Wellington Phoenix Men

Player ratings this season

6 replies · 1,752 views
over 8 years ago

Hi,

nobody has been posting player ratings yet so here's an attempt. This includes all 3 games.

It was taking a bit long so I didn't write comments for everyone.

Smith - 6

Bit shaky but there's definitely some potential there.

Galloway - 7

Solid down the right flank. Needs to work on his crossing though.

Durante - 6

Rossi - 7

Mullen - 6

Doyle - 7

Unlucky to be replaced by Abbas against City. Not sure who our best left back is :-)

Abbas - 6

Wasn't match fit at first but has improved rapidly. Nearly had a goal against City.

Paracki - 9

He's everywhere, and can not only defend but start attacks too. Kinda looks too good for the A-League (don't let him read that! :-)

Ridenton - 7

He's really improved. Decent corner taker too - should be hitting them instead of McGlinchey.

Vidosic - 7

Nice goals. Doesn't get on the ball as much as I thought he would.

Rufer - 5

Parkhouse - 5

Krishna - 7

K-vic - 7

Still not match fit, but great goal against Sydney.

McGlinchey - 6

Bit of passenger so far ...

Watson - 6

Not enough game time to comment.

Permalink Permalink
over 8 years ago

Fair enough Bevan, agree in most part.

Points of difference:

Rossi not up to his best, would be lucky to be a 6

McGlinchey I thought was very good on weekend, getting close to a 7

Kaledj one nice goal, but still only a 5 or 6

Oi Oi Edgecumbe... lets have a clean sheet

Permalink Permalink
over 8 years ago

That's all pretty fair, but I would differ on Keegan-Smith and give him a 7. This is because he is actually an 18 year old kid who is not embarrassing himself so far playing against adults. So from where he is at, a 7 is least he deserves.

Actually, getting outplayed quite a bit these days

Permalink Permalink
over 8 years ago

Fair enough Bevan, agree in most part.

Points of difference:

Rossi not up to his best, would be lucky to be a 6

McGlinchey I thought was very good on weekend, getting close to a 7

Kaledj one nice goal, but still only a 5 or 6

I tend to agree..Kaledjovic underwhelmingly so far.  Heysegems was better for me even without being able to head a ball.  Similar records tho.

A small town in Europe........looking to bounce straight back up....well that aint going to happen

Permalink Permalink
over 8 years ago

Jeez they would be easy to do this week...

Keegan 7, noone else above 5 and several below that.

Oi Oi Edgecumbe... lets have a clean sheet

Permalink Permalink
over 8 years ago

Keegan 7 , everyone else 3

Proud to have attended the first 175 Consecutive "Home" Wellington Phoenix "A League" Games !!

The Ruf, The Ruf, The Ruf is on Fire!!

Permalink Permalink
over 8 years ago

Lonegunmen wrote:

Keegan 7 , everyone else 3

3 at best.  It was absolutely unequivocally awful..  Agree with Keegan at 7 though - young fella played well.

Permalink Permalink