Nix vs Brisbane - Hamilton July 10

"In the opening match of the season on 8 August 2009, Theoklitos endured a disastrous debut for Norwich against Colchester United at Carrow Road, conceding five goals before half-time and seven in total. He missed his punch for the first goal, palmed a shot straight into the path of Clive Platt for the second and failed to save a free-kick for the fourth.[2] Theoklitos later admitted it was "the worst performance of my career."[3]

Despite the performance, Theoklitos still had the support of manager Bryan Gunn,[3] a former goalkeeper himself. However, Gunn did not have the support of the Norwich board and was sacked, to be replaced by Colchester manager Paul Lambert, who had engineered the 7-1 defeat. Under Lambert, Theoklitos slipped out of favour to third choice goalkeeper. He was recalled to the bench in October for a Football League Trophy game away to Gillingham, but inexplicably failed to turn up for the team bus,[4] effectively ending chances of another recall, continuing to play for the reserves team.

Lambert confirmed in December 2009 that he expected Theoklitos to be leaving the club.[5]

Theoklitos' contract was terminated by mutual consent in March of 2010.[6]