Normo's coming home
Regional Football - powered by Park Life
The Norman Conquests - Paying Players
Normo's coming home
Normo's coming home
Good article, JD. As a Coach at a Northern League Club who DON'T pay players in any shape or form and who are suffering in terms of player recruitment as a result, I'd be interested to hear people's views on this.
Apparently I'm apathetic, but I couldn't care less.
"Being a Partick Thistle fan sets you apart. It means youre a free thinker. It also means your team has no money." Tim Luckhurst, The Independent, 4th December 2003
Good article, JD. As a Coach at a Northern League Club who DON'T pay players in any shape or form and who are suffering in terms of player recruitment as a result, I'd be interested to hear people's views on this.
Its no longer a problem.
Its no longer a problem.
Apparently I'm apathetic, but I couldn't care less.
"Being a Partick Thistle fan sets you apart. It means youre a free thinker. It also means your team has no money." Tim Luckhurst, The Independent, 4th December 2003
Apparently I'm apathetic, but I couldn't care less.
"Being a Partick Thistle fan sets you apart. It means youre a free thinker. It also means your team has no money." Tim Luckhurst, The Independent, 4th December 2003
Incredible stamina. No shame. Yellow Fever.
on reflection im pretty sure any envelopes i saw were plain, standard white ones. brown is a myth
Apparently I'm apathetic, but I couldn't care less.
"Being a Partick Thistle fan sets you apart. It means youre a free thinker. It also means your team has no money." Tim Luckhurst, The Independent, 4th December 2003
With a note saying, play for us or we'll publish these photos ?
Perfect world � maybe it might be preferable to have no player payments in local football. However, obviously this is unrealistic.
Two part question for you
a) Do you support the concept of team-stacking?
b) Were you managing a team at the end of 2007 that �miraculously� overturned top of table Marist?
I think this demonstrates that despite our fluffy idealist views on these matters, sometimes in reality, the drive to succeed overshadows these ideals (also the fact that you have gratefully accepted payment in the past).
End of the day if some players weren�t being paid - there would be a drop in playing standards as some would literally not bother.
Clubs expect results from their top team, and if you are sensible and spend what you CAN AFFORD in order to raise the bar then all good. I say this as I believe clubs have a duty to foster football at the elite level (�elite� in the relative sense!).
Interesting in the financials how many clubs are running losses and depleting reserves..
I also suggest that those who adopt the same view as you, or indeed strong views on any club football topic, go and join your club committee and actively contribute, instead of barking from the sidelines.
Ps -�Wharfies are pursing players aggressively� � aye? so we are not allowed to try and attract new players now? yes I did tempt Buckle back to the club over a curry at lunch.
Pps � �our second team played in a mismatched kit� � about 85% of our 20 teams will have kit under a year old.
Ppps - My fines exceed my win bonuses anyway..
Pppps � Can you please repay any win bonuses we have given you so you can sit on this moral high-ground!
Ppppps -Who uses brown envelopes?!
Feverish2009-02-19 10:14:13Founder
Incredible stamina. No shame. Yellow Fever.
Founder
End of the day if some players weren�t being paid - there would be a drop in playing standards as some would literally not bother.
Founder

Incredible stamina. No shame. Yellow Fever.
End of the day if some players weren�t being paid - there would be a drop in playing standards as some would literally not bother.
End of the day if some players weren�t being paid - there would be a drop in playing standards as some would literally not bother.
Clubs expect results from their top team, and if you are sensible and spend what you CAN AFFORD in order to raise the bar then all good. I say this as I believe clubs have a duty to foster football at the elite level (�elite� in the relative sense!).
Interesting in the financials how many clubs are running losses and depleting reserves..
I also suggest that those who adopt the same view as you, or indeed strong views on any club football topic, go and join your club committee and actively contribute, instead of barking from the sidelines.
OK then, as someone who spent many years on the committee of BNU I'll have to disagree with you anyway.
BNU has always refused to pay players for exactly the reasons pointed out in James Dean's article. And we always knew what the consequences of that would be and that the club would always be perceived from the outside as being "second tier".
It all depends how you define success. For BNU even getting into Capital Premier and then staying there for 5 or so years was a big deal and everyone who was involved in that took tremendous pride from that. We also took pride from the fact that we weren't screwing the community trusts, that we had no debts, that we weren't ripping off our social members and/or juniors and that we didn't need a "sugar daddy" to artificially prop the club up. The only thing we ever did was not ask the first team for subs and even that got stopped in the end!
No doubt you will argue that BNU has not done anything to foster football at the "elite" level but what does that actually mean? We're talking about local leagues in Wellington, New Zealand - the very arsehole of world football. Where's the pay-off, the benefit from spending money on players?
Sure, some "elite" players may give up if there was no money in it but that would be a very short-term impact, if any. As LF1 points out most players just want to play. As soon as you had a younger generation coming through with no expectations of being paid you would have exactly the same standard as you would have had anyway. In fact, if you took the money currently being paid to players and put it into coaching, facilities etc the standard might even be higher in the long-term.
Anyway, I'm not pretending anything will change but I do take issue with your implication that poor old club committees have no choice except to pay players. It just isn't true and is more to do with what kind of club you want and how you define success.
Good debate anyway.
Cheers,
Regan.
Founder

Incredible stamina. No shame. Yellow Fever.
He's not looking for a hand out to play, just a job to help him survive while he plays.
Hard News2009-02-19 14:45:00
Don't get me wrong - I'm not trying to put BNU on a pedestal. The club is what it is, and definitely isn't perfect or to everybody's taste.
Teams will come and go but for the past 6 or 7 years we've always entered 13 or 14 senior teams across the grades, which is right up there and something that I would still define as being successful (although not quite on the scale of Wharfies!). BNU isn't knocking around in Capital 1 because nobody's got the brains to work out how to pay players, it's always been a very deliberate choice not to go down that path, for better or for worse. Does that demonstrate a lack of ambition? Not really, in fact maybe it's more ambitious. It certainly means that any success the club has feels like it's really been earned. Just ask anyone who was around the club the year we got promoted to Capital Premier, you would have thought we had won the FA Cup!
Anyway, this isn't really about BNU. I just wanted to make the point that clubs definitely do have choices about how they spend their money, it's all about perspective.
By the way, I'm also not currently involved with the committee (2 kids under the age of 3 put paid to that, at least for while) so my views are really my own. Future BNU committee members may feel differently which would be entirely their perogative if they are the ones putting in the time.
Normo's coming home
2ndbest Thanks for helping me out with what the agenda was. at least we agree that thier was a agenda.

