A 4-2-3-1 formation for me.
The formation picks itself really - with the Phoenix really only offering one goal scoring threat upfront. Smeltz to play - even if he has picked up bubonic plague.
The back four is weird, individually they look OK, but they're being overrun by opposing midfielders flooding forward. I'd go for a centre-back combination that shows some chemistry and understanding in training rather than based on the torrid 90 minutes they've been subjected too thanks to a weak midfield.
Didn't think too much of Mulligan on first view, even his much vaunted set-piece ability looked mediocre, but he might improve with more game time. In the mean time I'd play Muscat and Lochhead on the flanks. I know that theoretically they're both left sided - but I'd try it.
Two holding midfielders could be a choice of Dodd, Ferrante and Johnson - especially if someone gets into Dodd's face and explains that he's only there to tackle win the ball and play a simple 5 yard pass - no attemping the killer ball - YOU ARE NOT GOOD ENOUGH. But he can win tackles.
Daniel has to be the attacking midfielder, play him centrally and insist that he concentrate on being involved in most everything through short runs and passes. No mazy 30 yard sideways dribbles. Playing him for 45-60 minutews or on the flanks is a huge waste of footballing talent.
Out on the flanks I'd try Hearfield and Gao as both players have the ability to beat people, and do look to take a shot when it's one. Bertos is 2-3 seasons past his ability to live out wide in a team that's struggling for parity. I'd also look to bring on Barbarouses in this role too.
Moss vs Paston is a sideline debate really, there is little to choose between the two of them, although I'd probably go with Paston simply because Moss hasn't done well enough to lock in the spot - and if you're not going to use Paston now then WHEN ?
So thats :
Paston
Lochhead - McKain - Durante - Muscat
Ferrante - Johnson
Hearfield Daniel Gao
Smeltz
A five man midfield give more compactness - but it also helps to split the roles better to fit the Phoenix players. Ferrante, Dodd and Johnson can win ball, Daniel is a real playing talent, and Hearfield and Gao and Barbarouses can beat players and use space well.
I reckon that lineup would not have lost 0-3 last Saturday anyway.