Closed for new posts
Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
almost 13 years

Bullion wrote:

at the end of Ernie's first preseason we played acfc and signed hicks and Riera, just as last minute.

And this A Rod into defence thing is totally a tactic barca and spain use with busquets. Site search zonalmarking for some nice diagrams, possibly even a gif. Even the McGlinchy as a forward reeks of barca and Spain's use of false 9. Gareth will be pleased :p

A key part of how Barca play though is having their defensive line pushed extremely high up the pitch so they can press hard on the opposition and win the ball back quickly if they lose it. That  doesn't work if your defensive line is deeper because there's too much space between your forwards and your backs for the midfield to try to cover. If the opposition beat the first line of pressing they have effectively released the pressure. The flip side is Barca are vulnerable to counterattacks into the space behind their defence, so the keeper often acts as a sweeper. Although then he risks getting caught off his line by long shots, like happened in the game against Roma a couple of weeks ago. Because of Barca's high line, the distance that Busquets has to cover between being in a good position for a CB role to being in a good position for a DM role as is required isn't very far and they can transition easily between the two shapes. Pep has also done a similar thing with Lahm at Bayern too.

.

From the Nix perspective, we can't play a high line effectively because Siggy and Dura are too slow, and Moss isn't the sort of Neuer-esque sweeper keeper we require. I'm not saying A Rod dropping into the backline when fullbacks advance can't work for us, but I don't think it'll work the way Barca use it.

One in a million
4.4K
·
9.6K
·
over 17 years

Bullion wrote:

at the end of Ernie's first preseason we played acfc and signed hicks and Riera, just as last minute.

And this A Rod into defence thing is totally a tactic barca and spain use with busquets. Site search zonalmarking for some nice diagrams, possibly even a gif. Even the McGlinchy as a forward reeks of barca and Spain's use of false 9. Gareth will be pleased :p

A key part of how Barca play though is having their defensive line pushed extremely high up the pitch so they can press hard on the opposition and win the ball back quickly if they lose it. That  doesn't work if your defensive line is deeper because there's too much space between your forwards and your backs for the midfield to try to cover. If the opposition beat the first line of pressing they have effectively released the pressure. The flip side is Barca are vulnerable to counterattacks into the space behind their defence, so the keeper often acts as a sweeper. Although then he risks getting caught off his line by long shots, like happened in the game against Roma a couple of weeks ago. Because of Barca's high line, the distance that Busquets has to cover between being in a good position for a CB role to being in a good position for a DM role as is required isn't very far and they can transition easily between the two shapes. Pep has also done a similar thing with Lahm at Bayern too.

.

From the Nix perspective, we can't play a high line effectively because Siggy and Dura are too slow, and Moss isn't the sort of Neuer-esque sweeper keeper we require. I'm not saying A Rod dropping into the backline when fullbacks advance can't work for us, but I don't think it'll work the way Barca use it.

A Rod isn't exactly a speed merchant either

Starting XI
430
·
2.6K
·
almost 17 years

energy24.7 wrote:

My take on the whole third centre back - three at the back thing is that none of Lia/Manny/Rodriguez will ever play as one of the main 2 (unless really desperate) and that's never been Merrick's intention. As Dura mentioned on Phoenix City pod Lia and Rodriguez will be dropping back from midfield to be a temporary CB when we lose possession. The only reason they've played as one of the 'proper' CBs in pre season is to get used to the duties of the role.

My biggest worry, and I know it's been said before, is when either Siggy or Dura go down injured/suspended which is almost inevitable at some point during the season. Who then plays CB? As noted earlier I don't think any of Manny/Lia/Arod are starters at CB. I've seen nothing from Doyle that would suggest he'd be any better, and would prefer him to concentrate on nailing LB. Danaskos? That's a huge if currently, and he hasn't been billed as a CB on any of the official releases. I guess we're relying on a youth spot like DaMairo which would be a big leap in his first season.

Point is, regardless of which of these options they choose, I'm going to be very nervous this season about the health of Siggy/Dura.

Marquee
1.4K
·
5.3K
·
about 17 years

Bullion wrote:

at the end of Ernie's first preseason we played acfc and signed hicks and Riera, just as last minute.

And this A Rod into defence thing is totally a tactic barca and spain use with busquets. Site search zonalmarking for some nice diagrams, possibly even a gif. Even the McGlinchy as a forward reeks of barca and Spain's use of false 9. Gareth will be pleased :p

A key part of how Barca play though is having their defensive line pushed extremely high up the pitch so they can press hard on the opposition and win the ball back quickly if they lose it. That  doesn't work if your defensive line is deeper because there's too much space between your forwards and your backs for the midfield to try to cover. If the opposition beat the first line of pressing they have effectively released the pressure. The flip side is Barca are vulnerable to counterattacks into the space behind their defence, so the keeper often acts as a sweeper. Although then he risks getting caught off his line by long shots, like happened in the game against Roma a couple of weeks ago. Because of Barca's high line, the distance that Busquets has to cover between being in a good position for a CB role to being in a good position for a DM role as is required isn't very far and they can transition easily between the two shapes. Pep has also done a similar thing with Lahm at Bayern too.

.

From the Nix perspective, we can't play a high line effectively because Siggy and Dura are too slow, and Moss isn't the sort of Neuer-esque sweeper keeper we require. I'm not saying A Rod dropping into the backline when fullbacks advance can't work for us, but I don't think it'll work the way Barca use it.

Yeah, fair enough. Though seems very much like it the way it has been described.

Just weemac dropping deeper from the central attacking position. I suppose it is another string our bow and could be used depending on the opposition.

http://www.zonalmarking.net/2010/07/16/sergio-busquets-world-cup-final/

http://www.zonalmarking.net/2010/04/22/is-the-sweeper-set-for-a-return-to-prominence/

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
about 15 years

I personally would look at using Doyle as a left sided CB. I think he is more CB than WB and has the height for it. He does not need to get forward and he has Durante beside him. The alternative in Manny as a right sided CB and I am not in favour of that because he is rash with his challenges and tends to be flat footed and get beaten.

Appiah without the pace
6.8K
·
19K
·
about 17 years

Bullion wrote:

Bullion wrote:

at the end of Ernie's first preseason we played acfc and signed hicks and Riera, just as last minute.

And this A Rod into defence thing is totally a tactic barca and spain use with busquets. Site search zonalmarking for some nice diagrams, possibly even a gif. Even the McGlinchy as a forward reeks of barca and Spain's use of false 9. Gareth will be pleased :p

A key part of how Barca play though is having their defensive line pushed extremely high up the pitch so they can press hard on the opposition and win the ball back quickly if they lose it. That  doesn't work if your defensive line is deeper because there's too much space between your forwards and your backs for the midfield to try to cover. If the opposition beat the first line of pressing they have effectively released the pressure. The flip side is Barca are vulnerable to counterattacks into the space behind their defence, so the keeper often acts as a sweeper. Although then he risks getting caught off his line by long shots, like happened in the game against Roma a couple of weeks ago. Because of Barca's high line, the distance that Busquets has to cover between being in a good position for a CB role to being in a good position for a DM role as is required isn't very far and they can transition easily between the two shapes. Pep has also done a similar thing with Lahm at Bayern too.

.

From the Nix perspective, we can't play a high line effectively because Siggy and Dura are too slow, and Moss isn't the sort of Neuer-esque sweeper keeper we require. I'm not saying A Rod dropping into the backline when fullbacks advance can't work for us, but I don't think it'll work the way Barca use it.

Yeah, fair enough. Though seems very much like it the way it has been described.

Just weemac dropping deeper from the central attacking position. I suppose it is another string our bow and could be used depending on the opposition.

http://www.zonalmarking.net/2010/07/16 /sergio-busquets-world-cup-final/

http://www.zonalmarking.net/2010/04/22/is-the-sweeper-set-for-a-return-to-prominence/

  mighty ducks flying V
Legend
1.8K
·
22K
·
almost 16 years

I'd go for dribbling tiger, bounce pass dragon tactics.

Works a treat every time

Moar stars
2.1K
·
4.8K
·
over 12 years

Whoops. I thought I clicked on Yellow Fever Forum not the Football Manager 2016 Forum..... Jesus.

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
almost 13 years

nufc_nz wrote:

Whoops. I thought I clicked on Yellow Fever Forum not the Football Manager 2016 Forum..... Jesus.

Yeah, pretty shocking to find a discussion of football tactics on a football forum. 
and 5 others
First Team Squad
170
·
1.1K
·
about 17 years

hlmphil wrote:

energy24.7 wrote:

My take on the whole third centre back - three at the back thing is that none of Lia/Manny/Rodriguez will ever play as one of the main 2 (unless really desperate) and that's never been Merrick's intention. As Dura mentioned on Phoenix City pod Lia and Rodriguez will be dropping back from midfield to be a temporary CB when we lose possession. The only reason they've played as one of the 'proper' CBs in pre season is to get used to the duties of the role.

My biggest worry, and I know it's been said before, is when either Siggy or Dura go down injured/suspended which is almost inevitable at some point during the season. Who then plays CB? As noted earlier I don't think any of Manny/Lia/Arod are starters at CB. I've seen nothing from Doyle that would suggest he'd be any better, and would prefer him to concentrate on nailing LB. Danaskos? That's a huge if currently, and he hasn't been billed as a CB on any of the official releases. I guess we're relying on a youth spot like DaMairo which would be a big leap in his first season.

Point is, regardless of which of these options they choose, I'm going to be very nervous this season about the health of Siggy/Dura.

Yep I have the same concern. My guess is Doyle and Muscat are the two options there. Ok options but not ideal. I feel like Doyle may actually come good there - it's a relatively simple role so given the chance to concentrate on it, not having to worry about going forward, could do a job.

valeo
·
Legend
4.7K
·
18K
·
over 17 years

hlmphil wrote:

energy24.7 wrote:

My take on the whole third centre back - three at the back thing is that none of Lia/Manny/Rodriguez will ever play as one of the main 2 (unless really desperate) and that's never been Merrick's intention. As Dura mentioned on Phoenix City pod Lia and Rodriguez will be dropping back from midfield to be a temporary CB when we lose possession. The only reason they've played as one of the 'proper' CBs in pre season is to get used to the duties of the role.

My biggest worry, and I know it's been said before, is when either Siggy or Dura go down injured/suspended which is almost inevitable at some point during the season. Who then plays CB? As noted earlier I don't think any of Manny/Lia/Arod are starters at CB. I've seen nothing from Doyle that would suggest he'd be any better, and would prefer him to concentrate on nailing LB. Danaskos? That's a huge if currently, and he hasn't been billed as a CB on any of the official releases. I guess we're relying on a youth spot like DaMairo which would be a big leap in his first season.

Point is, regardless of which of these options they choose, I'm going to be very nervous this season about the health of Siggy/Dura.

Doesn't help that Siggy is already fighting several niggles.

Marquee
3.8K
·
5.9K
·
over 17 years

After what was posted by valeo and also mentioned by me elswhere im guessing himphil you are spending your days in a padded room and the season hasnt even started.LOL

Marquee
420
·
6.3K
·
over 17 years

valeo wrote:

hlmphil wrote:

energy24.7 wrote:

My take on the whole third centre back - three at the back thing is that none of Lia/Manny/Rodriguez will ever play as one of the main 2 (unless really desperate) and that's never been Merrick's intention. As Dura mentioned on Phoenix City pod Lia and Rodriguez will be dropping back from midfield to be a temporary CB when we lose possession. The only reason they've played as one of the 'proper' CBs in pre season is to get used to the duties of the role.

My biggest worry, and I know it's been said before, is when either Siggy or Dura go down injured/suspended which is almost inevitable at some point during the season. Who then plays CB? As noted earlier I don't think any of Manny/Lia/Arod are starters at CB. I've seen nothing from Doyle that would suggest he'd be any better, and would prefer him to concentrate on nailing LB. Danaskos? That's a huge if currently, and he hasn't been billed as a CB on any of the official releases. I guess we're relying on a youth spot like DaMairo which would be a big leap in his first season.

Point is, regardless of which of these options they choose, I'm going to be very nervous this season about the health of Siggy/Dura.

Doesn't help that Siggy is already fighting several niggles.

racist

Moar stars
2.1K
·
4.8K
·
over 12 years

nufc_nz wrote:

Whoops. I thought I clicked on Yellow Fever Forum not the Football Manager 2016 Forum..... Jesus.

Yeah, pretty shocking to find a discussion of football tactics on a football forum. 

Sorry Fergie... As you were fellas.

Marquee
4.5K
·
6.8K
·
about 14 years

Jeff Vader wrote:

I personally would look at using Doyle as a left sided CB. I think he is more CB than WB and has the height for it. He does not need to get forward and he has Durante beside him. The alternative in Manny as a right sided CB and I am not in favour of that because he is rash with his challenges and tends to be flat footed and get beaten.

I agree with that. I was looking forward to seeing Boxall grow into that role and it's a shame he's gone as he was faster than Doyle on his feet IMHO. That boat (Boxall) has sailed now, but no reason not to try to get Doyle moulded into that role.

Opinion Privileges revoked
5.2K
·
10K
·
almost 15 years

Cosimo wrote:

valeo wrote:

Doesn't help that Siggy is already fighting several niggles.

racist

I am so ashamed of myself for cracking up laughing at that gag.

Marquee
4.5K
·
6.8K
·
about 14 years

Ah, the last barren days of pre-season.

Phoenix Academy
110
·
400
·
about 15 years

Just had a look at the summary of ins and outs for all the teams. There is massive turnover in many teams but relatively less
for Nix Victory and Roar. For me squad stability for a "succesful" team seems important. So Nix making finals last year wih similar squad is a good starting point. While losing Burns and 10+ goals and defensive cover in Boxall seems to be detrimental maybe shrewd recruitment to refresh some areas and that some key players are into their 2nd or 3rd seasons (Roly, A rod, weemac and Albert

Legend
7.8K
·
15K
·
about 17 years

Transfer spec. Defender. Michael whatsit.

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
almost 13 years

martinb wrote:

Transfer spec. Defender. Michael whatsit.

Boxall?
Legend
7.8K
·
15K
·
about 17 years
WeeNix
170
·
670
·
over 11 years
Starting XI
1.6K
·
2.6K
·
about 17 years
Listen here Fudgeface
3.7K
·
15K
·
over 14 years
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
over 17 years
WeeNix
170
·
670
·
over 11 years

Killen???   ;)

HZA
Marquee
630
·
5.9K
·
about 15 years
Chant Savant
2.5K
·
12K
·
over 17 years
HZA
Marquee
630
·
5.9K
·
about 15 years

We actually need to sign a proper CB replacement don't we?... just do that

One in a million
4.4K
·
9.6K
·
over 17 years
HZA
Marquee
630
·
5.9K
·
about 15 years
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
over 17 years

HZA wrote:

We actually need to sign a proper CB replacement don't we?... just do that

Bobo Balde?

Marquee
4.5K
·
6.8K
·
about 14 years

C-Diddy wrote:

Obama?

Barack or Michelle?

valeo
·
Legend
4.7K
·
18K
·
over 17 years

I'd be surprised if Tam wasn't signed; though Danaskos may be in his way now unless Ernie views Doyle as specialist CB cover.

Overseas
630
·
2.7K
·
about 17 years

Ernie says he's looking for cover for RB.... Someone mentioned him earlier but Matthew Foschini. Is versatile and desperate for a gig.

Legend
7.8K
·
15K
·
about 17 years

has Gulley made the grade?

valeo
·
Legend
4.7K
·
18K
·
over 17 years

From Danaskos 

"The signing of Danaskos adds to the club's defensive stocks – he describes himself as an attacking left midfielder or left-sided centre back.



Read more: http://www.3news.co.nz/sport/wellington-phoenix-sign-troy-danaskos-2015100217#ixzz3nSPL01aB

Those are two very different positions..though he was signed as a left wing back?

Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
over 17 years

guess it's a sort of in between of those two positions!

The better Barnes
210
·
360
·
almost 13 years

Maybe he hasn't quite failed as a winger or centre back yet...


Legend
7.8K
·
15K
·
about 17 years

left footed winger/wing-back not a defender/ not a forward

ready for the season!!

Closed for new posts