Southern United capable of playing A League!!!!
It's more than just results that is considered in those scenarios however. Anyway, this isn't happening, Southern are in the league until 2015-2016 regardless of whatever goes on down there.
Six goals conceded in 15 minutes might be an international (i.e. Guinness) record for a national first division result. Anyone interested in checking/applying for the record? I can't be arsed.
Australia beat American Soama 31-0 in an International game. Otago are looking strong.
Speaking of the above match, anoraks may enjoy revisiting the report of it as presented in Sitter fanzine in May 2001
http://sitterfanzine.weebly.com/uploads/1/5/1/0/15102074/do_more_goals_mean_48.pdf
Do tell.....
Do you know what nemesis means
Like a Bye ...but with travel !!!
Do you know what nemesis means
Speaking of the above match, [Oz 31 American Samoa 0] anoraks may enjoy revisiting the report of it as presented in Sitter fanzine in May 2001
http://sitterfanzine.weebly.com/uploads/1/5/1/0/15102074/do_more_goals_mean_48.pdf
3 fifteen-yr-olds in the Samoa squad (unlike Southern with just the one?).
"... it was the appropriately named, and the recently convicted (getaway driver in an armed robbery) Con Boutsianis, that got the scoreboard rolling." ....
"Boutsi, won't you drive my car...
Boutsi's gonna be a star
Beep beep, Beep beep, yeah!" - Ericcson Stadium, Kingz v Sth Melbourne ... Ah, they were the days...
"At the end of the drive the lawmen arrive...
I'll take my chance because luck is on my side or something...
Her name is Rio, she don't need to understand...
Oh Rio, Rio, hear them shout across the land..."
Like a Bye ...but with travel !!!
But you wont travel anymore....
Ill take the points ...!
Speaking of the above match, [Oz 31 American Samoa 0] anoraks may enjoy revisiting the report of it as presented in Sitter fanzine in May 2001
http://sitterfanzine.weebly.com/uploads/1/5/1/0/15102074/do_more_goals_mean_48.pdf
3 fifteen-yr-olds in the Samoa squad (unlike Southern with just the one?).
"... it was the appropriately named, and the recently convicted (getaway driver in an armed robbery) Con Boutsianis, that got the scoreboard rolling." ....
"Boutsi, won't you drive my car...
Boutsi's gonna be a star
Beep beep, Beep beep, yeah!" - Ericcson Stadium, Kingz v Sth Melbourne ... Ah, they were the days...
Great song, great atmosphere. I remember that game well. Despite a lazy and ignorant Danny Hay recently claiming there wasn't an iota of support for the Kingz, we got over 9,000 to that game at Mt Smart, and that was in the old lowly ethnic-based NSL. Pity about the result because we would have made the playoffs otherwise. I remember Boutsi running over and giving the massed ranks of Bloc 5 the fingers after he scored from a freekick. Only earned him another rousing chorus of...
"Boutsi won't you drive my car...
...and we'll rob a restaurant, beep beep, beep beep, yeah!"
PS - I have to say, those first two years of Bloc 5 supporting the Kingz outstrips the size and noise made by Yellow Fever at Westpac. After the sacking of the Rufers however the decline set in. You don't believe me, look at some old TV clips.
Also a shit load cheaper for them to be playing in ASBP
More excuses.......
OK you figure out where a budget of in the region of $2 to $3m to fund a team that will have little commercial appeal is going to come from?
Might wanna re-check your estimate mate!!
We do you get a figure that high?
And which is it 2 Million or 3 Million? Big difference there
This is were NZF should come in then
Thats were Wanderers SC should be playing
What would be of higher quality, A League Youth Team League or ASBP? I would have thought ASBP.
Probably but they should not be in the ASBP.
Correct. Unjust that YHM were removed and sets a dangerous precedent. Do Southern now get removed or do we remove Wanderers because they're shit?
Can't have been that shit, ACFC could only put 2 goals past them both home and away!!
they're losing. on past criteria, they should be kicked out just like youngheart were
and until more recent years youngheart were consistently in the playoffs
This is were NZF should come in then
Thats were Wanderers SC should be playing
What would be of higher quality, A League Youth Team League or ASBP? I would have thought ASBP.
Probably but they should not be in the ASBP.
Correct. Unjust that YHM were removed and sets a dangerous precedent. Do Southern now get removed or do we remove Wanderers because they're shit?
Can't have been that shit, ACFC could only put 2 goals past them both home and away!!
they're losing. on past criteria, they should be kicked out just like youngheart were
and until more recent years youngheart were consistently in the playoffs
Yeah, but they are not there "on past criteria", instead they are a collection of 17 and 18 year olds who have been identified as potential NZ representatives for the 2015 WC, who have been entered into the ASBP by NZ Football as the most cost effective means to give them experience playing together against the best footballers available in NZ in the summers of 2013/14 and 2014/15 leading into and as preparation for the U20 WC in 2015.
As has been identified here, an alternative - playing in A Youth - would cost 100's of $1,000's (does NZ Football want to, or more importantly should NZ Football (and I'd say No!) invest that level of money into one age group team - even if the HPM's son is in the team!??
And yes Reg it's real easy to flippantly say the Wanderers are losing (and they are) however remember the big picture - team of 17 and 18 year olds getting ready to represent NZ in 2015 - and really they have been "in" most games, reading the match reports, if they had converted just a third of the chances they has created, they would at least be mid table. It will be interesting to see how they go next year.
So let's say NZ Football go, "shit Reg is right, Wanderers are shit, let's kick them out. Quick get Reg's number, we don't want another huge loss in the opening game by NZ when we are hosting in 2015, so let's find out how we should instead prepare the 2015 NZ team, Reg will know". What will you say?
Crickets from Reg.
Ali, same scenario, NZ Football's on the phone to you, "Ali, we can't get hold of Reg and we really don't want another huge loss in the opening game by NZ when we are hosting the U20 World Cup in 2015, but you're right Wanderers shouldn't be in the ASBP, so how should we instead prepare the 2015 NZ team". What will you say?
This is were NZF should come in then
Thats were Wanderers SC should be playing
What would be of higher quality, A League Youth Team League or ASBP? I would have thought ASBP.
Probably but they should not be in the ASBP.
Correct. Unjust that YHM were removed and sets a dangerous precedent. Do Southern now get removed or do we remove Wanderers because they're shit?
Can't have been that shit, ACFC could only put 2 goals past them both home and away!!
they're losing. on past criteria, they should be kicked out just like youngheart were
and until more recent years youngheart were consistently in the playoffs
Yeah, but they are not there "on past criteria", instead they are a collection of 17 and 18 year olds who have been identified as potential NZ representatives for the 2015 WC, who have been entered into the ASBP by NZ Football as the most cost effective means to give them experience playing together against the best footballers available in NZ in the summers of 2013/14 and 2014/15 leading into and as preparation for the U20 WC in 2015.
As has been identified here, an alternative - playing in A Youth - would cost 100's of $1,000's (does NZ Football want to, or more importantly should NZ Football (and I'd say No!) invest that level of money into one age group team - even if the HPM's son is in the team!??
And yes Reg it's real easy to flippantly say the Wanderers are losing (and they are) however remember the big picture - team of 17 and 18 year olds getting ready to represent NZ in 2015 - and really they have been "in" most games, reading the match reports, if they had converted just a third of the chances they has created, they would at least be mid table. It will be interesting to see how they go next year.
So let's say NZ Football go, "shit Reg is right, Wanderers are shit, let's kick them out. Quick get Reg's number, we don't want another huge loss in the opening game by NZ when we are hosting in 2015, so let's find out how we should instead prepare the 2015 NZ team, Reg will know". What will you say?
Crickets from Reg.
Ali, same scenario, NZ Football's on the phone to you, "Ali, we can't get hold of Reg and we really don't want another huge loss in the opening game by NZ when we are hosting the U20 World Cup in 2015, but you're right Wanderers shouldn't be in the ASBP, so how should we instead prepare the 2015 NZ team". What will you say?
Auckland City FC
This is were NZF should come in then
Thats were Wanderers SC should be playing
What would be of higher quality, A League Youth Team League or ASBP? I would have thought ASBP.
Probably but they should not be in the ASBP.
Correct. Unjust that YHM were removed and sets a dangerous precedent. Do Southern now get removed or do we remove Wanderers because they're shit?
Can't have been that shit, ACFC could only put 2 goals past them both home and away!!
they're losing. on past criteria, they should be kicked out just like youngheart were
and until more recent years youngheart were consistently in the playoffs
Yeah, but they are not there "on past criteria", instead they are a collection of 17 and 18 year olds who have been identified as potential NZ representatives for the 2015 WC, who have been entered into the ASBP by NZ Football as the most cost effective means to give them experience playing together against the best footballers available in NZ in the summers of 2013/14 and 2014/15 leading into and as preparation for the U20 WC in 2015.
As has been identified here, an alternative - playing in A Youth - would cost 100's of $1,000's (does NZ Football want to, or more importantly should NZ Football (and I'd say No!) invest that level of money into one age group team - even if the HPM's son is in the team!??
And yes Reg it's real easy to flippantly say the Wanderers are losing (and they are) however remember the big picture - team of 17 and 18 year olds getting ready to represent NZ in 2015 - and really they have been "in" most games, reading the match reports, if they had converted just a third of the chances they has created, they would at least be mid table. It will be interesting to see how they go next year.
So let's say NZ Football go, "shit Reg is right, Wanderers are shit, let's kick them out. Quick get Reg's number, we don't want another huge loss in the opening game by NZ when we are hosting in 2015, so let's find out how we should instead prepare the 2015 NZ team, Reg will know". What will you say?
Crickets from Reg.
Ali, same scenario, NZ Football's on the phone to you, "Ali, we can't get hold of Reg and we really don't want another huge loss in the opening game by NZ when we are hosting the U20 World Cup in 2015, but you're right Wanderers shouldn't be in the ASBP, so how should we instead prepare the 2015 NZ team". What will you say?
Me: "Hi NZ Football - how did you get my number?"
NZF: "Optimist gave it to us"
Me: "Oh, OK, How can I help"
NZF: "We'd like advice on how to best prepare the U20's team for the 2015 tournament"
Me: "Ah. Well I sell sound systems for a living so I'm probably not the best person to ask"
NZF: "Yes but we're NZF so we have even less clue than you as we've shown by kicking YHM out the ASB Prem in favour of some kids who may play for the U20's"
Me: "Right. Well why don't you ask the advice of any of the other 100's of footballing nations in the world"
NZF: Oh, OK, good idea."
Me: Bye
NZF: "Bye"
I guess time will tell if the Wanderers concept was a good idea.
But a few questions for you Optimist
How many of the Wanderers squad will actually make the U20 squad
4 or 5 at best i'd say
And didnt Manawatu have 2 players in U20 Squad in Turkey last year so they must of been doing something right
And Manawatu won 2 games last season Wanderers will win 1 at best this season so by your reasoning Wanderers shouldnt be in the league next year
And why was the Wanderers Squad for Youth league only selected 5 days before there 1st game (as was the Coach too) when it was supposed to be in on Dec 6th
Surely the supposed best players of the U20 age group would be expected to win more than 1 game between them?
Maybe just Maybe Optimist the Wanderers SC teams have not done what they were intially set up to do
As for the spirit of the forum I think its more do as we say not as we do and abuse posters as and when they feel like it
Do you know what nemesis means
I guess time will tell if the Wanderers concept was a good idea.
But a few questions for you Optimist
How many of the Wanderers squad will actually make the U20 squad
4 or 5 at best i'd say
And didnt Manawatu have 2 players in U20 Squad in Turkey last year so they must of been doing something right
And Manawatu won 2 games last season Wanderers will win 1 at best this season so by your reasoning Wanderers shouldnt be in the league next year
And why was the Wanderers Squad for Youth league only selected 5 days before there 1st game (as was the Coach too) when it was supposed to be in on Dec 6th
Surely the supposed best players of the U20 age group would be expected to win more than 1 game between them?
Maybe just Maybe Optimist the Wanderers SC teams have not done what they were intially set up to do
As for the spirit of the forum I think its more do as we say not as we do and abuse posters as and when they feel like it
Without knowing how much is being spent on keeping the Wanderers in the ASBP I have an alternative to putting them in the ASBP and diluting what should be a serious competition.
Why not spend the same amount on taking the best Under 20 players on a tour of Australia or Asia (or locally) this year and next prior to the WC so they can play as a unit and the Under 20 squad can get used to playing together. Much better to play the team you're going to put out for the 2015 World Cup in bursts than playing fringe players week in and week out in a competition that doesn't want them there. A good four to six match tour this year and the same next year for the full WC squad would be a much more productive way of spending the money than keeping a team of fringe players in the ASBP in mho.
Personally I think the Wanderers concept is just a stop-gap measure instead of a proper preparation.
Value of a tour without at least 5 of probable starting XI? As they are playing for pro clubs tuiloma, thomas, edge, rufer, ridenton may decide a tour not in a FIFA window might not be the best thing for their careers.
Wanderers concept. Will it be repeated for next crop of u17s - in ASB youth I wonder.
Kotahitanga. We are one.
Without knowing how much is being spent on keeping the Wanderers in the ASBP I have an alternative to putting them in the ASBP and diluting what should be a serious competition.
Why not spend the same amount on taking the best Under 20 players on a tour of Australia or Asia (or locally) this year and next prior to the WC so they can play as a unit and the Under 20 squad can get used to playing together. Much better to play the team you're going to put out for the 2015 World Cup in bursts than playing fringe players week in and week out in a competition that doesn't want them there. A good four to six match tour this year and the same next year for the full WC squad would be a much more productive way of spending the money than keeping a team of fringe players in the ASBP in mho.
Personally I think the Wanderers concept is just a stop-gap measure instead of a proper preparation.
Value of a tour without at least 5 of probable starting XI? As they are playing for pro clubs tuiloma, thomas, edge, rufer, ridenton may decide a tour not in a FIFA window might not be the best thing for their careers.
Wanderers concept. Will it be repeated for next crop of u17s - in ASB youth I wonder.
So optimist are there many WYNRS lads playing in that Wanderers youth team? Discussion elsewhere re auk NTC kids not being anywhere near best auk has to offer.
Kotahitanga. We are one.
Besides Tuiloma, Rufer, Ridington, Thomas and Edge, what other NZ Under 20 players playing for professional clubs would qualify for the WC Under 20 team in 1015? I understand there's a possibility David Browne's citizenship qualification may be speeded up and then there's also Sam Burfoot at ACFC.
Lets be honest, if most of the WC Under 20 squad is going to come from the Wanderers, then we're in for some hidings in this showcase event.
Auckland will rise once more
Besides Tuiloma, Rufer, Ridington, Thomas and Edge, what other NZ Under 20 players playing for professional clubs would qualify for the WC Under 20 team in 1015? I understand there's a possibility David Browne's citizenship qualification may be speeded up and then there's also Sam Burfoot at ACFC.
Lets be honest, if most of the WC Under 20 squad is going to come from the Wanderers, then we're in for some hidings in this showcase event.
So optimist are there many WYNRS lads playing in that Wanderers youth team? Discussion elsewhere re auk NTC kids not being anywhere near best auk has to offer.
jeebers optimist you need to chill out a touch. i don't think it's worth getting a hernia over
i thought i'd articulated my point quite well in the past and i'm not going to repeat myself to save you the time in reading back. i think that the idea has merit, but does not belong in the national league.
oh, and i reserve the right to not log on to my computer for a few days, if that's ok with you of course
Yep, agree, my apology to you and Ali is at the end of post #177.
Regarding the spirit of the forum, you're right, my apologies Reg and Ali, I allowed my frustrations in trying to engage in a serious discussion about the alternative to having Wanderers in the ASBP as a preparation/development tool being answered with shallow dismissive sentences/statements, result in personal statements, so again I apologise.
didn't see this until now sorry mate and it's sweet as
i understand your passion
no worries mate, i appreciate the apology, but you don't need to apologise for arguing your corner, which you did so effectively.
Danko a few years ago but not now. Not sure there is one at present in midfield. Perhaps Bale but he seems to have lost his edge of late. John Irving is the one who could step up, at the back, in my opinion. I think Tade is a better striker than Brockie because he knows how to make quick defence-splitting runs and has better ball control.
Danko a few years ago but not now. Not sure there is one at present in midfield. Perhaps Bale but he seems to have lost his edge of late. John Irving is the one who could step up, at the back, in my opinion. I think Tade is a better striker than Brockie because he knows how to make quick defence-splitting runs and has better ball control.
This.
"At the end of the drive the lawmen arrive...
I'll take my chance because luck is on my side or something...
Her name is Rio, she don't need to understand...
Oh Rio, Rio, hear them shout across the land..."
Alternative: Instead of midweek games against Phoenix 'A', why not get the ASB Prem teams to play midweek friendlies against the Wanderers rather than having them as a member of the league?
Auckland City FC
I think Irving is a better player than any of Phoenix's existing fullback options. By some distance.
I guess it's one of the hazards of the Merrick era that he is prone to picking up on things that Ricki may have disregarded.
Not sure about Clapham but definitely John Irving and Krishna. Sam Burfoot has been superb for the Auckland and could definitely make the grade. Jake Butler is not up to it
Sam Burfoot is a natural, and much younger, replacement for Riera
Sam Burfoot is a natural, and much younger, replacement for Riera