You are comparing a guy that plays up front/wide upfront to a midfielder/wide midfielder. The comparison is not the same! That's the point I am trying to make. If they played the same position, sure compare their strike records. They don't so the comparison is pointless. Do you compare Ivan Vicelichs goal scoring record the Shane Smeltz? No because they do not play the same position.
That would be the basis of our difference of opinion on this. Looking into it a bit more was interesting.
Everything i've found has Cunningham listed as a striker/CF/left wing/right wing and as far as i can tell he seems mostly striker/CF
http://www.transfermarkt.com/en/kenny-cunningham/profil/spieler_195463.html as striker-CF, secondary position wing
In the games that i can find where his playing position is listed he is down as a forward or striker
including internationals - this friendly v Canada
http://m.mlssoccer.com/news/article/2013/05/27/canada-vs-costa-rica-international-friendly-preview
but this one he is listed as midfiled
http://www.goal.com/en-us/match/114579/usa-vs-costa-rica/preview
as far as i can find at san carlos, where he has played most of his games, he was at striker (16 goals in 67)
http://www.costaricanewssite.com/saprissa-eliminated/
http://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/en/cs-cartagines-ad-san-carlos/index/spielbericht_2264171.html subbed off as striker
ditto for Carmelita where he played his next highest number of games, the very few bits of web info i can find has him at forward
we announced him as a "star striker" but also talk about him being a speedy winger
Wellington Phoenix head coach Ernie Merrick describes the signing of Costa Rican international striker Kenny Cunningham as a major coup for the A-League club.
New coach Ernie Merrick yesterday landed his second Costa Rican international, signing speedy winger Kenny Cunningham on a two-year contract.
Merrick said Cunningham was as ''quick as anything'' going around in the A-League, with skill and goal-scoring instincts to boot.
''Not only can Kenny score goals and set them up, but he's very good one-on-one,'' Merrick said.
''Those strikers are always the most difficult to find and the most expensive to pay for because they can just create something themselves. He has tremendous pace and dribbling ability.''
i'm not getting the basis for this apparantly robust view of yours that Huysegems and Cunningham have been playing in totally different positions over their careers or recently
hence our difference of opinion
i'm not here to score points, but what i've read and heard suggests kenny has been playing primarily as a forward, so the comparison of their records looks valid
but if you can point me to any contrary information i am happy to be enlightened
but regardless hopefully he's a very quick goal scoring machine
ok well you have you have done some work on this so fair play to you. My basis comes from the following:
1: Ernie himself said he is playing a 4-2-3-1 with Stein/Brockie in a shoot out up top, Carlos in the middle, and the two flanks with be the Bertos/Ifill/Cunningham/Boyd quad, manny in behind, another DM - amen
2: The recent qualifying games he had played for Costa Rica, 2nd best has reliably informed us he has played as a CM/LM/RM
Now I respect you've done a shit load of research above and on that basis alone, well the evidence is overwhelming, however the coach made a statement on what he is going to do, and the recent games he has played, have not been as a striker. If he was a striker, quite frankly his record screams do not sign him. So when you take that as fair, then it's logical he is not signed as a striker.