Sarpreet Singh

2017 replies · 708,003 views
about 2 months ago · edited about 2 months ago · History
No way that Singh should be on the bench. Has to be starting. 

Christ, you just need to look at the table and number of games remaining to see why.

The guy has had a mid season break, due to the climate in Serbia, not an end of season holiday.

He would be fit as a fiddle.


Auckland will rise once more

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
LGmartinbWanderingSheepWhoStoleMySock
about 2 months ago · edited about 2 months ago · History
whether you think he should be starting or not, we all know he wont be.
He'll be on the bench for the WSW away game. I, personally want him to be starting in the derby on the 21st but I suspect he'll be on the bench with an early-ish arrival in the 2nd half. He'll start with Sander against Adelaide on the 6th March.

Queenslander 3x a year.

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
LG
about 2 months ago · edited about 2 months ago · History
Why do we all know he won’t be starting?

He has to start.

6th of March?

You’re dreaming.

Auckland will rise once more

Permalink Permalink
about 2 months ago
He definitely should be able to start fitness wise, just depends if Chiefy thinks he understands how the team is trying to play and the role expected. Teague had only played 35 mins in Belgium and then started against Auckland a few days after he signed, and has started every game since then.
Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
AucklandPhoenixBullioncoochieetheprof+1
about 2 months ago · edited about 2 months ago · History
AucklandPhoenix
Why do we all know he won’t be starting?

He has to start.

6th of March?

You’re dreaming.
come on man be realistic, he may well be fit, but he hasnt been playing.
Italiano isnt known for rushing players into the starting lineup. he arrived in Wellington on the weekend, will be training this week and travelling to sydney where he'll come off the bench for 20 or 30 mins.
Even if he sets the world on fire he wont be starting against Auckland - even if I wish he would be.

edited sorry - I missed the game on the 1st in my initial blurb.
WSW away - Friday 13th - Singh subs on
AFC home - Saturday 21st - Singh Subs
Sydney home - Sunday 1st March - Singh starts

Point still stands is he's not starting this weekend or next.

Queenslander 3x a year.

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
Southernix
about 2 months ago · edited about 2 months ago · History
I fully accept that his minutes will depend on factors we don't know about.
My main concern is whether there will be enough time to work out on-pitch understanding between key players like Singh and Eze and Kartum.  
This instinctive familiarity is what Perth has done so well, the passes from Wooton to Pennington are so instinctive they may as well be wearing black and yellow stripes.


Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
WanderingSheep
about 2 months ago
I'm not sure we can afford not to start him. We need points, and lots of them.
Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
AucklandPhoenixcoochieeMainland FCWhoStoleMySock
about 2 months ago · edited about 2 months ago · History
Worth checking out Chiefy's post Victory press conference, makes some comments suggesting Singh might be rushed straight in, unlike how he usually slowly introduces players
Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
BullionHalf a PintWanderingSheepWhoStoleMySock
about 2 months ago
imanixsupporter
Worth checking out Chiefy's post Victory press conference, makes some comments suggesting Singh might be rushed straight in, unlike how he usually slowly introduces players

If he’s here for game time, he’s going to want game time!


Permalink Permalink
about 2 months ago · edited about 2 months ago · History
If Chief wants to keep his job, he also needs to play him 

I lost my job because I didn’t start the best player in the A league, will not look good on his CV 

Auckland will rise once more

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
hepatitisWanderingSheepwhWhoStoleMySock
about 2 months ago · edited about 2 months ago · History
Chico Geraldes arrived at almost the identical time last year (early Feb) and started on debut verus Auckland in that horrible 6-1 shellacking.

Yes I don't think Chiefy will muck around. Sarpreet to start against WSW.
Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
AucklandPhoenixballaneHalf a PintWanderingSheep+1
about 2 months ago
I'll be happy to be wrong.
heres hoping that Singh builds nto the squad quickly.

Queenslander 3x a year.

Permalink Permalink
about 2 months ago
Starting line up Professor 

Not squad 😂

Auckland will rise once more

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
hepatitismj
about 2 months ago
theprof
small steps smart ass!
building into the squad has nothing to do with starting lineups
https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360935507/back-where-it-started-sarpreet-singh-returns-lift-wellington-phoenix

Maybe it’s been a sign I’ve been watching too much DnD, but a collection of forum personalities would make an excellent fantasy adventuring party to watch, in an alternative world…


Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
theprof
about 2 months ago
martinb
theprof
small steps smart ass!
building into the squad has nothing to do with starting lineups
https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360935507/back-where-it-started-sarpreet-singh-returns-lift-wellington-phoenix

Maybe it’s been a sign I’ve been watching too much DnD, but a collection of forum personalities would make an excellent fantasy adventuring party to watch, in an alternative world…

indeed,
who are you watching?

Queenslander 3x a year.

Permalink Permalink
about 2 months ago · edited about 2 months ago · History
theprof
martinb
theprof
small steps smart ass!
building into the squad has nothing to do with starting lineups
https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360935507/back-where-it-started-sarpreet-singh-returns-lift-wellington-phoenix

Maybe it’s been a sign I’ve been watching too much DnD, but a collection of forum personalities would make an excellent fantasy adventuring party to watch, in an alternative world…

indeed,
who are you watching?

Various Viva La Dirt League games and their GM, Robert Hartley’s own games and Critical Role’s second campaign, The Mighty Nein. 

I used to enjoy reading fantasy as a kid, but some of the campaigns are superlative in design and many, many of the participants are highly experienced and trained actors…the Azerim ones at Viva have a bit more  comedy, so if you are wanting narrative drive more than banter and tangents the Twitch ones with Robert or Critical Role are slightly better there. And also the crit ones and main Azerim campaign were completed years ago so there’s plenty to binge. 

The Viva ones also do a bit of visual stuff and green screen gags interspersed. The others have minis and maps at times, but listening while doing other things is fine.

I’m not an expert, but all the new TV and books I’ve tried of late have annoyed me by comparison. And we’ve finished the Umbrella Academy finally!

So Balane, yourself, APhoenix, Doloras, ImaNix, OiOi, Fenix, one of the dudes with that German striker in their avatar, various recurring guest characters starting with Feverish, Buffy and Dale…LG as the god of Thunder and/War.

I’d probably have to be not in or just an NPC…


Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
theprof
about 2 months ago
martinb
theprof
martinb
theprof
small steps smart ass!
building into the squad has nothing to do with starting lineups
https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360935507/back-where-it-started-sarpreet-singh-returns-lift-wellington-phoenix

Maybe it’s been a sign I’ve been watching too much DnD, but a collection of forum personalities would make an excellent fantasy adventuring party to watch, in an alternative world…

indeed,
who are you watching?

Various Viva La Dirt League games and their GM, Robert Hartley’s own games and Critical Role’s second campaign, The Mighty Nein. 

I used to enjoy reading fantasy as a kid, but some of the campaigns are superlative in design and many, many of the participants are highly experienced and trained actors…the Azerim ones at Viva have a bit more  comedy, so if you are wanting narrative drive more than banter and tangents than the Twitch ones or Critical Role. And also the crit ones and main Azerim campaign were completed years ago so there’s plenty to binge. 

The Viva ones also do a bit of visual stuff and green screen gags interspersed. The others have minis and maps at times, but listening while doing other things is fine.

I’m not an expert, but all the new TV and books I’ve tried of late have annoyed me by comparison. And we’ve finished the Umbrella Academy finally!

nice, there are a good number of pro-actors in the game so to speak, there is a local amateur group that i was part of a few years back that are hilarious.
called Getting Dicey - they stream via twitch you - you should check them out.

sorry this is way way off topic.

Queenslander 3x a year.

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
martinb
about 2 months ago · edited about 2 months ago · History
It’s all the game, player. 😄

(Do they end up on Spotify or YouTube or some such? Not This Could Get Dicey?)
Sorry I keep editing which is a crappy way to continue a conversation. An hour of work avoided. Eh)
YouTube! Found them. Cheers.


Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
theprof
about 2 months ago
Singh should be given only one directive. "Beat Auckland !!" 
Proud to have attended the first 175 Consecutive "Home" Wellington Phoenix "A League" Games !!

The Ruf, The Ruf, The Ruf is on Fire!!

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
Mainland FCmartinbtheprofWanderingSheep+1
about 2 months ago
LG
Singh should be given only one directive. "Beat Auckland !!" 
Bit rough to throw that at him given they havnt done it before. Not sure i would be making a big deal out of it. They seem to be struggling to cope with a normal game without throwing more on with the derby.
Is what it is will come eventually save it for the finals. 😁😜

GET YOUR SHIRTS OFF FOR THE BOYS

Permalink Permalink
about 2 months ago
Still, I am looking forward to how he will fit in and how the understanding of others around him will develop.  He may provide better support not just for Eze but for Armiento, which would probably mean we still need a proper left fullback behind Armiento.  
Also, I have high hopes Singh and Sander Kartum will be at the same level of AM competence - it was sad seeing Sander running into spaces last week with nobody passing the ball early enough to him.


Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
WanderingSheep
about 2 months ago
Any update on Singh's injury during the game? Ice on the knee isn't a good sign, doubt he makes the derby game. 
Permalink Permalink
about 1 month ago
Since2007
Any update on Singh's injury during the game? Ice on the knee isn't a good sign, doubt he makes the derby game. 
8 weeks out. made of glass, waste of time bringing/rushing him back imo.
Permalink Permalink
about 1 month ago · edited about 1 month ago · History
observerfromuh
Since2007
Any update on Singh's injury during the game? Ice on the knee isn't a good sign, doubt he makes the derby game. 
8 weeks out. made of glass, waste of time bringing/rushing him back imo.

Did you say that when he was signed, or just triumphing your sage wisdom today post injury announcement.

It's a contact related match injury, that could have happened to anyone. Creative midfielders by nature can be smaller than most and yet prone to physical tackles. 

Didn't miss any games in Serbia to injury from memory, and also had a pretty okay run last season in Portugal.

Thank god it's a MCL rather than ACL, and hopefully he can still play a few Nix matches before the WC. Also praise be Eli Just could possibly fill his boots well for the AWs. 12 months ago both were languishing in 2nd tier Euro football.

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
ballanebrcodunnix+6
about 1 month ago
But of a disaster from the perspective of the man wanting to get ready for the Cup and from the club who’ve had 4 playmakers in 2 years lost to serious injury. The opposite kind of sign they’d want to be hanging in the window.


Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
coMainland FCWanderingSheepWhoStoleMySock
about 1 month ago · edited about 1 month ago · History
real shame for Singh, and us!
comments about him being made of glass or referencing this injury to the fact we train at NZCIS are reaching, the injury came from the knee on knee contact during the game - only way to avoid that was not being on the field.

https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360940623/wellington-phoenixs-returning-star-sarpreet-singh-ruled-out-eight-weeks

Queenslander 3x a year.

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
brcoochieecoMainland FC+2
about 1 month ago
observerfromuh
Since2007
Any update on Singh's injury during the game? Ice on the knee isn't a good sign, doubt he makes the derby game. 
8 weeks out. made of glass, waste of time bringing/rushing him back imo.
where's this made of glass coming from? He's only had 1 significant injury and not that many in total.

Also, with your crystal ball can you give me the winning lotto numbers.
Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
WanderingSheep
about 1 month ago
theprof
real shame for Singh, and us!
comments about him being made of glass or referencing this injury to the fact we train at NZCIS are reaching, the injury came from the knee on knee contact during the game - only way to avoid that was not being on the field.

https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360940623/wellington-phoenixs-returning-star-sarpreet-singh-ruled-out-eight-weeks
I continue to believe that there is a curse on the Nix, possibly laid when Terry Serepsisos ripped off a sorceress in a property deal.

Ramming liberal dribble down your throat since 2009
This forum needs less angst and more Kate Bush threads



Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
coFUMainland FCSouthernix+3
about 1 month ago
how do you recommend we appease said sorceress?

Queenslander 3x a year.

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
FUNoah4thenix
about 1 month ago
You do wonder about the Nixs bad luck. Its seems to haunt us.
Ok all sides have injuries. But first half of the season we had up to eight players out injured. 
Josh was on fire early season and we were appearing to get a grip on the high line then he gets injured which means new tactics required.
Plus we dont seem to get any penalty decisions going our way.
Now its derby week and we lose two key AWs. 
FFS its tough being a Nix supporter
Permalink Permalink
about 1 month ago
theprof
how do you recommend we appease said sorceress?
It's been a while since I dabbled in the dark arts, but I'd suggest the best precedent would be to follow the Socceroos' example

Ramming liberal dribble down your throat since 2009
This forum needs less angst and more Kate Bush threads



Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
BullioncoFUMainland FC
about 1 month ago
So we need to set up a go fund me page for a witch doctor.

Queenslander 3x a year.

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
DolorasMainland FCWanderingSheepWhoStoleMySock
about 1 month ago
austin111
You do wonder about the Nixs bad luck. Its seems to haunt us.
Ok all sides have injuries. But first half of the season we had up to eight players out injured. 
Josh was on fire early season and we were appearing to get a grip on the high line then he gets injured which means new tactics required.
Plus we dont seem to get any penalty decisions going our way.
Now its derby week and we lose two key AWs. 
FFS its tough being a Nix supporter

Was last season bad? I can't even remember tbh but we also had such a lack of depth a few injuries were very noticeable. Chiefys first season we had minimal injuries which showed with how well we did.

It'd be interesting to see how many times we had the same starting lineup that season compared to this season.
Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
co
about 1 month ago
wilbaker
austin111
You do wonder about the Nixs bad luck. Its seems to haunt us.
Ok all sides have injuries. But first half of the season we had up to eight players out injured. 
Josh was on fire early season and we were appearing to get a grip on the high line then he gets injured which means new tactics required.
Plus we dont seem to get any penalty decisions going our way.
Now its derby week and we lose two key AWs. 
FFS its tough being a Nix supporter

Was last season bad? I can't even remember tbh but we also had such a lack of depth a few injuries were very noticeable. Chiefys first season we had minimal injuries which showed with how well we did.

It'd be interesting to see how many times we had the same starting lineup that season compared to this season.

23/24
Screenshot_20260220_115939_Chrome.jpg 1.15 MB

24/25
Screenshot_20260220_120242_Chrome.jpg 709.92 KB

25/26
Screenshot_20260220_120201_Chrome.jpg 887.81 KB
Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
coochieemjwi
about 1 month ago
Our team is cursed, there is no other way to explain it.  I was looking forward to seeing Singh.  They said up to 8 weeks, perhaps it could be earlier??? You never know right, right?? 
Permalink Permalink
about 1 month ago · edited about 1 month ago · History
So in summary for season 23/24 the Nix had a very fortunate injury run. Zawada the only real long term injury absentee. 

Looking back it felt that way as well, so nice to know a 2 year old hazy memory aligns with the facts!

The Jets have 3 promising players all out long term with ACLs, yet they motoring along. Alex Badolato, Christian Bracco and Oscar Fryer. Not sure the Nix are cursed more than other teams. Though probably more than AFC, who have had few long term injuries since entering the league.
Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
FoWanderingSheepWhoStoleMySock
about 1 month ago · edited about 1 month ago · History
AFC have existed for less than 2 seasons, little bit difficult for them to have multiple season ending injuries in that time.

Queenslander 3x a year.

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
mj
about 1 month ago
theprof
AFC have existed for less than 2 seasons, little bit difficult for them to have multiple season ending injuries in that time.

Somehow in that time period the Nix have managed 3-4, and as above the Jets have 3 guys all out long term this season, all doing their ACL.

For sure is some link between a team performing well, and being mostly injury free.
Nix season 23/24 and AFC since birth.  The Jets a current outlier, same Melb City last season who won the toilet seat despite lots of guys in the infirmary at various times.

But it's a salary capped league. Not even the biggest, most powerful clubs can carry huge squad depth.
Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
coLeggySouthernixWanderingSheep