Harsh criticism unwarranted for some... some of my thoughts on the game yesterday
Cunningham - took some minutes to get into the flow of the game but what I saw in the 15 - 45 minute period was very promising. He was elusive, has an eye for a pass, works hard, I think he's got the goods.
Ciara - very promising in my opinion. Quick, attacking, looks to interplay with his winger/midfielders, and defensive positioning was ok for me - most of the attacking came through the middle or on adams side. Reckon Ciara should hold that LB spot with ease and will only improve with each game.
Lia - didn't watch him specifically, but as usual he popped up with some glaring giveaways and some poor fouls. I'm not as critical of his performance as others but I agree he's a weak link and we'd do well to give riera a start asap to see if he can give us something more.
Riera - good first impression for me but hard to judge without seeing him play in midfield
Muscat - excellent, excellent game in my opinion. His judgement when deciding to snap into a tackle, or drop off and hold, was near perfect. Can't recall him losing out in many (if any) attempted tackles. A lot of ball-wins in the attacking half. Better than anything I remember seeing from him last season. He also showed some nice short passes and touches I thought.
Hicks - one week contract, out of position. If it was cunningham, ifill or someone else already in our squad, I'd be critical, but for a one-week signing coming out of ASBP, he did ok. Tried hard, any errors were basically around their box so didn't cost us, I'm ok with that, thanks for giving us a hand mate.
Adams - I didnt notice all the errors others are claiming but there was a lot of space down his side when brisbane attacked, so he can't have been doing too well. However, calling him a donkey and writing him off after yesterday is frankly ridiculous. Many have given him decent praise based on his pre-season performances at CB, so, as with Riera, I'll reserve judgement until I see him at CB.
Siggy - a couple of errors i didnt like, but overall I think he played well. Captaincy good for him too i think. And I'm not sure if anyone else noticed, but in the 2nd half a roar player was about to take possession, siggy was steaming toward him, and I thought 'f*ck siggys too late here and he's gonna cut him in half' - but he didnt. He knew it would've been a foul and stopped and tried to hold. Was a minor moment but an important piece of discipline, hopefully he is learning.
Boxall - when roar had the ball on the wings i thought he got it wrong a couple of times and didnt get close enough to berisha to anticipate the cutback . Seemed to be waiting for mids to hit the box or their other winger to come in, when we all knew they would just look for berisha every time. Apart from that, very happy, impressed with a lot of his play and obviously the assist. Reckon he could shade siggy when durante is back even.
Spoonley - great game. Rushing out was a good ploy, probably prevented a berisha hat trick. He screwed it up once and got lucky with the leg block, but it was a risky tactic, so one error not costing a goal is ok. He actually reminded me a wee bit of the spurs keeper Lloris.
Huysegems/hernandez i wont get into - everyone seems to agree they both had great games, I'm in agreement.
Overall:
I think the key reason we lost (aside from missing starters) was tiredness. I know they're claiming we're the fittest we've been but we obviously tired badly at the end of the first half, and some players were out on their feet somewhat for the last 20 mins - half hour. Our game plan is clearly very high-tempo. When we were at our best for most of the first half, every player was covering a lot of ground, pressing high, taking quick free kicks, that's clearly how were going to play and I love it. Now get back to your beep tests boys! (or whatever that new fandangled version is called - havent been near one since high school!). We may be fit but we gotta get fitter to play the game this way.
sorry for JV-esque post length
Insert nufc's "didnt read it" bush gif here