Wellington Phoenix Men

Phoenix v Brisbane Raw. Sunday 21st of Oct

448 replies · 26,921 views
over 13 years ago

dairyflat wrote:

 Love all the MICRO-analysis.  I'd put the goal down to Siggy not having the right tension in the laces of his left training boot three seasons back. Buttefly effect  and all that....

The idea of causality is a hangover of centuries of deteministic classical thinking. There are no reasons for anything, only chaotic fluctuations in the quantum foam.Time is also an illusion imposed on existence by our mind's limited capacity confronting infinity. The goal was, is and shall be. There is nothing else that can be said about it.

Have you been reading too much David Hume or something Barry?
Don't worry the fluctuations aren't random and the quantum foam is consciousness. You see the greatest illusion is that of separation, there is no dualism between mind and matter, there is only mind, no substance only properties. The quantum foam/superstring/god are all one in the same, this is consciousness manifesting itself as the universe in a grand process of introspection in which all possible potentials are realized through the infinite diverging worlds parallel existences.
The goal both is and is not, only by the means of our collective free perception have we witnessed it and only in this spatio-temporal realm has the goal eventuated. All other possible occurrences and outcomes for the game and every other event have been brought into existence in other imperceptible parts of the universe.

"Yellow Fever are fantastic – I have to say that"

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Was initially disappointed on leaving the ring O fire with the draw yesterday, but then that's the Nix supporter in me expecting us to win every game at home (when in reality if we draw with the current champions, I should he happy???).

It's time for a repeat performance next week of the last time we played in Adelaide (although without Timmy) 

Masters Grade aint no run in the park on a Saturday...

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago · edited over 13 years ago · History

Love the dislike of the "sticky grass". It is exactly the reason the Nix decided to not bother with having the pitch watered before their home games. They've played and have done so well on it for so long that they thought they shouldn't change it.

Fuck this stupid game

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

asmodeus_82 wrote:

dairyflat wrote:

 Love all the MICRO-analysis.  I'd put the goal down to Siggy not having the right tension in the laces of his left training boot three seasons back. Buttefly effect  and all that....

The idea of causality is a hangover of centuries of deteministic classical thinking. There are no reasons for anything, only chaotic fluctuations in the quantum foam.Time is also an illusion imposed on existence by our mind's limited capacity confronting infinity. The goal was, is and shall be. There is nothing else that can be said about it.

Have you been reading too much David Hume or something Barry?
Don't worry the fluctuations aren't random and the quantum foam is consciousness. You see the greatest illusion is that of separation, there is no dualism between mind and matter, there is only mind, no substance only properties. The quantum foam/superstring/god are all one in the same, this is consciousness manifesting itself as the universe in a grand process of introspection in which all possible potentials are realized through the infinite diverging worlds parallel existences.
The goal both is and is not, only by the means of our collective free perception have we witnessed it and only in this spatio-temporal realm has the goal eventuated. All other possible occurrences and outcomes for the game and every other event have been brought into existence in other imperceptible parts of the universe.

Well played, sir.

In a parallel universe somewhere the new forum has the clapping emoticon, and I am using it.

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Best thread of the season so far.


A82, BZ, DF *clapping emoticon gif thingy*  However in conclusion, two words: Sonic. Screwdriver.



Supplemental two words: Amy. Pond. *sob*


"Phoenix till they lose"

Posting 97% bollox, 8% lies and 3.658% genuine opinion. 

Genuine opinion: FTFFA

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Junior82 wrote:

Best thread of the season so far.


A82, BZ, DF *clapping emoticon gif thingy*  However in conclusion, two words: Sonic. Screwdriver.



Supplemental two words: Amy. Pond. *sob*


I'll see you Sonic Screwdriver and raise you a LASER SCREWDRIVER!!

(what does this have to do with football?! Magic the gathering aaand Doctor Who?)

"Yellow Fever are fantastic – I have to say that"

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Fantastic to see all the angst back. All in all pretty happy with a draw from that one. Remember they are back to back champions, who tore an admittedly poor victory a new one last week.  

Manny was pretty solid and between Hysegums, Brockie and Smith, the managed to largely close down the player who is probably the key for the Roar in Portaloo.

I thought Siggy played pretty well on the whole apart from his one rush out of the line.

I have yet to see a replay on telly and of course seeing that my take on things may be completely different.

Yes a win would have been nice and may have been achieved  if we capitilised on some earlier chances but hey, am happy with 1) The draw 2) Our best start to a season ever 3) Only unbeaten side in the League

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

If Clarke is a replacement for Sanchez will we think about subbing him to be a playmaker in the mids? Playing either 1 forward or 3 forward? Manny didn't dominate the game as a playmaker the way he did against Sydney.



Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

asmodeus_82 wrote:

dairyflat wrote:

 Love all the MICRO-analysis.  I'd put the goal down to Siggy not having the right tension in the laces of his left training boot three seasons back. Buttefly effect  and all that....

The idea of causality is a hangover of centuries of deteministic classical thinking. There are no reasons for anything, only chaotic fluctuations in the quantum foam.Time is also an illusion imposed on existence by our mind's limited capacity confronting infinity. The goal was, is and shall be. There is nothing else that can be said about it.

Have you been reading too much David Hume or something Barry?
Don't worry the fluctuations aren't random and the quantum foam is consciousness. You see the greatest illusion is that of separation, there is no dualism between mind and matter, there is only mind, no substance only properties. The quantum foam/superstring/god are all one in the same, this is consciousness manifesting itself as the universe in a grand process of introspection in which all possible potentials are realized through the infinite diverging worlds parallel existences.
The goal both is and is not, only by the means of our collective free perception have we witnessed it and only in this spatio-temporal realm has the goal eventuated. All other possible occurrences and outcomes for the game and every other event have been brought into existence in other imperceptible parts of the universe.



Yeah, right!

When Hibs, went up, to win the Scottish Cup - I wisnae there - furfuxake!

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

martinb wrote:

If Clarke is a replacement for Sanchez will we think about subbing him to be a playmaker in the mids? Playing either 1 forward or 3 forward? Manny didn't dominate the game as a playmaker the way he did against Sydney.

Talked to Sanchez last night - approx 3 weeks away.

  Supporter For Ever - Keep The Faith - Foundation Member - Never Lets FAX Get In The Way Of A Good Yarn

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Blew.2 wrote:

2ndBest wrote:
Boxal ?l ball watching should have been going to close berisita earlier

 Just to illustrate how out of position Sigmund is. Left to play to close down the player that manny has picked up.  Think you can share a bit of blame with Manny as he wasn't with 10 years of the player with the ball.


No, that opens up space for Halloran to run across Locky straight into the box 1 on 1. This is Siggy's mistake through and through, there is absolutely no reason for him to be out of the defensive line in this situation.
Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago · edited over 13 years ago · History

ginger_eejit wrote:

asmodeus_82 wrote:

BarryZuckerkorn

[quote=dairyflat

wrote:

 Love all the MICRO-analysis.  I'd put the goal down to Siggy not having the right tension in the laces of his left training boot three seasons back. Buttefly effect  and all that....

[/quote] The idea of causality is a hangover of centuries of deteministic classical thinking. There are no reasons for anything, only chaotic fluctuations in the quantum foam.Time is also an illusion imposed on existence by our mind's limited capacity confronting infinity. The goal was, is and shall be. There is nothing else that can be said about it.

Have you been reading too much David Hume or something Barry?
Don't worry the fluctuations aren't random and the quantum foam is consciousness. You see the greatest illusion is that of separation, there is no dualism between mind and matter, there is only mind, no substance only properties. The quantum foam/superstring/god are all one in the same, this is consciousness manifesting itself as the universe in a grand process of introspection in which all possible potentials are realized through the infinite diverging worlds parallel existences.
The goal both is and is not, only by the means of our collective free perception have we witnessed it and only in this spatio-temporal realm has the goal eventuated. All other possible occurrences and outcomes for the game and every other event have been brought into existence in other imperceptible parts of the universe.



Yeah, right!
Hey man if you've got a better explanation for reality that can handle the paradoxes without contradicting itself while being consistent with contemporary physics I'd love to hear it. 

Non-dualism is the best explanation for existence/reality I've found thus far and I've been actively looking for four years or so. Of course then I go trying to combine it with string theory... (note: the above is actually what I genuinely believe is the ultimate nature of reality, convoluted as it is thinking about stuff is better than taking the universe at face value from your unreliable sense data.)

Yeah; metaphysics can be a real mindf***!

"Yellow Fever are fantastic – I have to say that"

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

martinb wrote:

If Clarke is a replacement for Sanchez will we think about subbing him to be a playmaker in the mids? Playing either 1 forward or 3 forward? Manny didn't dominate the game as a playmaker the way he did against Sydney.

"Injury replacement" doesn't necessarily mean an actual straight replacement position-wise.  

Fuck this stupid game

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

el grapadura wrote:

Blew.2 wrote:

2ndBest wrote:
Boxal ?l ball watching should have been going to close berisita earlier

 Just to illustrate how out of position Sigmund is. Left to play to close down the player that manny has picked up.  Think you can share a bit of blame with Manny as he wasn't with 10 years of the player with the ball.


No, that opens up space for Halloran to run across Locky straight into the box 1 on 1. This is Siggy's mistake through and through, there is absolutely no reason for him to be out of the defensive line in this situation.
Yeah agree it was mostly Siggy's fault here. He needed to be a bit careful in this game making interceptions because on the odd chance he gets caught out (not very often) he has Dura there to cover him. That's how the Siggy/Dura combo works. It would have been tough to expect Boxall to play Dura's role in that as he doesn't know it. 

Yesterday I saw a lot of confusion on a few occasions as to who was marking what player with BR on attack and Boxall was at the center of it each time. I'm not saying Boxall is to blame it's just that he's come into a system he's not used to and was never going to get it straight away. This is exactly why we should be pretty happy with the performance and result. 

Fuck this stupid game

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

It does surprise me how little I've seen fatigue mentioned as a factor in our uninspiring second half performance. I mean a good chunk of our players have traveled across the pacific and played two games since the last one. 

"Yellow Fever are fantastic – I have to say that"

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

asmodeus_82 wrote:

It does surprise me how little I've seen fatigue mentioned as a factor in our uninspiring second half performance. I mean a good chunk of our players have traveled across the pacific and played two games since the last one. 

Yet Ifill and Huysegems didn't and they looked more fatigued than most others in the second half - and I do understand that these two are probably the least fit two in our playing squad at the moment. Wouldn't use it as an excuse, they're professionals and that schedule isn't that much more demanding than what your average European league is week in week out. 

Fuck this stupid game

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

asmodeus_82 wrote:

It does surprise me how little I've seen fatigue mentioned as a factor in our uninspiring second half performance. I mean a good chunk of our players have traveled across the pacific and played two games since the last one. 



They must be SO knackered after that 6 month pre season too don't forget.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qe_B5CzbTJo - Caceres winning penalty v Perth - footage from the Fever Zone

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Stein Huysegems - 2 goals in 3 games and I feel like we haven't even started to see the best of him yet.


Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago · edited over 13 years ago · History

asmodeus_82 wrote:

ginger_eejit wrote:

asmodeus_82 wrote:

BarryZuckerkorn

[quote=dairyflat

wrote:

 Love all the MICRO-analysis.  I'd put the goal down to Siggy not having the right tension in the laces of his left training boot three seasons back. Buttefly effect  and all that....

[/quote] The idea of causality is a hangover of centuries of deteministic classical thinking. There are no reasons for anything, only chaotic fluctuations in the quantum foam.Time is also an illusion imposed on existence by our mind's limited capacity confronting infinity. The goal was, is and shall be. There is nothing else that can be said about it.

Have you been reading too much David Hume or something Barry?
Don't worry the fluctuations aren't random and the quantum foam is consciousness. You see the greatest illusion is that of separation, there is no dualism between mind and matter, there is only mind, no substance only properties. The quantum foam/superstring/god are all one in the same, this is consciousness manifesting itself as the universe in a grand process of introspection in which all possible potentials are realized through the infinite diverging worlds parallel existences.
The goal both is and is not, only by the means of our collective free perception have we witnessed it and only in this spatio-temporal realm has the goal eventuated. All other possible occurrences and outcomes for the game and every other event have been brought into existence in other imperceptible parts of the universe.



Yeah, right!
Hey man if you've got a better explanation for reality that can handle the paradoxes without contradicting itself while being consistent with contemporary physics I'd love to hear it. 

Non-dualism is the best explanation for existence/reality I've found thus far and I've been actively looking for four years or so. Of course then I go trying to combine it with string theory... (note: the above is actually what I genuinely believe is the ultimate nature of reality, convoluted as it is thinking about stuff is better than taking the universe at face value from your unreliable sense data.)

Yeah; metaphysics can be a real mindf***!
As much as such things can be expressed linguistically, I actually agree with your metaphorical ramblings. However the non-dualist position means that both your explanation of the universe, my explanation of the universe, and the classical/deterministic Siggy-was-responsible-for-the-goal explanation of the universe are not mutually exclusive and are in fact all simply imperfect representations of a greater structure which is beyond the ability of human language to express. 


Is this the most off-topic discussion ever?

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

asmodeus_82 wrote:

ginger_eejit wrote:

asmodeus_82 wrote:

BarryZuckerkorn

[quote=dairyflat

wrote:

 Love all the MICRO-analysis.  I'd put the goal down to Siggy not having the right tension in the laces of his left training boot three seasons back. Buttefly effect  and all that....

[/quote] The idea of causality is a hangover of centuries of deteministic classical thinking. There are no reasons for anything, only chaotic fluctuations in the quantum foam.Time is also an illusion imposed on existence by our mind's limited capacity confronting infinity. The goal was, is and shall be. There is nothing else that can be said about it.

Have you been reading too much David Hume or something Barry?
Don't worry the fluctuations aren't random and the quantum foam is consciousness. You see the greatest illusion is that of separation, there is no dualism between mind and matter, there is only mind, no substance only properties. The quantum foam/superstring/god are all one in the same, this is consciousness manifesting itself as the universe in a grand process of introspection in which all possible potentials are realized through the infinite diverging worlds parallel existences.
The goal both is and is not, only by the means of our collective free perception have we witnessed it and only in this spatio-temporal realm has the goal eventuated. All other possible occurrences and outcomes for the game and every other event have been brought into existence in other imperceptible parts of the universe.



Yeah, right!
Hey man if you've got a better explanation for reality that can handle the paradoxes without contradicting itself while being consistent with contemporary physics I'd love to hear it. 

Non-dualism is the best explanation for existence/reality I've found thus far and I've been actively looking for four years or so. Of course then I go trying to combine it with string theory... (note: the above is actually what I genuinely believe is the ultimate nature of reality, convoluted as it is thinking about stuff is better than taking the universe at face value from your unreliable sense data.)

Yeah; metaphysics can be a real mindf***!


An intresting existentialist proposition, there is no intrinsic meaning in an deterministic universe, only what we project as a meaning onto our actions, although I would've though the self-awareness/analysis that is present with non-duality, would present the following issue, an existential Bohr effect, being aware of your self, you can't truly observe one-self without affecting your own behaviour, the causality of introspection/self-awareness, if you wish, although non-dualism claims to transcend the inner and external self through the nirvana of enlightenment, a position I've yet to be sold on.

When Hibs, went up, to win the Scottish Cup - I wisnae there - furfuxake!

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

asmodeus_82 wrote:

ginger_eejit wrote:

asmodeus_82 wrote:

BarryZuckerkorn

[quote=dairyflat

wrote:

 Love all the MICRO-analysis.  I'd put the goal down to Siggy not having the right tension in the laces of his left training boot three seasons back. Buttefly effect  and all that....

[/quote] The idea of causality is a hangover of centuries of deteministic classical thinking. There are no reasons for anything, only chaotic fluctuations in the quantum foam.Time is also an illusion imposed on existence by our mind's limited capacity confronting infinity. The goal was, is and shall be. There is nothing else that can be said about it.

Have you been reading too much David Hume or something Barry?
Don't worry the fluctuations aren't random and the quantum foam is consciousness. You see the greatest illusion is that of separation, there is no dualism between mind and matter, there is only mind, no substance only properties. The quantum foam/superstring/god are all one in the same, this is consciousness manifesting itself as the universe in a grand process of introspection in which all possible potentials are realized through the infinite diverging worlds parallel existences.
The goal both is and is not, only by the means of our collective free perception have we witnessed it and only in this spatio-temporal realm has the goal eventuated. All other possible occurrences and outcomes for the game and every other event have been brought into existence in other imperceptible parts of the universe.



Yeah, right!
Hey man if you've got a better explanation for reality that can handle the paradoxes without contradicting itself while being consistent with contemporary physics I'd love to hear it. 

Non-dualism is the best explanation for existence/reality I've found thus far and I've been actively looking for four years or so. Of course then I go trying to combine it with string theory... (note: the above is actually what I genuinely believe is the ultimate nature of reality, convoluted as it is thinking about stuff is better than taking the universe at face value from your unreliable sense data.)

Yeah; metaphysics can be a real mindf***!


An intresting existentialist proposition, there is no intrinsic meaning in an deterministic universe, only what we project as a meaning onto our actions, although I would've though the self-awareness/analysis that is present with non-duality, would present the following issue, an existential Bohr effect, being aware of your self, you can't truly observe one-self without affecting your own behaviour, the causality of introspection/self-awareness, if you wish, although non-dualism claims to transcend the inner and external self through the nirvana of enlightenment, a position I've yet to be sold on.

When Hibs, went up, to win the Scottish Cup - I wisnae there - furfuxake!

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

ginger_eejit wrote:

asmodeus_82 wrote:

ginger_eejit wrote:

asmodeus_82 wrote:

BarryZuckerkorn

[quote=dairyflat

wrote:

 Love all the MICRO-analysis.  I'd put the goal down to Siggy not having the right tension in the laces of his left training boot three seasons back. Buttefly effect  and all that....

[/quote] The idea of causality is a hangover of centuries of deteministic classical thinking. There are no reasons for anything, only chaotic fluctuations in the quantum foam.Time is also an illusion imposed on existence by our mind's limited capacity confronting infinity. The goal was, is and shall be. There is nothing else that can be said about it.

Have you been reading too much David Hume or something Barry?
Don't worry the fluctuations aren't random and the quantum foam is consciousness. You see the greatest illusion is that of separation, there is no dualism between mind and matter, there is only mind, no substance only properties. The quantum foam/superstring/god are all one in the same, this is consciousness manifesting itself as the universe in a grand process of introspection in which all possible potentials are realized through the infinite diverging worlds parallel existences.
The goal both is and is not, only by the means of our collective free perception have we witnessed it and only in this spatio-temporal realm has the goal eventuated. All other possible occurrences and outcomes for the game and every other event have been brought into existence in other imperceptible parts of the universe.



Yeah, right!
Hey man if you've got a better explanation for reality that can handle the paradoxes without contradicting itself while being consistent with contemporary physics I'd love to hear it. 

Non-dualism is the best explanation for existence/reality I've found thus far and I've been actively looking for four years or so. Of course then I go trying to combine it with string theory... (note: the above is actually what I genuinely believe is the ultimate nature of reality, convoluted as it is thinking about stuff is better than taking the universe at face value from your unreliable sense data.)

Yeah; metaphysics can be a real mindf***!


An intresting existentialist proposition, there is no intrinsic meaning in an deterministic universe, only what we project as a meaning onto our actions, although I would've though the self-awareness/analysis that is present with non-duality, would present the following issue, an existential Bohr effect, being aware of your self, you can't truly observe one-self without affecting your own behaviour, the causality of introspection/self-awareness, if you wish, although non-dualism claims to transcend the inner and external self through the nirvana of enlightenment, a position I've yet to be sold on.


I dont think so, therefore I am
Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Is this the most off-topic discussion ever?

No, keep going. This is what makes us so superior to the idiots who support teams in the rest of the A-League.

My smug-o-meter is currently reading red hot.


Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

I am happy with the draw and I thought that was good going by the lads to come away with a draw against Brisbane.I thought the lads played well didnt see any of the game because I dont have sky but caught the last 45 minutes of the game on the radio

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

terminator_x wrote:

Is this the most off-topic discussion ever?

No, keep going. This is what makes us so superior to the idiots who support teams in the rest of the A-League.

My smug-o-meter is currently reading red hot.


I suppose you could argue that it is on-topic because it is about the absolute nature of reality and human experience. It encompasses everything from the question of why are here, to why we conceded that goal... 

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago · edited over 13 years ago · History

hepatitis wrote:

ginger_eejit wrote:

asmodeus_82 wrote:

ginger_eejit wrote:

asmodeus_82 wrote:

BarryZuckerkorn

[quote=dairyflat

wrote:

 Love all the MICRO-analysis.  I'd put the goal down to Siggy not having the right tension in the laces of his left training boot three seasons back. Buttefly effect  and all that....

[/quote] The idea of causality is a hangover of centuries of deteministic classical thinking. There are no reasons for anything, only chaotic fluctuations in the quantum foam.Time is also an illusion imposed on existence by our mind's limited capacity confronting infinity. The goal was, is and shall be. There is nothing else that can be said about it.

Have you been reading too much David Hume or something Barry?
Don't worry the fluctuations aren't random and the quantum foam is consciousness. You see the greatest illusion is that of separation, there is no dualism between mind and matter, there is only mind, no substance only properties. The quantum foam/superstring/god are all one in the same, this is consciousness manifesting itself as the universe in a grand process of introspection in which all possible potentials are realized through the infinite diverging worlds parallel existences.
The goal both is and is not, only by the means of our collective free perception have we witnessed it and only in this spatio-temporal realm has the goal eventuated. All other possible occurrences and outcomes for the game and every other event have been brought into existence in other imperceptible parts of the universe.



Yeah, right!
Hey man if you've got a better explanation for reality that can handle the paradoxes without contradicting itself while being consistent with contemporary physics I'd love to hear it. 

Non-dualism is the best explanation for existence/reality I've found thus far and I've been actively looking for four years or so. Of course then I go trying to combine it with string theory... (note: the above is actually what I genuinely believe is the ultimate nature of reality, convoluted as it is thinking about stuff is better than taking the universe at face value from your unreliable sense data.)

Yeah; metaphysics can be a real mindf***!


An intresting existentialist proposition, there is no intrinsic meaning in an deterministic universe, only what we project as a meaning onto our actions, although I would've though the self-awareness/analysis that is present with non-duality, would present the following issue, an existential Bohr effect, being aware of your self, you can't truly observe one-self without affecting your own behaviour, the causality of introspection/self-awareness, if you wish, although non-dualism claims to transcend the inner and external self through the nirvana of enlightenment, a position I've yet to be sold on.


I dont think so, therefore I am


LOL non cogito ergo sum

If I am no longer conscious of my self, do I cease to exist?

If we no longer discuss Sigmund's poor positioning, did it happen?

When Hibs, went up, to win the Scottish Cup - I wisnae there - furfuxake!

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

ginger_eejit wrote:

LOL non cogito ergo sum


If I am no longer conscious of my self, do I cease to exist?

If we no longer discuss Sigmund's poor positioning, did it happen?
Is there an abiding self? Does the entity we call Sigmund actually exist throughout time, or does each new experience and each change at a molecular level create a new entity which we also dub Sigmund? Can the Sigmund that exists in this moment be held accountable for the positioning of a previous Sigmund?

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

terminator_x wrote:

Is this the most off-topic discussion ever?

No, keep going. This is what makes us so superior to the idiots who support teams in the rest of the A-League.

My smug-o-meter is currently reading red hot.


I suppose you could argue that it is on-topic because it is about the absolute nature of reality and human experience. It encompasses everything from the question of why are here, to why we conceded that goal... 


Exactly. And I would note that thus far the discussion has been placed within a largely Western European philosophical framework and hasn't yet fully considered the relevance of Eastern philosophies where the distinction between the religious and secular is less clear. So we've got a long way to go yet.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

terminator_x wrote:

terminator_x wrote:

Is this the most off-topic discussion ever?

No, keep going. This is what makes us so superior to the idiots who support teams in the rest of the A-League.

My smug-o-meter is currently reading red hot.


I suppose you could argue that it is on-topic because it is about the absolute nature of reality and human experience. It encompasses everything from the question of why are here, to why we conceded that goal... 


Exactly. And I would note that thus far the discussion has been placed within a largely Western European philosophical framework and hasn't yet fully considered the relevance of Eastern philosophies where the distinction between the religious and secular is less clear. So we've got a long way to go yet.

See my previous post re: no abiding self

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

This thread has gone all Schreodinger's Siggie* and Herbert's Uncertainty Principle**



*If you put Siggie in a box, is a bear catholic?

** If Siggie was an electron, then where the f*ck has he gone?

"Phoenix till they lose"

Posting 97% bollox, 8% lies and 3.658% genuine opinion. 

Genuine opinion: FTFFA

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

 I am sure Siggy was quite split in his decision to go forward on Sunday in that crucial move. A part of him was back keeping an eye on Berisha, the other part ventured forward. A decision that doesnt abide well with he,  himself, or I



Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

BTW I should express some annoyance at my lazy-ass self for not informing my kiwi-saver provider to put another $5 on a draw and win this weekend.

Return would have been very modest, but still more shekels in the "retire in the style that I am accustomed to" plan.


"Phoenix till they lose"

Posting 97% bollox, 8% lies and 3.658% genuine opinion. 

Genuine opinion: FTFFA

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago · edited over 13 years ago · History

ginger_eejit wrote:

asmodeus_82 wrote:

ginger_eejit wrote:

asmodeus_82 wrote:

BarryZuckerkorn

[quote=dairyflat

wrote:

 Love all the MICRO-analysis.  I'd put the goal down to Siggy not having the right tension in the laces of his left training boot three seasons back. Buttefly effect  and all that....

[/quote] The idea of causality is a hangover of centuries of deteministic classical thinking. There are no reasons for anything, only chaotic fluctuations in the quantum foam.Time is also an illusion imposed on existence by our mind's limited capacity confronting infinity. The goal was, is and shall be. There is nothing else that can be said about it.

Have you been reading too much David Hume or something Barry?
Don't worry the fluctuations aren't random and the quantum foam is consciousness. You see the greatest illusion is that of separation, there is no dualism between mind and matter, there is only mind, no substance only properties. The quantum foam/superstring/god are all one in the same, this is consciousness manifesting itself as the universe in a grand process of introspection in which all possible potentials are realized through the infinite diverging worlds parallel existences.
The goal both is and is not, only by the means of our collective free perception have we witnessed it and only in this spatio-temporal realm has the goal eventuated. All other possible occurrences and outcomes for the game and every other event have been brought into existence in other imperceptible parts of the universe.



Yeah, right!
Hey man if you've got a better explanation for reality that can handle the paradoxes without contradicting itself while being consistent with contemporary physics I'd love to hear it. 

Non-dualism is the best explanation for existence/reality I've found thus far and I've been actively looking for four years or so. Of course then I go trying to combine it with string theory... (note: the above is actually what I genuinely believe is the ultimate nature of reality, convoluted as it is thinking about stuff is better than taking the universe at face value from your unreliable sense data.)

Yeah; metaphysics can be a real mindf***!


An intresting existentialist proposition, there is no intrinsic meaning in an deterministic universe, only what we project as a meaning onto our actions, although I would've though the self-awareness/analysis that is present with non-duality, would present the following issue, an existential Bohr effect, being aware of your self, you can't truly observe one-self without affecting your own behaviour, the causality of introspection/self-awareness, if you wish, although non-dualism claims to transcend the inner and external self through the nirvana of enlightenment, a position I've yet to be sold on.
For me I don't really see this as too much a problem. I interpret you as referring to the problem of an individual or collective consciousness observing/"measuring" itself and thus affecting and possibly projecting its own preconceptions on itself in doing so. The self affecting itself through measurement while affecting the measurement? (you'll have to forgive me, I've no idea which effect/affect I should be using by now)
Well that is what I believe is happening constantly,that is the process of the universe unfolding and if you look into yourself I think you find actually occurs. Firstly when you perform an act of introspection, think about yourself using your capacity for self-awareness you are effected by the observation in that you may change upon what you have come to discover, some burning desire or moral judgement or whatever. But your measurement is limited by the metric you use, you only act on or have desires you perceive to be possible and you only judge yourself morally by whatever you're ethics happens to be.
And secondly if nondualism is the case then I view this process of consciousness observing and realizing itself and altering for this realization and making futures observations effected by the previous realizations. As I believe the Universe/this process of Consciousness introspection contains every possibility, every way which consciousness could cause itself to collapse does occur so the process is infinitely infinite as it contains all the possible outcomes for this universe as well as all possible outcomes for all possible universes (i.e with different initial conditions/physical constants) So there is room for every realization/collapse of the collective consciousness as well as every possible collapse for each individual unit of consciousness.
I don't actually deny the individual to the extent of the monists/ancient eastern philosophers. I think that each unit of consciousness and every level of reality is as real as the next and purely part the purpose of the universe: to explore every possibility. I don't exactly buy the Nirvana deal as its sold either but the religious experience and other altered states of consciousness research is very interesting with neuroscience and neurotheology/neurotheosophy finally giving the field some credibility. For instance meditation actually physically alters your brain and changes its rest state permanently in pretty good ways.
Oh yeah... And I was pretty pleased with that point yesterday as well all round.

"Yellow Fever are fantastic – I have to say that"

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago · edited over 13 years ago · History

 I very much like the idea of a Schroedinger's Siggie, Sigmund is simultaneously both holding his defensive position and also closing the player down, the impacting random event being the Queensland player running with the ball, his invites the aforementioned Bohr effect of the causality of observation, our role as the observer defines the final observed state as "out of position"

Is this observation an identical shared experience?, as we progress through Descartian metaphysical solipsism, we can only be sure our own experience is true, if we apply the indiscernibility of identicals, you, I,  the rest of the Yellow Fever shared the experience of Sigmund being out of position, this experience being described as identical, but as the experience, although described as shared, is purely a number of self experiences that are identically described, we cannot prove that Sigmund was out of position, as that is beyond the self

When Hibs, went up, to win the Scottish Cup - I wisnae there - furfuxake!

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

I suggest we stick Berisha in the Hadron collider and press the big red button. 

That'll teach the smug f*cker.


"Phoenix till they lose"

Posting 97% bollox, 8% lies and 3.658% genuine opinion. 

Genuine opinion: FTFFA

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Junior82 wrote:

I suggest we stick Berisha in the Hadron collider and press the big red button. 

That'll teach the smug f*cker.




He'd only come out claiming he's the God particle.

When Hibs, went up, to win the Scottish Cup - I wisnae there - furfuxake!

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

ginger_eejit wrote:

An intresting existentialist proposition, there is no intrinsic meaning in an deterministic universe, only what we project as a meaning onto our actions, although I would've though the self-awareness/analysis that is present with non-duality, would present the following issue, an existential Bohr effect, being aware of your self, you can't truly observe one-self without affecting your own behaviour, the causality of introspection/self-awareness, if you wish, although non-dualism claims to transcend the inner and external self through the nirvana of enlightenment, a position I've yet to be sold on.

If I'm not mistaken, I think I have actually heard you chant this G-E.  If not, something very similar.

 

I know, I know, its serious!

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Turfmoore wrote:

ginger_eejit wrote:

An intresting existentialist proposition, there is no intrinsic meaning in an deterministic universe, only what we project as a meaning onto our actions, although I would've though the self-awareness/analysis that is present with non-duality, would present the following issue, an existential Bohr effect, being aware of your self, you can't truly observe one-self without affecting your own behaviour, the causality of introspection/self-awareness, if you wish, although non-dualism claims to transcend the inner and external self through the nirvana of enlightenment, a position I've yet to be sold on.

If I'm not mistaken, I think I have actually heard you chant this G-E.  If not, something very similar.

 


To the tune of "Go West"? 
Would work with the Pet Shop Boys version, Village People not so much.

"Phoenix till they lose"

Posting 97% bollox, 8% lies and 3.658% genuine opinion. 

Genuine opinion: FTFFA

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

asmodeus_82 wrote:

For anyone else getting into this you might find these amusing:

Action Philosophers! 

Dungeons and Discourse and Advanced Dungeons and Discourse 

Disclaimer: Very nerdy! Contains Philosophical Comedy! In Graphic Novel Format!! 

Particularly Dungeons and Discourse but couldn't help but laugh when I read that.


Not enough breasts.  I gave up reading D&D halfway down.

"Phoenix till they lose"

Posting 97% bollox, 8% lies and 3.658% genuine opinion. 

Genuine opinion: FTFFA

Permalink Permalink