Agree, I'd rather have Lochhead than Neill...
(----)
I would go as far as rating Lochhead higher than Neill in general. Neill was great 6-8 years ago, but has poor vision and makes mistakes (that is apart from not having any form to speak of now, and being a CB rather than a FB). In the later stages of his career he was dispossessed too often. And while a nice guy, he has a sense of entitlement and does not understand he is well past his best.
Lochhead may have limited skills, but does them competently within the limited plan of "direct" football. He may be a good stopgap fill, but not sure if Ernie would not prefer someone more suited to his passing-style game. Which Neill is not, by the way.