Wellington Phoenix Men

R26 vs Sydney FC Sunday 6th 7pm

426 replies · 22,209 views
almost 12 years ago
ForteanTimes wrote:
C-Diddy wrote:

How is it that people can still find angst after that? I gave up being angry about our predicament in Newcastle. For me we were gone after the pumping that Heart gave us, subsequent bummings have just been expected.

If anything, this season has highlighted our need for a reserve/youth team who are playing regular competitive football and if getting bummed a few times is what it takes for that to actually happen then the bumming was worth it!




Needs more bumming.

Theres always next week

"Ive just re-visited this and once again realised that C-Diddy is a genius - a drunk, Newcastle bred disgrace - but a genius." - Hard News, 11:39am 4th June 2009

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
Jeff Vader wrote:

Jesus we have made Frank Farina look like a rock star.


That's some solace you can take then, know you've possibly lumbered us with Farina for all of next season.



"Sharing rewards the weak"- Steven Colbert

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago

Fuck this stupid game

Once again it was the senior guys who did not perform....its no point blaming the kids. This side had a core of experianced players and they failed to deliver once again. 


. Ernie mate....Stein and Brockie together does not work.....and even if you try it 20 times it still will not work. As soon as I saw the conditions and that Ernie selected Stein and Brockie I knew we were not going to trouble their keeper. Brockie just does not make runs. We needed to stretch their defence....get their big defenders pulled wide or turn them around in the wet. We played niave wet weather football. At least Boyd and Krishna could have given us some width and pace out wide and Watson could have been handy up front.


In last two seasons we must have conceded close to 80 goals.....and we have fielded senior defenders like Dura, Siggy, Muscat and  Lia for most of these games....so WTF is going wrong. Leaking goals like we have been doing is just totally inexcusible....especially with so many senior defenders. We will always be at the arse end of the comp unless we can fix it.


I have never been in the Del Piero is a twat camp. i thought it was great having such a legend playing in the A-League. But I have changed my mind. He is a cynical diving cunt....he is a cheat of the worst kind....he is a disgrace to football and the sooner he gets his saggy old arse off the football pitch the better. The FFA will be happy....it looks like they will get their poster boy marquee into the playoffs




Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago


Am I right in thinking we only have one or two more years on the license? Gonna have to stop getting regularly pounded (regardless of the reasons/excuses) or the club might be gone. Not trying to be doom and gloomy but realistically the better we perform the stronger our case for staying in the competition. And vice versa

 

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
austin10 wrote:

Fuck this stupid game

Once again it was the senior guys who did not perform....its no point blaming the kids. This side had a core of experianced players and they failed to deliver once again. 


. Ernie mate....Stein and Brockie together does not work.....and even if you try it 20 times it still will not work. As soon as I saw the conditions and that Ernie selected Stein and Brockie I knew we were not going to trouble their keeper. Brockie just does not make runs. We needed to stretch their defence....get their big defenders pulled wide or turn them around in the wet. We played niave wet weather football. At least Boyd and Krishna could have given us some width and pace out wide and Watson could have been handy up front.


In last two seasons we must have conceded close to 80 goals.....and we have fielded senior defenders like Dura, Siggy, Muscat and  Lia for most of these games....so WTF is going wrong. Leaking goals like we have been doing is just totally inexcusible....especially with so many senior defenders. We will always be at the arse end of the comp unless we can fix it.


I have never been in the Del Piero is a twat camp. i thought it was great having such a legend playing in the A-League. But I have changed my mind. He is a cynical diving cunt....he is a cheat of the worst kind....he is a disgrace to football and the sooner he gets his saggy old arse off the football pitch the better. The FFA will be happy....it looks like they will get their poster boy marquee into the playoffs




you have to blame the young guys , to cover for the slow old guys . Lets hope things change
Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago

And ridenton was the only young guy to start , so blame away on the kids

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago

Jeez my memory must be failing. Surprised we finished 4th in 2012! Almost completely forgot that Sydney 3-2 game in the finals. In fairness, I was drunk.

Well, despite my ramblings, we've had quite a fall from grace since then.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qe_B5CzbTJo - Caceres winning penalty v Perth - footage from the Fever Zone

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago · edited almost 12 years ago · History
austin10 wrote:


.In last two seasons we must have conceded close to 80 goals.....and we have fielded senior defenders like Dura, Siggy, Muscat and  Lia for most of these games....so WTF is going wrong. Leaking goals like we have been doing is just totally inexcusible....especially with so many senior defenders. We will always be at the arse end of the comp unless we can fix it.


96 actually - 49 last year, 47 this year with one more game to go. Can we break the 100? Will be riveting watching on Saturday.


But seriously, we've had the worst defence in the league for 2 years now. Last season as Ricki was about to leave I was saying that we needed to start revamping the backline and get a decent centre-back last off-season. We didn't, and of course it looks extremely unlikely we'll do it this offseason.


Ye gods - with each passing week I dread the next season even more.

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago

I think we need to really talk about the defence. Is Sigmund and Durante really a good enough centre back pairing? They look good but the amount of goals we concede speaks for itself.

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
Steve-O wrote:

We should be thinking about replacing Durante, Sigmund, Muscat, Lia, Brockie, Stein.

I think that particular core of players have run their course now.


Note to Mr Morgan.I wouldn't cross the road to the local park to watch these guys let alone take a car ride to see them and a few other usless under performers. 
Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
Ryan54 wrote:

I think we need to really talk about the defence. Is Sigmund and Durante really a good enough centre back pairing? They look good but the amount of goals we concede speaks for itself.

to old to slow
Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago

Check link about Baseball and how umpires favor players with a higher status.

Baseball insiders have long suspected what our research confirms: that umpires tend to make errors in ways that favor players who have established themselves at the top of the game’s status hierarchy. But our findings are also suggestive of the way that people in any sort of evaluative role — not just umpires — are unconsciously biased by simple “status characteristics.

What Umpires Get Wrong

It's pretty easy for Del Piero, he has a little charming chat with the ref before the game, looking like a nice guy and then on the field he falls very quick to trick the referee.

And, the commentators, there are just total ADP fanboys, it is so obvious, every little flick is pure genius to them.

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
Junior82 wrote:
nufc_nz wrote:

whats on tv 1 ?


A documentary on bandwagoning.

I think you'd like it.

Haha - owned

                                                                        COYN    

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
Ryan54 wrote:

I think we need to really talk about the defence. Is Sigmund and Durante really a good enough centre back pairing? They look good but the amount of goals we concede speaks for itself.

Thought we already knew Siggy is a hack with a big heart and a hot head and Dura best years are well past.

Also don't rate Dura as much of a leader. We fall apart too often.

The goals conceded relate to the whole team but these two don't make it any easier


Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
number8 wrote:

Check link about Baseball and how umpires favor players with a higher status.

Baseball insiders have long suspected what our research confirms: that umpires tend to make errors in ways that favor players who have established themselves at the top of the game’s status hierarchy. But our findings are also suggestive of the way that people in any sort of evaluative role — not just umpires — are unconsciously biased by simple “status characteristics.

What Umpires Get Wrong

It's pretty easy for Del Piero, he has a little charming chat with the ref before the game, looking like a nice guy and then on the field he falls very quick to trick the referee.

And, the commentators, there are just total ADP fanboys, it is so obvious, every little flick is pure genius to them.

If ADP played for us most would cover him in cream

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
el grapadura wrote:
austin10 wrote:


.In last two seasons we must have conceded close to 80 goals.....and we have fielded senior defenders like Dura, Siggy, Muscat and  Lia for most of these games....so WTF is going wrong. Leaking goals like we have been doing is just totally inexcusible....especially with so many senior defenders. We will always be at the arse end of the comp unless we can fix it.


96 actually - 49 last year, 47 this year with one more game to go. Can we break the 100? Will be riveting watching on Saturday.


But seriously, we've had the worst defence in the league for 2 years now. Last season as Ricki was about to leave I was saying that we needed to start revamping the backline and get a decent centre-back last off-season. We didn't, and of course it looks extremely unlikely we'll do it this offseason.


Ye gods - with each passing week I dread the next season even more.

Yeah if we don't revamp our backline for next season ( and a decent controlling midfielder) maybe a punt on last might be the best bet.

Seems to me that while happy to have a team, it's done half arsed, then cry about the crowds and take more home games away.

Sounds like a recipe for disaster. Even the away/home crowds won't put up with half arsed forever.

Next year most teams will be better...

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
Munk wrote:
crewemad wrote:

Think we are trying to keep the spoon!

Embrace the Spoon


Spoons are too small to embrace.
A trophy shaped like a toilet seat, however ...
Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago

Just got home- missed the game, and from some of the comments I am glad I did.

If you are old and wise you were probably young and stupid

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
auskiwi wrote:
number8 wrote:

Check link about Baseball and how umpires favor players with a higher status.

Baseball insiders have long suspected what our research confirms: that umpires tend to make errors in ways that favor players who have established themselves at the top of the game’s status hierarchy. But our findings are also suggestive of the way that people in any sort of evaluative role — not just umpires — are unconsciously biased by simple “status characteristics.

What Umpires Get Wrong

It's pretty easy for Del Piero, he has a little charming chat with the ref before the game, looking like a nice guy and then on the field he falls very quick to trick the referee.

And, the commentators, there are just total ADP fanboys, it is so obvious, every little flick is pure genius to them.

If ADP played for us most would cover him in cream


AusKiwi = David Lynch?


Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago


Am I right in thinking we only have one or two more years on the license? Gonna have to stop getting regularly pounded (regardless of the reasons/excuses) or the club might be gone. Not trying to be doom and gloomy but realistically the better we perform the stronger our case for staying in the competition. And vice versa

 

I do not agree (well, I agree we should be winning the league every season.... but someone always gets pounded in any given season).

According to your logic Perth should be really shitting themselves. What have they done for the league anyway (note: sarcasm). They are likely to come last or second last behind us this year. It takes longer to fly from Sydney to Perth, than it is from Sydney to Wellington. Perth have not won the league either (not since the halcyon days of Berndt Stange in the old NSL anyway).... etc etc.

Until there is a whole pile of well-run, financially viable clubs ready to enter the comp, I think we're OK for as long as WelNix are happy to be on board. Even with one of two more we're fine.

FFA does not care if we win or lose, as long as we put bums on seats. If we play well, we achieve that objective even if we lose.

Actually, getting outplayed quite a bit these days

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
number8 wrote:

Check link about Baseball and how umpires favor players with a higher status.

Baseball insiders have long suspected what our research confirms: that umpires tend to make errors in ways that favor players who have established themselves at the top of the game’s status hierarchy. But our findings are also suggestive of the way that people in any sort of evaluative role — not just umpires — are unconsciously biased by simple “status characteristics.

What Umpires Get Wrong

It's pretty easy for Del Piero, he has a little charming chat with the ref before the game, looking like a nice guy and then on the field he falls very quick to trick the referee.

And, the commentators, there are just total ADP fanboys, it is so obvious, every little flick is pure genius to them.

Watching the game on the big telly at the Spectators' Bar with my fellow ChCh YF Masochists' Club, we were pleasantly surprised by Mark Bosnich calling the penalty for SFC a joke. And Bozza is not a natural WPX fan. He said the ref got it wrong because otherwise he'd have to book ADP for diving (which he did in the second half).

Actually, getting outplayed quite a bit these days

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
crewemad wrote:

Think we are trying to keep the spoon!


Embrace the Spoon

We're the WELLINGTON Phoenix

And this is our Home

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
Mainland FC wrote:


Am I right in thinking we only have one or two more years on the license? Gonna have to stop getting regularly pounded (regardless of the reasons/excuses) or the club might be gone. Not trying to be doom and gloomy but realistically the better we perform the stronger our case for staying in the competition. And vice versa

 

I do not agree (well, I agree we should be winning the league every season.... but someone always gets pounded in any given season).

According to your logic Perth should be really shitting themselves. What have they done for the league anyway (note: sarcasm). They are likely to come last or second last behind us this year. It takes longer to fly from Sydney to Perth, than it is from Sydney to Wellington. Perth have not won the league either (not since the halcyon days of Berndt Stange in the old NSL anyway).... etc etc.

Until there is a whole pile of well-run, financially viable clubs ready to enter the comp, I think we're OK for as long as WelNix are happy to be on board. Even with one of two more we're fine.

FFA does not care if we win or lose, as long as we put bums on seats. If we play well, we achieve that objective even if we lose.



You are probably right, but let's not forget that not so many years ago our future was in serious doubt when Bin Hammam was the president of the Asian Confederation and declared he was going to have us ejected from the A League. At that time quite a few football pundits in Australia revealed that they were perfectly happy with this and eagerly put forward their suggestions for new Oz franchises to take our place. So there is definitely a lobby that would not be concerned at all if the Nix disappeared.

If AFC decide to put the magnifying glass on us again we need to be in as strong a position as possible to ensure we stay in the league. We would be reliant on FFA to fight our corner, and in my opinion it's no sure thing that they would if we continue to be abject failures season after season with a steadily declining support base. If it comes to the crunch they might find it more expedient to allow another local Oz franchise to replace us.

I'm not saying this is a likely scenario but we are geographical outsiders permitted to play in the A League on what amounts to a technicality, and therefore a little bit more expendable than the Australian clubs. That's why seeing us get constantly clobbered fills me with the same kind of unease as it does Conan.


Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
Outpost wrote:
Mainland FC wrote:


Am I right in thinking we only have one or two more years on the license? Gonna have to stop getting regularly pounded (regardless of the reasons/excuses) or the club might be gone. Not trying to be doom and gloomy but realistically the better we perform the stronger our case for staying in the competition. And vice versa

 

I do not agree (well, I agree we should be winning the league every season.... but someone always gets pounded in any given season).

According to your logic Perth should be really shitting themselves. What have they done for the league anyway (note: sarcasm). They are likely to come last or second last behind us this year. It takes longer to fly from Sydney to Perth, than it is from Sydney to Wellington. Perth have not won the league either (not since the halcyon days of Berndt Stange in the old NSL anyway).... etc etc.

Until there is a whole pile of well-run, financially viable clubs ready to enter the comp, I think we're OK for as long as WelNix are happy to be on board. Even with one of two more we're fine.

FFA does not care if we win or lose, as long as we put bums on seats. If we play well, we achieve that objective even if we lose.



You are probably right, but let's not forget that not so many years ago our future was in serious doubt when Bin Hammam was the president of the Asian Confederation and declared he was going to have us ejected from the A League. At that time quite a few football pundits in Australia revealed that they were perfectly happy with this and eagerly put forward their suggestions for new Oz franchises to take our place. So there is definitely a lobby that would not be concerned at all if the Nix disappeared.

If AFC decide to put the magnifying glass on us again we need to be in as strong a position as possible to ensure we stay in the league. We would be reliant on FFA to fight our corner, and in my opinion it's no sure thing that they would if we continue to be abject failures season after season with a steadily declining support base. If it comes to the crunch they might find it more expedient to allow another local Oz franchise to replace us.

I'm not saying this is a likely scenario but we are geographical outsiders permitted to play in the A League on what amounts to a technicality, and therefore a little bit more expendable than the Australian clubs. That's why seeing us get constantly clobbered fills me with the same kind of unease as it does Conan.



The FFA will not drop our licence. It's all to do with the TV rights. By having a NZ team in the league, their TV rights revenue rises dramatically. The other thing? Our club is in good financial health. Morgan might be a stingy owner who really doesn't want to spend money, but he HAS money. That's what The FFA care about. Morgan should realise that a club coming last anywhere in the world can't turn a profit. A team winning trophies however...
Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago

Heres mud in ya eye Sydney...

A small town in Europe........looking to bounce straight back up....well that aint going to happen

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
Djinksta wrote:
Outpost wrote:
Mainland FC wrote:


Am I right in thinking we only have one or two more years on the license? Gonna have to stop getting regularly pounded (regardless of the reasons/excuses) or the club might be gone. Not trying to be doom and gloomy but realistically the better we perform the stronger our case for staying in the competition. And vice versa

 

I do not agree (well, I agree we should be winning the league every season.... but someone always gets pounded in any given season).

According to your logic Perth should be really shitting themselves. What have they done for the league anyway (note: sarcasm). They are likely to come last or second last behind us this year. It takes longer to fly from Sydney to Perth, than it is from Sydney to Wellington. Perth have not won the league either (not since the halcyon days of Berndt Stange in the old NSL anyway).... etc etc.

Until there is a whole pile of well-run, financially viable clubs ready to enter the comp, I think we're OK for as long as WelNix are happy to be on board. Even with one of two more we're fine.

FFA does not care if we win or lose, as long as we put bums on seats. If we play well, we achieve that objective even if we lose.



You are probably right, but let's not forget that not so many years ago our future was in serious doubt when Bin Hammam was the president of the Asian Confederation and declared he was going to have us ejected from the A League. At that time quite a few football pundits in Australia revealed that they were perfectly happy with this and eagerly put forward their suggestions for new Oz franchises to take our place. So there is definitely a lobby that would not be concerned at all if the Nix disappeared.

If AFC decide to put the magnifying glass on us again we need to be in as strong a position as possible to ensure we stay in the league. We would be reliant on FFA to fight our corner, and in my opinion it's no sure thing that they would if we continue to be abject failures season after season with a steadily declining support base. If it comes to the crunch they might find it more expedient to allow another local Oz franchise to replace us.

I'm not saying this is a likely scenario but we are geographical outsiders permitted to play in the A League on what amounts to a technicality, and therefore a little bit more expendable than the Australian clubs. That's why seeing us get constantly clobbered fills me with the same kind of unease as it does Conan.



The FFA will not drop our licence. It's all to do with the TV rights. By having a NZ team in the league, their TV rights revenue rises dramatically. The other thing? Our club is in good financial health. Morgan might be a stingy owner who really doesn't want to spend money, but he HAS money. That's what The FFA care about. Morgan should realise that a club coming last anywhere in the world can't turn a profit. A team winning trophies however...

Yeah theres no way FFA are going to jepardise themselves by getting rid of us. They're still trying to find owners for WSW and would kill to have someone like Welnix come along and take ownership of a club. One of the reasons theyre not expanding with more clubs is because suitable owners are few and far between. Axe us and FFA are going to have to create a new club themselves and then risk leaving it on the back burner for who knows how long until someone comes along wanting to take it off their hands.
Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
Jeff Vader wrote:
siac wrote:

That Gary Phillips guy is making Dewhurst seem like a great commentator.

Thats a huge call.
Gary Phillips is probably the only one who is worse.
Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago


Ok, fair call. I was just in the immediate post-match angst phase when I wrote that post about the license.

However, I still think that the longterm future of the club is concerning. There doesn't seem to be any plan in place beyond "develop kiwi youth" which itself isn't exactly easy when we don't have a youth/reserve team. At this rate Welnix may as well save themselves some cash and build a 7000 seat stadium because we aren't going to be getting anywhere near 12,000 if we keep serving up performances like that.

We did play well midseason, but I think some of our older players are declining worryingly fast. And we're talking about extending more of their contracts. And it would be naive to think that other teams in the league won't continue to improve.

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago

Siggy has got to go... he just doesn't have the brain to play at the higher level.

Thus why Emblem started Boxall at CB ahead of him.

Would like to see Boxall drop back into the middle next year. His strength and speed is needed, plus he's much better on the ball.

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago

Our defence has been shit... but how many goals did we conceed when we had Riera playing?

What a difference one player can make. This is why Ernies for signings are going to be crucial, crucial  for the team and whether he has a job at the end of next year.

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago · edited almost 12 years ago · History

And finally, if we get two EPL teams here next season for friendlies they better not fuck up the momentum that this will generate and use it to build numbers and support.

Offer half price tickets with every season pass brought or something.

So much angst... my students are going to have a great day!!

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
AJ13 wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:
siac wrote:

That Gary Phillips guy is making Dewhurst seem like a great commentator.

Thats a huge call.

Gary Phillips is probably the only one who is worse.



He'll improve greatly when his voice breaks.
And Phillips is way better than Dewhurst, which in itself should be the minimum requirement for commentators.
Nix, Leyton Orient and Alloa Athletic supporting schmuck.

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago

With all the drawing of fouls Hernandez gets away with, I cannot understand why he didn't go down from that 'rugby tackle' challenge (as Simon Hill put it) in first half injury time. Carlos was away and Ryall was already on a yellow, so would've been sent off.

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
MetalLegNZ wrote:

Siggy has got to go... he just doesn't have the brain to play at the higher level.

Thus why Emblem started Boxall at CB ahead of him.

Would like to see Boxall drop back into the middle next year. His strength and speed is needed, plus he's much better on the ball.



Boxall and Timmins as centre backs, release Sigmund, keep Durante on the bench.
I've been a fan of Sigmund's for a while, but I think he's proved this season that at his absolute peak he was good enough for the A League but at anything other than that he's not.
Nix, Leyton Orient and Alloa Athletic supporting schmuck.

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago

I think there is a lot of emotional angsting after this loss which is really knee jerk.

 

Our defence was not an issue until we got tonked by the Heart. We bounced back and did CCM but then got the same from Adelaide. We had kept it very tight at the back and that was in part because the guys in front of them did their job and stopped play getting there. It is obvious that Lia is not a DM stop gap which is not his fault - he is just not that type of player.

 

Sigmund and Durante are aging and are not the quickest but if they had the midfield in front of them that did their job, then all of those things are a lot less of an issue because they get protection from guys who are doing their job. At the moment, opposition stare solely at our CBs because that's what they can see. There is no defensive line between them and the CBs. Break that line with some slick inter play (or allow players to hit shots in from outside the box) then yeah, Sigmund and Durante are going to look past it.

I'm not a Sigmund fan but I don't think its fair to go 'well you are past it' when the help he is meant to be getting from the guys in the DM position in front of him, he is not getting. Its effectively a black hole position for us on the field cause the guy that is in there, is not his natural game and I think it is a little unfair to smash Lia for that when its not his game. He has been asked to play there and he has gone 'ok boss'. If Leo was asked to play there, he would go 'ok boss'. Both would be effective as each other in that role.

 

This points back to recruitment. As JD reminded me, we lucked into Riera and prior to that, we were content with Manny and Lia. Ernie needs a DM recruit this winter pure and simple and these defensive woes go away.

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
Jeff Vader wrote:

I think there is a lot of emotional angsting after this loss which is really knee jerk.

 

Our defence was not an issue until we got tonked by the Heart. We bounced back and did CCM but then got the same from Adelaide. We had kept it very tight at the back and that was in part because the guys in front of them did their job and stopped play getting there. It is obvious that Lia is not a DM stop gap which is not his fault - he is just not that type of player.

 

Sigmund and Durante are aging and are not the quickest but if they had the midfield in front of them that did their job, then all of those things are a lot less of an issue because they get protection from guys who are doing their job. At the moment, opposition stare solely at our CBs because that's what they can see. There is no defensive line between them and the CBs. Break that line with some slick inter play (or allow players to hit shots in from outside the box) then yeah, Sigmund and Durante are going to look past it.

I'm not a Sigmund fan but I don't think its fair to go 'well you are past it' when the help he is meant to be getting from the guys in the DM position in front of him, he is not getting. Its effectively a black hole position for us on the field cause the guy that is in there, is not his natural game and I think it is a little unfair to smash Lia for that when its not his game. He has been asked to play there and he has gone 'ok boss'. If Leo was asked to play there, he would go 'ok boss'. Both would be effective as each other in that role.

 

This points back to recruitment. As JD reminded me, we lucked into Riera and prior to that, we were content with Manny and Lia. Ernie needs a DM recruit this winter pure and simple and these defensive woes go away.

Agree 100%. Posted something similar in other thread.
Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
Djinksta wrote:

The FFA will not drop our licence. It's all to do with the TV rights. By having a NZ team in the league, their TV rights revenue rises dramatically. The other thing? Our club is in good financial health. Morgan might be a stingy owner who really doesn't want to spend money, but he HAS money. That's what The FFA care about. Morgan should realise that a club coming last anywhere in the world can't turn a profit. A team winning trophies however...

Gareth Morgan isn't our owner, he is one of a group of 8 or 7 or whatever. I've never heard anyone rant and rave about Rob Morrison not spending any money, or Henry Tait. Why is he all of a sudden becoming the biggest scapegoat since Tim Brown? Because of the cat thing? Or the stupid comments he made about total football over a year ago?
Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
hlmphil wrote:
Djinksta wrote:

The FFA will not drop our licence. It's all to do with the TV rights. By having a NZ team in the league, their TV rights revenue rises dramatically. The other thing? Our club is in good financial health. Morgan might be a stingy owner who really doesn't want to spend money, but he HAS money. That's what The FFA care about. Morgan should realise that a club coming last anywhere in the world can't turn a profit. A team winning trophies however...

Gareth Morgan isn't our owner, he is one of a group of 8 or 7 or whatever. I've never heard anyone rant and rave about Rob Morrison not spending any money, or Henry Tait. Why is he all of a sudden becoming the biggest scapegoat since Tim Brown? Because of the cat thing? Or the stupid comments he made about total football over a year ago?



Yes because he is/was the gobbiest of the owners - so fair game.

Permalink Permalink
almost 12 years ago
Jeff Vader wrote:

I think there is a lot of emotional angsting after this loss which is really knee jerk.

 

Our defence was not an issue until we got tonked by the Heart. We bounced back and did CCM but then got the same from Adelaide. We had kept it very tight at the back and that was in part because the guys in front of them did their job and stopped play getting there. It is obvious that Lia is not a DM stop gap which is not his fault - he is just not that type of player.

 

Sigmund and Durante are aging and are not the quickest but if they had the midfield in front of them that did their job, then all of those things are a lot less of an issue because they get protection from guys who are doing their job. At the moment, opposition stare solely at our CBs because that's what they can see. There is no defensive line between them and the CBs. Break that line with some slick inter play (or allow players to hit shots in from outside the box) then yeah, Sigmund and Durante are going to look past it.

I'm not a Sigmund fan but I don't think its fair to go 'well you are past it' when the help he is meant to be getting from the guys in the DM position in front of him, he is not getting. Its effectively a black hole position for us on the field cause the guy that is in there, is not his natural game and I think it is a little unfair to smash Lia for that when its not his game. He has been asked to play there and he has gone 'ok boss'. If Leo was asked to play there, he would go 'ok boss'. Both would be effective as each other in that role.

 

This points back to recruitment. As JD reminded me, we lucked into Riera and prior to that, we were content with Manny and Lia. Ernie needs a DM recruit this winter pure and simple and these defensive woes go away.

Again, fair call. I've said previously that another DM would also help us be more tactically adaptable too. I'm over the 4-3-1-2 formation and I think other teams have worked it out - choke the middle of the pitch and force our fullbacks to push forward to give us width then when you get the ball back counterattack at pace and stretch our defence. Happens all the time. I did think yesterday that Hernandez was playing more of a free role than usual and that helped, but I'd still rather we played a 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3, and we need a better midfield platform for that.

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink