Player ratings v Reds
Oi Oi Edgecumbe... lets have a clean sheet
Permalink
Permalink
Wow another top result, team effort
Pasty 5.5 Not as assured as could be
Manny 7.5 great
Siggy 7.5 bloodied head bandage said it all
Dura 7.5 Led team strongly
Lochie 7 Did well
Leo 6.5 Used pace well
Timmy 7 What a great finish, tracked back well
Smith 7 Unsung hero
Sanchez 5.5 Lovely header, but not much else
Ifill 9 What a game, should have had two pens
Greenie 6 Nice cross for Dani's goal
Daniel 6.5 Made a good impact, held ball well
Lia 5 A couple of fouls
What do you think??
Oi Oi Edgecumbe... lets have a clean sheet
Permalink
Permalink
I'd take 1 off Ifill for the yellow card and give him an 8.
Permalink
Permalink
I'd take 1 off Ifill for the yellow card and give him an 8.
Permalink
Permalink
Probably Browns best game of the season - his work rate was much better than it has been most of the year.
Sanchez is due a good game, goal aside, 2nd quiet game in a row - I just don't think right half is his position, he is much better in the middle.
Smith impresses more and more each week - a real honest grafter and very good in the air.
He dribbles a lot and the opposition dont like it - you can see it all over their faces. (Ron Atkinson)
Permalink
Permalink
take 5 off ifill for diving 
And leo might actually deserve a 7 
chefmivec2012-02-04 08:34:27
And leo might actually deserve a 7 chefmivec2012-02-04 08:34:27I LOVE LAMP
Permalink
Permalink
Probably Browns best game of the season - his work rate was much better than it has been most of the year.
Excellent first half, little quieter in the second I thought, but excellent game. Could not agree any more with your statement aboveSanchez is due a good game, goal aside, 2nd quiet game in a row - I just don't think right half is his position, he is much better in the middle.
Smith impresses more and more each week - a real honest grafter and very good in the air.
Permalink
Permalink
Those ratings seem pretty spot on to me. I'd maybe dock SigmUnd a point for that dickish gesture to the Adelaide fans - its probably going to cost him a game on review, and that's the last thing we need (especially if Griffiths is off in China). And I'd give Sanchez an extra point. He scored a goal, and did nothing else wrong.
Probably�Browns best�game of the�season - his work rate was much better than it has been most of the year.
Yep. And did you see his neat little turn at the top of the box? He showed a number of classy touches. I did think he tired badly though - there were a number of occasions where he gave up a chase, or was left sitting on his heels, at the end of the game. Not a surprise given the conditions and his earlier effort.
Probably�Browns best�game of the�season - his work rate was much better than it has been most of the year.
Yep. And did you see his neat little turn at the top of the box? He showed a number of classy touches. I did think he tired badly though - there were a number of occasions where he gave up a chase, or was left sitting on his heels, at the end of the game. Not a surprise given the conditions and his earlier effort.
Permalink
Permalink
I think Siggy deserves a 10 just for giving it to the pissant fans
Permalink
Permalink
I think Siggy deserves a 10 just for giving it to the pissant fans
Might be a hollow 10 if there is any consequence from FFA, but top marks for intent!
"Phoenix till they lose"
Posting 97% bollox, 8% lies and 3.658% genuine opinion.
Genuine opinion: FTFFA
Permalink
Permalink
Brown's best game in some time, that can't be said enough, every time I thought he was about to disappear he did something great! Really nice finish too, fooled the keeper, picked his spot, awesome. Lets ave some more of that brownie!
Thought some or all of our defenders were marked pretty highly considering our impersonation of a sieve in the first 20 mins or so, i was freaking out at times, pinball in the box with every delivery, it wasnt good
Thought some or all of our defenders were marked pretty highly considering our impersonation of a sieve in the first 20 mins or so, i was freaking out at times, pinball in the box with every delivery, it wasnt good
Permalink
Permalink
Can't argue with the ratings, maybe drop leo and lochy .5?
Permalink
Permalink
i liked brown's interview after the game said he thought about taking a touch and at the last second changed and hit it first time.
Permalink
Permalink
Yes agree with the ratings. Pasty had me worried a few times. Just doesn't seem assertive enough.
Loved the gesture from Siggy. He had blood pouring from his head and the Adelaide fans screaming "Who are ya" at him. Bad form.
Permalink
Permalink
i liked brown's interview after the game said he thought about taking a touch and at the last second changed and hit it first time.
Funny you should say that. I had a dream about Mel McLaughlin last night and it was exactly this!
"Ive just re-visited this and once again realised that C-Diddy is a genius - a drunk, Newcastle bred disgrace - but a genius." - Hard News, 11:39am 4th June 2009
Permalink
Permalink
Yes agree with the ratings. Pasty had me worried a few times. Just doesn't seem assertive enough.
Loved the gesture from Siggy. He had blood pouring from his head and the Adelaide fans screaming "Who are ya" at him. Bad form.
Sounds just like us then...." Dig a hole".. "She fell over"...
Improving,,on the up, a work in progress from Italiano and the Nix. Bring on the bathroom bling in '24! COYN!
Permalink
Permalink
i liked brown's interview after the game said he thought about taking a touch and at the last second changed and hit it first time.
Funny you should say that. I had a dream about Mel McLaughlin last night and it was exactly this!
well done there i don't think you were the only one to have that dream.
Permalink
Permalink
Yes agree with the ratings. Pasty had me worried a few times. Just doesn't seem assertive enough.
Loved the gesture from Siggy. He had blood pouring from his head and the Adelaide fans screaming "Who are ya" at him. Bad form.
Sounds just like us then...." Dig a hole".. "She fell over"...
Yeah but a lot of times the player is faking it or trying to milk it to influence the ref. Last night it was pretty obvious that Siggy had a genuine injury.
Permalink
Permalink
i liked brown's interview after the game said he thought about taking a touch and at the last second changed and hit it first time.
Funny you should say that. I had a dream about Mel McLaughlin last night and it was exactly this!
If I remember rightly, you were still awake when having thoughts about Mel. You may also not have been wearing pants 
I have the text evidence!
I have the text evidence!
Permalink
Permalink
Yes agree with the ratings. Pasty had me worried a few times. Just doesn't seem assertive enough.
Loved the gesture from Siggy. He had blood pouring from his head and the Adelaide fans screaming "Who are ya" at him. Bad form.
Sounds just like us then...." Dig a hole".. "She fell over"...
Yeah but I guess we don't know about the injury cuse we are usually so far away, it was clear he'd had a head injury ffs their fans were right on top of it. I liked the ol' "up yours" though, don't really see that these days.
Stupid though baiting Siggy, turning him from mild-mannered CB into the:
Permalink
Permalink
Yes agree with the ratings. Pasty had me worried a few times. Just doesn't seem assertive enough.
Loved the gesture from Siggy. He had blood pouring from his head and the Adelaide fans screaming "Who are ya" at him. Bad form.
Sounds just like us then...." Dig a hole".. "She fell over"...
GET YOUR SHIRTS OFF FOR THE BOYS
Permalink
Permalink
Jason Culina did exactly that to the zone when cold ghost equalized at the beginning of last season. With out any form of sanction from the FFA.
Permalink
Permalink
A full down trou. It's a training ground manoeuvre apparently.
Permalink
Permalink
wat did siggy do?�
i think he gave the adelaide fan base the up ya with raised arm and fist as he jogged passed them after he got his head bandaged
Permalink
Permalink