It's a difficult subject because some words have connotations when applied to one individual that they don't have for another. So if you shout "monkey" at a European player it's okay but not at a darker skinned player. I understand why but isn't it a bit silly in this day and age when the most powerful man in the world is an African-American. It's like not being able to say the slightest thing that could be perceived as an insult by a devout Islamist or orthodox Jew or raving Catholic. If John Terry calls another player a "c**t" then that's just football, but if he calls him a "black c**t" then all hell breaks loose.
Football isn't tiddlewinks and while I'm all for good manners, things get said in the heat of a game and we should just get over it.I've been known to hurl the odd (relatively mild) insult during moments of frustration watching City, but fortunately being a smug and high and mighty supporter of the best football club in the land those are few and far between (cue sound of JV furiously tapping on his computer keyboard). Having said that I get fed up with the abusive sods on the sidelines who never have anything good to say. You know who you are so stop it you *#@"<>&#!
The way I perceive that is if someone wanted to go me on a football pitch, or from the sidelines, and attack my heritage, race or colour, then I would seek them out and sort that situation out.
Like on this forum, when you confront somebody face to face about something they've said, most times they either p*ss off and run away, or they shrink. I've had some positive dialogue with some people after similar scenarios, and I respect those folks for their willingness to discuss things afterwards, its the cowards who scuttle off that strike me as pathetic.
I would say if you think its ok to call somebody a "black c**t" and you get your nose broken, then its your own fault.
I recall playing in a game where an opponent called me a "black b*stard" and my family was on the sideline, including my nieces mother and family friends. At the after match function, my club coach, unprompted, waited to be asked to make his post-match speech, then said something to the effect, "You can keep your man of the match awards, we're leaving."
As a player, I could certainly "take it", and dish it out, but why should, say, a player's family be subjected to that treatment?
If you flip the argument on its head, you could suggest that instead of saying something ambiguous and potentially offensive, say something else? Or is there a deep seated need, desire, to 'ride the lightening' of good taste for greater effect?
By the way, if Paul Temple heard something racist, specifically targeted at one of Waitakere United's players, I would support any restorative action taken by the competition's governing body. If it happened.
Why would any New Zealand club, and its supporter base, want to legitimise racism in its own stadium, when ten of the 11 OFC member association countries belong to other ethnic groups?
It's a sordid, unwise, reprehensible aspiration for any club, particularly when you can set your team up for a very hostile reception at away venues as a result of a reputation that goes before you.
I work for Auckland City as their media manager and I'm very proud of that role, and proud of being involved with a club I have always had great respect and admiration for. I enjoy the company of the coaching and backroom staff, and the players are also excellent to deal with both on and off the park. The diversity of the group is one of its most attractive qualities.
Football is a universal language that transcends colour, religion, culture and difference, and for that reason alone its a quality to be cherished, not abused or sullied with something as embarrassing and moronic as racism or bigotry of any type.
We can get precious about what language we employ these days, but there should always be boundaries of good taste we should strive not to cross.
I appreciate what your saying and agree, there are boundaries that shouldn't be crossed. I love Kiwitea Street because of its racial and cultural diversity. As a European I don't always appreciate how hurtful certain stereotype comments can be for some people. I've heard some shocking racial abuse hurled at players in England and that always makes me cringe. I can't say I've ever heard it at ACFC, but your right, if it happened then the culprit should be kicked out of the ground. I also don't like the individuals who constantly use obscenities when commenting on the action onfield, particularly as I sometimes bring my young nephew to the game and there's usually lots of kids in the stand.