limited game time or in Lindsay's case NONE
George Costanza2012-04-04 14:28:59

I used 2nd bests name

Ifill, Muscat, Brown

Bugger, knew I'd forgotten someone


George Costanza2012-04-04 14:55:48

Siggy, Manny, Iffy for me.

Pantellis wasn't on the list. Not sure if Lindsay was either.

Siggy, Ifill, Manny

Every nix player is listed.  The player of the season, which was on the Nix website, who people can vote for each week had a few names missing

^^ +1
I-I-Iffy2012-04-04 15:46:45

So... at the end of season awards, who's going to win under 23 player of the year? Brent Griffiths?

SigmUnd
Smith
Ifill

under 23 award could go to Pav lol.

This

Well his goal-minutes played ratio is about twice as good as Greenies lol (straws lol).. and no other young player has played much
raynes2012-04-04 21:31:53

Lindsay, he hasn't done anything wrong this season ...

I'm a big Manny fan but for me it's Durante this year. 

muskrat, siggy, durante

siggy hands down for me. apart from the penalty he gave away that one time, he's been incredible and incredibly consistent for the whole season

Dura, Manny, Ifill.

Siggy is a good defender but woeful playing out from the back, a real sticking point for me I'm afraid.

Refresh my memory, when did Siggy give away a penalty.  I think we've only given away one this season and that was Vinnie Lia.  I remember Siggy giving one away when the All Whites played Australia last year though

near the start of the season. was a home game. dont against who

Round 4 against Melbourne Victory. Was last player and denied a clear goal scoring oppourtunity, so got sent off and gave away a penalty which Hernandez calmly slotted, causing us to lose 2-1.

ah sh*t.  I thought that was Ward or was that another game?

Ward and Brown got sent off in the 2-0 win over Newcastle in round 2.

has to be siggy

not enough dura in this thread

love manny to bits but he hasnt been top 3 this season

i went;

3 pts: siggy
2 pts: iffy
1 pt: dura

Really not sure why Ifill rates so highly.Yep has done okay but has also been very quiet in many games and hasnt had the influence on games that some think he has.

Cod liver oil.

Moosecat
Siggy
Iffy Iffy I

Manny gets 3 just for his last-minute flights to play when his baby was due.

Siggy/Dura/Ifill hard call

Good point. Above and beyond the callof duty.

i thought the same thing when i was pondering my choices, but if you ask the question how many points would we have got without him the answer is a sh*tload less than what we got

And you can't argue that someone else in his place would've bought the same goals/assists and general pants-sh*tting of the opposition, his un-predictability and sweet eye for a pass are un-matched by any in our squad, and almost any in the league - maybe broich but struggle to think of any others

Hell even when he has nothing to do with a goal it's often because the other team are concentrating so much on him that brownie etc go un-marked to score - not that that is a reason to get the award of course, but just sayingpaulm2012-04-07 10:09:14