New Zealand Women's U-17s

779 replies · 212,947 views
about 12 years ago

Why is it (from my limited view of the U17s here a few years back) that the tecnical ability of goalies is so much poorer than the other 10 on the pitch in women's football?

Or am I just wrong?

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago · edited about 12 years ago · History
HH wrote:

Why is it (from my limited view of the U17s here a few years back) that the tecnical ability of goalies is so much poorer than the other 10 on the pitch in women's football?

Or am I just wrong?


I think it is because it's a position not specialised in until they are 13/14 so takes a few years to catch up to the outfield players who most likely started in the 6-9 year range.

Then they are lucky to get decent training. I know a girl who trialed at fed level a few years back as an outfield player, saw she wouldn't make it, trialed as goalie got in, received 3 actual goalie training's over 2 seasons, rest of time trained as an outfield player and was goalie for the end of training games for the balance of her "Goalie training".

I think things have improved now with fed Goalies getting goalie specific training each session, but it may take a few years for us to see the improvement.

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago

Cheers for that...I'd imagined that there might be some good netball-footy crossovers for GK, but perhaps not?

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago
HH wrote:

Cheers for that...I'd imagined that there might be some good netball-footy crossovers for GK, but perhaps not?


Have seen a couple of netballers try, they could catch ok but positioning was terrible, have seen outfielders play keeper, with good positioning but poor hands. (catch 22)
Good female keepers are like hen's teeth, there have been a couple good young ones over the years that have succumbed to injury.
Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago
kwlap wrote:

what a cracking goal!!! marvelous run!!

pity the keeper came out for the equaliser


The header rocketed into the roof of the net so wouldn't have been saved anyway

Founder

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago

NZ team tournament preview: interviews with coach and players:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4ySE0k4Gb8

Match highlights vs. Paraguay:

http://es.fifa.com/u17womensworldcup/highlights/video/video=2298125/index.html

Daisy Cleverley's goal vs. Paraguay:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ni6IRJm2C5Q

There's a NZ ref (Anna Marie Keighley) and two assistants at the tournament too:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNhWCX6AhuE


Big Pete 65, Christchurch

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago

Spain another level today. 

we play too zonally when Spain have width and then play in pockets of space which we are not prepared to track the player into.

pen could have been retaken considering how far keeper came off line.

Founder

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago

And Japan edged past Paraguay today ..,by 10 goals to nil!

Kotahitanga. We are one.

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
Feverish
about 12 years ago

Love the commentators knowledge of The Wharfies, nice little history lesson thrown in there towards the end of the 1st half 

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
Feverish
about 12 years ago · edited about 12 years ago · History

So we have paid big money for this foreign coach... For what..?


The loss to Spain was 3-0 but my word it was a massacre.. 30% possession!  2 shots to Spain's 27. 

WOW!!!!

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago
MrWaikato wrote:

So we have paid big money for this foreign coach... For what..?


The loss to Spain was 3-0 but my word it was a massacre.. 30% possession!  2 shots to Spain's 27. 

WOW!!!!


You're blaming the coach of a national U17  team??!!! Who's been in the role about 18 months (if that ?). Did you praise the coach for the draw with Paraguay? Seriously, do you not think at this age group, the issue is one of structure - talent ID, opportunities to train and play together, pre-tournament tournaments etc? Need to justify your stance Mr Waikato.

Kotahitanga. We are one.

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago
Global Game wrote:
MrWaikato wrote:

So we have paid big money for this foreign coach... For what..?


The loss to Spain was 3-0 but my word it was a massacre.. 30% possession!  2 shots to Spain's 27. 

WOW!!!!


You're blaming the coach of a national U17  team??!!! Who's been in the role about 18 months (if that ?). Did you praise the coach for the draw with Paraguay? Seriously, do you not think at this age group, the issue is one of structure - talent ID, opportunities to train and play together, pre-tournament tournaments etc? Need to justify your stance Mr Waikato.
I'm not agreeing with Mr Waikato but don't pull out the 'development' card that every NZ age group side pulls out when they lose.
Apparently she is a decent coach

Founder

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago
Feverish wrote:
Global Game wrote:
MrWaikato wrote:

So we have paid big money for this foreign coach... For what..?


The loss to Spain was 3-0 but my word it was a massacre.. 30% possession!  2 shots to Spain's 27. 

WOW!!!!


You're blaming the coach of a national U17  team??!!! Who's been in the role about 18 months (if that ?). Did you praise the coach for the draw with Paraguay? Seriously, do you not think at this age group, the issue is one of structure - talent ID, opportunities to train and play together, pre-tournament tournaments etc? Need to justify your stance Mr Waikato.

I'm not agreeing with Mr Waikato but don't pull out the 'development' card that every NZ age group side pulls out when they lose.

Apparently she is a decent coach


Didn't use the word Feverish. Just stating lack of football infrastructure in NZ to get results; and hey, it is Spain.

Kotahitanga. We are one.

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago
MrWaikato wrote:

So we have paid big money for this foreign coach... For what..?


The loss to Spain was 3-0 but my word it was a massacre.. 30% possession!  2 shots to Spain's 27. 

WOW!!!!


Can you elaborate on the "Big Money paid"?

Not as much as the Canadians paid for their U17 coach I take?

Spain looked like one of the most Indivually talented teams I have seen so far at that age group

We don't have enough quality players that were close to the Spanish girls

This NZ U17 team is the first that has been totally grown from the NTC programme and out of the 4 WC teams 2008/2010/2012 looks the weakest! It will be interesting if the next crop are any better I hope for sake of women's football it is.

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
Royz
about 12 years ago

Stevo how can you sday they are the weakest when they've secured a point?

Kotahitanga. We are one.

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago · edited about 12 years ago · History
Stevo38 wrote:
MrWaikato wrote:

So we have paid big money for this foreign coach... For what..?


The loss to Spain was 3-0 but my word it was a massacre.. 30% possession!  2 shots to Spain's 27. 

WOW!!!!


Can you elaborate on the "Big Money paid"?

Not as much as the Canadians paid for their U17 coach I take?

Spain looked like one of the most Indivually talented teams I have seen so far at that age group

We don't have enough quality players that were close to the Spanish girls

This NZ U17 team is the first that has been totally grown from the NTC programme and out of the 4 WC teams 2008/2010/2012 looks the weakest! It will be interesting if the next crop are any better I hope for sake of women's football it is.

Context is important here - NZ played no qualifying matches due to the Pacific countries not being financially able to field teams and were appointed as Oceania qualifiers without kicking a ball.

By comparison, in the toughest qualifying environment in the world for women's u-17's, Spain qualified undefeated as second best side in Europe, losing on pens to Germany in the final (and conceded three goals in their eight qualifiers). Spain had thrashed Germany 4-0 in the group stage of the Finals and England 3-0 in the semi. 21 goals scored in 8 qualifiers. So us losing 3-0 was pretty credible.

2010: Euro u-17 champions   2011: Euro u-17 champions  2013: third 

Spain's players mostly come from the womens' teams of the men's clubs like Barcelona, Athletico Madrid, Real Sociedad, Real Betis etc. - so you'd expect their coaching and resources to be somewhat ahead of us!  


Paraguay: semi-finalists in all four South American u-17 championships ever held (two third place finishes including last time)

We have a good chance of finishing third in the group ahead of Paraguay on goal difference if we keep the score down against Japan.

Big Pete 65, Christchurch

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago

Interesting to see Stevo38's comments, alongside those I wrote six weeks ago - post #298 on this thread.

Global Game, they may have secured a point, but it was against a team which shipped ten in their next game! Mark my words, this current crop of Young Ferns isn't much chop.

There are a mere handful of quality players sprinkled throughout the squad who are good enough to compete and make their mark at this level now, Cleverley and Puketapu most notably. A couple of them are eligible for the 2016 FIFA U17 WWC Finals in Jordan, so hopefully that squad will benefit from this experience.

Meantime, Japan ...

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago
Scousekiwi wrote:

Interesting to see Stevo38's comments, alongside those I wrote six weeks ago - post #298 on this thread.

Global Game, they may have secured a point, but it was against a team which shipped ten in their next game! Mark my words, this current crop of Young Ferns isn't much chop.

There are a mere handful of quality players sprinkled throughout the squad who are good enough to compete and make their mark at this level now, Cleverley and Puketapu most notably. A couple of them are eligible for the 2016 FIFA U17 WWC Finals in Jordan, so hopefully that squad will benefit from this experience.

Meantime, Japan ...

Agree, not a lot of quality there. Could barely string passes together and weak midfield and defence.
Think Paige Satchell showed some skill and pace- a small but promising 15 year-old. 
Losing 5-0 or 6-0 v Japan may be achievable... After all they kept it to 5-0 in a friendly in the States pre-tournament.
Be interesting to see if Paraguay bounces back v Spain this morning too.

Big Pete 65, Christchurch

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago

Not sure why Satchel was playing on the left (for one and half games) when her left foot is very weak whenever she got to the byline.

Founder

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago

Improved defensive performance v. Japan - though Japan only started three players from the Paraguay rout ("thanks for sparing us, Japan!")

but some of the lamest goal attempts I've seen in my life. These players need to learn the fundamentals of striking the ball with a bit of power.

No one in the side looked a capable goal scorer.

Much improved performance from the Young Ferns' goalie.

Big Pete 65, Christchurch

Permalink Permalink
about 12 years ago

Gee.  Japan vs Spain in the final.  Both teams from Group C where NZ lost 3-0 and 3-0 against the World Cup Winners and World Cup Runners-Up.  Just sayin ...  

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
chopah
about 12 years ago

Pretty tough group.

Permalink Permalink
about 11 years ago

Hurrah!

Great appointment for a number of reasons.

E's Flat Ah's Flat Too

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
alanshearerFeverish
about 11 years ago

I like this appointment, he seems to have worked hard an proven himself as a coach at a national level. Unlike the lads u17 coach

Permalink Permalink
about 11 years ago

I like this appointment, he seems to have worked hard an proven himself as a coach at a national level. Unlike the lads u17 coach

and you base this on?

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
sthn.jeff
about 11 years ago

his work at federation and national level has has proven success which he is being recognised for. Not sure the other guy has done the same, maybe won youth league with ACFC youth team but really its harder to lose it then win it for them! I have heard questionable things about his actualy involvment at red bull.

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

11-0 win

Kotahitanga. We are one.

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

New Zealand v Samoa highlights

New Zealand v New Caledonia highlights

I'm an optimistic pessimist. 
I'm positive things will go wrong.
Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Here is our game against Tonga, we now face Fiji in the semifinals.

(Also this game was played at Takitumu School... )

I'm an optimistic pessimist. 
I'm positive things will go wrong.
Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Well done to GT and the squad on World Cup qualification.

Kotahitanga. We are one.

Permalink Permalink
Endorsed by
foal30
about 10 years ago

Yet another OFC women's qualifying tournament where NZ was not remotely challenged by any of the opposition.

While it's great that our women's teams get to play at all the FIFA tournaments, it makes the qualifying tournaments completely uninteresting.

 This time around: 55 goals scored, zero conceded in NZ's five victories.

Big Pete 65, Christchurch

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Would you feel happy that your daughter is going to a tournament in Jordan, on the the border with Iraq and Syria (and Israel)...volatile mix and such a tournament would no doubt be a target by terror groups in that area. I hope security is really up to it, and even then, that is no guarantee that something won't happen

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

Big Pete 65 wrote:

While it's great that our women's teams get to play at all the FIFA tournaments, it makes the qualifying tournaments completely uninteresting.

Group B final matchday was very interesting (following via twitter) to see who would make it to SF. For a while it seemed like Cook Islands may overcome a bit of a goal difference hurdle to make it out of the group. They conceded a late goal, and a late goal in the other match, meant they didn't quite pull it off IIRC; but it was a fascinating end to the group stage.

Permalink Permalink
about 10 years ago

D-Sidi wrote:

Would you feel happy that your daughter is going to a tournament in Jordan, on the the border with Iraq and Syria (and Israel)...volatile mix

Costa Rica (2014 hosts) had lots of nasty spiders and snakes and the players/staff/supporters appear to have got through that OK.

Permalink Permalink