Player ratings v Gloryboys Eden Park

Real hard to rate objectively when watching live, distracted by the fun on the terraces, haven't watched replay so, feel free to disagree (as always)

Pasty 6 Kept a clean sheet
Leo 6 Lively and well used
Dura 7 Lead the team well
Siggy 5 Still worried about seeing him the midfield too often
Hogg 6 Good debut
Manny 5.5 Sound
Lia 5.5 Unobtrusive (a good thing), keeping the gaps covered
Cernak 6.5 Lots of energy, making a difference
Ifill 6 Provided the cross
Waffles 4 Not making a difference
Brockie 5.5 Good header
Dani 5 Did well when came on
Louis 5 Energy, useful

Your opinion?

Watched on tele but I largely agree with these, although can't remember Siggy disgracing himself so badly that he only deserved a 5. Probably push Manny up half a point too and Stein not as bad as a 4 suggests either. Pumping long ball to him is a waste of time.

Second half effort was very tentative from nearly all, but thankfully Perth were shite and we didn't get punished.

Stein looked quite good first half.
Better than Brockie, if he hadn't scored. Obviously that's what he's there for, but if he hadn't like the last 4 games he would have been invisible.