Rest of A-League Transfer (Now with 99% RR - Love your work)

8803 replies · 1,570,375 views
about 10 years ago

Jeff Vader wrote:

Tegal wrote:

the other 9 clubs who aren't allowed to pay transfer fees between clubs for players. I don't mind people saying "good on city" but for fairness sake you need to either close the loophole, or scrap the "no transfer" rule. I'm in favour of scrapping it personally, it seems to me to be one of those legacy rules that is past its date of usefulness. 

I can see both sides of it.

The best way out of a financial hole for clubs like CCM and Newcastle is to sell players. Who is going to buy them? The only teams with cash that would pay are Melbourne, Melbourne and Sydney. CCM and Newcastle wont want to sell them cheap so then you have a situation of a club selling a player they may not want to sell but are also not prepared to sell him cheap and the only clubs that could pay over the line are 3.

Its an antiquated rule I agree but the there is also the other side of it which *could* skew the competition even further.

As long as transfer fees are included towards a players salary cap, I don't see an issue with clubs buying players off each other.

 Lets say Melbourne City pays $200k for Caceres and he signs a 4 year deal, 50k of the transfer fee should be included every season. So if you go around buying other sides players, you effectively have less salary cap.

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

RR wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

Tegal wrote:

the other 9 clubs who aren't allowed to pay transfer fees between clubs for players. I don't mind people saying "good on city" but for fairness sake you need to either close the loophole, or scrap the "no transfer" rule. I'm in favour of scrapping it personally, it seems to me to be one of those legacy rules that is past its date of usefulness. 

I can see both sides of it.

The best way out of a financial hole for clubs like CCM and Newcastle is to sell players. Who is going to buy them? The only teams with cash that would pay are Melbourne, Melbourne and Sydney. CCM and Newcastle wont want to sell them cheap so then you have a situation of a club selling a player they may not want to sell but are also not prepared to sell him cheap and the only clubs that could pay over the line are 3.

Its an antiquated rule I agree but the there is also the other side of it which *could* skew the competition even further.

As long as transfer fees are included towards a players salary cap, I don't see an issue with clubs buying players off each other.

 Lets say Melbourne City pays $200k for Caceres and he signs a 4 year deal, 50k of the transfer fee should be included every season. So if you go around buying other sides players, you effectively have less salary cap.

What about deals which include options for extensions? Or what's stopping a club from signing a player for ten years, to spread out that payment, but having a clause which says after four years a player can be terminated for X reason.

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Melbourne City has made the most obvious statement of their intent to win this season’s title by sacrificing talented Stefan Mauk to secure experienced Adelaide United defender Osama Malik.

The shock swap will be completed within 48 hours, with Malik travelling with Adelaide to Brisbane for tonight’s A-League clash before relocating to Melbourne.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/football/a-league/teams/melbourne-city/melbourne-city-trade-olyroo-stefan-mauk-for-adelaides-osama-malik/news-story/30138eb3d4460578c62a4b0e7a6d8f7b
Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Haven't seen anything suggesting this but I wouldnt be surprised if City chuck a ton of cash at Oar. They have the marquee spot open and need another attacker if they do end up giving Mauk to Adelaide for Malik.

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Piovaccari free to leave, as long as it doesnt cost WSW money.

http://www.smh.com.au/sport/soccer/federico-piovaccaris-exit-from-western-sydney-wanderers-hinges-on-deal-elsewhere-20160124-gmcyi4.html

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Brandon said gone by round 13. Very insightful

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

RR wrote:

Perth Glory have confirmed their ex-skipper is on the verge of a move to China, although they're very confident of keeping Josh Risdon
http://www.goal.com/en-au/news/4021/a-league/2016/01/17/19411492/thwaite-leaving-risdon-staying-glory-ceo?ICID=SP

Glory also can't get Taggart cuz of the 3 clubs in a season rule

And City are on the verge of signing Fitzgerald as an IR for Gameiro

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

RR wrote:

RR wrote:

Perth Glory have confirmed their ex-skipper is on the verge of a move to China, although they're very confident of keeping Josh Risdon
http://www.goal.com/en-au/news/4021/a-league/2016/01/17/19411492/thwaite-leaving-risdon-staying-glory-ceo?ICID=SP

Glory also can't get Taggart cuz of the 3 clubs in a season rule

And City are on the verge of signing Fitzgerald as an IR for Gameiro

So Perth have signed Taggart however he can't play till next season.

"Under FIFA rules, Taggart will not be eligible to play for Glory in the remainder of this current season because he has already played for two clubs in the one year.

However he can be registered with up to three clubs in the same time-frame."

http://www.a-league.com.au/article/perth-glory-sig...

I'm an optimistic pessimist. 
I'm positive things will go wrong.
Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago
Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

It's really shocking seeing how clubs with similar ambitions that we are supposed to have but are sitting about where we are on the ladder are moving, releasing players, signing players, trying something - and we are just sitting there doing nothing.

This lack of movement in the window is kind of making me nervous about the license extension.

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
Argie-
about 10 years ago

Ryan wrote:

It's really shocking seeing how clubs with similar ambitions that we are supposed to have but are sitting about where we are on the ladder are moving, releasing players, signing players, trying something - and we are just sitting there doing nothing.

This lack of movement in the window is kind of making me nervous about the license extension.

Exactly, though it isn't making me nervous about the licence extension issue. What will be will be there.

It is concerning that Perth are seemingly leaving us in the dust.

a.haak

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Its making me concerned because we are showing no ambition, at a time when we need to be driving up the metrics / building on the good will that was generated the team is stagnant. The only reason not to go to market is if we've given up and don't want to waste money so that the club can wind down with a minimum of additional cost.

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago · edited about 10 years ago · History

Ryan wrote:

Its making me concerned because we are showing no ambition, at a time when we need to be driving up the metrics / building on the good will that was generated the team is stagnant. The only reason not to go to market is if we've given up and don't want to waste money so that the club can wind down with a minimum of additional cost.

The club has signed a number of players recently that haven't been announced. Contracts don't become valid until the licence is confirmed.

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
Ryan
about 10 years ago · edited about 10 years ago · History

I'm guessing its mainly current squad players like the rumor that Krishna has resigned?

Still with all the publicity and good will from #savethenix we should be showing ambition in the transfer window now and not for next season.

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

so you're saying the Phoenix should start selling dick smith gift vouchers? 


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Ryan wrote:

I'm guessing its mainly current squad players like the rumor that Krishna has resigned?

Still with all the publicity and good will from #savethenix we should be showing ambition in the transfer window now and not for next season.

You think many players want to come play for a club that may not be around in 6 months?

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Then say that, not that we are content with the squad, because saying that makes is look like we have no ambition.

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Um Ernie has said he is looking at bringing in people. Just hasn't found anyone yet.

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

RR wrote:

dunnix wrote:

Jets linked to Danish striker

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morten_Nordstrand

Morten Nordstrand sounds like an international shipping firm

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

2ndBest wrote:

Um Ernie has said he is looking at bringing in people. Just hasn't found anyone yet.

he said he is always on the look out for players 365 days of the year but that he is happy with the squad.
Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Ryan wrote:

2ndBest wrote:

Um Ernie has said he is looking at bringing in people. Just hasn't found anyone yet.

he said he is always on the look out for players 365 days of the year but that he is happy with the squad.

atleast someone is happy, i guess.

yung thug

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Not sure if that is a senior or NYL deal

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Ryan wrote:

2ndBest wrote:

Um Ernie has said he is looking at bringing in people. Just hasn't found anyone yet.

he said he is always on the look out for players 365 days of the year but that he is happy with the squad.

“52 weeks of the a year I’m actively chasing players, but unless we find the right one, we won’t make a move”

"We've got a space plus we can bring in an injury replacement player”.

"I'm not going to bring in someone unless they're exactly what I'm after”.

"You never know what can happen before the end of the window but I haven't got anyone (lined up) in particular."

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

2ndBest wrote:

Ryan wrote:

2ndBest wrote:

Um Ernie has said he is looking at bringing in people. Just hasn't found anyone yet.

he said he is always on the look out for players 365 days of the year but that he is happy with the squad.

“52 weeks of the a year I’m actively chasing players, but unless we find the right one, we won’t make a move”

"We've got a space plus we can bring in an injury replacement player”.

"I'm not going to bring in someone unless they're exactly what I'm after”.

"You never know what can happen before the end of the window but I haven't got anyone (lined up) in particular."

To be fair he has been sending pretty mixed messages e.g. (sauce)

"We've got no one in sight at the moment, obviously we'll keep an eye out but with Jeffrey coming back in, with Blake Powell, with some of the youngsters - Joel Stephens will be promoted to the bench - I think we've got enough to cover for the rest of the season, and remember when more and more players come back, we've got attacking midfielders who are virtually strikers as well, so I feel that we've got enough cover and we've got a good squad."

You could read that any number of ways including - I'm happy with the squad but if someone amazing turns up I'll grab him, or I'll make do with the squad but am hoping that something else turns up. Your background info probably gives you a better insight, but from what has come out in the media it is pretty unclear.

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

"we've got attacking midfielders who are virtually strikers"

Sure, Ernie. Sure.

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Hard News wrote:

Pretty sure we weren't looking foir anyone last year when we signed the Sharkcod.

Imagine what we would have got if we had been looking!

Oi Oi Edgecumbe... lets have a clean sheet

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Wow, Norway. Don't think that would have been a popular guess among fans

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

dunnix wrote:

Wow, Norway. Don't think that would have been a popular guess among fans

Sounds like he is off to Rosenborg for 300k & add ons
Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago
Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

The NRMA Insurance Western Sydney Wanderers have bolstered their left side with a double swoop, signing Joeys representative Jackson Bandiera and attacker Matt Sim.

http://www.wswanderersfc.com.au/article/wanderers-boost-left-hand-side-with-two-signings/1xrnstzucbyzm16hszdjntaxpg

Permalink Permalink