General Football Discussion

AW v Defending Champs June 21 @ 2am SS2,

862 replies · 97,970 views
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Doloras wrote:
OMG you guys, you must read this. On the BBC website, an Italian fan goes off on the most spoilt, petulant, arrogant, entitled tirade ever seen. It's full of delicious salty tears of what I believe the young people these days call "butthurt".


ha ha good value. Fabio sounds like an Italian who spent one year on exchange at an English University but is now stuck back home in Italy.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
he barely pulled his shirt...and it in no way hindered him. especially not to the point of falling over. but i guess there are always those who enjoy being devils advocate.

Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
It kind of reminds me of when the AB;s tumble out of RWC comps early.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Yeah i sort of changed my mind half way through writing that from 'no way' to 'doubtful'. We all see the shirt pull, but we also see the whistle go well and truly after the dive. Of course there is the idea that the referee was waiting to see how it played out, like advantage wise. I guess we'll never really know unless the ref comes out and tells us. 
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
It kind of reminds me of when the AB;s tumble out of RWC comps early.
Not in the group stage though . I heard a comparison in ratings today between football and rugby, which said it'd be like Iran holding the ABs to a draw during a World Cup. Although it's not quite the same, it does put some perspective on it.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Tegal wrote:
he barely pulled his shirt...and it in no way hindered him. especially not to the point of falling over. but i guess there are always those who enjoy being devils advocate.
 
Doesn't matter. You know that Tegal - your postings on other refereeing matters illustrate good familiarity with the LotG. You pull the shirt and you get caught, it's a foul and a yellow card... exactly the action the ref took.
 
When I saw it in real time, I was totally against the penalty. When they replayed it and showed the pulll, I swore and accepted it. Still, I guess there are those who believe their team is exempt from the rules....
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
timmymadden wrote:
Yeah i sort of changed my mind half way through writing that from 'no way' to 'doubtful'. We all see the shirt pull, but we also see the whistle go well and truly after the dive. Of course there is the idea that the referee was waiting to see how it played out, like advantage wise. I guess we'll never really know unless the ref comes out and tells us. 


Hmmm I doubt very much that if he had not fallen over deliberately that there would have been a whistle


Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
SiNZ wrote:
Tegal wrote:
he barely pulled his shirt...and it in no way hindered him. especially not to the point of falling over. but i guess there are always those who enjoy being devils advocate.
 
Doesn't matter. You know that Tegal - your postings on other refereeing matters illustrate good familiarity with the LotG. You pull the shirt and you get caught, it's a foul and a yellow card... exactly the action the ref took.
 
When I saw it in real time, I was totally against the penalty. When they replayed it and showed the pulll, I swore and accepted it. Still, I guess there are those who believe their team is exempt from the rules....
I realize the ref probably had a better view than we had on TV, but I think it's important to note what you said there. At full speed there was nothing in it, only when we got a slow motion replay from a very convenient angle did we see it.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
timmymadden wrote:
SiNZ wrote:
Tegal wrote:
he barely pulled his shirt...and it in no way hindered him. especially not to the point of falling over. but i guess there are always those who enjoy being devils advocate.
 
Doesn't matter. You know that Tegal - your postings on other refereeing matters illustrate good familiarity with the LotG. You pull the shirt and you get caught, it's a foul and a yellow card... exactly the action the ref took.
 
When I saw it in real time, I was totally against the penalty. When they replayed it and showed the pulll, I swore and accepted it. Still, I guess there are those who believe their team is exempt from the rules....
I realize the ref probably had a better view than we had on TV, but I think it's important to note what you said there. At full speed there was nothing in it, only when we got a slow motion replay from a very convenient angle did we see it.
 
Yep, fair call. From the angle we had and at real speed, I could see no reason for the penalty.
 
What I wanted to know, but couldn't get a replay to give me an answer... did the linesman flag at all?
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
timmymadden wrote:
It kind of reminds me of when the AB;s tumble out of RWC comps early.
Not in the group stage though . I heard a comparison in ratings today between football and rugby, which said it'd be like Iran holding the ABs to a draw during a World Cup. Although it's not quite the same, it does put some perspective on it.
 
Sorry Timmy,
 
My reference was to Italy not beating us today,(see blog above) and how the vultures quickly circle when favourites stumble.
 
Italy might go the same way as France and have a spectacular implosion!!!! 
 
 COYAW's
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
That's also a good point, not sure SiNZ.

Whitehartlane - sorry, I missed your point the first time.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
What a great result. Have read a few threads but too many to go through as I need some sleep.
These are some of the things I think.
It was always on the cards that Fallon was going to get booked because he almost always fouls when he jumps.
Nelson deserved to get booked, and it is not a stupid rule.
I am sorry that we gave away the penalty, but it pleases me(not today) as I am sick of all these players that pull shirts.It is about time they paid the price. Leo almost ripped the guys shirt in a rugby tackle and did not get a card.
To say we were playing 12 mean is crap. We gave away twice as many few kicks.
They had a pile more possession, ten times the corners(I don't think we had any)and miles more shots on goal.
I am not bagging the AW's, it is putting the game in perspective
Some of threads sounded like they were off an OZ forum.
What a bunch of wingers.
We should all enjoy the result as it was a fantastic achievement. We were not good enough to win, but we are still in with a chance to go through.
We have to stop giving the ball away too cheaply.

What we should remember is that it is far easier to defend than attack.

If you are old and wise you were probably young and stupid

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
whats this penalty talk i hear. Apparently we should of got one?
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Leggy wrote:

It was always on the cards that Fallon was going to get booked because he almost always fouls when he jumps.
Nelson deserved to get booked, and it is not a stupid rule.


agree with the bit about Fallon. He does need to stop it if he is going to wanna stay on the field for 90 minutes. But that Nelsen deserves to be booked, thats complete sh!t. he hurt himself and he did not ask for a strecther, the ref did, and Nelsen gets punished for trying to play on and run it off. IMO if the player needs a stretcher he should signal to the ref. Instead of the ref making a call and it turns out the player doesnt need it. Anyway with the penalty, well I was just too shocked to talk and complain. But now I look at it, De Rossi is one hell of a c**t! he gets a slight pull and fuking falls over like he just got shot in the leg. Then he gets up and runs to his teammates and celebrates. Thats why Footballs called a pussy sport FFS.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
SiNZ wrote:
Actually, thinking also about the USA goal being disallowed against Slovenia for a shirt pull and how unpopular a decision that was one wonders whether people would prefer some way of shirt pulling being legal instead? Because I can't think of a way to make spotting it easier. 
seems to me it's just a matter of which holding/shirt pulling is seen in the box and whether they think it's material - not that the rules say that
 
must be one of the toughest areas of the game to referee - probably 8 pairs of players in the box, half of them obstructing/holding/pushing/offside
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Comment from that I-talian on the BBC page posted in previous page - talking about Nelsen: "I understand the emotion of a guy who is technically quite poor on the pitch and who happens to have played in a game where he ended up drawing against a much better team".

I wonder if Nelsen could make the I-talian squad if he was unfortunate enough to be I-talian.  Certainly been better than any of them these last few games.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
tomrewi wrote:
Leggy wrote:

It was always on the cards that Fallon was going to get booked because he almost always fouls when he jumps.
Nelson deserved to get booked, and it is not a stupid rule.


agree with the bit about Fallon. He does need to stop it if he is going to wanna stay on the field for 90 minutes. But that Nelsen deserves to be booked, thats complete sh!t. he hurt himself and he did not ask for a strecther, the ref did, and Nelsen gets punished for trying to play on and run it off. IMO if the player needs a stretcher he should signal to the ref. Instead of the ref making a call and it turns out the player doesnt need it. Anyway with the penalty, well I was just too shocked to talk and complain. But now I look at it, De Rossi is one hell of a c**t! he gets a slight pull and fuking falls over like he just got shot in the leg. Then he gets up and runs to his teammates and celebrates. Thats why Footballs called a pussy sport FFS.


It was the Ref that called for the strecher, that is why he got booked. I am sure that if Nelson had asked forone he would have used it.I know what you are saying, but he should have known better.
Your right about De Rossi, but players( and most of them seem to do it these days) should keep there hands away from shirts etc. It is also cheating.

If you are old and wise you were probably young and stupid

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
SiNZ wrote:
Tegal wrote:
he barely pulled his shirt...and it in no way hindered him. especially not to the point of falling over. but i guess there are always those who enjoy being devils advocate.
 
Doesn't matter. You know that Tegal - your postings on other refereeing matters illustrate good familiarity with the LotG. You pull the shirt and you get caught, it's a foul and a yellow card... exactly the action the ref took.
 
When I saw it in real time, I was totally against the penalty. When they replayed it and showed the pulll, I swore and accepted it. Still, I guess there are those who believe their team is exempt from the rules....
 
Yeah but im also a big advocate for common sense in refereeing decisions. Its never as simple as hand on shirt = penalty = yellow card. 99% of the time that quite correctly wouldn't be given as a penalty.
 
But I see what you're saying,we were just unlucky to be in that 1%. There is no conspiracy,just a very strict referee who favours the book and uses no common sense.
 
It is a fair argument to say that our guys should have known this,based on previous performances by this referee (most noteably in the USA game? Where he disallowed a goal based on practically nothing).
 
Nevertheless,we have a right to feel pretty pissed off about the decision.

Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Blah, blah blah!!!!!
 
Shirt pulls, offsides.....who gives a shiite!!!!
 
We....that is us...little NZ....world cup minnows have just held Italy, current World Champion and four times World Champion to a draw in a full World cup tournament.
 
That is ABSOLUTELY FERKIN UNBELIEVABLE!!!!!!!
 
Living in Europe, I get to see all the football media from this side of the world. The AW's are everyones favourites. They are getting heaps of amazingly positive press. Everyone is making the comparison between a team that plays for the shirt, for the team spirit and not for the money vs the overpayed overpampered "stars" of France, England and Italy.
 
You really have to give Rickie, Ryan and the rest of the lads the utmost respect. They are making history and we all should be immensley proud of them.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
zinidane wrote:
Blah, blah blah!!!!!
 
Shirt pulls, offsides.....who gives a shiite!!!!
 
We....that is us...little NZ....world cup minnows have just held Italy, current World Champion and four times World Champion to a draw in a full World cup tournament.
 
That is ABSOLUTELY FERKIN UNBELIEVABLE!!!!!!!
 
Living in Europe, I get to see all the football media from this side of the world. The AW's are everyones favourites. They are getting heaps of amazingly positive press. Everyone is making the comparison between a team that plays for the shirt, for the team spirit and not for the money vs the overpayed overpampered "stars" of France, England and Italy.
 
You really have to give Rickie, Ryan and the rest of the lads the utmost respect. They are making history and we all should be immensley proud of them.
I think that is one of the things I love the most. It is bringing football down to earth,to what it is all about. And making some of the spoilt brats of other nations look completely stupid.

Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Man I hate diving.  I don't wish injuries on other players very often (in fact, almost never) but I was hoping that on 93 minutes Mulligan would be subbed on so he could bobsled Cannavarro who was being a petulant dickhead.  He'd be sent off, sure, but Cannavarro wouldn't be so smug and let's be honest, it'd be the only way Mully will get game-time in this tournament.

One thing I don't understand is that a fair few Australian-I-talians are hard as nails (Durante for example) but normal I-talians are so disgraceful.  Anyone shed any knowledge on this?
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Some random t shirt company jumping on the bandwagon to make money?

a.haak

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
loyalgunner wrote:
One thing I don't understand is that a fair few Australian-I-talians are hard as nails (Durante for example) but normal I-talians are so disgraceful.� Anyone shed any knowledge on this?

Australians are obsessed with being 'ard in sport, as i'm guessing New Zealanders are. i'm guessing the italian-australian players know they're more likely to be liked and hence more likely to succeed if they don't subscribe to the italian drama-queen mentality.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
melbhoy wrote:
loyalgunner wrote:
One thing I don't understand is that a fair few Australian-I-talians are hard as nails (Durante for example) but normal I-talians are so disgraceful.� Anyone shed any knowledge on this?

Australians are obsessed with being 'ard in sport, as i'm guessing New Zealanders are. i'm guessing the italian-australian players know they're more likely to be liked and hence more likely to succeed if they don't subscribe to the italian drama-queen mentality.


Because they are Australian, not Italian (though some muzza's like to think they are)valeo2010-06-22 00:21:34

a.haak

Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Yahooo! Such an awesome result! Still only just sinking in for me.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Awesome result! Chris Wood deserved that effort to go in and Mr Paston better kep his spot in goal for the last group game going by what happened there.

My only real gripe: Am I the only one who cringes just a little bit when Leo is chasing down someone who has got past him. The hands almost always seem to come up and pull back on the shoulder...


Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Yea I know what you mean, I'm gonna say that was one of the only instances where we gave away a legitimate free kick.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Great result, loved giving it large to the Italian fans at the pub... who to their credit took it well.
 
We were out played, out skilled but not for a single moment out worked.
 
Thats the true strength of this team.
Permalink Permalink
almost 16 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
loyalgunner wrote:
Man I hate diving.  I don't wish injuries on other players very often (in fact, almost never) but I was hoping that on 93 minutes Mulligan would be subbed on so he could bobsled Cannavarro who was being a petulant dickhead.  He'd be sent off, sure, but Cannavarro wouldn't be so smug and let's be honest, it'd be the only way Mully will get game-time in this tournament.

One thing I don't understand is that a fair few Australian-I-talians are hard as nails (Durante for example) but normal I-talians are so disgraceful.  Anyone shed any knowledge on this?
I'm assuming Durante was born and raised in Australia and there for brought up playing that way. I don't watch much Italian league football because it's just like what we saw Monday morning, as soon as you're touched you drop like you've been shot.
Permalink Permalink
over 15 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Leggy wrote:
What a great result. Have read a few threads but too many to go through as I need some sleep.
These are some of the things I think.
It was always on the cards that Fallon was going to get booked because he almost always fouls when he jumps.
Nelson deserved to get booked, and it is not a stupid rule.
I am sorry that we gave away the penalty, but it pleases me(not today) as I am sick of all these players that pull shirts.It is about time they paid the price. Leo almost ripped the guys shirt in a rugby tackle and did not get a card.
To say we were playing 12 mean is crap. We gave away twice as many few kicks.
They had a pile more possession, ten times the corners(I don't think we had any)and miles more shots on goal.
I am not bagging the AW's, it is putting the game in perspective
Some of threads sounded like they were off an OZ forum.
What a bunch of wingers.
We should all enjoy the result as it was a fantastic achievement. We were not good enough to win, but we are still in with a chance to go through.
We have to stop giving the ball away too cheaply.

What we should remember is that it is far easier to defend than attack.
Permalink Permalink
over 15 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
loyalgunner wrote:
Comment from that I-talian on the BBC page posted in previous page - talking about Nelsen: "I understand the emotion of a guy who is technically quite poor on the pitch and who happens to have played in a game where he ended up drawing against a much better team".

I wonder if Nelsen could make the I-talian squad if he was unfortunate enough to be I-talian.  Certainly been better than any of them these last few games.
I get the impression that this guy didn't know who Ryan was or what his pedigree is. Probably an example of the arrogance and failure to prepare properly that his national team showed yesterday. [Fabio, not Ryan].
Permalink Permalink
over 15 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
LOLz
 
"Lippi was further incensed when a New Zealand journalist asked if Daniele De Rossi was guilty of �gamesmanship� when going down for the penalty.

�I saw that the New Zealand goal was offside. It was also a clear penalty on De Rossi. I also saw Rory Fallon immediately went on to the field and started elbowing people left, right and centre.�"
 
No, that would be just your centre backs he was elbowing sir...
Rainman2010-06-22 09:54:44
Permalink Permalink
over 15 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Tegal wrote:
he barely pulled his shirt...and it in no way hindered him. especially not to the point of falling over. but i guess there are always those who enjoy being devils advocate.


He pulled his shirt but in no way hindered him? What?

This is the sequence of events: cross from Chiellini coming in to the far post - De Rossi steals in behind Smith, putting himself in the best position to get to the ball - Smith senses this, instinctively outstretches his arm and grabs De Rossi to slow him down - succeeds, De Rossi realises he can't get to the ball and drops down - penalty. No problem. At all. But of course, Italians are cheating, diving c**ts, and it was only a little tug, it's not like he shot him, is it?

Whatever. If the same thing had happened to Smeltzy in the Italian box and we didn't get the penalty, everyone here would be screaming about the cheating ref and cheating Italian c**ts, and how Smeltzy would have buried the header in the top corner, and how we waz robbed.

But I guess we show respect for the laws of the game only when it suits us.
Permalink Permalink
over 15 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Tegal wrote:
It is a fair argument to say that our guys should have known this,based on previous performances by this referee (most noteably in the USA game? Where he disallowed a goal based on practically nothing).



Different ref - that was Boubacar from Mali. Our guy previosly reffed Algeria and Slovenia.
Permalink Permalink
over 15 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
el grapadura wrote:
Tegal wrote:
he barely pulled his shirt...and it in no way hindered him. especially not to the point of falling over. but i guess there are always those who enjoy being devils advocate.


He pulled his shirt but in no way hindered him? What?

This is the sequence of events: cross from Chiellini coming in to the far post - De Rossi steals in behind Smith, putting himself in the best position to get to the ball - Smith senses this, instinctively outstretches his arm and grabs De Rossi to slow him down - succeeds, De Rossi realises he can't get to the ball and drops down - penalty. No problem. At all. But of course, Italians are cheating, diving c**ts, and it was only a little tug, it's not like he shot him, is it?

Whatever. If the same thing had happened to Smeltzy in the Italian box and we didn't get the penalty, everyone here would be screaming about the cheating ref and cheating Italian c**ts, and how Smeltzy would have buried the header in the top corner, and how we waz robbed.

But I guess we show respect for the laws of the game only when it suits us.
 
 
Hang on what about the arm from De Rossi across Smiths chest holding HIM back as well. Yes Smith has hold of his shirt for a second but De Rossi was fouling him at the same time.
Permalink Permalink
over 15 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
There's mutual holding at the start while jostling for position. That's fine, can't penalise either player. Then De Rossi peals away, Smith grabs him. Foul. Penalty. Every time.el grapadura2010-06-22 12:16:18
Permalink Permalink