Wellington Phoenix Men

Phoenix Ownership - Rob says FTFFA

4003 replies · 795,143 views
about 13 years ago

I know the topic has long passed, but wouldn't it be great to build a 15000 rectangular seater beside the caketin for the Nix and Hurricanes and any other team. Could be run by the same staff that run westpac.

i believe that was an option once, but they chose to go ahead with the venue at Kilbirnie

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History

 Not many tracks just north of the stadium: https://maps.google.co.nz/?ll=-41.271727,174.785721&spn=0.002778,0.006539&t=h&z=18

Build a rectangular pitch just north, can also be a training field.

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

nufc_nz wrote:

I know the topic has long passed, but wouldn't it be great to build a 15000 rectangular seater beside the caketin for the Nix and Hurricanes and any other team. Could be run by the same staff that run westpac.


Where exactly ? On the train tracks ? 

Have a look at a map sunshine
Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

nufc_nz wrote:

I know the topic has long passed, but wouldn't it be great to build a 15000 rectangular seater beside the caketin for the Nix and Hurricanes and any other team. Could be run by the same staff that run westpac.


Where exactly ? On the train tracks ? 

Have a look at a map sunshine





Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

@SamJBoyer Did you bother seeking a response from anyone from the Phoenix before writing your article this morning?

@Dale_Warburton Which one? The feature on the state of affairs at the club, or the story on Newtown Park?

@SamJBoyer Newtown one. But while I'm at it, quoting from a forum is hardly great journalism.

@Dale_Warburton 'Nix in lock-down, other than AM stand-up. Found out in PM. & I've no problem with it; it's a fan's voice.

@SamJBoyer Given development of Newtown was first raised in April '12, Im sure you

@SamJBoyer Then why not quote some fans that have an opposing view (because there are some)

 

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

 He really is a terrible journo.


Yellow Fever - Misery loves company

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

patrick478 wrote:

 He really is a terrible journo.

I know this is off topic but I am firmly of the belief that all journalists should have to take a legally binding Hippocratic oath. Also that journalists should at least be held to similar standards to wikipedia page! Ever heard of footnotes? Keeping embellishment to a minimum, not taking excessive license with wording ect.

"Yellow Fever are fantastic – I have to say that"

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

patrick478 wrote:

 He really is a terrible journo.


Sorry Patrick, that's just bang out of order.  I know Sam well, he plays, watches and supports football.  The idea that he is biased against the Phoenix is just a joke.


His piece on the Phoenix today - "What's going on with the Phoenix?" -  is about the most coherent thing anyone has written on the subject.


If the Phoenix knew how to manage the club the venue change story would have been a non - issue.  Instead they refuse to comment and it gets fueled - that's not bad journalism, that's just incredibly bad PR management.  Right now we're just a comedy outfit and blaming the dom post is just part of that - it's just weak.  If you don't like the stories, start getting on top of the message.  The club is an absolute rabble right now, on and off the pitch.


And as for forums being a source of quotes - twitter has for a long time been an accepted source for stories.  I really don't see how on here is much different.  People write on here knowing they are airing their views publicly - I don't see why you get precious about that.



Normo's coming home

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

The Newtown story however Normo was all rubbish.  Sam may have well been handed a hospital pass on it but his name is on it.

How's my driving? - Whine here

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

james dean wrote:

patrick478 wrote:

 He really is a terrible journo.


Sorry Patrick, that's just bang out of order.  I know Sam well, he plays, watches and supports football.  The idea that he is biased against the Phoenix is just a joke.


His piece on the Phoenix today - "What's going on with the Phoenix?" -  is about the most coherent thing anyone has written on the subject.


If the Phoenix knew how to manage the club the venue change story would have been a non - issue.  Instead they refuse to comment and it gets fueled - that's not bad journalism, that's just incredibly bad PR management.  Right now we're just a comedy outfit and blaming the dom post is just part of that - it's just weak.  If you don't like the stories, start getting on top of the message.  The club is an absolute rabble right now, on and off the pitch.


And as for forums being a source of quotes - twitter has for a long time been an accepted source for stories.  I really don't see how on here is much different.  People write on here knowing they are airing their views publicly - I don't see why you get precious about that.




Two points:
1) There isn't a story about venue change. Sam thought he had an exclusive, wrote the piece based on what John Morrison said, and didn't get any comment from the nix.  That is poor.
2) Disagree that twitter is acceptable. Sure if it is a famous person saying some, then fine. But picking out one post in a forum is lazy.  As you know there are a variety of views on here about all issues so surely one post doesn't reflect those views.
Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Royal wrote:
i believe that was an option once, but they chose to go ahead with the venue at Kilbirnie


Think was the Kilbirnie type venue and was meant to be over the concourse, rather than 15,000 outdoor.  The logical spot for an outdoor is across the road from the stadium where the logs are and a new log depot to go North of the ferry terminal.  That move has already been mooted a number of times, albeit without the stadium.  However no one is going to support that while they all have an investment in Westpac.

What it needs is Westpac to be flattened by a VERY localised earthquake or a run away train so you can build a 35k rectangular stadium with a 15k lower tier for smaller crowds.

How's my driving? - Whine here

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History

Hard News wrote:

Royal wrote:
i believe that was an option once, but they chose to go ahead with the venue at Kilbirnie


Think was the Kilbirnie type venue and was meant to be over the concourse, rather than 15,000 outdoor.  The logical spot for an outdoor is across the road from the stadium where the logs are and a new log depot to go North of the ferry terminal.  That move has already been mooted a number of times, albeit without the stadium.  However no one is going to support that while they all have an investment in Westpac.

What it needs is Westpac to be flattened by a VERY localised earthquake or a run away train so you can build a 35k rectangular stadium with a 15k lower tier for smaller crowds.

Bu but what about the All Blacks? and the 7s? (for Wellington not for me. I don't care for either)

"Yellow Fever are fantastic – I have to say that"

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Hard News wrote:

Royal wrote:
i believe that was an option once, but they chose to go ahead with the venue at Kilbirnie


Think was the Kilbirnie type venue and was meant to be over the concourse, rather than 15,000 outdoor.  The logical spot for an outdoor is across the road from the stadium where the logs are and a new log depot to go North of the ferry terminal.  That move has already been mooted a number of times, albeit without the stadium.  However no one is going to support that while they all have an investment in Westpac.

What it needs is Westpac to be flattened by a VERY localised earthquake or a run away train so you can build a 35k rectangular stadium with a 15k lower tier for smaller crowds.



If a 20 something year old swedish cleaner can steal a train and crash it, I'm sure we can arrange it
Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History

I didn't realise he also wrote the Whats Going On piece (which I enjoyed reading and thought was a well thought out piece), I thought he just wrote the Newtown Park piece. And you're right, I was in the wrong saying he is a terrible journo based on reading just one piece of his, I'll retract my statement and adjust it to saying it was a terrible article he wrote. My mistake, sorry. 

But I agree with Dale, there was no story to be written about the venue changed. I went and talked to Henry Tait at the Tee Dubs today and he laughed off the suggestions that Welnix were considering a move. All Boyer needed to do was talk to one of the owners and he would have learnt that the story he was going to run on the front page of the paper (and attach of photo of me to) was absolute codswallop. Oh wait, the reason he couldn't do that was because the Nix are shutting out Dom Post due to the large amount of negativity in their recent articles that are based on facts that are unresearched and incorrect. While this probably isn't Boyer's fault (and for the record I never said that he was biased against the Phoenix), it's the fault of the newspaper he works for.


Yellow Fever - Misery loves company

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

2ndBest wrote:
2) Disagree that twitter is acceptable. Sure if it is a famous person saying some, then fine. But picking out one post in a forum is lazy.  As you know there are a variety of views on here about all issues so surely one post doesn't reflect those views.
This again and +1
No offence to theprof but I thought there were other posts which summarised the general feeling better as well the opportunity to include a variety of voices and opinions.

"Yellow Fever are fantastic – I have to say that"

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

patrick478 wrote:

I didn't realise he also wrote the Whats Going On piece (which I enjoyed reading and thought was a well thought out piece), I thought he just wrote the Newtown Park piece. And you're right, I was in the wrong saying he is a terrible journo based on reading just one piece of his, I'll retract my statement and adjust it to saying it was a terrible article he wrote. My mistake, sorry. 

But I agree with Dale, there was no story to be written about the venue changed. I went and talked to Henry Tait at the Tee Dubs today and he laughed off the suggestions that Welnix were considering a move. All Boyer needed to do was talk to one of the owners and he would have learnt that the story he was going to run on the front page of the paper (and attach of photo of me to) was absolute codswallop. Oh wait, the reason he couldn't do that was because the Nix are shutting out Dom Post due to the large amount of negativity in their recent articles that are based on facts that are unresearched and incorrect. While this probably isn't Boyer's fault (and for the record I never said that he was biased against the Phoenix), it's the fault of the catalogue he works for.

Fixed

"Yellow Fever are fantastic – I have to say that"

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History

asmodeus_82 wrote:
Bu but what about the All Blacks? and the 7s? (for Wellington not for me. I don't care for either)


Total is still 35k but have a lower tier with 15k that you can use for the smaller crowds to pack people in and get atmosphere and an upper tier holding 20. Perhaps with corporate boxes between the two tiers.

How's my driving? - Whine here

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

You guys ever read or heard about the Earthquake machine Nikola Tesla built?

We will never fully decide who has won the football.

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Azevo wrote:

You guys ever read or heard about the Earthquake machine Nikola Tesla built?

Hmm wonder what the resonant frequency of Westpac Stadium is...

"Yellow Fever are fantastic – I have to say that"

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

2ndBest wrote:

james dean wrote:

patrick478 wrote:

 He really is a terrible journo.


Sorry Patrick, that's just bang out of order.  I know Sam well, he plays, watches and supports football.  The idea that he is biased against the Phoenix is just a joke.


His piece on the Phoenix today - "What's going on with the Phoenix?" -  is about the most coherent thing anyone has written on the subject.


If the Phoenix knew how to manage the club the venue change story would have been a non - issue.  Instead they refuse to comment and it gets fueled - that's not bad journalism, that's just incredibly bad PR management.  Right now we're just a comedy outfit and blaming the dom post is just part of that - it's just weak.  If you don't like the stories, start getting on top of the message.  The club is an absolute rabble right now, on and off the pitch.


And as for forums being a source of quotes - twitter has for a long time been an accepted source for stories.  I really don't see how on here is much different.  People write on here knowing they are airing their views publicly - I don't see why you get precious about that.




Two points:
1) There isn't a story about venue change. Sam thought he had an exclusive, wrote the piece based on what John Morrison said, and didn't get any comment from the nix.  That is poor.
2) Disagree that twitter is acceptable. Sure if it is a famous person saying some, then fine. But picking out one post in a forum is lazy.  As you know there are a variety of views on here about all issues so surely one post doesn't reflect those views.

 

Sorry but so long as he gave the Phoenix the chance to respond then that is acceptable.  He has a wellington city councillor on the record saying the venue change story is a goer.  The phoenix come back with a no comment.  Seriously - that is just more appalling media management.  

Like it or not twitter is a source.  The Times, Guardian etc all quote from it directly - celebrity or not - here in the UK.  You may not like ot personally but that's the reality of news gathering these days.


Seriously this blaming of the dom post is pretty pathetic - let's look to get our own house in order before we start shooting the messenger.  I mean the phoenix still can't decide whether there was or wasn't a mid - season instruction to change style.  Who is to say Gareth hasn't proposed moving to the fucking moon for all we know he can get a good deal on a stadium up there.

Normo's coming home

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History

Christ JD, nobody is blaming the Dom Post solely for the club's problems. But it is totally fair to say that they are a part of the problem, because they are. There were some good pieces in yesterday's paper and there were some bad too. The Newtown Park story was fiction. If John Morrison says Ricki Herbert is an alien and the Nix are unavailable for comment do the Dom Post run that too?

You admitted yourself that the Dom Post overall has become a crappy paper. That's the editorial environment these journos are writing in. It's undeniable.

Edit: and I actually thought the DP had a good day yesterday. The Newtown Park story was the only real stinker. The Editorial was great.


Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History

 Oh dear God almighty.

"I've had a s...load of hate mail," Morgan told the Star-Times on the phone from China, where he was attending a wedding. "A lot of it out of America, actually. Now I understand why those people shoot each other so much. God, they're mad."  


I particularly like the bit where he supported the racist Ian Smith regime in Rhodesia. Maybe AucklandNotALawyer is right,

Ramming liberal dribble down your throat since 2009
This forum needs less angst and more Kate Bush threads



Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago



"We don't have a PR department that massages all these things to make them nice and soft and Rob [Morrison, chairman] and I will communicate with the fans and public honestly and when necessary. We don't need to employ someone to learn lines,"

So... Gareth is making a virtue of having no media management?!?

Ramming liberal dribble down your throat since 2009
This forum needs less angst and more Kate Bush threads



Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago


And yet he was anti Vietnam war
Not everyone can be pigeonholed into a category much as we would like it to be.

"Phoenix till they lose"

Posting 97% bollox, 8% lies and 3.658% genuine opinion. 

Genuine opinion: FTFFA

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

james dean wrote:
 

Sorry but so long as he gave the Phoenix the chance to respond then that is acceptable.  He has a wellington city councillor on the record saying the venue change story is a goer.  The phoenix come back with a no comment.  Seriously - that is just more appalling media management.  

Like it or not twitter is a source.  The Times, Guardian etc all quote from it directly - celebrity or not - here in the UK.  You may not like ot personally but that's the reality of news gathering these days.

Seriously this blaming of the dom post is pretty pathetic - let's look to get our own house in order before we start shooting the messenger.  I mean the phoenix still can't decide whether there was or wasn't a mid - season instruction to change style.  Who is to say Gareth hasn't proposed moving to the fucking moon for all we know he can get a good deal on a stadium up there.



Never anywhere does it say that he gave the Phoenix a opportunity to respond. Never in the story does it say that the Phoenix's response was 'no comment'.

Like I say, the use of twitter is lazy journalism. End of. Just because others do, doesn't change that fact. Same with forums. It allows journalism to pick and choose their quotes without retaining any form of balance.

Incidentally, when do you last see a rugby article that include a comment from their forum?
Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

 Oh and by the way, I thought the article where he used a forum quote was very good.

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

james dean wrote:

Sorry but so long as he gave the Phoenix the chance to respond then that is acceptable. 

Printing something with no truth in it is never a good look for a journalist. It is up to them to check things, especially far fetched stories, not for others to correct them.
Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

rjmiller wrote:

james dean wrote:

Sorry but so long as he gave the Phoenix the chance to respond then that is acceptable. 

Printing something with no truth in it is never a good look for a journalist. It is up to them to check things, especially far fetched stories, not for others to correct them.

Yea, I'm confused. Is he a journalist or a gossip columnist  ?


Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

 Journalism standards don't matter as long as it's an article which accords with the prejudices of the reader. If it was a bigging-up, pro-Herbert article, then JD would be complaining as loud as anyone.


Ramming liberal dribble down your throat since 2009
This forum needs less angst and more Kate Bush threads



Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Doloras wrote:



"We don't have a PR department that massages all these things to make them nice and soft and Rob [Morrison, chairman] and I will communicate with the fans and public honestly and when necessary. We don't need to employ someone to learn lines,"

So... Gareth is making a virtue of having no media management?!?
Honestly what I got out of that was "I don't care you don't like it, I'll keep doing it and you'll get used to it" Feels like unwanted anal.
Maybe we will get used to it but if he keeps going in the media like this Wellington at large isn't going to come out and support us. 
Further more the article mentions various committees which make up the running of the club. Would it be an idea perhaps to include players in some of these committees? Only senior players on long term contracts preferably. Dura for instance. Players are what the club is about so would be nice if they had some understanding of the clubs direction and maybe even some input toward it?

"Yellow Fever are fantastic – I have to say that"

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Gareth wrote:

"We don't have a PR department that massages all these things to make them nice and soft and Rob [Morrison, chairman] and I will communicate with the fans and public honestly and when necessary. We don't need to employ someone to learn lines,"


That is all well and good, but we need a decent communications strategy.
Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History


the question has to be why not?? Not sure I'd be saying that's all well and good. 

The Phoenix want a flat tax and to kill your cats and according to this forum is are extreme right wingers/extreme left wingers (going by forum posts). great. Even if that's not what he meant that has been the message. Confusion is a good way to provoke debate, but a confusing brand.  

Keep it simple. Less is more. Get some one with no baggage and a football profile or no other profile to front. Someone who is nothing to the public but Phoenix. If they see their name in the paper it is Phoenix related and to the point. Don't make coming to Phoenix games a referenda on other opinions!



Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

2ndBest wrote:

james dean wrote:
 

Sorry but so long as he gave the Phoenix the chance to respond then that is acceptable.  He has a wellington city councillor on the record saying the venue change story is a goer.  The phoenix come back with a no comment.  Seriously - that is just more appalling media management.  

Like it or not twitter is a source.  The Times, Guardian etc all quote from it directly - celebrity or not - here in the UK.  You may not like ot personally but that's the reality of news gathering these days.

Seriously this blaming of the dom post is pretty pathetic - let's look to get our own house in order before we start shooting the messenger.  I mean the phoenix still can't decide whether there was or wasn't a mid - season instruction to change style.  Who is to say Gareth hasn't proposed moving to the fucking moon for all we know he can get a good deal on a stadium up there.



Never anywhere does it say that he gave the Phoenix a opportunity to respond. Never in the story does it say that the Phoenix's response was 'no comment'.

Like I say, the use of twitter is lazy journalism. End of. Just because others do, doesn't change that fact. Same with forums. It allows journalism to pick and choose their quotes without retaining any form of balance.

Incidentally, when do you last see a rugby article that include a comment from their forum?


Also, that story took up half of the front page. Out of 5 Nix stories run yesterday it was given by far the most prominence. Not Boyer's choice I know but it does highlight that this lazy sensationalism is now endemic at the Dom Post and driven from the top.

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Just on the Rickie & Gareth show ... and I assume this article was not written about them but it's worth looking at from Fossie..


Mariners teach big spenders a lesson in professionalism

http://www.smh.com.au/sport/football/mariners-teach-big-spenders-a-lesson-in-professionalism-20130126-2ddk1.html#ixzz2J8hEkCa7

The best compliment that can be handed to Central Coast Mariners - the little engine that could - is that they are predictable. That is, in terms of their results.

For the third year now under head coach Graham Arnold, it has become commonplace to look at the weekend results and find that the Mariners have won, or at least drawn. A more familiar uncertainty may be a part of life for fans of every team underneath the table-toppers but not for those of the Mariners.

They play well and win, and play poorly and get the result. Or they go behind and come back, as they did against the second-placed Adelaide United on Friday evening. Central Coast pretty much find a way to negotiate any type of game scenario, increasingly with any combination of players.

Where football results are concerned, consistency is the most elusive beast, regardless of the league. But with a budget that is dwarfed by other teams in the top half of the table, the ability of the Mariners to regularly overcome more illustrious, experienced and far more costly opponents is something to be admired - and copied.

The two words that best describe the regime in place at Gosford is ''preparation'' and ''professionalism''.

In many respects, the Mariners have raised the bar of what it means to develop a professional football environment in Australia, where so much thinking, understanding and decision-making is still mired in amateurism - certainly technically.

Even as the club continues to set the pace nationally, resources have been scarce, most particularly in the past season, when new investors were not forthcoming. Yet the Mariners technical staff have continued to work on and off the field to overcome their disadvantages, especially when compared to clubs with greater facilities and resources to throw around or, in most cases, throw away.

The Mariners' excellence draws into focus the exorbitant spending of their competitors, who must be deeply embarrassed to be beaten by an operation that exists on several million dollars less per year. If not, they damn well should be.

The A-League was started by people who wouldn't know a football if it hit them in the face and so too were most of the clubs. Strategy was almost non-existent, past lessons were overlooked and hundreds of millions of dollars were thrown at poor recruits and average coaches - all in the name of the personal ambition of people who just wanted to be involved in the game.

It will take another decade for clubs to professionalise to such an extent that a different degree of rigour, analysis, strategy and vision is applied to every football department.

Football will increasingly look to football for guidance, knowledge and answers. The Mariners have challenged every other club to look at their own accepted beliefs, often developed only from watching a few games on the box, without the decades of experience, study and application. In other words, there are still too many people with no idea about football making harmful decisions.

This actually helps the Mariners, who plug away every day doing the right thing, working tactically, building a strong group, enforcing and enhancing rules and standards, turning the game from a fun pursuit (in which a few business people can get their jollies by hobnobbing with famous players and getting their name in the press) to a profession.

At the Mariners, players come to know what it means to be a footballer. Forget glamour, it's about daily grind, individual and group, accountability, and hours assessing opponents and preparing at length to neutralise their strengths and exploit their weaknesses.

In the early years of the league, both players and coaches struggled to adapt to the concept of professionalism but this is changing as more clubs learn what it takes to achieve success.

It is not about luck, but about work. Every day.

It was necessary and beneficial for Graham Arnold to develop and prove his competence and methods in the daily grind of a club environment, where he has excelled and grown in many respects. Privately and publicly.

For eight years we have had what was called a ''professional league'' simply by virtue of the full-time environment and financial rewards, yet much of it was still amateur. Thanks in no small part to the Mariners, the term professional can now apply.




Socceroo/ Mariner / Whangarei

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

I second that BRING BACK TERRY IS RIGHT

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History

james dean wrote:

Sorry Patrick, that's just bang out of order.  I know Sam well.  (Defending your mates)


And as for forums being a source of quotes - twitter has for a long time been an accepted source for stories.  I really don't see how on here is much different.  People write on here knowing they are airing their views publicly - I don't see why you get precious about that. (There are other points of view that didnt get reported, where is the balance)


 

Sorry but so long as he gave the Phoenix the chance to respond then that is acceptable. (Do you know this or just wild speculation to support your mate) He has a wellington city councillor on the record saying the venue change story is a goer.  The phoenix come back with a no comment.  Seriously - that is just more appalling media management.  


Seriously this blaming of the dom post is pretty pathetic - let's look to get our own house in order before we start shooting the messenger.  I mean the phoenix still can't decide whether there was or wasn't a mid - season instruction to change style.  (It has been made eminently clear, you just dont want to go with it) Who is to say Gareth hasn't proposed moving to the fucking moon for all we know he can get a good deal on a stadium up there.



It is a total beat up of a story, poor from their consumer affairs reporter

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

But the Monkeys will side with the greens who will side with the orangotanges ( Spelt Heineken) no lights no expansion on town belt just ask Squash #wellington

  Supporter For Ever - Keep The Faith - Foundation Member - Never Lets FAX Get In The Way Of A Good Yarn

Permalink Permalink