Marquee
2.9K
·
7.4K
·
over 17 years

Pretty sure Thompson is the most-capped A-League player - so I wouldn't call him injury prone and I would think he could do better job as CM than Lia, Smith, Sanchez etc.

I'd try offering him a cheeky 2-year deal. Even his most fierce detractors will admit he is a decent squad member - and he doesn't take up an import slot - so why not trying to sign him???

Starting XI
480
·
3.5K
·
about 14 years

I think that's it for me as well, still targetting a top quality Central Midfielder, but Thompson doesn't take an import slot, is an improvement on Smith/Lia in that role, and if we can't get an import then at least we have upgraded at the position. 

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
about 15 years

terminator_x wrote:

Hmm, I have no problem with signing Thompson per se (especially if it's not big money) but it does feel like a tinkering round the edges signing, rather than a let's get fucking serious about this signing.

I certainly don't think that it's such a slam dunk, no risk option that you would do it before the new coach is appointed. If he's still available in a month and the new coach thinks he's a good fit then fine.


You do realise that what gets discussed in here is completely different from what happens in real life Phoenix HQ yes?
Marquee
970
·
6.5K
·
over 11 years

Jeff Vader wrote:

terminator_x wrote:

Hmm, I have no problem with signing Thompson per se (especially if it's not big money) but it does feel like a tinkering round the edges signing, rather than a let's get fucking serious about this signing.

I certainly don't think that it's such a slam dunk, no risk option that you would do it before the new coach is appointed. If he's still available in a month and the new coach thinks he's a good fit then fine.


You do realise that what gets discussed in here is completely different from what happens in real life Phoenix HQ yes?

 

Ah.... the sweet breath of reality. Good for you JV. Sometimes one does wonder.

Still Believin'
750
·
5.7K
·
over 17 years

Jeff Vader wrote:

terminator_x wrote:

Hmm, I have no problem with signing Thompson per se (especially if it's not big money) but it does feel like a tinkering round the edges signing, rather than a let's get fucking serious about this signing.

I certainly don't think that it's such a slam dunk, no risk option that you would do it before the new coach is appointed. If he's still available in a month and the new coach thinks he's a good fit then fine.


You do realise that what gets discussed in here is completely different from what happens in real life Phoenix HQ yes?


Are you saying you don't think they will actually appoint Lee Norfolk??


Marquee
970
·
6.5K
·
over 11 years


Although this is the wrong thread (should be new coaching appointments) I think you're on the right track Term-X. I have heard (from the highest sources) i.e. Leinster FC's legal dept. who has (there's only one) allowed Lee N to open full and frank discussions with the Nix's board re a management position thereof, pending the aquiescence of one H Sanchez, res of Mehico, to step back and allow Lee N his rightful place in assuming full control and managment of Wellington Phoenix AFC, NZ, FFA, Oceania, The World.

Marquee
2.1K
·
8.2K
·
over 17 years

gings wrote:

 While we're playing the midfielder with a link to Dura game how about Wheelhouse? 27, plenty of A-League experience and a free agent.


loves the disco...if you know what I mean

WeeNix
39
·
620
·
about 13 years

Would be happy if Thompson was playing for us next season. Experienced. Goal Scorer. Not an Aussie. Free Agent.

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
about 15 years

terminator_x wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

terminator_x wrote:

Hmm, I have no problem with signing Thompson per se (especially if it's not big money) but it does feel like a tinkering round the edges signing, rather than a let's get fucking serious about this signing.

I certainly don't think that it's such a slam dunk, no risk option that you would do it before the new coach is appointed. If he's still available in a month and the new coach thinks he's a good fit then fine.


You do realise that what gets discussed in here is completely different from what happens in real life Phoenix HQ yes?


Are you saying you don't think they will actually appoint Lee Norfolk??


you fucking what?? You have to be kidding me. Lee is the only option
RR
·
Bossi Insider
11K
·
34K
·
about 16 years

joshyboy007 wrote:

Would be happy if Thompson was playing for us next season. Experienced. Goal Scorer. Not an Aussie. Free Agent.

We are talking Matt Thompson, not Tardchie.
WeeNix
39
·
620
·
about 13 years

joshyboy007 wrote:

Would be happy if Thompson was playing for us next season. Experienced. Goal Scorer. Not an Aussie. Free Agent.

We are talking Matt Thompson, not Tardchie.

Ah another epic fail by me. Meant "An Aussie, not an Import" but it came out together. Haha :)
Trialist
0
·
4
·
over 11 years

Billy Mehmet has handed in trasnfer request in Thailand. The manager was sacked after one game, the translator has left and the fitness coach has resigned.

He has been linked with a move back to the Turkish Super league and other European leagues. Rumours posted on European Rumour Mill.

Would he suit Phoenix now we will have a new manager? Im sure a few A-League clubs would be interested after his performances last season. 

Trialist
0
·
4
·
over 11 years


There were supposed to be over 300 top coaches applications for the job - why would we go for LN - Who else is on the shortlist.

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
about 15 years

ASIANAUS wrote:

Billy Mehmet has handed in trasnfer request in Thailand. The manager was sacked after one game, the translator has left and the fitness coach has resigned.

He has been linked with a move back to the Turkish Super league and other European leagues. Rumours posted on European Rumour Mill.

Would he suit Phoenix now we will have a new manager? Im sure a few A-League clubs would be interested after his performances last season. 

Why would we look to sign a former A league striker when A: striker is not a need of ours and B: Mehmut wasn't any good?
Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
about 15 years

ASIANAUS wrote:


There were supposed to be over 300 top coaches applications for the job - why would we go for LN - Who else is on the shortlist.

I respect you are new so some reading back will help. It's a pisstake
Marquee
2.1K
·
6.4K
·
almost 15 years

Jeff Vader wrote:

ASIANAUS wrote:


There were supposed to be over 300 top coaches applications for the job - why would we go for LN - Who else is on the shortlist.

I respect you are new so some reading back will help. It's a pisstake

That was very Gentle Jeffrey!
Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
about 15 years

If I said anything else, I'd probably get accused of being elitist, this place being all about the in-jokes and in-crowd, we are harsh on noobs, don't support grassroots coalface good honest domestic footballers from Spain, racist, abuse footballers without backing up the point and some other completely irrelevant stuff that has absolutely no truth or factual basis but gets thrown at this forum anyway...

Starting XI
430
·
2.6K
·
almost 17 years

I think it's pretty amazing how quickly Fred has fallen. We would have broken the bank for him (well if there was actually any money in there) a couple of seasons ago when he joined heart. Fills a similar role to Hernandez so no need for us to make a play for him now, just sayin.

RR
·
Bossi Insider
11K
·
34K
·
about 16 years

hlmphil wrote:

I think it's pretty amazing how quickly Fred has fallen. We would have broken the bank for him (well if there was actually any money in there) a couple of seasons ago when he joined heart. Fills a similar role to Hernandez so no need for us to make a play for him now, just sayin.

Last season he was fantastic ... in the games he managed to play. Sadly I think his legs have gone.

With Carlos, Ifill, Brockie and Waffles, we will need someone with a heck of an engine in the midfield to compensate for the lack of work rate.
Phoenix Academy
0
·
470
·
almost 12 years

Jeff Vader wrote:

If I said anything else, I'd probably get accused of being elitist, this place being all about the in-jokes and in-crowd, we are harsh on noobs, don't support grassroots coalface good honest domestic footballers from Spain, racist, abuse footballers without backing up the point and some other completely irrelevant stuff that has absolutely no truth or factual basis but gets thrown at this forum anyway...

Cup of tea and a lie down time again JV.

Starting XI
430
·
2.6K
·
almost 17 years

hlmphil wrote:

I think it's pretty amazing how quickly Fred has fallen. We would have broken the bank for him (well if there was actually any money in there) a couple of seasons ago when he joined heart. Fills a similar role to Hernandez so no need for us to make a play for him now, just sayin.

Last season he was fantastic ... in the games he managed to play. Sadly I think his legs have gone.

With Carlos, Ifill, Brockie and Waffles, we will need someone with a heck of an engine in the midfield to compensate for the lack of work rate.

Totally agree. It's just amazing how much can change for a player in 2 years. Makes me wonder what we'll be saying about CH in 2 years...

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
about 15 years

Trueblue wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

If I said anything else, I'd probably get accused of being elitist, this place being all about the in-jokes and in-crowd, we are harsh on noobs, don't support grassroots coalface good honest domestic footballers from Spain, racist, abuse footballers without backing up the point and some other completely irrelevant stuff that has absolutely no truth or factual basis but gets thrown at this forum anyway...

Cup of tea and a lie down time again JV.

You really are a bit irrelevant aren't you. If you completely missed the sarcasm in that, then I would suggest you are the one who needs a lie down.
Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
about 15 years

hlmphil wrote:

hlmphil wrote:

I think it's pretty amazing how quickly Fred has fallen. We would have broken the bank for him (well if there was actually any money in there) a couple of seasons ago when he joined heart. Fills a similar role to Hernandez so no need for us to make a play for him now, just sayin.

Last season he was fantastic ... in the games he managed to play. Sadly I think his legs have gone.

With Carlos, Ifill, Brockie and Waffles, we will need someone with a heck of an engine in the midfield to compensate for the lack of work rate.

Totally agree. It's just amazing how much can change for a player in 2 years. Makes me wonder what we'll be saying about CH in 2 years...

Or what we were saying about Paul Ifill 2 years ago, or Sigmund 2 years ago, or ....
valeo
·
Legend
4.7K
·
18K
·
over 17 years

JonoNewton wrote:

I think that's it for me as well, still targetting a top quality Central Midfielder, but Thompson doesn't take an import slot, is an improvement on Smith/Lia in that role, and if we can't get an import then at least we have upgraded at the position. 


Now this I can agree with - he is an improvement on Smith and Lia. (a great improvement over Smith, a smaller improvement over Lia)
Marquee
1.1K
·
7.6K
·
about 13 years

It is interesting an Ozzy playing at the Phoenix is not an import player - but a Kiwi playing in an Ozzy Team is an import. They nust be worried we will flood their teams.  

Early retirement
3.1K
·
34K
·
over 17 years

The league started with kiwi's not being imports but then when Asian Champions league spots came along it was changed.  This is why Newcastle had Old and Brown and Perth had Leo, Plodder and Adrian Webster.

WeeNix
39
·
620
·
about 13 years

They should really make a 1 NZ player allowance, especially because it gives more chance to improve the league. Teams won't waste it on an anybody. Just means it allows more imports not from NZ/Aus

TV
On probation
250
·
4.2K
·
over 13 years

joshyboy007 wrote:

They should really make a 1 NZ player allowance, especially because it gives more chance to improve the league. Teams won't waste it on an anybody. Just means it allows more imports not from NZ/Aus


Why should FFA and AFC help us out though? Already doing us a favour really. 

Marquee
7.7K
·
9.6K
·
almost 14 years

 It also gives us an advantage, although our players are disadvantaged.

We have a pool of 25 million to find players from, they have a pool of 20. For the NZ population we are really the only option therefore we can potentially get better quality for less.


TV
On probation
250
·
4.2K
·
over 13 years

Ryan wrote:

 It also gives us an advantage, although our players are disadvantaged.

We have a pool of 25 million to find players from, they have a pool of 20. For the NZ population we are really the only option therefore we can potentially get better quality for less.



I can not make any sense of that

Marquee
4.4K
·
5.8K
·
about 12 years

I think what he is saying the A League will always struggle to find good players at cheap prices if we continue to look overseas for them.

If Australia could look at NZ they would potentially have the option to sign good players that might play without the fear of losing an important import slot and save money.

Hogg is probably a good example of this with various rumours of A League sides apparently interested in him but nothing ever happening. If he wasn't an import slot he may of actually got a gig sooner. Good for NZ player development and for Aussie teams as they get a good player at a fraction of the cost of brining a foreigner in.


 

Moar stars
2.1K
·
4.8K
·
over 12 years

tripvincent wrote:

Ryan wrote:

 It also gives us an advantage, although our players are disadvantaged.

We have a pool of 25 million to find players from, they have a pool of 20. For the NZ population we are really the only option therefore we can potentially get better quality for less.



I can not make any sense of that


Quite clearly saying we have a pool of 25 million people to find a footballer. Do you have any idea how big of a pool that is ? like 3 trillion Liters at least. Surely we can find one swimming around. Easy. But you see, they only have a pool of 20 i guess because of the drought.
In conclusion 25million>20 = We win the league
Ryan is a genius
Marquee
1.4K
·
5.3K
·
about 17 years

tripvincent wrote:

Ryan wrote:

 It also gives us an advantage, although our players are disadvantaged.

We have a pool of 25 million to find players from, they have a pool of 20. For the NZ population we are really the only option therefore we can potentially get better quality for less.



I can not make any sense of that

Basically we have a bigger pool of players to sign than the australian HAL teams, and since NZers are imports for australian HAL teams we have a competitive advantage because if a NZ player is not worth an import slot to an australian HAL side it gives us a stronger bargaining position.
Woof Woof
2.7K
·
19K
·
about 17 years

tripvincent wrote:

Ryan wrote:

 It also gives us an advantage, although our players are disadvantaged.

We have a pool of 25 million to find players from, they have a pool of 20. For the NZ population we are really the only option therefore we can potentially get better quality for less.



I can not make any sense of that

It's a pretty clear point really.

Woof Woof
2.7K
·
19K
·
about 17 years

Bullion wrote:

tripvincent wrote:

Ryan wrote:

 It also gives us an advantage, although our players are disadvantaged.

We have a pool of 25 million to find players from, they have a pool of 20. For the NZ population we are really the only option therefore we can potentially get better quality for less.



I can not make any sense of that

Basically we have a bigger pool of players to sign than the australian HAL teams, and since NZers are imports for australian HAL teams we have a competitive advantage because if a NZ player is not worth an import slot to an australian HAL side it gives us a stronger bargaining position.

I find it stunning that there are people who could not understand this from Ryan's post.

Listen here Fudgeface
3.7K
·
15K
·
over 14 years

el grapadura wrote:

Bullion wrote:

tripvincent wrote:

Ryan wrote:

 It also gives us an advantage, although our players are disadvantaged.

We have a pool of 25 million to find players from, they have a pool of 20. For the NZ population we are really the only option therefore we can potentially get better quality for less.



I can not make any sense of that

Basically we have a bigger pool of players to sign than the australian HAL teams, and since NZers are imports for australian HAL teams we have a competitive advantage because if a NZ player is not worth an import slot to an australian HAL side it gives us a stronger bargaining position.

I find it stunning that there are people who could not understand this from Ryan's post.

What do you mean? 


(nb:this is a lame attempt at a joke)  


Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
over 17 years

Why haven't we signed players for next season yet blah blah blah DOOMED blah blah

WeeNix
39
·
620
·
about 13 years

New free agents:

  • Kruno Lovrek
  • Paul Reid
  • Nathan Sherlock
  • Trent McClenahan
  • Adam Griffiths
  • Jarrod Kyle
  • Nick Ward
  • Dean Heffernan
  • Evan Berger
  • Lewis Italiano

Any for us?

Marquee
5K
·
6.8K
·
almost 12 years

The sound of honking from that lot is deafening. The Paul Reid of 3 years ago maybe but he's gone stale now.

Marquee
260
·
5K
·
about 17 years

Would take Adam Griffiths, can he play RB?

Also ..didn't I read somewhere that Jeremy Christie was back in New Zealand? Could be worth chasing up.

You’ll need an account to join the conversation!

Sign in Sign up