All Whites, Ferns, and other international teams

The next All Whites coach

1207 replies · 212,695 views
20 Nov 09:28
Jeff Vader wrote:

No it was a 4-4-2 on Honiara. They sent over Tim Myers who played RB.

Wasnt that where Ricki threw a spaz at the senior players for questioning him and he dropped about six of them. Siggy being one of them. Perhaps they voiced an opinion based on truth? 
Proud to have attended the first 175 Consecutive "Home" Wellington Phoenix "A League" Games !!

The Ruf, The Ruf, The Ruf is on Fire!!

20 Nov 23:32
SurgeQld wrote:

So... who's the next coach?

 

Be interesting to hear if any of the failed applicants for the Nix job re-apply again to fill RH's patent shiny slip-ons. I'm sure one who won't will be H Sanchez. (boo-hiss!)

"At the end of the drive the lawmen arrive...

I'll take my chance because luck is on my side or something...

Her name is Rio, she don't need to understand...

Oh Rio, Rio, hear them shout across the land..."

20 Nov 23:46
Jeff Vader wrote:

No it was a 4-4-2 on Honiara. They sent over Tim Myers who played RB.

I'm pretty sure we played a mixture of 3-4-3 and 4-4-2 at Honiara. I think it was 3-4-3 for the first two, 4-4-2 for the draw and I'm not sure about the last two.
21 Nov 00:05

i think i'm being idealistic but...

i'd like to think that we would have a kiwi resident appointed as coach from now until the next world cup.  whoever it is, should have one or a series of foreign coaches seconded on a mentor/consultant basis.

i'd really like us avoid jumping on the international coaching gravy train which sees a different frenchman, german or dutchman appointed to each country every 6 months.  we will achieve nothing by going down this path.  all we will get is a half committed contract jumper who will leave us in the lurch.

simon elliott, gavin wilkinson, shane knowles, chris milicich, paul marshall, steve cain, neil emblen could all be goers

short of finding a good kiwi, i'd go australian, ideally graeme arnold, but he's just been snaffled up

please cast aside local rivalries and petty dislikes before you reply to this post - i hate it when people do that - considered evaluation only

360footballnews.com

21 Nov 00:32

I think of the Kiwi names you have listed, you rule out Marshall, Knowles, Milicich, and Cain straight away. I think you have to be coaching at the ASBP level first. While that's not applicable to Emblen, he was there for 3 years and is the current assistant and Oly White coach. Mili has just been dumped and that's a frosty relationship and Cain has personal boundary issues. Knowles is coaching a team in the bottom half of NRFL (without national league experience in the last 10 years). Marshall.... well the oil on him is that he has no real friends in football which is not a pre-requisite for being a coach but he is a micro managing coach from the sidelines.

Realistically, the only NZ resident ones that would get looked at are Emblen, Ramon, and Ernie. If I were to throw in another name that comes up is Tony Readings. I can't think of anyone else that I think would get looked at although I have this nagging suspicion that I am missing someone.

From Australia, who knows. I still think that should tap up Poppa as unlikely as he is to say yes. Phil Moss was rumoured for the Phoenix gig, would be a good profile boost for him.

Kiwis overseas - Wilkinson has been coaching a while. Elliott hasn't really done any coaching and may still be too close to some of the players, same with Nelsen who is a rookie coach and Oughton has had a couple of years as an assistant? Too soon for 3 of those but Wilkinson might be tempted (I don't really know of him so he is just a name to me)

Where else do you go? There will be a boat load of names from overseas but like you say, you do not want to get into this revolving door thing like we had with Clark and McGrath etc. Makes it tough really.

I heard Piney on the radio yesterday about the situation and he said that you may not get the coach you want today. Maybe you get the one you need in a couple of years time but get the person that will do the job right now. Interesting thoughts that.

 

You would hope that NZF are transparent with all applicants about the lack of programme and lack of support they will give them rather than lie to them to get them here (if it was overseas) and then they bugger off when they understand whats going on here.

Grumpy old bastard alert

21 Nov 00:39
reg22 wrote:

i think i'm being idealistic but...

i'd like to think that we would have a kiwi resident appointed as coach from now until the next world cup.  whoever it is, should have one or a series of foreign coaches seconded on a mentor/consultant basis.

i'd really like us avoid jumping on the international coaching gravy train which sees a different frenchman, german or dutchman appointed to each country every 6 months.  we will achieve nothing by going down this path.  all we will get is a half committed contract jumper who will leave us in the lurch.

simon elliott, gavin wilkinson, shane knowles, chris milicich, paul marshall, steve cain, neil emblen could all be goers

short of finding a good kiwi, i'd go australian, ideally graeme arnold, but he's just been snaffled up

please cast aside local rivalries and petty dislikes before you reply to this post - i hate it when people do that - considered evaluation only

I don't think you're being idealistic. Sounds like a reasonable plan.
Add Duncan Oughton's name to that list?

21 Nov 00:39
Jeff Vader wrote:

Realistically, the only NZ resident ones that would get looked at are Emblen, Ramon, and Ernie. If I were to throw in another name that comes up is Tony Readings. I can't think of anyone else that I think would get looked at although I have this nagging suspicion that I am missing someone.

Maybe you're thinking of Aaron McFarland. I don't really know enough about him but was impressed with teams he coached and he said the right things in the paper. I highly doubt he would get it but at the same time you could easily do worse.
21 Nov 00:46
rjmiller wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:

Realistically, the only NZ resident ones that would get looked at are Emblen, Ramon, and Ernie. If I were to throw in another name that comes up is Tony Readings. I can't think of anyone else that I think would get looked at although I have this nagging suspicion that I am missing someone.

Maybe you're thinking of Aaron McFarland. I don't really know enough about him but was impressed with teams he coached and he said the right things in the paper. I highly doubt he would get it but at the same time you could easily do worse.

It was not Aaron. He is a good coach that probably needs to get his hands on an U20 or Oly White team and generate himself a bit of profile. Assistant to the Ferns alone is probably not enough if I was looking at the calibre of candidate (and again, that's just my opinion, others will no doubt disagree). He has had ACFC but that can muddy the waters because that side always performs. I think he could be a bet for the future though.

Grumpy old bastard alert

21 Nov 00:53

Aaron McFarland is a great coach, he player/coached a team I was in in Wellington around 12 years back, not saying much but he would be the best coach I ever had. Had excellent ideas, communication and enthusiasm back then and always lead by example. Be cool to see him go on higher honours in coaching.

21 Nov 00:58

I thought he was an ex Dunedin man? Played national league for Caversham or something?

Grumpy old bastard alert

21 Nov 01:00

Yep, came up from Dunners and was a teacher at Wellington College for a few years in the early 2000's

21 Nov 03:36

I understand Tony Readings is currently undertaking his Pro Licence with the likes of Tony Popovic, Frank Farina, Phil Moss, John Kosmina and former Waikato FC Coach Dave Edmondson in Australia at the moment, so could be a long shot for the National Team position - does he have any experience in the men's game apart from a brief spell with Birkenhead a few years ago..?


What about Roger Wilkinson? Kevin Fallon?

21 Nov 03:47

Of the "go forward" squad being bandied about on the AW game thread (post match), the starting XI don't even play their football in NZ - aside from Moss. Plenty of the "next XI" don't either.
How much does this come into play, if at all?

Kotahitanga. We are one.

21 Nov 05:26 · edited 21 Nov 05:27 · History


Think they (though the 'they' thing terrifies me) will appoint an interim coach, and make the big appointment for the WC push down the track a bit. No need to fork out big bucks (by our standards) yet, as realistically there will be few games. If Ernie goes well at the Phoenix - think he'll get the gig at the end of his contract, when Greenacre takes over there.  Unlikely anyone of compulsory note will apply for the job yet.

I like the NZ homegrown concept in principal, but it's gotta be someone the overseas based players respect. If Reid and co see a micky mouse setup, they'll be as interested as Reid looked sometimes down here under Herbert. He's got to be the leader, but has to want to be the leader. 

21 Nov 07:02 · edited 21 Nov 07:24 · History
I really think it is critical that the next all whites coach  also has sole control over the next Olympic team. I don't bank on NZ football being able to organize the all whites half a dozen games a year so this campaign will be important along with allowing the new coach to get alongside the young players and developing a new style. Out of interest anyone here know the cut of age for the next campaign and who of the current world cup squad would be eligible?



Auckland will rise once more

21 Nov 07:33

NZ needs to play between 8 to 10 friendlies next year at least, with the fifa windows, and would love a tour for games to Southamerica, to take advantage that most teams are eager for friendlies just before the wc

21 Nov 07:34

Roux Tuiloma Payne Ridenton Fenton Howieson Rufer Thomas Boyd

Overage: Reid Rojas Wood or Barbarouses?


21 Nov 07:37

?

Fenton Reid Smith Roux

Tuiloma Payne

Ridenton Rufer or Howieson Thomas

Boyd or Wood

Big potential under right coach


21 Nov 07:43
JAVIER16 wrote:

NZ needs to play between 8 to 10 friendlies next year at least, with the fifa windows, and would love a tour for games to Southamerica, to take advantage that most teams are eager for friendlies just before the wc



And you think NZ Football  will be willing to spend the money? I doubt it.

If you are old and wise you were probably young and stupid

21 Nov 08:01
Hard News wrote:
MrWaikato wrote:
What about Roger Wilkinson? Kevin Fallon?


Comedy gold.



Even I found that comical, not the age thing but --- really.

If you are old and wise you were probably young and stupid

21 Nov 08:02
terminator_x wrote:
reg22 wrote:

i think i'm being idealistic but...

i'd like to think that we would have a kiwi resident appointed as coach from now until the next world cup.  whoever it is, should have one or a series of foreign coaches seconded on a mentor/consultant basis.

i'd really like us avoid jumping on the international coaching gravy train which sees a different frenchman, german or dutchman appointed to each country every 6 months.  we will achieve nothing by going down this path.  all we will get is a half committed contract jumper who will leave us in the lurch.

simon elliott, gavin wilkinson, shane knowles, chris milicich, paul marshall, steve cain, neil emblen could all be goers

short of finding a good kiwi, i'd go australian, ideally graeme arnold, but he's just been snaffled up

please cast aside local rivalries and petty dislikes before you reply to this post - i hate it when people do that - considered evaluation only


I don't think you're being idealistic. Sounds like a reasonable plan.

Add Duncan Oughton's name to that list?




good point, absolutely

360footballnews.com

21 Nov 08:03
Jeff Vader wrote:

I think of the Kiwi names you have listed, you rule out Marshall, Knowles, Milicich, and Cain straight away. I think you have to be coaching at the ASBP level first. While that's not applicable to Emblen, he was there for 3 years and is the current assistant and Oly White coach. Mili has just been dumped and that's a frosty relationship and Cain has personal boundary issues. Knowles is coaching a team in the bottom half of NRFL (without national league experience in the last 10 years). Marshall.... well the oil on him is that he has no real friends in football which is not a pre-requisite for being a coach but he is a micro managing coach from the sidelines.

Realistically, the only NZ resident ones that would get looked at are Emblen, Ramon, and Ernie. If I were to throw in another name that comes up is Tony Readings. I can't think of anyone else that I think would get looked at although I have this nagging suspicion that I am missing someone.

From Australia, who knows. I still think that should tap up Poppa as unlikely as he is to say yes. Phil Moss was rumoured for the Phoenix gig, would be a good profile boost for him.

Kiwis overseas - Wilkinson has been coaching a while. Elliott hasn't really done any coaching and may still be too close to some of the players, same with Nelsen who is a rookie coach and Oughton has had a couple of years as an assistant? Too soon for 3 of those but Wilkinson might be tempted (I don't really know of him so he is just a name to me)

Where else do you go? There will be a boat load of names from overseas but like you say, you do not want to get into this revolving door thing like we had with Clark and McGrath etc. Makes it tough really.

I heard Piney on the radio yesterday about the situation and he said that you may not get the coach you want today. Maybe you get the one you need in a couple of years time but get the person that will do the job right now. Interesting thoughts that.

 

You would hope that NZF are transparent with all applicants about the lack of programme and lack of support they will give them rather than lie to them to get them here (if it was overseas) and then they bugger off when they understand whats going on here.



heck sorry mate, i meant cameron knowles, not shane

i think elliott's one of those guys who sort of comes ready equipped to coach. a lot of his playing attributes would transfer over to the role well

the same with duncan oughton

360footballnews.com

21 Nov 08:17

First up, I don't think we're likely to get a coach who'll make as an immediate an impact as Ricki. On the flip side, I don't think he has to. The talent is there, so it doesn't need something dramatic from the coach, but someone who can manage and facilitate talent, and has a reasonable tactical awareness. Ok, so that is likely to be a big ask. But the bigger ask will be a platform of games for the AWs as they had with Graham Seatter that saw Ricki take the squad to Europe and other places. Administration backed with some finance will be the call that can make the most difference. Maybe we could look to try and play games against club teams associated with our top players?

Anyway I'm half tempted to say Danny Hay, just so he can take a turn in the hot seat. All in all though, too many cb coaches...Ricki, Danny hay, Neil Emblen etc etc...



21 Nov 08:19

I think we really have to look at the pathways for our coaches as well. If they are serious we want to get them involved with teams overseas like Poppa was. It would be nice if the person who coached the AWs wasn't the one left holding the baby, but like Ricki (and hopefully more) had done their licenses and got some real momentum in their coaching career before taking on the chalice...



21 Nov 08:48
MrWaikato wrote:

I understand Tony Readings is currently undertaking his Pro Licence with the likes of Tony Popovic, Frank Farina, Phil Moss, John Kosmina and former Waikato FC Coach Dave Edmondson in Australia at the moment, so could be a long shot for the National Team position - does he have any experience in the men's game apart from a brief spell with Birkenhead a few years ago..?


What about Roger Wilkinson? Kevin Fallon?

Dave Edmondson is another name who might back himself but he left to make a name for himself in Australia with women's football and had a booze issue with his 1st stint at Waikato so not sure where he would sit. Some one mentioned in another thread Aurelio Vidmar?

As for the last two, you are surely having a wind up right? With Danny Hay and Billy Harris as assistants?

Grumpy old bastard alert

21 Nov 08:50
martinb wrote:

First up, I don't think we're likely to get a coach who'll make as an immediate an impact as Ricki. On the flip side, I don't think he has to. The talent is there, so it doesn't need something dramatic from the coach, but someone who can manage and facilitate talent, and has a reasonable tactical awareness. Ok, so that is likely to be a big ask. But the bigger ask will be a platform of games for the AWs as they had with Graham Seatter that saw Ricki take the squad to Europe and other places. Administration backed with some finance will be the call that can make the most difference. Maybe we could look to try and play games against club teams associated with our top players?

Anyway I'm half tempted to say Danny Hay, just so he can take a turn in the hot seat. All in all though, too many cb coaches...Ricki, Danny hay, Neil Emblen etc etc...

I think you are right on a fair chunk of this. Emblen was a midfielder for most of his career though.

Grumpy old bastard alert

21 Nov 08:56

deep lying DM yeh? and CB for Knights and Waitak?



21 Nov 08:59
Jeff Vader wrote:
martinb wrote:

First up, I don't think we're likely to get a coach who'll make as an immediate an impact as Ricki. On the flip side, I don't think he has to. The talent is there, so it doesn't need something dramatic from the coach, but someone who can manage and facilitate talent, and has a reasonable tactical awareness. Ok, so that is likely to be a big ask. But the bigger ask will be a platform of games for the AWs as they had with Graham Seatter that saw Ricki take the squad to Europe and other places. Administration backed with some finance will be the call that can make the most difference. Maybe we could look to try and play games against club teams associated with our top players?

Anyway I'm half tempted to say Danny Hay, just so he can take a turn in the hot seat. All in all though, too many cb coaches...Ricki, Danny hay, Neil Emblen etc etc...

I think you are right on a fair chunk of this. Emblen was a midfielder for most of his career though.

And not a very good one.

If you are old and wise you were probably young and stupid

21 Nov 09:13
Leggy wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:
martinb wrote:

First up, I don't think we're likely to get a coach who'll make as an immediate an impact as Ricki. On the flip side, I don't think he has to. The talent is there, so it doesn't need something dramatic from the coach, but someone who can manage and facilitate talent, and has a reasonable tactical awareness. Ok, so that is likely to be a big ask. But the bigger ask will be a platform of games for the AWs as they had with Graham Seatter that saw Ricki take the squad to Europe and other places. Administration backed with some finance will be the call that can make the most difference. Maybe we could look to try and play games against club teams associated with our top players?

Anyway I'm half tempted to say Danny Hay, just so he can take a turn in the hot seat. All in all though, too many cb coaches...Ricki, Danny hay, Neil Emblen etc etc...

I think you are right on a fair chunk of this. Emblen was a midfielder for most of his career though.

And not a very good one.
yeah. Bloody average footballer who played EPL..... 
He was an attacking midfielder

Grumpy old bastard alert

21 Nov 09:32 · edited 21 Nov 09:33 · History

What about Danny Hay and Billy Harris as a coaching team? Then they can feel the heat in the kitchn together!

Shit just saw someone else already suggesting it. Sorry for the double up.

Proud to have attended the first 175 Consecutive "Home" Wellington Phoenix "A League" Games !!

The Ruf, The Ruf, The Ruf is on Fire!!

21 Nov 09:48
Lonegunmen wrote:

What about Danny Hay and Billy Harris as a coaching team? Then they can feel the heat in the kitchn together!

Shit just saw someone else already suggesting it. Sorry for the double up.



before all you billy haters get started, i played for him for a short time and he was excellent technically and a really nice guy too

both he and danny hay haven't taken a decent senior team for sometime though (or have they).  i'd say that whoever was going to step up to this role would have to have been in the game either as a top level player or at least ASB Prem coach recently

360footballnews.com

21 Nov 09:54

Aye but both have always been quick to throw in the cheap shots at Herbert in the past.

Proud to have attended the first 175 Consecutive "Home" Wellington Phoenix "A League" Games !!

The Ruf, The Ruf, The Ruf is on Fire!!

21 Nov 09:55
Lonegunmen wrote:

Aye but both have always been quick to throw in the cheap shots at Herbert in the past.



oh, i see, good call!

360footballnews.com

21 Nov 09:59 · edited 21 Nov 10:01 · History
Lonegunmen wrote:

What about Danny Hay and Billy Harris as a coaching team? Then they can feel the heat in the kitchn together!

Shit just saw someone else already suggesting it. Sorry for the double up.

Not sure if Harris deserves the honour as much as Tony Smith...or one of the other Stuffians whose name I can't recall...used to enjoy Billy Harris' guff as it usually had very little seriousness about it. Whereas Hay gets on the stump from time to time for sure



21 Nov 10:02
reg22 wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:

I think of the Kiwi names you have listed, you rule out Marshall, Knowles, Milicich, and Cain straight away. I think you have to be coaching at the ASBP level first. While that's not applicable to Emblen, he was there for 3 years and is the current assistant and Oly White coach. Mili has just been dumped and that's a frosty relationship and Cain has personal boundary issues. Knowles is coaching a team in the bottom half of NRFL (without national league experience in the last 10 years). Marshall.... well the oil on him is that he has no real friends in football which is not a pre-requisite for being a coach but he is a micro managing coach from the sidelines.

Realistically, the only NZ resident ones that would get looked at are Emblen, Ramon, and Ernie. If I were to throw in another name that comes up is Tony Readings. I can't think of anyone else that I think would get looked at although I have this nagging suspicion that I am missing someone.

From Australia, who knows. I still think that should tap up Poppa as unlikely as he is to say yes. Phil Moss was rumoured for the Phoenix gig, would be a good profile boost for him.

Kiwis overseas - Wilkinson has been coaching a while. Elliott hasn't really done any coaching and may still be too close to some of the players, same with Nelsen who is a rookie coach and Oughton has had a couple of years as an assistant? Too soon for 3 of those but Wilkinson might be tempted (I don't really know of him so he is just a name to me)

Where else do you go? There will be a boat load of names from overseas but like you say, you do not want to get into this revolving door thing like we had with Clark and McGrath etc. Makes it tough really.

I heard Piney on the radio yesterday about the situation and he said that you may not get the coach you want today. Maybe you get the one you need in a couple of years time but get the person that will do the job right now. Interesting thoughts that.

 

You would hope that NZF are transparent with all applicants about the lack of programme and lack of support they will give them rather than lie to them to get them here (if it was overseas) and then they bugger off when they understand whats going on here.



heck sorry mate, i meant cameron knowles, not shane

i think elliott's one of those guys who sort of comes ready equipped to coach. a lot of his playing attributes would transfer over to the role well

the same with duncan oughton

If I was running NZF he's the guy I'd be looking to get involved as soon as possible in the coaching (Elliot).  Or Ivan as was suggested on the pod.  In the end whether you've coached in the ASBP or taken an under age team isn't that much of a qualification for the national team job

Normo's coming home

21 Nov 10:30 · edited 21 Nov 11:20 · History

I think not having too many cooks is a good idea, and having either an explicitly caretaker or someone who is clearly the boss and can pick his own management/coaching team and has the confidence of NZF and the rest of us...Elliot got coaching licences?



21 Nov 11:16

I think Ivan and Elliott are too close to the team still. I would also like to see Ivan retire as a player first before getting our national job.

Grumpy old bastard alert

21 Nov 16:34

Perhaps we should appoint Emblen as caretaker and wait until Nelsen gets sacked from Toronto like all the coaches before him 

Founder

21 Nov 18:19

Ha ha ha Feverish.

Grumpy old bastard alert