Ratings tonight
Oi Oi Edgecumbe... lets have a clean sheet
Permalink
Permalink
hmmm
Moss 6 did nothing wrong, exposed to the max
OdOr 4 Struggled first half but better in centre
back
Clebs 3 Woeful, worst was when he got beaten, didn't try to
get back
Dodd 5 looked reasonable again
Lochhead 6 Did his job
Christie 6 More involved than last week
Aloisi 5 sat back, a real shame his header didn't go
in
Ferrante 4 Runs a lot
Daniel 5 Quiet compared to last week
Smeltz 7 Very good, always trying something
Covs 6 good in air
Felipe 7 Go man go
Oi Oi Edgecumbe... lets have a clean sheet
Permalink
Permalink
I'd give Daniel a 3. Thought he was dreadful tonight.
Apparently I'm apathetic, but I couldn't care less.
"Being a Partick Thistle fan sets you apart. It means youre a free thinker. It also means your team has no money." Tim Luckhurst, The Independent, 4th December 2003
Permalink
Permalink
Are we not missing our centre back here or do we not rate him??.i
think his last name stars with C
Permalink
Permalink
I'd give Daniel a 3. Thought he was dreadful tonight.
He wasn't great but a 3 is abit low i think he is good at a 5.
It's just that he did so well last week our expectations were too
high.
Permalink
Permalink
Moss 6 Let down by a sh*te defence
OdOr 2 Makes you appreciate Old - he played that bad/
Clebs 3 Rubbish.
Dodd 5 Average
OdOr 2 Makes you appreciate Old - he played that bad/
Clebs 3 Rubbish.
Dodd 5 Average
Lochhead 5 Avergae
Christie 6 Not bad.
Aloisi 5 Hit the bar, worked hard to no avail
Ferrante 3 Couldnt hit a barn door from a meter away
Daniel 5 Very anonymous
Smeltz 8 Creative, needs someone to help him (FELIPE)
Covs 4 Not liking him so far.
Felipe 8 He's my idol.
* Note: All judgements are until about the 70th minute where I was too pissed to notice much. I did pick up that Felipe played well.
3-0
Permalink
Permalink
I'd give Daniel a 3. Thought he was dreadful tonight.
�
He wasn't great but a 3 is abit low i think he is good at a 5.
It's just that he did so well last week our expectations were too
high.
The fact that Daniel dives all of the time is a real putoff, he needs to get his act together.
He got a yellowcard last week, and one this week, does that mean he's suspended for the next game?
Permalink
Permalink
I'd give Daniel a 3. Thought he was dreadful tonight.
He wasn't great but a 3 is abit low i think he is good at a 5.
It's just that he did so well last week our expectations were too
high.
The fact that Daniel dives all of the time is a real putoff, he needs to get his act together.
He got a yellowcard last week, and one this week, does that mean he's suspended for the next game?
Agree, he's got to stay on his feet more. The refs have worked
him out pretty quickly and he needs to change his game.
Thought we played some very nice stuff in the second half but
by then the horse had bolted, jumped the fence and was eating the
next-door neighbour's flowers.
Permalink
Permalink
felipe seems 2 change the whole team when he comes on, would be
good 2 see daniel an smeltz up front i think to let felipe into the
mids an bring coveny on as a sub
Permalink
Permalink
Id like Brownlie to start with Smeltz, Daniel on nleft Felipe in
middle with Aloisi and brown on the right
Permalink
Permalink
Moss--------6 Again not much could do
O'dor--------4 Left isolated and was poor
Cleberson---4 Tentative and no aggression
Dodd---------6 decent
O'dor--------4 Left isolated and was poor
Cleberson---4 Tentative and no aggression
Dodd---------6 decent
Lochhead----7 did everything well
Christie------5 offered little again
Aloisi---------6 worked hard, good determination
Ferrante ---4 ruined play every time he got the ball, poor set
pieces, passing
Daniel-------5 delivered a few decent corners and free kicks
thats it
Smeltz-------8 strong on the dribble, held up ball well and
worked hard
Coveny-----5 tried hard
Felipe-------8 added spark
linds2007-09-01 11:22:30
Permalink
Permalink
We have nobody who can go past their back four.
Dodd was tremendous and with two other defenders invisible (we've got no right back...no right baaaaack...) he did a lot of good.
News will correct me but I don't think O'Dor (odour?) is a natural right back.
Smeltz was great, would be nice if he had someone to run off him.
As I understand it Felipe isn't fit enough for 90 minutes yet.
Ferrante is, to date, the worst player in the league. Why we have him taking our set pieces I cannot fathom. Still, Tricky's other signings to date have been good so perhaps he'll settle. Too early in the year to write anyone off completely.
Player of the day was undoubtedly the crowd at the Fever Lounge. Superb. And credit to Matt for getting it all ready on time too. Some of the Lab's clientelle from the past (including News's grandma) wandered in and looked VERY put out.
Guy.
smithy2462007-09-01 11:05:43
Dodd was tremendous and with two other defenders invisible (we've got no right back...no right baaaaack...) he did a lot of good.
News will correct me but I don't think O'Dor (odour?) is a natural right back.
Smeltz was great, would be nice if he had someone to run off him.
As I understand it Felipe isn't fit enough for 90 minutes yet.
Ferrante is, to date, the worst player in the league. Why we have him taking our set pieces I cannot fathom. Still, Tricky's other signings to date have been good so perhaps he'll settle. Too early in the year to write anyone off completely.
Player of the day was undoubtedly the crowd at the Fever Lounge. Superb. And credit to Matt for getting it all ready on time too. Some of the Lab's clientelle from the past (including News's grandma) wandered in and looked VERY put out.
Guy.
smithy2462007-09-01 11:05:43
Incredible stamina. No shame. Yellow Fever.
Permalink
Permalink