Phoenix Awards 2012/13, Wednesday 7pm

Forgive and delete if there is already a thread on these lines....

This is a really difficult one to pick this year

There's prob a huge list for who shouldn't get it, but who should get it??

I can't think of anyone who has been consistently good, or even consistently reliable.

Jimmy downey

Bertos I suppose springs to mind? 

But probably brockie for scoring so many goals and pushing golden boot all season with a bottom placed club. 

when does the fan vote open?

There's only one player than you can realistically pick, should be a landslide.

Brocks.

Brockie by default.

Easy choice. May even be another whitewash of all the awards, similar to what happened last season. 

Although Ifill with 7 assists in a bad year isn't too shabby.

Brockie 

Brockie by a mile.

Interesting to see all the Brockie love, considering how much knitting people did over him this season. Did he even win a Man of the Match poll?

Brockie had a great season in terms of goals, but my player of the season would be Leo. He has been very consistent all season despite playing in an unfamiliar role.

i really despised brockie for most of the seazson. Just had no work rate until greeny took over.
Whether that be because he was part of a front 2, or if Greeny just made him run more.

Yeah pretty hard to pick someone. Guess that sort of sums up our season though. 

brockie's only saving grace was the 16 goals, shure that looks brilliant when the team only scored 31, but having scored 16 he only gained 2 or three assists, and 2 of those were in one game. To me that speaks more of the type of player he is - a great goal scorer, but nothing else. Leo on the other hand has shown he's mre than capable of playing at RB and then when Greenie put him back at RM he has looked rejuvinated.

Really difficult choice this one. Agree it probably has to be Brockie or Leo. Maybe Manny as an outsider? He hasn't been in his best form, but has still probably been one of our more consistent performers other than a few shockers? But yeah, I'd probably go with Brockie in the end, particularly given his improvement in workrate towards the end of the season.

i'll try go back and check the MOM awards tonight.

Bertos definantly for me. Consistantly hard working, didnt do that much wrong and changed the team moving into midfield

Tom biss

i dont know if i can answer this it's so hard

 I would have thought that the player of the year would have been somebody that week in week out was above average.

Brockie does not fall into that category.

I'm in the Bertos camp as well. Brockie scored a lot of goals but went missing far too often. Leo was played out of position most of the season but was one of our best week-in-week-out. 

Edit: and no one else came close...

I've just gone through and tallied up the votes from the MOM polls on here. The result is ... interesting. See if you can guess who won.

Bertos? Lochhead?

Paston win the votes

Bertos was not our best player this season.

Brockie was.

How much of the Bertos vote is going his way for the surprise factor? He'd probably be my pick for player of the year off the top of my head, but how many of us are just saying that because we expected his move to RB to be a total trainwreck?

Lol Paston. No.

Brocky for me, not even a hard decision to make. Nobody was outstanding, but he was the most polished turd of the bunch. He wins by default pretty much

Spoiler alert: the Fever didn't choose Brockie nor Bertos as the winner from the MoM awards. Brockie actually came 11th in the votes.

Fenton? He was getting a lot of love early in the season... Or failing that, Ifill or Stein.

P.S. Trying to guess here, not giving my opinion.

not bertos or brockie, Stein scored a fair few votes, manny? god they all played so poorly/inconsitantly it's hard to remember any good performances.

Stein or Tyler Boyd ?, especially with his good start to the season with a lot more people voting in the early stages.