Rest of A-League Transfer (Now with 99% RR - Love your work)

8803 replies · 1,570,099 views
over 11 years ago

maynardf wrote:

Ryan wrote:

I thought to exploit some sort of loop hole Melbourne City had paid Villa $5million and New York City had paid him a couple of hundred k?

Sucks if its true, really crippling your club by removing their marquee.

I thought the point of buying Heart was to extend City's brand and fan base - surely shenanigans like this and playing third fiddle is going to alienate the people who you want to convert to city fans

It seems really weird that if Melbourne pay the majority of his wages, and he stays for 4 games. That means villa is getting 1.25 million a game!

Yep but it circumvents whatever they are trying to circumvent in the US.

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

http://www.foxsports.com.au/football/a-league/david-villa-will-return-to-new-york-but-melbourne-city-still-hopeful-of-his-return-to-the-aleague/story-e6frf4gl-1227096964319

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Was a shambles from the start.

Maybe thought the rubbish bin ice baths were beneith him?

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

It sounds like he will just miss the round 5 game. Still I feel Melbourne City going forward are probably going to get fucked around a bit. They have huge work to do if they want to rival the Victory in terms of support.

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago · edited over 11 years ago · History

This isn't new news, is it? Don't understand why it is being reported as such. He was always going to go back to NYC to help his family settle etc. - was said in his first interview for the club..

Everyone knew that it was just a short stint.

a.haak

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

valeo wrote:

This isn't new news, is it? Don't understand why it is being reported as such. He was always going to go back to NYC to help his family settle etc. - was said in his first interview for the club..

Everyone knew that it was just a short stint.

It was originially meant to be a ten game stint but it now appears it might not be.

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Josh Kennedy  to Melbourne City.

If you are old and wise you were probably young and stupid

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Leggy wrote:

Josh Kennedy  to Melbourne City.

Been rumoured for awhile, he was the most obvious Aussie marquee for them. He isn't coming to January tho.
Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Leggy wrote:

Josh Kennedy  to Melbourne City.

Been rumoured for awhile, he was the most obvious Aussie marquee for them. He isn't coming to January tho.

And if he makes the Socceroos Asian Cup squad as seems likely he won't be available until February.

Reports suggest he will be fit enough to play by January  - he's been injured since before the World Cup.

Big Pete 65, Christchurch

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

maynardf wrote:

Ryan wrote:

I thought to exploit some sort of loop hole Melbourne City had paid Villa $5million and New York City had paid him a couple of hundred k?

Sucks if its true, really crippling your club by removing their marquee.

I thought the point of buying Heart was to extend City's brand and fan base - surely shenanigans like this and playing third fiddle is going to alienate the people who you want to convert to city fans

It seems really weird that if Melbourne pay the majority of his wages, and he stays for 4 games. That means villa is getting 1.25 million a game!

Note that Villa is a "guest player" according to A-League regulations - not a marquee  -the injured Koren is their marquee.

(A guest player can play up to 10 matches). Villa is only on loan from New York City.

There will be no problem with the financial aspects as City Football Group own both clubs (Melbourne City and New York City - as well as Man City). They'll just juggle things around.

It seems that Melbourne City knew some time ago that Villa was going to have to end his ten game guest stint prematurely but didn't make it public in order to drive season ticket and merchandise sales. Really dishonest.

Good opinion piece here:

http://www.theroar.com.au/2014/10/23/melbourne-cit...

Big Pete 65, Christchurch

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago
Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Wow. Think they have someone decent in the pipeline? Otherwise what is going on in Brisbane??




Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago
Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

and there are no strikers to be signed?

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

not unless you have the money city has. 


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

When is Kennedy arriving?

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Ryan54 wrote:

When is Kennedy arriving?

Can't play until the transfer window opens in mid Jan. By that time it means he probably wouldn't have played a competitive fixture for 6 months due to injury.
Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Western Sydney local Kearyn Baccus today joined the Western Sydney Wanderers as an injury replacement player for Wanderers striker Brendon Santalab.

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago · edited over 11 years ago · History

Anderson asking for a release from CCM after being benched the last few weeks? Talk that Moss has lost the dressing room.

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Well the rumor was that McGlinchey explicitly told the Mariners that he didn't want to play for Moss - and with some of the odd things he's been saying (dropped from a team because he wasn't greek) you can kind of see why.

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

karma is a bitch


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Ryan54 wrote:

When is Kennedy arriving?

Can't play until the transfer window opens in mid Jan. By that time it means he probably wouldn't have played a competitive fixture for 6 months due to injury.

By that time it will probably be too too late for Melbourne City.

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Former Melbourne Victory player Adama Traore got called up for the Ivory Coast team. Always thought he was a top player. Aussies must be spewing he wasn't eligible even after getting australian citizenship.

a.haak

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

valeo wrote:

Former Melbourne Victory player Adama Traore got called up for the Ivory Coast team. Always thought he was a top player. Aussies must be spewing he wasn't eligible even after getting australian citizenship.

Best left back the A-league has ever had (harsh on cassio in his prime) in my opinion

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Brockie to Malaysia?

If you are old and wise you were probably young and stupid

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

So it seems (has not signed yet though) - but that is probably for a different thread.



Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

maynardf wrote:

valeo wrote:

Former Melbourne Victory player Adama Traore got called up for the Ivory Coast team. Always thought he was a top player. Aussies must be spewing he wasn't eligible even after getting australian citizenship.

Best left back the A-league has ever had (harsh on cassio in his prime) in my opinion

Cassio or Zullo as for me

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago · edited over 11 years ago · History

Heart sign Miller as an injury replacement.

[Edit: whoops, its not an injury replacement - "Miller, 33, will be eligible for selection under Football Federation Australia’s National Team Replacement Player rule" ]

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Mulvey to be sacked?

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Surely not. They are 3 points off the top 6. Brisbane just need to bring in some better imports. The A-League is the sort of competition teams don't dominate. You have a good year and then you fall back into the pack and get ready to go again.

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago · edited over 11 years ago · History

Ryan54 wrote:

Surely not. They are 3 points off the top 6. Brisbane just need to bring in some better imports. The A-League is the sort of competition teams don't dominate. You have a good year and then you fall back into the pack and get ready to go again.

That is pretty much on the money. Remember that MV let go of Ernie because the team did not win the championship the following season? I am pleased the Roar do not have the same stupid attitude. If we do not win the toilet seat I won't be blaming Ernie - in this league there are always other factors at play. 

In contrast, when early on Melb Victory thrashed Adelaide in the grand Final (I think 5:1?) Kosmina resigned as Adelaide coach, such was the shock. That doesn't mean Adelaide were bad. It became a one-sided game when Adelaide (and Kosmina) became demoralised, when they were trailing 3:0 well before halftime.  The clash of Kossie with Muscat was hilarious.



Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Wonder what the odds on Mulvey being sacked first would have been. Seems ridiculous to sack him but everything appears that he has been.

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Frans Thijssen is being touted as the Mulvey replacement

Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago

Mainland FC wrote:

Seems I was wrong and Ryan's Rovers was right:

http://www.fourfourtwo.com/au/news/official-mulvey...

As for Frans Thijssens, just a "rumour" at this stage, nothing confirmed.

Anyway, wishing all the best to Mulvey. Any thoughts whether their championship last year was due to the good work laid down by Angie previously, or to his own talents?



Permalink Permalink
over 11 years ago · edited over 11 years ago · History

This is a good blog post (in two parts) that was written earlier in the season:

http://goodluckpunters.wordpress.com/2014/11/08/a-...

Basically stipulates Mulvey inherited a talented but unmotivated squad and managed to motivate them but that he won the championship by such a massive margin mainly because the top clubs were in disarray with lots of coach rotation, etc.

Permalink Permalink