Also, surprised to see that Tuiloma is being praised a lot here. For a full professional and international, he's been decidedly average.
From what I saw, he was all over the park trying to do too much to compensate for everyone elses weaknesses. If he tries to do that, of course he will look average. What is he supposed to do? Clone himself 9 times?
Easily a level above everyone else in the team and is feeling the added pressure of captaincy. He doesn't strike me as a natural leader, but he's certainly doing his best.
Well, if you look at the basic role he's meant to play - be a screen in front of the backline, and an outlet to receive the ball from the backline and get us moving forward - he's not really doing it. He really should show some basic competence in that regard before trying to do much else.
I almost get the feeling that people on here think - gee, he plays professionally in Europe, so he's really awesome, and correspondingly look for evidence that backs up that view (i.e. a decent run, couple of nice passes are evidence of him being on 'much higher level'). All I see is a guy who's failing to perform his basic task in the team.
I agree wholeheartedly El Grap, for example I've been quite underwhelmed by Edge, I'm still waiting for him to do something that Messenger hasn't done week in week out for Wanderers - to date, nothing. After 2 full seasons with Wanderers I hope Messenger gets a run today.
And it's not just Edge, other U20's overseas or "professional" players I don't think have really delivered, Ridenton and Rufer immediately spring to mind, although Rufer is for some reason playing out of his usual position.
I know a lot of comments revolve around the long build up, but most of the overseas and Phoenix players have really only had limited game time in the "system" that the Wanderers players have played a lot of games in. Has this contributed to the stuttering performances to date, because Ukraine really were quite poor against us.