Wellington Phoenix Men

R2 vs Perth Glory | Sun 16 Oct | 9:00pm | SS2

550 replies · 42,799 views
over 9 years ago

Fenix wrote:

Mainland FC wrote:

MetalLegNZ wrote:

That's the DM's role to tuck into cover the break and to be an outlet if momentum stops, but Lia is holding to central and pushing into the middle, yeah, its great in his mind because he gets the ball with time in a central area, but it leaves us short, chasing runners while trying to close space.

He's better tucking in and then looking to rebuild through the back and maintain possession and then tuck back into the middle and look for options....

Lia needs to know when to hold, push and drop in... seems to lack positional nous.

I would agree with the above. The role Lia has now in this team requires more speed / nimbleness. Even if his positional nous was any better chances are he would not have the legs to get there, especially with the speed and accuracy Perth was playing.

It makes sense to use A-Rod more simply because he is younger and fitter, and not any less skillful than Lia, assuming it is the same position.

If we are losing 6 games in a row, not scoring a goal so far this season, and bottom of the league, why are we playing Lia? We can achieve the same thing ie nothing just by playing the youngsters, at least they may improve.

By your reasoning why not drop Durante, McGlinchey, Roly, Krishna........

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

reg22 wrote:

inafoxhole wrote:

djtim3000 wrote:

reg22 wrote:

barbarouses is a right winger and that's all he is use him there.

Apart from that one time he was played as a striker and won the A-League as the second highest goal scorer...

He played on the right of the front three for Brisbane, didn't he?

yip, he sure did

hi tim :-)

I'm assuming you are Regan!

Right in a front three still isn't on the wing :)

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Jeff Vader wrote:

Fenix wrote:

Mainland FC wrote:

MetalLegNZ wrote:

That's the DM's role to tuck into cover the break and to be an outlet if momentum stops, but Lia is holding to central and pushing into the middle, yeah, its great in his mind because he gets the ball with time in a central area, but it leaves us short, chasing runners while trying to close space.

He's better tucking in and then looking to rebuild through the back and maintain possession and then tuck back into the middle and look for options....

Lia needs to know when to hold, push and drop in... seems to lack positional nous.

I would agree with the above. The role Lia has now in this team requires more speed / nimbleness. Even if his positional nous was any better chances are he would not have the legs to get there, especially with the speed and accuracy Perth was playing.

It makes sense to use A-Rod more simply because he is younger and fitter, and not any less skillful than Lia, assuming it is the same position.

If we are losing 6 games in a row, not scoring a goal so far this season, and bottom of the league, why are we playing Lia? We can achieve the same thing ie nothing just by playing the youngsters, at least they may improve.

So your basic premise is 'season over, lets play the kids for development'

You don't think its a little early to be making that call round 3 of a 27 round season?!?!?!?!?!?

Some people are nuts. We did not played flash in both games. But the stats showed we had our chances and could have scored in both games, which would have total different result. I don't like to play the luck argument, but if no trip, no penalty no counter attack, would be at least a Nil all. The whole youth think is false hope, we need seasoned pro's who can pull us out of this. Tratt and Parkhouse are already to much young potential. I hope Doyle and Fox are back (still youth full but at least played a few games at this level)

I think we score early against Sydney and then we will have good Sunday evening partying.

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Number 8 we need " seasoned pros" who are up to A league standard. Unfortunatey the stats show we have suffered  6 straight loses and only had 7 wins last season, The " seasoned pros" now need to come under the microscope because clearly some are not up to it.

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Jeff Vader wrote:

Fenix wrote:

Mainland FC wrote:

MetalLegNZ wrote:

That's the DM's role to tuck into cover the break and to be an outlet if momentum stops, but Lia is holding to central and pushing into the middle, yeah, its great in his mind because he gets the ball with time in a central area, but it leaves us short, chasing runners while trying to close space.

He's better tucking in and then looking to rebuild through the back and maintain possession and then tuck back into the middle and look for options....

Lia needs to know when to hold, push and drop in... seems to lack positional nous.

I would agree with the above. The role Lia has now in this team requires more speed / nimbleness. Even if his positional nous was any better chances are he would not have the legs to get there, especially with the speed and accuracy Perth was playing.

It makes sense to use A-Rod more simply because he is younger and fitter, and not any less skillful than Lia, assuming it is the same position.

If we are losing 6 games in a row, not scoring a goal so far this season, and bottom of the league, why are we playing Lia? We can achieve the same thing ie nothing just by playing the youngsters, at least they may improve.

So your basic premise is 'season over, lets play the kids for development'

You don't think its a little early to be making that call round 3 of a 27 round season?!?!?!?!?!?

Do you see it any differently? I have watched every Phoenix A-League game there has been.
Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago · edited over 9 years ago · History

Rosco wrote:

Fenix wrote:

Mainland FC wrote:

MetalLegNZ wrote:

That's the DM's role to tuck into cover the break and to be an outlet if momentum stops, but Lia is holding to central and pushing into the middle, yeah, its great in his mind because he gets the ball with time in a central area, but it leaves us short, chasing runners while trying to close space.

He's better tucking in and then looking to rebuild through the back and maintain possession and then tuck back into the middle and look for options....

Lia needs to know when to hold, push and drop in... seems to lack positional nous.

I would agree with the above. The role Lia has now in this team requires more speed / nimbleness. Even if his positional nous was any better chances are he would not have the legs to get there, especially with the speed and accuracy Perth was playing.

It makes sense to use A-Rod more simply because he is younger and fitter, and not any less skillful than Lia, assuming it is the same position.

If we are losing 6 games in a row, not scoring a goal so far this season, and bottom of the league, why are we playing Lia? We can achieve the same thing ie nothing just by playing the youngsters, at least they may improve.

By your reasoning why not drop Durante, McGlinchey, Roly, Krishna........

If we keep losing then yes, you are correct. Krishna can still improve and contribute. Durante is adding something as he gradually hands over to Fox. But its not clear to me what Lia is gonna do now. As for McGlinchey and Roly, well all I can say is I expect them to improve.
Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

It's just one big revolution. , sack Greenie, Rolys fudgeed, why did we sign Guy, sharkhouse is as the names suggests, shark team, shark fans.

Fudge me the fans always know more than management and at round 2, people are seriously advocating torching the whole thing. Just amazing.

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

I'm just sick of all the f'ing negativity world wide. Everything is doom and gloom all the time and it's bloody well depressing. The world is going to crap, why can't there just be a little positivitiy around my football team? Is that too much to ask?

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago
Yeah absolutely there can be, just don't bother coming here to find it!

Fuck this stupid game

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Ryan wrote:

I'm just sick of all the f'ing negativity world wide. Everything is doom and gloom all the time and it's bloody well depressing. The world is going to crap, why can't there just be a little positivitiy around my football team? Is that too much to ask?

I am totally sick of losing so a Phoenix win should create a lot positivilty.

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

We will beat Sydney. Rant over

For all your Waikato realestate needs contact me!!
Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Fenix wrote:

Rosco wrote:

Fenix wrote:

Mainland FC wrote:

MetalLegNZ wrote:

That's the DM's role to tuck into cover the break and to be an outlet if momentum stops, but Lia is holding to central and pushing into the middle, yeah, its great in his mind because he gets the ball with time in a central area, but it leaves us short, chasing runners while trying to close space.

He's better tucking in and then looking to rebuild through the back and maintain possession and then tuck back into the middle and look for options....

Lia needs to know when to hold, push and drop in... seems to lack positional nous.

I would agree with the above. The role Lia has now in this team requires more speed / nimbleness. Even if his positional nous was any better chances are he would not have the legs to get there, especially with the speed and accuracy Perth was playing.

It makes sense to use A-Rod more simply because he is younger and fitter, and not any less skillful than Lia, assuming it is the same position.

If we are losing 6 games in a row, not scoring a goal so far this season, and bottom of the league, why are we playing Lia? We can achieve the same thing ie nothing just by playing the youngsters, at least they may improve.

By your reasoning why not drop Durante, McGlinchey, Roly, Krishna........

If we keep losing then yes, you are correct. Krishna can still improve and contribute. Durante is adding something as he gradually hands over to Fox. But its not clear to me what Lia is gonna do now. As for McGlinchey and Roly, well all I can say is I expect them to improve.

Fox is nowhere near Durante's class. 

Normo's coming home

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Ryan wrote:

I'm just sick of all the f'ing negativity world wide. Everything is doom and gloom all the time and it's bloody well depressing. The world is going to crap, why can't there just be a little positivitiy around my football team? Is that too much to ask?

We have lost 100% of the games we have played this season.

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Bananas wrote:

Ryan wrote:

I'm just sick of all the f'ing negativity world wide. Everything is doom and gloom all the time and it's bloody well depressing. The world is going to crap, why can't there just be a little positivitiy around my football team? Is that too much to ask?

We have lost 100% of the games we have played this season.

n = 2. Terrible sample size.


Yellow Fever - Misery loves company

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

patrick478 wrote:

Bananas wrote:

Ryan wrote:

I'm just sick of all the f'ing negativity world wide. Everything is doom and gloom all the time and it's bloody well depressing. The world is going to crap, why can't there just be a little positivitiy around my football team? Is that too much to ask?

We have lost 100% of the games we have played this season.

n = 2. Terrible sample size.

But if you create a pattern from what we have it goes L,L,L,L,L,L,L,L,L,L,L,L

Now n = 12 and that's a less terrible sample size.  

Sorry I thought that's how we do the forums, negativity.  Thought to be fair I can understand the negativity a bit with two losses out of the gate, but its a long race so we have plenty of time to win.

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

1 loss missing half our team to international duty. 

1 loss where half our team travelled after playing 2 games halfway around the world, to play another game in Perth. 

I don't understand the negativity at all. 


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Tegal wrote:

1 loss missing half our team to international duty. 

1 loss where half our team travelled after playing 2 games halfway around the world, to play another game in Perth. 

I don't understand the negativity at all. 

It's been more than a season of the same problems, you go back to when SFC beat us 3-0 at home when we were top of the league - what has changed in the process that gives you confidence? The same issues surfaced again against Perth, you could probably dig up comments on here after that SFC game and apply them to games like we had against Perth (and Jets, CCM, Perth etc. last year). 

We have had 8 wins since that SFC game. 

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

"you go back to when we were top of the league" isn't a great argument that we should be all doom and gloom...


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Tegal wrote:

"you go back to when we were top of the league" isn't a great argument that we should be all doom and gloom...

Don't be flippant. That was more than a season ago, 35 games. That game clearly laid out issues with the team's process/tactics/structure that has been taken advantage of in many games since then - we need to evolve to still be competitive.

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

it's 2 games into the season. I reserve the right to be flippant. 


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Tegal wrote:

1 loss missing half our team to international duty. 

1 loss where half our team travelled after playing 2 games halfway around the world, to play another game in Perth. 

I don't understand the negativity at all. 

really? Conan wrote about 1000 words explaining it really well

I like tautologies because I like them.
Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

i'm sick to death of people coming to these forums to moan about people moaning

360footballnews.com

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

reg22 wrote:

i'm sick to death of people coming to these forums to moan about people moaning

This forum is terrible to masty to.

I like tautologies because I like them.
Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

reg22 wrote:

i'm sick to death of people coming to these forums to moan about people moaning

a moan about people moaning about people moaning

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

MOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAANNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN

I like tautologies because I like them.
Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Phoenix doing badly = Users at Phoenix forum won't be happy.

Phoenix doing well = Users at Phoenix forum will be happy.

Am I missing something? Doesn't seem hard to grasp. Once we win a few and look different to what we have been then there'll be a lot of positivity in this forum, I guarantee it.

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Jaume wrote:

Phoenix doing badly = Users at Phoenix forum won't be happy.

Phoenix doing well = Users at Phoenix forum will be happy.

Am I missing something? Doesn't seem hard to grasp. Once we win a few and look different to what we have been then there'll be a lot of positivity in this forum, I guarantee it.

You're new here, aren't you? :p


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Tegal wrote:

it's 2 games into the season. I reserve the right to be flippant. 

I like the way we intend/try to play, Ernie's general philosophy. I feel we have some issues within that, trying to play out with a 'keeper not confident to receive and play to feet and trying to press and win the ball high up the pitch when one of those players high up the pitch doesn't press.

There are issues with tactics that have seen teams able to make it hard for us to create chances, sitting deep looking to counter us. Many games last season followed this pattern, even going back to the end of the previous season, and it was similar against Perth.

Getting better players may allow Ernie to better implement the tactics he wants to employ.

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

How often we give the ball away so easily is a major concern for me and it starts with Moss and finishes with the 10 players in front of him doing the same. High punts from a goalkeeper make it a 50/50 chance of winning except when our very short forwards (Except Watson) try to out jump the big 6'4" defenders. Although Krishna does give it a go.

Proud to have attended the first 175 Consecutive "Home" Wellington Phoenix "A League" Games !!

The Ruf, The Ruf, The Ruf is on Fire!!

Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago

Jaume wrote:

Phoenix doing badly = Users at Phoenix forum won't be happy.

Phoenix doing well = Users at Phoenix forum will be happy.

Am I missing something? Doesn't seem hard to grasp. Once we win a few and look different to what we have been then there'll be a lot of positivity in this forum, I guarantee it.

See: Hudson, Anthony



Permalink Permalink
over 9 years ago · edited over 9 years ago · History

Bullion wrote:

Tegal wrote:

it's 2 games into the season. I reserve the right to be flippant. 

I like the way we intend/try to play, Ernie's general philosophy. I feel we have some issues within that, trying to play out with a 'keeper not confident to receive and play to feet and trying to press and win the ball high up the pitch when one of those players high up the pitch doesn't press.

There are issues with tactics that have seen teams able to make it hard for us to create chances, sitting deep looking to counter us. Many games last season followed this pattern, even going back to the end of the previous season, and it was similar against Perth.

Getting better players may allow Ernie to better implement the tactics he wants to employ.

Don't want to sound harsh - but Ernie has had 3 seasons to get the players he wants. If he doesn't have the players, he needs to modify his tactics. Not rocket science.

a.haak

Permalink Permalink