Sky Commentary Team

Piney was good, I thought he talked a bit to much and got a bit to overexcited. But much better than the other guy who clearly has no plan, just blurbing along. The co-moderator was even more useless besides Piney, he could add nothing of value to it. Piney need someone like Ifill who is closer to the game and talk from experience on the field and actually can see when a player shows 'individual brilliance'.

I liked the fact he actually talked about what was going on rather than waffling on about mindless crap not relating to the game.

Could not possibly agree more Ifill/Piney would be an absolute dream

Dewhurst still goes on about the 2010 AWs...

I think Dewhurst and de Jong do it from the Mt Wellington studios (I read that on here courtesy of Chopah I think)

Who's the Fox Sports commentator? Is it Robbie Slater? When Sigmund committed the foul on Milligan (penalty) the commentator said 'Yeah, that's a freekick'.

Hear it at 01:05.

Who's the Fox Sports commentator? Is it Robbie Slater? When Sigmund committed the foul on Milligan (penalty) the commentator said 'Yeah, that's a freekick'.

Hear it at 01:05.

Anyway, I don't really want to distract this thread away from the one true narrative:

Dewhurst - OUT

Piney - IN

Pretty sure he said it by way of making the point that it would have been a freekick outside the area, so should be deemed a penalty in the area.

Piney was good, I thought he talked a bit to much and got a bit to overexcited. But much better than the other guy who clearly has no plan, just blurbing along. The co-moderator was even more useless besides Piney, he could add nothing of value to it. Piney need someone like Ifill who is closer to the game and talk from experience on the field and actually can see when a player shows 'individual brilliance'.