All Whites, Ferns, and other international teams

The next All Whites coach

1207 replies · 212,695 views
30 Nov 06:10

I trust JV's and his source, he may be an old curmudgeon but he is no troll. If he has the word that its not Emblen then I will go with that.


As for Raul Blanco. Great CV....really experianced guy who is highly regarded for his technical knowledge of football. Probably one of the unsung hereos of the AW's South africa campaign. Would make a great coach EXCEPT for his age. 71 now would make him 76 for WC Russia 2018. Way too old. If NZ goes into the Asia playoff it would involve a lot of really long haul travel. Not the place for a guy in his  70's. Guus Hiddink is moving out of international football and he is 67, Marcello Lippi is talking of retiring soon and he is 65. Sorry but Blanco is too old.


Who we get as coach depends on the WC playoff setup. If it stays the way it is now with us getting a two headed playoff against a side from either CONCACAFF or AFC or CONCOBOL?? Then we could probably get away with a local coach to get us through the next few years and then get some good international technical backup to help when it came to the playoffs. However if we are in the final playoff round in Asia then its all completely different. We would have at least 8 full on high pressure games, possibly 10 if the pools are enlarged. We will need a high level coach with experiance, preferably in Asia.


Thats when names like Graham Arnold come in. If he does his two years coaching in Japan then the timing would be perfect to get him in for the two+ year run up to the WC.....his contract finishes May 20 2015????? at the end of the Jap season. Other possibilities would be Vidmar...who has taken a club team to the AFC Champions league final and was/is OZ assistant coach. Might not pass the "no dicks" test though. We are going to need a coach who knows what its like managing a team in high pressure games in places like Seoul and Tehran. If we are going to playoff in Asia then its no point NZF nickle and diming on a coach. 


Other names like Elliot and Nelson have only just finished playing. They need to go and spend 4+ years coaching and prove themselves first.

30 Nov 06:14

Blanco was coaching the MacArthur Rams from 08 until 2010, He still has a role there but i don't know what. Before then it was Marconi in 02/03.

Even though his name was brought up when i did some sniffing around. What makes Raul Blanco any better then say Wynton Rufer (please no laughing) who has more coaching experience then Simon Elliot?. Okon is doing well but is still learning his trade. Would the public go for that? Would it be Blasphemy!!! 

And do we get a coach now or after the draw? Like Australia did in 2005 to conquer Uruguay with Guus Hiddink?




Mr Positive

30 Nov 06:21

Blanco would be a massive step back.

30 Nov 06:31
Well Vader if this is correct I am glad I called you on your sauce. By the way I don think you are a troll but knew it would make you divulge a little more, so I am glad it worked. What does everyone think of Raul? I can see the positives but to be honest wanted a clean break and something new

well played to you sir.

Grumpy old bastard alert

30 Nov 06:34
austin10 wrote:

I trust JV's and his source, he may be an old curmudgeon but he is no troll. If he has the word that its not Emblen then I will go with that.


As for Raul Blanco. Great CV....really experianced guy who is highly regarded for his technical knowledge of football. Probably one of the unsung hereos of the AW's South africa campaign. Would make a great coach EXCEPT for his age. 71 now would make him 76 for WC Russia 2018. Way too old. If NZ goes into the Asia playoff it would involve a lot of really long haul travel. Not the place for a guy in his  70's. Guus Hiddink is moving out of international football and he is 67, Marcello Lippi is talking of retiring soon and he is 65. Sorry but Blanco is too old.


Who we get as coach depends on the WC playoff setup. If it stays the way it is now with us getting a two headed playoff against a side from either CONCACAFF or AFC or CONCOBOL?? Then we could probably get away with a local coach to get us through the next few years and then get some good international technical backup to help when it came to the playoffs. However if we are in the final playoff round in Asia then its all completely different. We would have at least 8 full on high pressure games, possibly 10 if the pools are enlarged. We will need a high level coach with experiance, preferably in Asia.


Thats when names like Graham Arnold come in. If he does his two years coaching in Japan then the timing would be perfect to get him in for the two+ year run up to the WC.....his contract finishes May 20 2015????? at the end of the Jap season. Other possibilities would be Vidmar...who has taken a club team to the AFC Champions league final and was/is OZ assistant coach. Might not pass the "no dicks" test though. We are going to need a coach who knows what its like managing a team in high pressure games in places like Seoul and Tehran. If we are going to playoff in Asia then its no point NZF nickle and diming on a coach. 


Other names like Elliot and Nelson have only just finished playing. They need to go and spend 4+ years coaching and prove themselves first.

Good post and I think you have really hit on something.

For a couple of home and away games, you can ride with a local coach and pay for the technical help when needed. If it's Asia home and away for 8-10 games, then there is no coasting.

Grumpy old bastard alert

30 Nov 06:38
Royz wrote:

Blanco was coaching the MacArthur Rams from 08 until 2010, He still has a role there but i don't know what. Before then it was Marconi in 02/03.

Even though his name was brought up when i did some sniffing around. What makes Raul Blanco any better then say Wynton Rufer (please no laughing) who has more coaching experience then Simon Elliot?. Okon is doing well but is still learning his trade. Would the public go for that? Would it be Blasphemy!!! 

And do we get a coach now or after the draw? Like Australia did in 2005 to conquer Uruguay with Guus Hiddink?

Ange getting the gig has locked out a few names for a couple of years and you'd have to think, that unless things go tits up, he'll ride that train to Russia. Is u20s and WSW going to satisfy Okon and Poppa? 

I like the idea of a quality Australian coach purely because they understand the culture that a Euro coach would struggle to adapt to (I.e. NZ has no football culture)

Grumpy old bastard alert

30 Nov 06:43
2ndBest wrote:

Blanco would be a massive step back.

he is fine as a wingman (which is what he does) but how much longer does he have? If they want a tactics guy, there is Trani and Ramon.

Grumpy old bastard alert

30 Nov 07:33
Jeff Vader wrote:
2ndBest wrote:

Blanco would be a massive step back.

he is fine as a wingman (which is what he does) but how much longer does he have? If they want a tactics guy, there is Trani and Ramon.


I'm with 2nd Best on this one.

If you are old and wise you were probably young and stupid

30 Nov 07:54

Just watching Brisbane - Mike Mulvey?

Grumpy old bastard alert

30 Nov 07:57

Popovic will go to europe i think

Okon is worth debating

Nelsen/Elliott combo maybe not not Elliott sole charge


30 Nov 08:46
Jeff Vader wrote:

Just watching Brisbane - Mike Mulvey?



I think he is a very good coach, however I wonder how you would feel if you were a club coach doing well and offered the AW job which would mean very few game a year and for what? I'm not knocking it but at least at the Roar he has games week in and week out. Much easier to work with.

If you are old and wise you were probably young and stupid

30 Nov 08:56

I like the idea of Trani. I think he was the brains behind the Nix doing well. His coaching was great to watch at Newtown number 2.

Proud to have attended the first 175 Consecutive "Home" Wellington Phoenix "A League" Games !!

The Ruf, The Ruf, The Ruf is on Fire!!

30 Nov 09:27 · edited 30 Nov 09:52 · History
Leggy wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:

Just watching Brisbane - Mike Mulvey?



I think he is a very good coach, however I wonder how you would feel if you were a club coach doing well and offered the AW job which would mean very few game a year and for what? I'm not knocking it but at least at the Roar he has games week in and week out. Much easier to work with.
With a guy like that, you run it as a part time gig. 100k a year and considering he won't do much....

As I suggested with Poppa, you go to Brisbane and you do a deal whereby the 100k is a top up to his A League salary. How much time is the AWs gonna take up? He is on a good wedge and Brisbane get to keep their coach who just got bumped up by 100k. Everyone is happy

(Pretty much the same deal NZF had with Ricki and the Phoenix)

Grumpy old bastard alert

30 Nov 09:44

only take Blanco if Herbert is his assistant...



01 Dec 13:03

It was said on fox sports Argentina that former gold olympics football winner in 2008and Argentina manager, and world cup winner in Mexico 86, Sergio Batista, has been linking to the nz national team,  any news over there ?  He also coached in China a year ago, so he knows the region

01 Dec 13:04

Any news about it ?

01 Dec 13:04

Any news about it ?

01 Dec 18:08 · edited 01 Dec 18:10 · History
terminator_x wrote:

For some context here's a list of the last ten All Whites coaches (which conveniently takes us back to Adshead '82) and the other highlights from their coaching CVs. This is the market we're in people...

Mick Waitt 2002-2004 - Napier City Rovers, Capital Football DoF, Wellington Olympic

Ken Dugdale 1998-2002 - Football Kingz, Vollen UL (Norway)

Joe McGrath 1997-1998 - Rep of Ireland U17, Bohemians, Kilkenny City

Keith Pritchett 1996-1997 - Waitakere City, United Soccer 1 DoF

Bobby Clark 1994-1995 - Dartmouth College, Stanford University, Notre Dame

Ian Marshall 1990-1993 - Rangers (Chch), Christchurch United

John Adshead 1989 - Western Australia State Leagues, Manurewa, NZ Knights

Kevin Fallon 1985-1988 - Gisborne City, Waikato Utd, Mt Albert Grammar School

Allan Jones 1983-1984 - Bristol City, Blyth Spartans, Darlington, Bermuda

John Adshead 1979-1982 - see above

So basically, if we get in a coach with experience at a higher level than English League 1, US College Football or the A-League they will be the most qualified coach we have ever had.

Don't hold your breath for Hiddink.


There is the incredible story of the three All Whites coaches in the 1960's unknown to most (especially Brocic and Schwanner):
 

While modest coaching backgrounds is true for the last ten coaches  -but actually "the most qualified coach" (es) we have ever had were: 

- Ken Armstrong AW's coach 1957-64 (Chelsea: 362 apps; one England cap: against Scotland at Wembley in England's famous 7–2 win in the British Home Championship in April 1955): 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ken_Armstrong_(footballer_born_1924)


- Lou Brocic AW's coach 1962-64 and 1968-69 (former manager of Juventus, PSV Eindhoven, Barcelona, Red Star Belgrade, Albania, Egypt, Lebanon, Kuwait): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ljubi%C5%A1a_Bro%C4%87i%C4%87


- Juan Schwanner AW's coach 1967-68 (of Hungarian & Chilean parentage - played for top tier clubs in Hungary and Chile; plus mighty Flamengo in Brazil !!!; managed Grazer AK, Austria & Club Brugge, Belgium before taking the NZ job - Swiss clubs Lucerne & FC Zurich after): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Juan_Schwanner

Big Pete 65, Christchurch

01 Dec 23:07

Wow! Lou Brocic was my coach (briefly) in 1967. Had no idea I was being moulded by the one-time manager of Juve, PSV, Barca, Red Star, etc.

Wait til the knitters get a load of that!

"At the end of the drive the lawmen arrive...

I'll take my chance because luck is on my side or something...

Her name is Rio, she don't need to understand...

Oh Rio, Rio, hear them shout across the land..."

02 Dec 10:36
JAVIER16 wrote:

It was said on fox sports Argentina that former gold olympics football winner in 2008and Argentina manager, and world cup winner in Mexico 86, Sergio Batista, has been linking to the nz national team,  any news over there ?  He also coached in China a year ago, so he knows the region


Is it the same Sergio Batistuta who lives (now) permanently in Perth and refuses any involvement with local (Aust) football, according to SBS "World game" programme? Or did I confuse him with any other argentinian greats of the 80s-90s era?

Actually, getting outplayed quite a bit these days

02 Dec 10:39
Jeff Vader wrote:
Leggy wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:

Just watching Brisbane - Mike Mulvey?



I think he is a very good coach, however I wonder how you would feel if you were a club coach doing well and offered the AW job which would mean very few game a year and for what? I'm not knocking it but at least at the Roar he has games week in and week out. Much easier to work with.
With a guy like that, you run it as a part time gig. 100k a year and considering he won't do much....

As I suggested with Poppa, you go to Brisbane and you do a deal whereby the 100k is a top up to his A League salary. How much time is the AWs gonna take up? He is on a good wedge and Brisbane get to keep their coach who just got bumped up by 100k. Everyone is happy

(Pretty much the same deal NZF had with Ricki and the Phoenix)


If I was the Brisbane Roar board I would take a long hard look at the possibility of the Phoenix squad benefitting "by proxy" from such arrangement, simply by having a good number of players in the All Whites. Might be a conflict of interest.

Actually, getting outplayed quite a bit these days

02 Dec 12:21
Mainland FC wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:
Leggy wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:

Just watching Brisbane - Mike Mulvey?



I think he is a very good coach, however I wonder how you would feel if you were a club coach doing well and offered the AW job which would mean very few game a year and for what? I'm not knocking it but at least at the Roar he has games week in and week out. Much easier to work with.
With a guy like that, you run it as a part time gig. 100k a year and considering he won't do much....

As I suggested with Poppa, you go to Brisbane and you do a deal whereby the 100k is a top up to his A League salary. How much time is the AWs gonna take up? He is on a good wedge and Brisbane get to keep their coach who just got bumped up by 100k. Everyone is happy

(Pretty much the same deal NZF had with Ricki and the Phoenix)


If I was the Brisbane Roar board I would take a long hard look at the possibility of the Phoenix squad benefitting "by proxy" from such arrangement, simply by having a good number of players in the All Whites. Might be a conflict of interest.
That's a bloody good point. I had not thought of that.

Grumpy old bastard alert

02 Dec 12:44
Jeff Vader wrote:
Mainland FC wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:
Leggy wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:

Just watching Brisbane - Mike Mulvey?



I think he is a very good coach, however I wonder how you would feel if you were a club coach doing well and offered the AW job which would mean very few game a year and for what? I'm not knocking it but at least at the Roar he has games week in and week out. Much easier to work with.
With a guy like that, you run it as a part time gig. 100k a year and considering he won't do much....

As I suggested with Poppa, you go to Brisbane and you do a deal whereby the 100k is a top up to his A League salary. How much time is the AWs gonna take up? He is on a good wedge and Brisbane get to keep their coach who just got bumped up by 100k. Everyone is happy

(Pretty much the same deal NZF had with Ricki and the Phoenix)


If I was the Brisbane Roar board I would take a long hard look at the possibility of the Phoenix squad benefitting "by proxy" from such arrangement, simply by having a good number of players in the All Whites. Might be a conflict of interest.
That's a bloody good point. I had not thought of that.

There are so many down sides for a club that we should really eliminate the idea of a club guy also doing the job on the side

Normo's coming home

03 Dec 16:16
Royz wrote:

If NZF hire a local coach who has only coached Amatuer /Semi Pro league teams in a very poor League other then World Club championships, Then NZF would have to answer some serious questions like WTF? and "Scraping the bottom of the barrel" syndrome.

Ricki Herbert's coaching experience before taking the AW's: only three seasons' experience as a national league coach (& never won it)!!!
1990 - 93: Papakura City (Northern League)
1993 - 1996: Papatoetoe (Northern League)
1996 - 1999: Central United (National League '96-'98; 1999: North Island League + national play-off winner v. South Island League winner)
1999 - 2004: NZ u-23 national coach
2003: NZ u-17 national coach
2001 - 2004: assistant coach NZ national team.

Big Pete 65, Christchurch

03 Dec 16:44 · edited 03 Dec 17:01 · History
Mainland FC wrote:
JAVIER16 wrote:

It was said on fox sports Argentina that former gold olympics football winner in 2008and Argentina manager, and world cup winner in Mexico 86, Sergio Batista, has been linking to the nz national team,  any news over there ?  He also coached in China a year ago, so he knows the region


Is it the same Sergio Batistuta who lives (now) permanently in Perth and refuses any involvement with local (Aust) football, according to SBS "World game" programme? Or did I confuse him with any other argentinian greats of the 80s-90s era?

Sergio Batista is not your man living in Perth - this former Argentinian international managed Argentina as recently as July 2011 when he was sacked after a poor Copa America - that tournament was actually on Sky TV in NZ - I remember it well...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sergio_Batista

Manager of Shanghai Shenua in Chinese Super League May 2012 - July 2013 (their ninth manager in six seasons !!!):

http://wildeastfootball.net/2013/07/nine-coaches-in-six-seasons-sergio-batista-quits-shanghai-shenhua/

Seems unlikely to me he would accept such a reduction in status and wages as to coach NZ !!!

But then again NZF may seem supremely competent and a good employer after his bad experience in China:

"Former Argentina international coach Sergio Batista has decided enough is enough and has resigned as Shanghai Shenhua manager after going unpaid for four months, according to local reports.

Batista is just one of several staff and players at Shenhua whose wages are in arrears, due to the long-running shareholder conflict between owner Zhu Jun and the remaining shareholders, a bloc of state-owned enterprises.

And, as predicted my many fans and media, Batista will be succeeded by former Henan Jianye and Beijing Guoan manager Shen Xiangfu, who, in a rather peculiar appointment, joined Shenhua at the start of this season as “Chinese player head coach."

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

You are thinking of Gabriel Batistuta, the great Argentinian striker who lived briefly in Perth but went back to Argentina way back in 2007:

"Batistuta retired in 2005 and moved to Perth, Australia, but moved back to Argentina in 2007. Despite having completed his coaching badges in Argentina, he currently has no involvement with football (instead he prefers to play polo and golf). He expressed an interest in coaching Australia's national team and Argentina's team.[18] During the 2006 FIFA World Cup he worked as a commentator for Televisa Deportes. Batistuta currently runs his own construction company in Argentina. He also worked as technical secretary in the professional football club Colón, joining the club's staff in January 2012, and leaving at the end of the 2012–2013 season."

Big Pete 65, Christchurch

05 Dec 04:01
Big Pete 65 wrote:
Royz wrote:

If NZF hire a local coach who has only coached Amatuer /Semi Pro league teams in a very poor League other then World Club championships, Then NZF would have to answer some serious questions like WTF? and "Scraping the bottom of the barrel" syndrome.

Ricki Herbert's coaching experience before taking the AW's: only three seasons' experience as a national league coach (& never won it)!!!

1990 - 93: Papakura City (Northern League)

1993 - 1996: Papatoetoe (Northern League)

1996 - 1999: Central United (National League '96-'98; 1999: North Island League + national play-off winner v. South Island League winner)

1999 - 2004: NZ u-23 national coach

2003: NZ u-17 national coach

2001 - 2004: assistant coach NZ national team.

 

Looking at the above, Emblen would have to be top of NZF's present list.

"At the end of the drive the lawmen arrive...

I'll take my chance because luck is on my side or something...

Her name is Rio, she don't need to understand...

Oh Rio, Rio, hear them shout across the land..."

05 Dec 07:01
Jerzy Merino wrote:
Big Pete 65 wrote:
Royz wrote:

If NZF hire a local coach who has only coached Amatuer /Semi Pro league teams in a very poor League other then World Club championships, Then NZF would have to answer some serious questions like WTF? and "Scraping the bottom of the barrel" syndrome.

Ricki Herbert's coaching experience before taking the AW's: only three seasons' experience as a national league coach (& never won it)!!!

1990 - 93: Papakura City (Northern League)

1993 - 1996: Papatoetoe (Northern League)

1996 - 1999: Central United (National League '96-'98; 1999: North Island League + national play-off winner v. South Island League winner)

1999 - 2004: NZ u-23 national coach

2003: NZ u-17 national coach

2001 - 2004: assistant coach NZ national team.

 

Looking at the above, Emblen would have to be top of NZF's present list.

However Herbert was coaching a professional football club in a better league (Knights+Phoenix). That is not the case with Neil and contingent.

Mr Positive

05 Dec 23:18
Royz wrote:

However Herbert was coaching a professional football club in a better league (Knights+Phoenix). That is not the case with Neil and contingent.


Not when he took over he wasn't.

Three for me, and two for them.

06 Dec 03:50

Makes no difference's, He was still coaching a professional club from December 2006 onwards and had the All Whites job for 1 year before then. So coaching a pro club for 3 years before the play-off's , The Nix's gig surely helped him get the tactics right for the World Cup 2010.


 

Mr Positive

08 Dec 02:15
Big Pete 65 wrote:

Sergio Batista is not your man living in Perth - this former Argentinian international managed Argentina as recently as July 2011 when he was sacked after a poor Copa America - that tournament was actually on Sky TV in NZ - I remember it well...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sergio_Batista

Manager of Shanghai Shenua in Chinese Super League May 2012 - July 2013 (their ninth manager in six seasons !!!):

http://wildeastfootball.net/2013/07/nine-coaches-in-six-seasons-sergio-batista-quits-shanghai-shenhua/

Seems unlikely to me he would accept such a reduction in status and wages as to coach NZ !!!

But then again NZF may seem supremely competent and a good employer after his bad experience in China:

"Former Argentina international coach Sergio Batista has decided enough is enough and has resigned as Shanghai Shenhua manager after going unpaid for four months, according to local reports.

Batista is just one of several staff and players at Shenhua whose wages are in arrears, due to the long-running shareholder conflict between owner Zhu Jun and the remaining shareholders, a bloc of state-owned enterprises.

And, as predicted my many fans and media, Batista will be succeeded by former Henan Jianye and Beijing Guoan manager Shen Xiangfu, who, in a rather peculiar appointment, joined Shenhua at the start of this season as “Chinese player head coach."

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

You are thinking of Gabriel Batistuta, the great Argentinian striker who lived briefly in Perth but went back to Argentina way back in 2007:

"Batistuta retired in 2005 and moved to Perth, Australia, but moved back to Argentina in 2007. Despite having completed his coaching badges in Argentina, he currently has no involvement with football (instead he prefers to play polo and golf). He expressed an interest in coaching Australia's national team and Argentina's team.[18] During the 2006 FIFA World Cup he worked as a commentator for Televisa Deportes. Batistuta currently runs his own construction company in Argentina. He also worked as technical secretary in the professional football club Colón, joining the club's staff in January 2012, and leaving at the end of the 2012–2013 season."



You sir are an exemplary model of a deep command of fotballing facts.

Actually, getting outplayed quite a bit these days

08 Dec 02:20

After reading the article on Ramon Tribulietx I think the financial aspects of appointing him to the AW job would work if he was allowed to keep coaching Auckland City as well. It is less intense than coaching the Nix at the same time (which Ricki found a bit hard), but keeps him busy and involved. In contrast, a job involving only coaching the AWs would make it awfully hard to get value for money coach from overseas.

Actually, getting outplayed quite a bit these days

08 Dec 07:46

Yes, give him 2 years coaching both, if he doesn't work out - get someone else.

08 Dec 14:48
Jeff Vader wrote:
Leggy wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:
Leggy wrote:
Leggy wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:
Leggy wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:
martinb wrote:

First up, I don't think we're likely to get a coach who'll make as an immediate an impact as Ricki. On the flip side, I don't think he has to. The talent is there, so it doesn't need something dramatic from the coach, but someone who can manage and facilitate talent, and has a reasonable tactical awareness. Ok, so that is likely to be a big ask. But the bigger ask will be a platform of games for the AWs as they had with Graham Seatter that saw Ricki take the squad to Europe and other places. Administration backed with some finance will be the call that can make the most difference. Maybe we could look to try and play games against club teams associated with our top players?

Anyway I'm half tempted to say Danny Hay, just so he can take a turn in the hot seat. All in all though, too many cb coaches...Ricki, Danny hay, Neil Emblen etc etc...

I think you are right on a fair chunk of this. Emblen was a midfielder for most of his career though.

And not a very good one.
yeah. Bloody average footballer who played EPL..... 

He was an attacking midfielder



Being sarcastic does not suit you JV.
I made the comment on all the times I've seen Emblen play. If we are being truthful most people in NZ had never heard of him until he arrived to play for the Knights.He was 34 years old then and had been playing for Walsall which at the time was less than average. I watched the first game in Brisbane and he was miles away from the standard. required . I saw every game that he played and he had one great game. Sure he played  in the EPL but I never remembered him. Perhaps because he only played 8 games and for a side that got relegated.
It was as a coach that I was impressed. I saw the Olympic side play in the UK last year (on TV)  and I thought they played some lovely football. On that basis I believe that he could do a pretty good job for the AW given the young talent we have.
I was at that game too Leggy, lived in Brisbane at the time. Decided to become a roar fan but at the game couldn't bring myself to cheer against NZ. So made Brisbane my Aussie team :) Still have the Roar cap we bought at the game.


The same NP. Apart from the Nix will support the Roar for the same reasons.
Obviously JV is not going to reply, especially as he could be wrong.
No I am commenting because I think your argument is wrong.

I've hardly seen Wynton Rufer play but the times I did (for the Kingz) I didn't think much. Does that mean he was an average footballer? Just cause he was not the best player in the EPL or you saw him at a time towards the end of his career where he was out of shape and not great, does not make him an average footballer. Ifill was average footballer last year. Does that mean he has always been that way?


I see you point but I don't think for one moment that he was a great player- ever. For the Knights he was awful.
I have this feeling that he might be a better coach.
I agree Auckland Phoenix he was rubbish for the Knights. It was a retirement gig for him and he is in better shape now, than when he turned up.

Leggy I'm not saying he is a great player by any stretch but you have to give him respect for the fact he played at that level. When you think of our best Kiwi footballers, only two have done on with regular appearances because it's not an easy level to live in unless you have talent. I'll grant you that Nelsen and Reid were/are 2 good EPL players but to live at that level, average is a bad adjective especially when you look at all the competition you have to get ahead of to get there



I think some here have short memories.  yes he was a bit out of shape when he arrived but he improved as the two seasons went on.  Baze, him, Moss and Tambo were about the only good players we had.  Josh Rose was absolute pants, even caught him eating pies will training on a tread-mill during training.
Supporter world's best and worst football teams: Waikato/WaiBop, Kingz, Knights, Phoenix, The Argyle, The Whites & the All Whites

10 Dec 14:49
Mainland FC wrote:

After reading the article on Ramon Tribulietx I think the financial aspects of appointing him to the AW job would work if he was allowed to keep coaching Auckland City as well. It is less intense than coaching the Nix at the same time (which Ricki found a bit hard), but keeps him busy and involved. In contrast, a job involving only coaching the AWs would make it awfully hard to get value for money coach from overseas.

That article also mentions he's already been employed by Canadian Soccer in the past as a technical adviser. Interesting!
"The step up from the ASB Premiership to an international job would be huge but maybe not insurmountable. At the least, Tribulietx should be engaged in a role within NZF. He has already been used by the Canadian Soccer Association on various campaigns, but strangely ignored by NZF."

Big Pete 65, Christchurch

10 Dec 20:06
Big Pete 65 wrote:
Mainland FC wrote:

After reading the article on Ramon Tribulietx I think the financial aspects of appointing him to the AW job would work if he was allowed to keep coaching Auckland City as well. It is less intense than coaching the Nix at the same time (which Ricki found a bit hard), but keeps him busy and involved. In contrast, a job involving only coaching the AWs would make it awfully hard to get value for money coach from overseas.

http://www.nzherald.co.nz/soccer-football/news/article.cfm?c_id=86&objectid=11168908

That article also mentions he's already been employed by Canadian Soccer in the past as a technical adviser. Interesting!

"The step up from the ASB Premiership to an international job would be huge but maybe not insurmountable. At the least, Tribulietx should be engaged in a role within NZF. He has already been used by the Canadian Soccer Association on various campaigns, but strangely ignored by NZF."



Maybe he was found wanting in Canada
Supporter world's best and worst football teams: Waikato/WaiBop, Kingz, Knights, Phoenix, The Argyle, The Whites & the All Whites

10 Dec 20:09

Ignored by NZF or he has ignored them?

I believe he was a technical adviser on one WC campaign. It might have been Mili's first one U20 in 2011 but I am vague on it.

Grumpy old bastard alert

12 Dec 09:02

After the AC performances against Casablanca and Espanyol in the last few days you would have to think Ramon has improved his chances of getting the AWs job. It shows he can step up to the big time. AC looked well drilled and disciplined at the WCC. His side  tried to play football but more importantly were very well organised in defense...something that NZ sides have to be against the big guys. Would love to see Ramon work with  talented youngster like Rojas, Thomas, Costa Tuiloma etc....

14 Dec 01:40
austin10 wrote:

After the AC performances against Casablanca and Espanyol in the last few days you would have to think Ramon has improved his chances of getting the AWs job. It shows he can step up to the big time. AC looked well drilled and disciplined at the WCC. His side  tried to play football but more importantly were very well organised in defense...something that NZ sides have to be against the big guys. Would love to see Ramon work with  talented youngster like Rojas, Thomas, Costa Tuiloma etc....

Ryan Thomas just played another 90 minutes for PEC Zwolle in the Dutch Eredivisie, and Herbert chose to play someone who hadn't kicked a ball in earnest for two years in midfield instead for the game at the Azteca. Ramon would definitely be a significant improvement, but then any half decent coach would be. I'm just so glad Herbert's finally gone. I think the problem is Ramon is too closely associated with ACFC for some on this forum.

14 Dec 01:47
Bluemagic wrote:
austin10 wrote:

After the AC performances against Casablanca and Espanyol in the last few days you would have to think Ramon has improved his chances of getting the AWs job. It shows he can step up to the big time. AC looked well drilled and disciplined at the WCC. His side  tried to play football but more importantly were very well organised in defense...something that NZ sides have to be against the big guys. Would love to see Ramon work with  talented youngster like Rojas, Thomas, Costa Tuiloma etc....

Ryan Thomas just played another 90 minutes for PEC Zwolle in the Dutch Eredivisie, and Herbert chose to play someone who hadn't kicked a ball in earnest for two years in midfield instead for the game at the Azteca. Ramon would definitely be a significant improvement, but then any half decent coach would be. I'm just so glad Herbert's finally gone. I think the problem is Ramon is too closely associated with ACFC for some on this forum.


so what - it's not like the people on this forum choose who the all whites manager is now do they?  the only reason you have mentioned that is too have a dig - not very mature!
14 Dec 02:00

^ Agree. Crap point Bluemagic.

"At the end of the drive the lawmen arrive...

I'll take my chance because luck is on my side or something...

Her name is Rio, she don't need to understand...

Oh Rio, Rio, hear them shout across the land..."