And out of those three, I hope that it is Fred that gets the chop
All Whites, Ferns, and other international teams
New Zealand U-23s - Quali Whites
Next question is: If someone here in NZF is in the wrong, will they fall on the sword or will they have to be pushed?
Option C: none of the above.
Nobody will fall on their sword, and there is nobody around to do the pushing. It is a mutual appreciation society.
Incredible stamina. No shame. Yellow Fever.
I'm not a lawyer and I respect all those who have studied the statues and formed an opinion. The only thing I'd say on this is that in similar situations the Aussies realised they needed exemption clearance for Abini and the yanks realised they needed exemption clearance for Gedion Zelalem. We on the other hand either didn't realise or chose to ignore it.
For those who believe it is a big OFC conspiracy; from what I can see even if we were playing in Asia, Deklan is still ineligible and we would have defaulted 3-0.
And out of those three, I hope that it is Fred that gets the chop
because of some man love for Mr Pickstock and Hudson I assume?
This is just the latest in a series of farces that FDJ has presided over. Not sure how many own goals he needs to score before he gets the shove. Such a shame because I used to enjoy watching him for the Kingz. Good feet for a big man.
Incredible stamina. No shame. Yellow Fever.
Just saw Gourdies vid. He pretty much laid blame solely at the feet of Rob Pickstock and FDJ with Hudson being an accessory
Yeah, Gourdie sums things up pretty well in the vid:
If NZF didn't get dispensation from FIFA for Wynne to play for NZ, I think their appeal is doomed.
But we don't know all the facts yet, so it's going to be really frustrating until we have them and the appeal process runs its course.
Big Pete 65, Christchurch
And out of those three, I hope that it is Fred that gets the chop
because of some man love for Mr Pickstock and Hudson I assume?
This is just the latest in a series of farces that FDJ has presided over. Not sure how many own goals he needs to score before he gets the shove. Such a shame because I used to enjoy watching him for the Kingz. Good feet for a big man.
I'm not on the defend FDJ boat (although Vader will say I am) - but i think any organisation which allows such continual cockups and general incompetance at most levels can't be blamed on one person. Something there needs a shake up and i prefer not to focus on the sacking of this person or this person because if that person did leave won't the next person be allowed to make the same mistakes?
And out of those three, I hope that it is Fred that gets the chop
because of some man love for Mr Pickstock and Hudson I assume?
This is just the latest in a series of farces that FDJ has presided over. Not sure how many own goals he needs to score before he gets the shove. Such a shame because I used to enjoy watching him for the Kingz. Good feet for a big man.
I'm not on the defend FDJ boat (although Vader will say I am) - but i think any organisation which allows such continual cockups and general incompetance at most levels can't be blamed on one person. Something there needs a shake up and i prefer not to focus on the sacking of this person or this person because if that person did leave won't the next person be allowed to make the same mistakes?
That is fair.
"FDJ Out" is my favourite hobby horse so I couldn't resist giving it a little nudge.
Poor old Deklan aye, this really is his Wynnter of Discontent.
Incredible stamina. No shame. Yellow Fever.
Interesting to hear that Hudson will front the media session tomorrow as well with Martin.
Hudson seems pretty outspoken, so if someone from within NZF has stuffed up I'd expect him to say just as much.
How pathetic is it calling an 11:30pm presser at the airport. If they had any guts they'd do it at 9am tomorrow. Such a childish play.
Incredible stamina. No shame. Yellow Fever.
OK. I’m confident (mildly) of a good outcome. Notwithstanding that Articles 5,6 & 7, taken together, seem to me to written to befuddle any reader wanting to establish eligibility around bithplace, residence etc. I’m assuming there are no other regulations that apply and impact (there may well be of course).
There are all sorts of ways to look at things when taking those 3 articles together, depending on where you place the emphasis. Many at present (especially media) putting emphasis on the a,b,c,d conditions of article 7 (lived 5 years after 18 etc).
I’m gonna put my emphasis on Article 5. Why? It has greater gravitas. Why? Because Art. 5 is the ‘Principles’. They are the first article under the section ‘eligibility to play for representative teams’. As principles, they have gotta hold a bit of gravitas.
Article 5 cl. 1 is as follows: ‘Any person holding a permanent nationality that is not dependent on residence in a certain country is eligible to play for the representative teams of the association of that country.’
So, he’s perfectly entitled to play for NZ? I don’t see much in the remainder of5, 6 or 7 that rules him out. It’s a minefield however. Many things need to be established first (like proving that the implication within Art.7 is that Art. 7 is intended to apply only if you are trying to change from representing one country to representing another. He’s been sitting around for years with 2 options: represent SA or NZ. When the time came he chose NZ (as he’s entitled to according to ‘principles’ of Art.5 cl.1)
Great for lawyers, however, things considered I think I’ld rather be a lawyer on the NZ side. I’m not a lawyer so probably completely wrong. Comments?
Here’s the actual doc:
The issue is that his permanent nationality (his passport) indeed is dependent on residence within this country (you get a passport by getting residence and then serving your time).
However you cut, slice or dice this we are screwed
However, I don't think that "Art. 7 is intended to apply only if you are trying to change from representing one country to representing another." - because if it is then there's nothing in those regulations to stop countries just handing out passports to talented players who haven't represented their birth nation. And countries definitely do that sort of thing - in fact I believe NZ fast-tracked Irene van Dyk's citizenship so she could play netball for us. That very situation is why the rule exists, and Wynn's situation is why exemptions to it have been granted. The key questions really seem to be whether he's had an exemption granted, and whether OFC followed due process.
At least that's how I read it.
You're right, it's section 8 that deals with that scenario. Section 7 applies because Deklan doesn't have permanent NZ nationality, as he wasn't a NZ national at birth (i.e. he has legitimately acquired NZ nationality, but hasn't always been a NZ national).
How pathetic is it calling an 11:30pm presser at the airport. If they had any guts they'd do it at 9am tomorrow. Such a childish play.
Ha, I bet if they held it at 9am there would be people complaining that they should have fronted up as soon as they got off the plane. However 11:30pm does give the media time to get more copy together for the morning news so maybe its a good idea?
Everyone loses in this. Simply the worst event I can think of in NZF history during my time here of over 50 years.
How pathetic is it calling an 11:30pm presser at the airport. If they had any guts they'd do it at 9am tomorrow. Such a childish play.
Ha, I bet if they held it at 9am there would be people complaining that they should have fronted up as soon as they got off the plane. However 11:30pm does give the media time to get more copy together for the morning news so maybe its a good idea?
Everyone loses in this. Simply the worst event I can think of in NZF history during my time here of over 50 years.
I still think making kids pay a fee to play for their national team was a lower ebb than this.
Incredible stamina. No shame. Yellow Fever.
How pathetic is it calling an 11:30pm presser at the airport. If they had any guts they'd do it at 9am tomorrow. Such a childish play.
Ha, I bet if they held it at 9am there would be people complaining that they should have fronted up as soon as they got off the plane. However 11:30pm does give the media time to get more copy together for the morning news so maybe its a good idea?
Everyone loses in this. Simply the worst event I can think of in NZF history during my time here of over 50 years.
I still think making kids pay a fee to play for their national team was a lower ebb than this.
Very True.

How pathetic is it calling an 11:30pm presser at the airport. If they had any guts they'd do it at 9am tomorrow. Such a childish play.
Ha, I bet if they held it at 9am there would be people complaining that they should have fronted up as soon as they got off the plane. However 11:30pm does give the media time to get more copy together for the morning news so maybe its a good idea?
Everyone loses in this. Simply the worst event I can think of in NZF history during my time here of over 50 years.
What's sight without sound? Love without peace? Copulation without conception?
How pathetic is it calling an 11:30pm presser at the airport. If they had any guts they'd do it at 9am tomorrow. Such a childish play.
Ha, I bet if they held it at 9am there would be people complaining that they should have fronted up as soon as they got off the plane. However 11:30pm does give the media time to get more copy together for the morning news so maybe its a good idea?
Everyone loses in this. Simply the worst event I can think of in NZF history during my time here of over 50 years.
Interesting. I disagree with almost all of that.
I think if you look at NZF's behaviour they don't usually do the thing they think is "best" or "the most straight up". They will have organised this presser at a time which they think generates the least media attention without being ridiculous.
They will certainly blow smoke. As if that is even in doubt.
The Board are just there to hire people and set strategy. This is a management issue, unless the Board want to sack Andy Martin over it they really don't have any place fronting things.
Incredible stamina. No shame. Yellow Fever.
Tribulietx for Head Coach?
"Phoenix till they lose"
Posting 97% bollox, 8% lies and 3.658% genuine opinion.
Genuine opinion: FTFFA
Probably a good thing that Ramon didn't get the Brisbane gig then.
Yellow Fever - Misery loves company
How pathetic is it calling an 11:30pm presser at the airport. If they had any guts they'd do it at 9am tomorrow. Such a childish play.
Ha, I bet if they held it at 9am there would be people complaining that they should have fronted up as soon as they got off the plane. However 11:30pm does give the media time to get more copy together for the morning news so maybe its a good idea?
Everyone loses in this. Simply the worst event I can think of in NZF history during my time here of over 50 years.
Interesting. I disagree with almost all of that.
I think if you look at NZF's behaviour they don't usually do the thing they think is "best" or "the most straight up". They will have organised this presser at a time which they think generates the least media attention without being ridiculous.
They will certainly blow smoke. As if that is even in doubt.
The Board are just there to hire people and set strategy. This is a management issue, unless the Board want to sack Andy Martin over it they really don't have any place fronting things.
Yep. Failure to confirm eligibility is squarely management as is contesting the fairness of a disciplinary process.
"Phoenix till they lose"
Posting 97% bollox, 8% lies and 3.658% genuine opinion.
Genuine opinion: FTFFA
I hate the fact they are making Deklan himself front the media. As if any blame can be apportioned to him.
With respect to "would Hudson walk?".
What does he lose with the Olympics, 3 valuable games and however many warmup games with his team. Then once that is over he would have 18 moths or so before a WC qualifier?.
So are NZF capable of putting in place a schedule of games to help partly compensate for the lack of an Olympic campaign?
With respect to "would Hudson walk?".
What does he lose with the Olympics, 3 valuable games and however many warmup games with his team. Then once that is over he would have 18 moths or so before a WC qualifier?.
So are NZF capable of putting in place a schedule of games to help partly compensate for the lack of an Olympic campaign?
Yellow Fever - Misery loves company
How pathetic is it calling an 11:30pm presser at the airport. If they had any guts they'd do it at 9am tomorrow. Such a childish play.
Ha, I bet if they held it at 9am there would be people complaining that they should have fronted up as soon as they got off the plane. However 11:30pm does give the media time to get more copy together for the morning news so maybe its a good idea?
Everyone loses in this. Simply the worst event I can think of in NZF history during my time here of over 50 years.
I still think making kids pay a fee to play for their national team was a lower ebb than this.
Think its the same level of horrible; in both cases theyve completely let down the team.
a.haak

With respect to "would Hudson walk?".
What does he lose with the Olympics, 3 valuable games and however many warmup games with his team. Then once that is over he would have 18 moths or so before a WC qualifier?.
So are NZF capable of putting in place a schedule of games to help partly compensate for the lack of an Olympic campaign?
Grumpy old bastard alert
With respect to "would Hudson walk?".
What does he lose with the Olympics, 3 valuable games and however many warmup games with his team. Then once that is over he would have 18 moths or so before a WC qualifier?.
So are NZF capable of putting in place a schedule of games to help partly compensate for the lack of an Olympic campaign?
Maybe we could organise a 4 team tournament with some of the island nations, 3 games in 3 days held in Dunedin july next year
With respect to "would Hudson walk?".
What does he lose with the Olympics, 3 valuable games and however many warmup games with his team. Then once that is over he would have 18 moths or so before a WC qualifier?.
So are NZF capable of putting in place a schedule of games to help partly compensate for the lack of an Olympic campaign?
And out of those three, I hope that it is Fred that gets the chop
because of some man love for Mr Pickstock and Hudson I assume?
This is just the latest in a series of farces that FDJ has presided over. Not sure how many own goals he needs to score before he gets the shove. Such a shame because I used to enjoy watching him for the Kingz. Good feet for a big man.
I'm not on the defend FDJ boat (although Vader will say I am) - but i think any organisation which allows such continual cockups and general incompetance at most levels can't be blamed on one person. Something there needs a shake up and i prefer not to focus on the sacking of this person or this person because if that person did leave won't the next person be allowed to make the same mistakes?
.
I know his tie to Ellerslie and yours so it is also reasonable as an associate, to perhaps look at his performance with rosier coloured eyes than others. I would ask to you, fairly, what has he done that's been good in his time there. He may have some wins, but you would not know it. Perhaps they are out of sight of the general public? I would actually like to hear them cause I want our high performance guy to be making positive differences.
.
Giving the chance for a good case to be presented for FDJ, you have to say that a decent chunk of it does not look good but I do leave my ears open to hear the other side of it.
Grumpy old bastard alert
What to expect in the media conference:
(1) Andy Martin and FDJ announce they are stepping down to allow the Boy Wonder Hudson to become the first person in history to be simultaneously CEO, technical director and national coach of an association.
#alignment
Hudson: "I like a high pressing style in administration - so right now I'm going to spray words around like Barcelona does passes and you journos won't be able to get a word in edgeways...."
(2) Deklan Wynne reveals he is the secret love child of an All Black who was seeking consolation after the 1995 Rugby World Cup loss in South Africa. Think about it - the dates match up... Wynne is 20.
Therefore he is eligible after all....
Later, Declan Edge and Wynton Rufer lay rival claims to adopting him at birth and being exclusively responsible for developing his football skills - and even naming him. "Deklan" = obviously Declan E. "Wynne" = WYNERS. Obviously....
Big Pete 65, Christchurch
How do you think of this stuff at this hour? Very good.
Does anyone know how we can hear the conference or do we wait for an edit tomorrow?
- hope there are a few sharks thrown in. Ramon are you waiting in the wings?
"Ufuk with the Club, Ufuk with the Country".
If your girlfriend's got gloves, she's a keeper.
And out of those three, I hope that it is Fred that gets the chop
because of some man love for Mr Pickstock and Hudson I assume?
This is just the latest in a series of farces that FDJ has presided over. Not sure how many own goals he needs to score before he gets the shove. Such a shame because I used to enjoy watching him for the Kingz. Good feet for a big man.
I'm not on the defend FDJ boat (although Vader will say I am) - but i think any organisation which allows such continual cockups and general incompetance at most levels can't be blamed on one person. Something there needs a shake up and i prefer not to focus on the sacking of this person or this person because if that person did leave won't the next person be allowed to make the same mistakes?
.
I know his tie to Ellerslie and yours so it is also reasonable as an associate, to perhaps look at his performance with rosier coloured eyes than others. I would ask to you, fairly, what has he done that's been good in his time there. He may have some wins, but you would not know it. Perhaps they are out of sight of the general public? I would actually like to hear them cause I want our high performance guy to be making positive differences.
.
Giving the chance for a good case to be presented for FDJ, you have to say that a decent chunk of it does not look good but I do leave my ears open to hear the other side of it.
i'm not on here to defend him - i'm here saying if you sack him and Pickstock do you honestly believe that will turn around NZF - if not then are the problems deeper than them.
Personally like i said earlier NZF have been a shambles for a while and while FDJ in a lot of peoples eyes has not covered himself in roses the NZF office was not functioning before his reign either.
The amount of turnover of office staff there is pretty massive - every couple of years there is a cleanout of people, that can't be good - so what is the problem there, culture? accountability? pure arrogance?
How pathetic is it calling an 11:30pm presser at the airport. If they had any guts they'd do it at 9am tomorrow. Such a childish play.
And out of those three, I hope that it is Fred that gets the chop
because of some man love for Mr Pickstock and Hudson I assume?
This is just the latest in a series of farces that FDJ has presided over. Not sure how many own goals he needs to score before he gets the shove. Such a shame because I used to enjoy watching him for the Kingz. Good feet for a big man.
I'm not on the defend FDJ boat (although Vader will say I am) - but i think any organisation which allows such continual cockups and general incompetance at most levels can't be blamed on one person. Something there needs a shake up and i prefer not to focus on the sacking of this person or this person because if that person did leave won't the next person be allowed to make the same mistakes?
.
I know his tie to Ellerslie and yours so it is also reasonable as an associate, to perhaps look at his performance with rosier coloured eyes than others. I would ask to you, fairly, what has he done that's been good in his time there. He may have some wins, but you would not know it. Perhaps they are out of sight of the general public? I would actually like to hear them cause I want our high performance guy to be making positive differences.
.
Giving the chance for a good case to be presented for FDJ, you have to say that a decent chunk of it does not look good but I do leave my ears open to hear the other side of it.
i'm not on here to defend him - i'm here saying if you sack him and Pickstock do you honestly believe that will turn around NZF - if not then are the problems deeper than them.
Personally like i said earlier NZF have been a shambles for a while and while FDJ in a lot of peoples eyes has not covered himself in roses the NZF office was not functioning before his reign either.
The amount of turnover of office staff there is pretty massive - every couple of years there is a cleanout of people, that can't be good - so what is the problem there, culture? accountability? pure arrogance?
So are you saying that FDJ shouldn't be sacked just because the problems might (probably do) run deeper than him? Because if he has done an awful job, and I think a lot of people on here believe he has, then he should walk no matter how deep the rot is.
And out of those three, I hope that it is Fred that gets the chop
because of some man love for Mr Pickstock and Hudson I assume?
This is just the latest in a series of farces that FDJ has presided over. Not sure how many own goals he needs to score before he gets the shove. Such a shame because I used to enjoy watching him for the Kingz. Good feet for a big man.
I'd have to say that Fred has scored more (own)goals while managing NZ then he managed playing for NZ!!!
NZ Footall system of checking - have they got a NZ passport. Yes. Sweet!
Take that Vanuatu!
New Zealand Football @NZ_Football
RECORD WIN l The #FutsalWhites hit their highest tally on home soil in Sunday's win v Vanuatu! http://bit.ly/1TuKg2L
I am prepared to wait and hear all the facts before I pass judgement. Though its been hugely entertaining reading 30 pages of legalise and angst and rage.
I want NZF to show the FIFA clearance that they obtained for Wynn....either for the senior AW's or the U20's.
Because it seems to me that unless they can show that clearance then we are Toast. OFC kicked us out under a FIFA rule. We have to counter argue using FIFA's regulations. We can argue about unfair process or what ever but if we did not clear the player then I can't see what case we have to argue.
I don't have a good feeling about this at all. I think NZF has stuffed up. Its not Hudsons fault. He selects...the managers clear eligibility. if we lose this then its a massive setback for the AW program. The Olympics was Hudsons major plan to field a shadow AW team. I think he will seriously consider his further role. He is a young ambitious coach. He must now realise this region is an amateur joke.
If NZF did not have a proper process to clear eligibility for anyone selected for NZ, then heads should roll. The alarm bells should have rung when Hudson stated we would search the globe for players. Anyone who was not a NZer from birth should have been carefully checked out. At the moment I will give them the benefit of doubt. But I feel this is not going to end well.
I can't blame Vanuatu for the way they acted. However I have a real real problem with the way OFC is run and managed.