English (and other British lower league) Football Discussion

Coliseum Sports - EPL Overlords

2837 replies · 725,373 views
over 12 years ago · edited over 12 years ago · History

Product is fine for me. And I reckon a majority of their users. I recognise it isn't going to be all that good for everyone. I had pointed out the the Internet in nz was a problem for them, ripthejacka said that wasn't all of their issues. So I was wondering what other issues there was that he knew of (out of genuine interest). Then you bring up the Internet as another issue to the Internet. 

Makes sense...

Oh and the 'p' that you're looking for would be "place" not "product"


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

I suppose one way to test if it is the PLP website or if the internet is struggling is to try the NFL Pass, link below.  Try watching one of the games in week 9 (it's all free - besides the bandwidth) and see if it pauses/has the same issues as PLP.  To be fair, it would probably be more accurate if people tried it on Monday morning our time when the live games are actually on and therefore demand would be higher - but give a go in the meantime, I'd be interested to see the results for those who can't watch PLP.

  https://gamepass.nfl.com/nflgp/secure/schedule

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

Recently discovered that my ISP zero rates national data, so when streaming from NZ based servers the data doesn't count towards my cap, pretty pleased about that.

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

I suppose one way to test if it is the PLP website or if the internet is struggling is to try the NFL Pass, link below.  Try watching one of the games in week 9 (it's all free - besides the bandwidth) and see if it pauses/has the same issues as PLP.  To be fair, it would probably be more accurate if people tried it on Monday morning our time when the live games are actually on and therefore demand would be higher - but give a go in the meantime, I'd be interested to see the results for those who can't watch PLP.

  https://gamepass.nfl.com/nflgp/secure/schedule

Interestingly, when I stream baseball on MLBTV I get a worse picture and more issues occasionally. But then that does kind of make sense. 

Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago
Tegal wrote:

Product is fine for me. And I reckon a majority of their users. I recognise it isn't going to be all that good for everyone. I had pointed out the the Internet in nz was a problem for them, ripthejacka said that wasn't all of their issues. So I was wondering what other issues there was that he knew of (out of genuine interest). Then you bring up the Internet as another issue to the Internet. 

Makes sense...

Oh and the 'p' that you're looking for would be "place" not "product"


No Tegal, it is the product part of the marketing mix which is wrong. The place is fine. I think you will find that the majority of users have  simply given up and can't even be bothered going online any more

Auckland will rise once more

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago · edited over 12 years ago · History
Tegal wrote:

Product is fine for me. And I reckon a majority of their users. I recognise it isn't going to be all that good for everyone. I had pointed out the the Internet in nz was a problem for them, ripthejacka said that wasn't all of their issues. So I was wondering what other issues there was that he knew of (out of genuine interest). Then you bring up the Internet as another issue to the Internet. 

Makes sense...

Oh and the 'p' that you're looking for would be "place" not "product"


No Tegal, it is the product part of the marketing mix which is wrong. The place is fine. I think you will find that the majority of users have  simply given up and can't even be bothered going online any more

The place being the method of distribution where customers can access the product - the Internet. The product being the EPL and highlights packages. 

Do you have any evidence other than 3-4 people having the odd bad experience on this forum that the majority have given up on the service? I don't think a few complaints on a forum represent a complete failure.

Naturally, I'm just as bad assuming that just because I'm having a good experience, that a majority are fine with it too. But you seem to be a lot more convinced that this is a complete failure, while I admit that I am just making assumptions. 


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago · edited over 12 years ago · History
Tegal, if you read this thread from the start you will see a significant larger quantity then 3-4. Discount your threads and do the maths. The lemon of this product has also been well published in the media 



Auckland will rise once more

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

5-6? 

Still hardly representative sample size of a whole country. Especially when people are more likely to post something when they have a bad experience, than when they have a good experience. 

As I said, I'm not claiming to know anything, but you seem absolutely convinced by this. So show me how what you're saying is so correct. I'd be genuinely interested to know. Part of the reason I'm in this thread as much as I am is not to defend PLP (I've said many times I couldn't give 2 shits if they go under), but because I find it an interesting topic of discussion. 

But you throwing incorrect marketing theories and telling me how most of the country has given up on the service based on nothing, isn't interesting. It would however be interesting if you backed what you say up with something of substance. 


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

I've had NO problems with the stream quality since the first week. Airplaying from an iPod Touch to an Apple TV has been fantastic, no buffering required and the quality is very good (at 720p).


Yellow Fever - Misery loves company

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

My experience has been pretty good overall, a few instances of buffering/freezing but generally pretty good.  

Quality drops significantly when I try to watch on my smartphone using 3G (which I expected).

Just took advantage of the $49 upgrade and am looking forward to watching the highlights shows again :)

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

I've only had one night with streaming issues and that may have been down to the internet connection - it was one of only two times I haven't been at home for the game. 

The issues I've had have been with the android app. Two weeks of mind-numbing problems giving false error messages.

The apps also weren't available at the beginning of the season - although that didn't impact me thank god.

Logging on via the regular web-page and watching games has presented me with zero issues. The quality could be better for sure, and that's been the biggest media criticism, but to be fair that is a known issue, and they are still delivering what they said they'd deliver - android app aside. 

The fact that the app issues cost me one and a half games made me absolutely wild though. If they had just not done apps, I wouldn't be angry about it, I just wanted what they said they were providing. They said I could watch on my tablet when I wasn't near a pc, and they failed in that respect.

If they don't go under and we're back with them next season, I want;

- HD

- Improved app reliability

- Stop cutting me off so soon after the final whistle - I like to watch the little goals re-cap before the credits roll. It feels cold and impersonal that they abruptly cut out the way they do

- Give a better highlights recap to tvone! Sick of the 'sunday review', it's got nothing on the 'premier league review' sky used to show. If the supplier has changed the way they do it and sky would've changed this year anyway, then I can understand I guess

- Dont display scores on the front page by default - the default setting should be not to show scores, with an option on each game panel to 'display score' or something like that. I know you can change it and now I have, but it's cost me one result before I watched the game already so the horse has bolted...


Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

GIVE US HD STREAMING THROUGH APPLE TV.



Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago
nufc_nz wrote:

GIVE US HD STREAMING THROUGH APPLE TV.

Would be nice. But probably not a priority since they figure you can just stream to your Apple TV via laptop (so I've heard?). Maybe next season?

Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

Paulm - that's been about my experience too. Good to know I'm not alone! Haha. 

Had one or two iPad issues, though its fee really a bit patchy on the wifi anyway. The main annoyance of the iPad app I had though was that if you start a live game late, you can only scroll back/rewind about a minute or so. They didn't make this clear and it cost me 60mins of a game when I did it. 

Hoping sometime soon they introduce being able to start a game from the start if you come in partway through a live game (for both the app and on the website). They have indicated they will do this at some point. 


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

It seems BT Sport have got the rights for the champions and Europa league in England from 2015 for three years for £900m. Up from £400m from the previous deal with sky. Quite a few of the people I follow on twitter not very happy that they'll have to fork out for BT for the CL aswell as sky for the premier league. Most wishing BT go the same way as sentanta and espn, similar as to how people want coliseum to fail.

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

Massive news in the UK this morning. BT are a very different beast than the likes of Setanta or Coliseum though - this is a bigger company than BSkyB.

From 2015 it will be impossible to be a football fan in the UK without having both Sky and BT. 

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

Not forgetting no one will be able to afford to actually going to a game without taking out a mortgage. Also watch those cnuts also known as "agents" upon reading of this, will most certainly be adding an extra zero or two at the end of any contract offer.

Proud to have attended the first 175 Consecutive "Home" Wellington Phoenix "A League" Games !!

The Ruf, The Ruf, The Ruf is on Fire!!

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

sound lagged during #hcafc game today 

a bit of a drag

but not as bad as being overwhelmed in the first half and thus losing

(dear PLP, not being quiet as bad a a loss is not exactly high praise from a consumer/client/customer/sucker ... any chance you could sort it out when you next read this thread?)

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago
Tegal, if you read this thread from the start you will see a significant larger quantity then 3-4. Discount your threads and do the maths. The lemon of this product has also been well published in the media 



How is the product a lemon? All it's doing is streaming video from a server. The only issues I've had were when the UK timezone changed and they messed up when the game was meant to start one week.
Anything related to quality issues is purely up to your internet connection. PLP use Akamai as their CDN. Enough said
Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

I've just contacted PLP to see what I have to do to cancel and get a refund. They replied to say they don't have a cancellation policy.

I've just had enough of the poor quality and can get my football from elsewhere now. What I find surprising in this thread is the number of people who say the service is fine, but still have glitches, or the audio is out, or the picture quality could be better. Whilst I've no doubt the service will work for quite a few people, are you really happy to pay money for something which still gives problems ?

I'm not interested in watching on a tablet, or a smartphone, so the apps are worthless to me. I want to get up and watch the game on my big tv without any problems and without ending up with a headache at the end of the game. But I haven't had a single week since it started where I've been happy with the quality and believe me I'm no rookie when it comes to HTPC's and streaming tv.

Has anyone else tried to cancel and get a refund ?

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

I just tried the NFLPass link posted above and the video stream was absolutely fine. The graphics they posted to show the players was a little chunky but the game play was very watchable.

I then tried the ManU - Arsenal game and it was nothing but a serious of stutters. Completely unwatchable (scoreline included ;)


Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago
According to some here it must be your internet



Auckland will rise once more

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

That's only based on the fact that I've always used it without any problems. I don't know all the technical stuff, but it therefore seems to me the only variable between me having it work perfectly fine, and someone else having issues is the Internet or hardware of the individual. 

It could be something else, I don't know, and neither do you. 


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

I spoke to CSM yesterday and they confirmed if you have anything less than 7Mbps you can forget about getting an acceptable video quality.

The fact I can stream both BBC iPlayer and the NFL's GamePass with no problems doesn't seem to phase them.

They have given me a refund though so I'll continue to get my football from elsewhere from now on.

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago · edited over 12 years ago · History
Well done. Perhaps they should have actually advertised what you said above to their customers before selling them a product which was not going to work for them? What do you think Tegal? Interesting that the other streams work fine is it not? Perhaps it is the product? 



Auckland will rise once more

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago
martyyn wrote:

I spoke to CSM yesterday and they confirmed if you have anything less than 7Mbps you can forget about getting an acceptable video quality.

The fact I can stream both BBC iPlayer and the NFL's GamePass with no problems doesn't seem to phase them.

They have given me a refund though so I'll continue to get my football from elsewhere from now on.


is this the start of an exodus???

Queenslander 3x a year.

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago · edited over 12 years ago · History
Well done. Perhaps they should have actually advertised what you said above to their customers before selling them a product which was not going to work for them? What do you think Tegal? Interesting that the other streams work fine is it not? Perhaps it is the product? 


I think its on their website somewhere. But yeah their website is quite confusing to find information like that on, they need to get better on communication etc for sure. 

As the product, I don't know. Still tend to think its Internet connection, plus a bit on their end as well (people seem to have more of a problem during peak times). Not that I know any of the technical stuff. 

Mine has always worked perfectly fine, so I'm probably the wrong person to ask. Maybe it has a lower limit of what speed Internet is required etc for some reason. 


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago
Do you know what 7Mbps is?



Auckland will rise once more

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago
martyyn wrote:

I spoke to CSM yesterday and they confirmed if you have anything less than 7Mbps you can forget about getting an acceptable video quality.

The fact I can stream both BBC iPlayer and the NFL's GamePass with no problems doesn't seem to phase them.

They have given me a refund though so I'll continue to get my football from elsewhere from now on.


Did you get it all back?

Auckland will rise once more

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago · edited over 12 years ago · History
Do you know what 7Mbps is?


Yes. 

And it'd still be the place that is the problem (whether it be their software/hardware that is delivering it, or the individuals internet, or a mixture of the two), the product is the EPL :p


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago
Tegal wrote:
Do you know what 7Mbps is?


Yes. 

And it'd still be the place that is the problem (whether it be their software that is delivering it, or the individuals Internet), the product is the EPL :p


Well what is it?

Auckland will rise once more

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago
Tegal wrote:
Do you know what 7Mbps is?


Yes. 

And it'd still be the place that is the problem (whether it be their software that is delivering it, or the individuals Internet), the product is the EPL :p


Well what is it?

Do you read anything I say before you respond?

Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago
Yes and I asked you a question. Do you know what 7Mbps is? You said "yes" and I asked "well what is it"?p>

Auckland will rise once more

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago · edited over 12 years ago · History

Ah. Download speed. Mine was at about 14 last I checked it. 


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

Thanks. What would the average in NZ be? Above 7?


Auckland will rise once more

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

the average should be above 7. see this blog post here http://www.geekzone.co.nz/sbiddle/8433. Over 80% of premises are capable of receiving speeds of at least 10Mbps. but most people don't get this because of the wiring in their house, which can easily be fixed/improved.

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

If 7mbs is the point at which PLP becomes "watchable/acceptable" then all they need to do is tell all their potential customers that clearly before (or as) they sign up and link to a speedtest... then advise potential solutions for those getting less. This would save a lot of negative feelings about "their" product (which is the platform/mechanism for delivery of EPL content - not the EPL itself).

E + R + O

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

Thanks. What would the average in NZ be? Above 7?


Why do you care? You don't have PLP yet all you do is bag it - you have no experience of using it regularly at all so your comments carry zero weight. Unlike martyn's which are legit, he has a serious gripe and is telling us how he dealt with Coliseum, like you would expect of someone in that situation. 
You just constantly pester Tegal as if he's the one who personally built and maintains it. 
If you have a problem with Coliseum then take it to them, directly, or ask them questions, directly, like a normal person would. Tegal keeps saying over and over that he's not the best person to ask, and that he's not sure why people are having issues, yet you continue to ask and ask and ask. So then he offers an opinion at your constant insistence, and you bag that too. I feel his posts have been pretty clear as to where he stands and what he knows about it - which isn't a lot. 
In fact I applaud Tegal for constantly keeping his cool and answering your trolling questions with a level head - obviously it's rarking me up more than it is him, and yet I've had issues with the service more than he has!

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago

Anyway... if someone sees a special offer/code for it could they let me know?... I could use it when I'm in hospital and after I go home so if I could get it cheapish I'd go and buy a Nexus/iPad mini as that seems to be watchable in most instances :-)

E + R + O

Permalink Permalink
over 12 years ago
SurgeQld wrote:

If 7mbs is the point at which PLP becomes "watchable/acceptable" then all they need to do is tell all their potential customers that clearly before (or as) they sign up and link to a speedtest... then advise potential solutions for those getting less. This would save a lot of negative feelings about "their" product (which is the platform/mechanism for delivery of EPL content - not the EPL itself).



I just checked mine using the site 'Speedtest.net' and got a pathetic 1.6mbs when on wireless and when plugging the laptop directly into the router I got 7.2mbs.

If using the iPad (I assume at 1.6mbs) I rarely have an issue with the quality (one out of about six games was a bad experience in terms of picture quality) and when watching on the TV, i plug the laptop in to the router and the tv and have had only relatively minor problems. I live in Surburban Christchurch and would expect my situation to be like many others.


"You can never get a bloody tradesman at Easter, it's a wonder Jesus got crucified" - Karl Pilkington

Permalink Permalink