Player ratings v Roar
Oi Oi Edgecumbe... lets have a clean sheet
Permalink
Permalink
Oh dear.
Crowther 4 Palmed the ball to Heinaldo when he should have caught it, missed another cross....
Manny 4 Was taken to the cleaners, should have been subbed before the red card. Dumb.
Siggy 6 Tried his best to turn it around. Siilly "tackle" to give the free kick away.
Dura 6 Chanced his arm a few times
Lochie 6 Did OK
Leo 6 Nice cross for thw goal. Should have scored with early header.
Timmo 5.5 Worked hard
Lia 5.5 Coimbination with Brown somehow left too many midfielders running at our defence
Daniel 6.5 Poor statr but caused them quite a few problems
Ifill 6.5 Could have scored several
Greenie 7 Yay a goal, their keeper lucky to saved his shot too.
Troy 7 Did well
Costa 5 Ran around
Caceras
Hmmmm I guess Troy will play RB against Melbourne
Oi Oi Edgecumbe... lets have a clean sheet
Permalink
Permalink
done
bringbacksmeltz2009-11-29 23:38:23rojas, so special
Permalink
Permalink
Not so sure Crowther can be marked down so low while some of those up the park are still able to score better than average in what was very much a below average performance.
GET YOUR SHIRTS OFF FOR THE BOYS
Permalink
Permalink
Crowther 0 - He was woefull. The wall for the free kick wtf only 4 (ish) players
Permalink
Permalink
Crowther 0 - He was woefull. The wall for the free kick wtf only 4 (ish) players
but, Lia could have put his body on the line and stopped it. But instead he ducked away from the ball.
Permalink
Permalink
bringbacksmeltz could you please make those changes look like you did them?
Oi Oi Edgecumbe... lets have a clean sheet
Permalink
Permalink
Crowther 0 - He was woefull. The wall for the free kick wtf only 4 (ish) players
but, Lia could have put his body on the line and stopped it. But instead he ducked away from the ball.
If Paston was there he would have organised Siggi to be there instead of Lia. But yea Lia 
Permalink
Permalink
Its worrying when Lochhead is in the top group.
Jeez, I cant be bothered tovote for any of them
Permalink
Permalink
Crowther 3 Palmed the ball to Heinaldo when he should have caught it, missed another cross....
Manny 2Was taken to the cleaners, should have been subbed before the red card. Dumb.
Siggy 4.5 Tried his best to turn it around. Siilly "tackle" to give the free kick away.
Dura 6 Chanced his arm a few times
Lochie 5 Did OK
Leo 5 Nice cross for thw goal. Should have scored with early header.
Timmo 5Worked hard
Lia 4.5 Combination with Brown somehow left too many midfielders running at our defence
Daniel 4 .5Poor statr but caused them quite a few problems
Ifill 5 Could have scored several
Greenie 7 Yay a goal, their keeper lucky to saved his shot too.
Troy 6 Did well
Costa 4 Ran around
rojas, so special
Permalink
Permalink
Crowther�3 Palmed the ball to Heinaldo when he should have caught it, missed another cross....
Manny 2Was taken to the cleaners, should have been subbed before the red card. Dumb.
Siggy�4.5 Tried his best to turn it around. Siilly "tackle" to give the free kick away.
Dura 6 Chanced his arm a few times
Lochie�5 Did OK
Leo�5 Nice cross for thw goal. Should have scored with early header.
Timmo 5Worked hard
Lia�4.5 Combination with Brown somehow left too many midfielders running at our defence
Daniel 4 .5Poor statr but caused them quite a few problems
Ifill�5 Could have scored several
Greenie 7 Yay a goal, their keeper lucky to saved his shot too.
Troy�6 Did well
Costa�4 Ran around
Only changes I'd make to these:-
Ifill 6 while not at his best still managed to trouble their keeper a number of times.
Lia > Timmo
Daniel 4 big part in their 2nd goal and control abysmal too often, couple of nice through balls but other than that a passenger
Permalink
Permalink
Adjusted
Crowther 3 Great reaction to palm the ball to Heinaldo but to get nutmegged and beaten easily around the wall....? Let down on the 2nd goal and the back 4 never helped him.
Muscat 2 Was shown by a school boy how to play football then subbed himself off long after Ricki should have done. Very stupid
Sigmund 3 Finally turned up in the 60th minute only to nail Miller not long after. Got dragged out of position easily and most likely his worst game we will see this year from him.
Durante 6 Played a lone hand for the first 60. After that, it was damage control.
Lockhead 5 Occasionally popped up beside Durante when he wasn't standing 10 yards off half way while they were in our box.
Bertos 5 Nice cross for the goal but that was all.
Brown 4.5 Other than a stray hand to the face, did he play? Brisbane midfield clogged and denied the ball.
Lia 4.5 Lucky not to get a card but other than foul, did he play? Brisbane midfield clogged and denied the ball.
Daniel 5 What happened on the 2nd goal. Do you chase back when you lose possession? +.5 for doing the Borat.
Ifill 6 Could have scored several had McMaster not pull of some good saves.
Greenacre 7 Clinical finish, got more involved and probably should have had a 2nd. Looked more like the striker we need.
Jeff Vader2009-11-30 00:15:22Grumpy old bastard alert
Permalink
Permalink
My take:
Crowther 4.5 Flapped once, got nutmegged, looked shaky
Manny 2 Red card or no red card, made no difference he was just as easy for Oar to get passed when he was on as when he wasn't
Siggy 4.5 Ridiculous tackle to give away 3rd goal, seemed completely lost
Dura 5.5 Marking in the middle was poor
Lochie 6 Did OK, make a couple of crucial interventions to save almost certain goals
Leo 6 Nice cross for thw goal. Should have scored with early header.
Timmo 5.5 Brown and Lia were outmanned in a very crowded midfield
Lia 5.5 As above
Daniel 6.5 When we were attacking, Daniel was at the hub of most of it
Ifill 6 Probably his worst game in the yellow and black
Greenie 7 Yay a goal, their keeper lucky to saved his shot too and continued the typical hard work we expect.
Troy 7 Did well
Costa 5 Ran around?
Caceras
Permalink
Permalink
Sorry Oi I agree with the others, Manny, who I've been having major doubts about his defensive ability for weeks now,which all I got in response was "well he's helping out in midfield" or "he's good going forward" etc was sh*te, worse even than Mulligan RB sh*te. I'd give him a 2.
Crowther - where do you begin? Also 2.
Troy was the best and deserved the 7.
Ifill were was he? 5
ForteanTimes2009-11-30 09:53:19
Crowther - where do you begin? Also 2.
Troy was the best and deserved the 7.
Ifill were was he? 5
ForteanTimes2009-11-30 09:53:19
Permalink
Permalink
I thought Ifill was ok tbh, not nearly as bad as people are making out on here. Muscat was utter gash though, as was Crowther.
Permalink
Permalink
I will admit this is the 1st game where I thought WTF! when Manny put the elbow in, it was a Red Card offense and a big let down, always going to be damage control after that! Trot was the too late answer for keeping Oar in check.
Permalink
Permalink
Sorry Oi I agree with the others, Manny, who I've been having major doubts about his defensive ability for weeks now,which all I got in response was "well he's helping out in midfield" or "he's good going forward" etc was sh*te, worse even than Mulligan RB sh*te. I'd give him a 2.
Crowther - where do you begin? Also 2.
Troy was the best and deserved the 7.
Ifill were was he? 5
not the 1st time mannys been done like that either. was it melbourne last season who destroyed him? bring back mulligan. Ifills 6 is generous as he had 3-4 good chances to bring us back in the game. The goal from daniels lost ball summed him up nicely. sulks to muchCrowther - where do you begin? Also 2.
Troy was the best and deserved the 7.
Ifill were was he? 5
rojas, so special
Permalink
Permalink
I thought Ifill was ok tbh, not nearly as bad as people are making out on here. Muscat was utter gash though, as was Crowther.
I think we just expect more every match.
Permalink
Permalink
Sorry Oi I agree with the others, Manny, who I've been having major doubts about his defensive ability for weeks now,which all I got in response was "well he's helping out in midfield" or "he's good going forward" etc was sh*te, worse even than Mulligan RB sh*te. I'd give him a 2.
Crowther - where do you begin? Also 2.
Troy was the best and deserved the 7.
Ifill were was he? 5
not the 1st time mannys been done like that either. was it melbourne last season who destroyed him? bring back mulligan. Ifills 6 is generous as he had 3-4 good chances to bring us back in the game. The goal from daniels lost ball summed him up nicely. sulks to much
Crowther - where do you begin? Also 2.
Troy was the best and deserved the 7.
Ifill were was he? 5
Now, now don't be hasty with this bring back Mulligan talk...
Permalink
Permalink
I thought Ifill was ok tbh, not nearly as bad as people are making out on here. Muscat was utter gash though, as was Crowther.
I think it's cause he didn't do nearly as much as he has in the past and we expect him to be amazing every game. When you compare him to everyone else, Ifill on an off day, is still decent.
Permalink
Permalink
I will admit this is the 1st game where I thought WTF! when Manny put the elbow in, it was a Red Card offense and a big let down, always going to be damage control after that! Trot was the too late answer for keeping Oar in check.
Troy showed Oar that he had the pace to keep up with him within minutes of coming on the pitch, (when he went around him), which was a great thing to do, great to see him mess with Oar's mind. Top stuff Troy.
Permalink
Permalink
Crowther 3 - well I had faith in him, before tonight. Horrible keeping with that free kick - beaten easily and it wasnt even in the corner. Nutmegged too
Manny 0 - Worst display from an aleague player ive seen in awhile. Beaten everytime out wide. Gets 1 for having the sense to sub himself off when ricky wouldnt but then loses that for a horrible attempt at elbowing someone in the face. If the opponent gets up straight away you failed horribly.
Siggy 4 - He was poor, just an off day for him. Got frustrated very quickly
Durante 5.5 - Solid without being outstanding. Couple of very good late tackles
Lochhead 4.5 - Slow last night, poor defending for one goal when 2 players went to cover 1 guy leaving 1 free in the middle
Leo - 5.5 Was ok, couple of good deliveries, couple of horrible ones. Should have scored
Brown 5 - didnt see enough of him, didnt really make that many mistakes but didnt do too much good either
Lia - 5.5 Ok return from suspension, went missing for his standards, alot of poor passes
Daniel - 6 Started slowly but picked up later, source of most of our attacking
Greenacre - 6.5 Good finish, worked hard, should of scored the second
Ifill - 6 Pretty Meh game for him, troubled the keeper a coupel of times
Hearfield 7- Good game for him, came on and showed manny how to defend, looked decent going forward showing some good skill
Costa - 5 not good not bad
Caceras - didnt notice he was even on the park
Manny 0 - Worst display from an aleague player ive seen in awhile. Beaten everytime out wide. Gets 1 for having the sense to sub himself off when ricky wouldnt but then loses that for a horrible attempt at elbowing someone in the face. If the opponent gets up straight away you failed horribly.
Siggy 4 - He was poor, just an off day for him. Got frustrated very quickly
Durante 5.5 - Solid without being outstanding. Couple of very good late tackles
Lochhead 4.5 - Slow last night, poor defending for one goal when 2 players went to cover 1 guy leaving 1 free in the middle
Leo - 5.5 Was ok, couple of good deliveries, couple of horrible ones. Should have scored
Brown 5 - didnt see enough of him, didnt really make that many mistakes but didnt do too much good either
Lia - 5.5 Ok return from suspension, went missing for his standards, alot of poor passes
Daniel - 6 Started slowly but picked up later, source of most of our attacking
Greenacre - 6.5 Good finish, worked hard, should of scored the second
Ifill - 6 Pretty Meh game for him, troubled the keeper a coupel of times
Hearfield 7- Good game for him, came on and showed manny how to defend, looked decent going forward showing some good skill
Costa - 5 not good not bad
Caceras - didnt notice he was even on the park
Permalink
Permalink
Sorry Oi I agree with the others, Manny, who I've been having major doubts about his defensive ability for weeks now,which all I got in response was "well he's helping out in midfield" or "he's good going forward" etc was sh*te, worse even than Mulligan RB sh*te. I'd give him a 2.
Crowther - where do you begin? Also 2.
Troy was the best and deserved the 7.
Ifill were was he? 5
not the 1st time mannys been done like that either. was it melbourne last season who destroyed him? bring back mulligan. Ifills 6 is generous as he had 3-4 good chances to bring us back in the game. The goal from daniels lost ball summed him up nicely. sulks to much
Crowther - where do you begin? Also 2.
Troy was the best and deserved the 7.
Ifill were was he? 5
Now, now don't be hasty with this bring back Mulligan talk...
rojas, so special
Permalink
Permalink
Sorry Oi I agree with the others, Manny, who I've been having major doubts about his defensive ability for weeks now,which all I got in response was "well he's helping out in midfield" or "he's good going forward" etc was sh*te, worse even than Mulligan RB sh*te. I'd give him a 2.
Crowther - where do you begin? Also 2.
Troy was the best and deserved the 7.
Ifill were was he? 5
not the 1st time mannys been done like that either. was it melbourne last season who destroyed him? bring back mulligan. Ifills 6 is generous as he had 3-4 good chances to bring us back in the game. The goal from daniels lost ball summed him up nicely. sulks to much
Crowther - where do you begin? Also 2.
Troy was the best and deserved the 7.
Ifill were was he? 5
Now, now don't be hasty with this bring back Mulligan talk...
I rather play Troy then.
Permalink
Permalink
was just thinking to myself, troy actually went pretty well didnt he. Couple good shots which the keeper struggled with, one of them almost finished by ifill. He looks hungry
rojas, so special
Permalink
Permalink
was just thinking to myself, troy actually went pretty well didnt he. Couple good shots which the keeper struggled with, one of them almost finished by ifill. He looks hungry
He's no Charlie Miller
Founder
Permalink
Permalink
look ok to me, clearly manny was out of his depth pace wise, hearfied looked ok in that dept but was lacking a little awareness - he got caught out on the inside ball. Ifill was ok, but some touches were really bad....crowther just looked star struck, the first palm off th Reinaldo, WTF??? it wasn't a hard shot to catch.
Queenslander 3x a year.
Permalink
Permalink