Split Personalities
57
·
520
·
over 10 years
whatever wrote:

Chairman Canton appears to have problems remembering where he played his football during the 1990s. He has told a number of people that he has been with Stop Out all of his playing life. In fact he has posted on Old Friends website under Clubs/Stop Out that he has been with Stop Out from 1966 until present. I have taken a photo of the said screen off old friends

 

I can recall Chairman Canton playing for Stokes Valley for several seasons during the 1990s. I can remember games at Delaney Park and his eldest boy was just a toddler on the sideline.

 

So it seems that Capital Football has a Chairman with a bad memory or is it a case of Pants On Fire Mr Chairman?

 


 

so i wonder what his real history is and why he has painted the picture he has?
any stop out people who can fill in the blanks or correct this post….
Trialist
0
·
130
·
about 11 years

Really? Is this even an issue? I would have thought that this would be the least of his worries.

Trialist
0
·
8
·
about 10 years

I agree with Tegal, who cares.

Get back to discussing the issue rather than attacking one person.


Split Personalities
57
·
520
·
over 10 years
Feverish wrote:

Last day for nominations for one CF elected board member.

how many got voted in last year?
as elected members need to be elected every two years so there must of been 2?.
and i thought the rules also say two appointed board members are removed each year even if they have not been in for the full two years as per rule 12.7.2 
so each year there should be nominations asked for from the clubs for these two positions?
and if so who is leaving and who is up for these positions and selection from the almighty selection committee as per rule12.9?

Trialist
11
·
66
·
almost 11 years
whatever wrote:

Chairman Canton appears to have problems remembering where he played his football during the 1990s. He has told a number of people that he has been with Stop Out all of his playing life. In fact he has posted on Old Friends website under Clubs/Stop Out that he has been with Stop Out from 1966 until present. I have taken a photo of the said screen off old friends

 

I can recall Chairman Canton playing for Stokes Valley for several seasons during the 1990s. I can remember games at Delaney Park and his eldest boy was just a toddler on the sideline.

 

So it seems that Capital Football has a Chairman with a bad memory or is it a case of Pants On Fire Mr Chairman?

 


 

so i wonder what his real history is and why he has painted the picture he has?

any stop out people who can fill in the blanks or correct this post….


Heaps of people know he played up in the vegas for a period of time when he left the club in the 90s.  He's never tried to tell me he's been at the club all his life but if he did I would be quick to correct him. Can look into more if you want? In the mean time you could ask your mate paolo who started this thread what he thinks.
Stage Punch
2.1K
·
11K
·
over 16 years

This conversation needs to move along from picking apart Chris Canton's playing history. It's neither interesting nor useful.

 

If you have serious things to contribute about his job as CF Chairman then go for it, but if you don't, then shuddup.


Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years

Jam2/ whatever he changed his name from and Paulo (via Skype) to get on board?

Split Personalities
57
·
520
·
over 10 years

Feverish did you put your name forward for the one vacant spot?

or do you think your card is marked and the board will use rule 23.4.3 last section to use the unused votes against you?

it would be nice to have some people elected who will say what is happening rather than just resign and let it go under the carpet.

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years

Feverish did you put your name forward for the one vacant spot?

or do you think your card is marked and the board will use rule 23.4.3 last section to use the unused votes against you?

it would be nice to have some people elected who will say what is happening rather than just resign and let it go under the carpet.

No I didn't. Too many club responsibilities. Hopefully there are some good names in the mix.
Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years

Peculiar how the CF Board refuse to give out even an extract of their meeting minutes to their member clubs IMO.

Also seems members of the Men's Advisory Group not happy at Chris Canton's statement to clubs implying that the MAG recommended an 11 team Cap 1 where in reality their opinion was to the contrary.

Marquee
1.1K
·
7.6K
·
over 12 years
Feverish wrote:

Peculiar how the CF Board refuse to give out even an extract of their meeting minutes to their member clubs IMO.

Also seems members of the Men's Advisory Group not happy at Chris Canton's statement to clubs implying that the MAG recommended an 11 team Cap 1 where in reality their opinion was to the contrary.

Who are the share holders (commonly know as stake holders br RR) who controls who?
Split Personalities
57
·
520
·
over 10 years
Blew.2 wrote:
Feverish wrote:

Peculiar how the CF Board refuse to give out even an extract of their meeting minutes to their member clubs IMO.

Also seems members of the Men's Advisory Group not happy at Chris Canton's statement to clubs implying that the MAG recommended an 11 team Cap 1 where in reality their opinion was to the contrary.

Who are the share holders (commonly know as stake holders br RR) who controls who?
Well you see it seems the board controls itself and this is the whole federation monster that NZF (NZS then) created to allow them more control over the administration of the sport and for funding from government to be more available.
this is why they and the Hillary commission elect the majority of the board and they have the power to inspect the actions of the board only.
so your only available option is to protest to NZF and request them to look into the dealings at CF board meetings and to give good direction as to what to look for as a concern.
Trialist
11
·
66
·
almost 11 years
Feverish wrote:

Peculiar how the CF Board refuse to give out even an extract of their meeting minutes to their member clubs IMO.

Also seems members of the Men's Advisory Group not happy at Chris Canton's statement to clubs implying that the MAG recommended an 11 team Cap 1 where in reality their opinion was to the contrary.

 

So are you saying he's telling porkies about what the Men's Advisory Group actually said?

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years

'the Board of CF is of the opinion...the Board has remained impartial and acted professionally"

Tui ad?

Split Personalities
57
·
520
·
over 10 years

twice they have made rulings as per there rules and on both occasions they were told they were wrong by a higher power and told to follow the rules as set for 2013 so i have to agree with the tui


maybe the new board member to be elected will get the ship back on course or is this also a tui ad?

do we know who has applied yet?

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years

nobody has applied for the Board

Split Personalities
57
·
520
·
over 10 years

poor form from the clubs or are you meaning people get nominated not applying for the position ?

democracy only works if there are people who are willing to stand and do the hard yards.

what happened to last years unsuccessful canadate?

First Team Squad
200
·
1.4K
·
about 17 years

Isn't it a breach of the rules for them to not supply meeting minutes to member clubs? Seems absurd to me.

Split Personalities
57
·
520
·
over 10 years

just finished checking out the capital football accounts that someone dropped off for me to look at and it looks like the ship still has issues……

is this great asset of the ASB sports centre really doing football any good? i was told when i questioned this in 2012 that FUTSAL was the winner for CF but it keeps loosing large chunks of coin so is it a winner.

who's been drinking that tiger blood………..

This is probably why the Rapa and Coast boys have had there subs increased…..

and is probably the reason there subs were set lower in the first place as this "ASSET" is of no benefit to them so why are they contributing to make up the loss on this potential white elephant?

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
over 14 years

Didn't understand a word of that. Don't know what that means.

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years
Jeff Vader wrote:

Didn't understand a word of that. Don't know what that means.

since Futsal has been brought into the Federations it has incurred losse$
Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
over 13 years
Feverish wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:

Didn't understand a word of that. Don't know what that means.

since Futsal has been brought into the Federations it has incurred losse$


Feverish, do you know if this is Capital-specific - as I've heard ASB centre is pretty expensive - or across the feds?
Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years
Global Game wrote:
Feverish wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:

Didn't understand a word of that. Don't know what that means.

since Futsal has been brought into the Federations it has incurred losse$


Feverish, do you know if this is Capital-specific - as I've heard ASB centre is pretty expensive - or across the feds?
no idea about other Feds - but definitely is being subsided by 'proper football' in Capital
Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
over 14 years

Ah I follow now.

My understanding is that futsal is a negative dollar burden but NZF are invested in it because of the skill factor it can teach.

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years
Jeff Vader wrote:

Ah I follow now.

My understanding is that futsal is a negative dollar burden but NZF are invested in it because of the skill factor it can teach.

it would be interesting to have that explained fully
Split Personalities
57
·
520
·
over 10 years

correct me if i am wrong but is not FUTSAL just indoor soccer under a different name?

so if i am correct then why have CF not engaged the privately run programs and built a business model that includes them and cut some of the overheads of rolling out there program like venues and levels of participation payments?

Listen here Fudgeface
3.7K
·
15K
·
about 14 years

correct me if i am wrong but is not FUTSAL just indoor soccer under a different name?

Nope. Far from it. 


Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Still sounds an awful lot like indoor football to me. Only difference that I can see is that you can slide tackle and goals scored by females don't count as 2 (terrible sexist rule anyway)

Listen here Fudgeface
3.7K
·
15K
·
about 14 years
Tegal wrote:

Still sounds an awful lot like indoor football to me. Only difference that I can see is that you can slide tackle and goals scored by females don't count as 2 (terrible sexist rule anyway)

No walls to bounce the ball off is a pretty big change.
Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Yeah guess so. Not all indoor football courts do that though. 

Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
over 13 years

Falcao. That is all.

WeeNix
57
·
760
·
about 16 years
Tegal wrote:

Still sounds an awful lot like indoor football to me. Only difference that I can see is that you can slide tackle and goals scored by females don't count as 2 (terrible sexist rule anyway)


You have to play it to understand the massive differences. The size and weight of the ball, the size of the court. The speed of the game.
It's pretty easy to see a correlation between early Futsal play and really better footballers in later age. Capital football encouraging it, will be good for football in the long run.
Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years
thelastnomad wrote:
Tegal wrote:

Still sounds an awful lot like indoor football to me. Only difference that I can see is that you can slide tackle and goals scored by females don't count as 2 (terrible sexist rule anyway)


You have to play it to understand the massive differences. The size and weight of the ball, the size of the court. The speed of the game.

It's pretty easy to see a correlation between early Futsal play and really better footballers in later age. Capital football encouraging it, will be good for football in the long run.

 have you (or anyone else) got any proof of that throwaway line used by futsal promoters though?
That Brazilian guy who played for you last year who seems to be Mr Futsal wasn't a great 11 asider when I saw him. The NZF futsal team hardly play 11 aside.
Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
over 13 years
Feverish wrote:
thelastnomad wrote:
Tegal wrote:

Still sounds an awful lot like indoor football to me. Only difference that I can see is that you can slide tackle and goals scored by females don't count as 2 (terrible sexist rule anyway)


You have to play it to understand the massive differences. The size and weight of the ball, the size of the court. The speed of the game.

It's pretty easy to see a correlation between early Futsal play and really better footballers in later age. Capital football encouraging it, will be good for football in the long run.

 have you (or anyone else) got any proof of that throwaway line used by futsal promoters though?

That Brazilian guy who played for you last year who seems to be Mr Futsal wasn't a great 11 asider when I saw him. The NZF futsal team hardly play 11 aside.


Iniesta, Ronaldo, Ronaldhino?
Rojas? Rogic?
Footballers who played futsal
English FA looks to futsal to produce a Messi

About 75% of current Australian Matilda (football) womens team played futsal at a young age.
If you look through the age group teams coming through NZ now, I would say many have played a reasonable amount of futsal.
If you drop down to NTC level, the percentages are even greater.
It doesn't mean a good futsal player makes a good footballer. But the proportion of good footballers who have played futsal is growing in this part of the world.
Do some research.
Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

A lot of good footballers have....I dunno....been to the dentist too. 

Therefore good dental hygiene can make you a good footballer?

That's not to say good dental hygiene equates to a good footballer, but the proportion of footballers with good dental hygiene is increasing in this part of the world. 

Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
over 13 years

Tegal, this won't hurt a bit:
All I'm saying is that an increasing % of our better footballers coming through the system have played futsal.

Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years
Global Game wrote:

Tegal, this won't hurt a bit:
All I'm saying is that an increasing % of our better footballers coming through the system have played futsal.

And all I'm saying is that an increasing % of our better footballers coming through the system have good dental hygiene. 
Both are meaningless statements. 
Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
over 13 years

Hey, stats & logic was never my strong point but I'm a stubborn fcuk so I'll keep trying.
Futsal makes you a better footballer because:
Every player get many many times more touches in 40 minutes of futsal than 90 minutes of football.
Players learn to control the ball with the sole if their foot as the basis for trapping the ball and playing the ball.
Due to the confined space, speed of thought, speed of feet, speed of creativity and speed of pass/move/play are vastly faster than football.
Due to a smaller weighted ball played (usually) on a smooth court surface, the player gets 100% accurate return for their touches on the ball. This leads to far greater ball control mastery.

Split Personalities
57
·
520
·
over 10 years

So Futsal is indoor soccer with just some rule changes……

you all make some good points and they all have a base of truth and both sides want good footballers to have opportunity to develop.

But is the cost too high for the return to your major stake holders of possible better players?


Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
over 13 years

Well done for bring it back on topic Spartacus. Good question. Is the return on investment worth it? Is developing and paying coaches worth it? Is the FTC programme worth it? The 'value' or ROI on FTC investment has yet to be borne out. There are discussions in most of the regions about the value of the FTC programme. Is it developing better players, than what the clubs can do, or private academies? 

IMO futsal is worth it. I'd also add that Wellington, with its plethora or turfs, is ideally placed to develop a low cost outdoor futsal scene. Obviously the benefits of indoor remain - easily played at night, great courts, doesn't matter what the weather is doing.

If I had a choice (and my time again), I'd actually 'invest' in playing futsal exclusively - from the earliest ages until they are 10 or 11 and then introduce football 7 a side. FTC - in some of the the format I've witnessed it, hmm, not so sure on those returns yet.

You’ll need an account to join the conversation!

Sign in Sign up