Wellington Phoenix Men

R22 V Western Sydney Wanderers | Sun 17th March | 7pm | Westpac

340 replies · 46,583 views
about 7 years ago · edited about 7 years ago · History

Great result for the Nix.

However it’s a shame that the Vigil was not held at the Stadium then given all attendees free admission to the game 

Attendance at the Basin, reported at 11,000. A tribute/vigil at the Stadium, followed by the game would have been a great opportunity for Wellingtonians to commiserate the loss of our country men, women and children, then demonstrate that our city goes on with grief, whilst acknowledging one of our darkest days as a nation.

Tickets? Tickets? We talkin’ about tickets?

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Not to mention it was always a dangerous tackle with how high his foot was and studs up, if Rufer did not move that could have been nasty

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Warwick Hunt wrote:

Wellington City and the Wellington Phoenix should have held the vigil at the Stadium then given all attendees free admission to the game

Attendance at the Basin, reported at 11,000. A tribute/vigil at the Stadium, followed by the game would have been a great opportunity for Wellingtonians to commiserate the loss of our country men, women and children, then acknowledge that our city goes on, whilst acknowledging one of our darkest days as a nation.

I think it was right that the vigil WCC organised was a standalone event, not tied into some other event.

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Warwick Hunt wrote:

Great result for the Nix.

However it’s a shame that the Vigil was not held at the Stadium then given all attendees free admission to the game 

Attendance at the Basin, reported at 11,000. A tribute/vigil at the Stadium, followed by the game would have been a great opportunity for Wellingtonians to commiserate the loss of our country men, women and children, then demonstrate that our city goes on with grief, whilst acknowledging one of our darkest days as a nation.

No, if the vigil was held at the stadium then they would need to cancel the game. It wouldn't be right or make any sense to tie them together.

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Incredible result. Still don’t trust all this video interpretation.  

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Poor work doesn't make it dubious work!

First one has no evidence to overturn the free kick decision. Second one is a yellow, which I'd believed the VAR couldn't get involved in. 



Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Warwick Hunt wrote:

Great result for the Nix.

However it’s a shame that the Vigil was not held at the Stadium then given all attendees free admission to the game 

Attendance at the Basin, reported at 11,000. A tribute/vigil at the Stadium, followed by the game would have been a great opportunity for Wellingtonians to commiserate the loss of our country men, women and children, then demonstrate that our city goes on with grief, whilst acknowledging one of our darkest days as a nation.

Very much disagree. It was a shame it was held at a similar time; but the vigil should be a standalone event.

a.haak

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago · edited about 7 years ago · History

Looking forward to seeing Sheridan get a start. With no game this weekend. Rudan has two weeks to work on tactics how best to employ Cillian in attack. Will he play him as a No. 9 or a number 10. Will it be a Sheridan/ Willo/ Burgess combo ?

Good opportunity to change things up a bit, keep opposition guessing. Hope Roy enjoys his rest.

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago · edited about 7 years ago · History

Munk wrote:

C-Diddy wrote:

james dean wrote:

very strange decision 

It's the A-League

its the eh? League

There have been shockers in European Continental football too (see Man U's lucky goal). Time to scrap VAR. Ruins games.

Supporter world's best and worst football teams: Waikato/WaiBop, Kingz, Knights, Phoenix, The Argyle, The Whites & the All Whites

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

aitkenmike wrote:

Munk wrote:

im pretty over the booing of Roly -today of all days when we should be showing our class...

I thought the exact same thing.  Pretty dissapointed with that.

Thought the booing of Roly, was very poor form. Was pretty embarrassed by it

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Villanix wrote:

aitkenmike wrote:

Munk wrote:

im pretty over the booing of Roly -today of all days when we should be showing our class...

I thought the exact same thing.  Pretty dissapointed with that.

Thought the booing of Roly, was very poor form. Was pretty embarrassed by it

With you all on that one.

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago · edited about 7 years ago · History

one_eyed_nik wrote:

Villanix wrote:

aitkenmike wrote:

Munk wrote:

im pretty over the booing of Roly -today of all days when we should be showing our class...

I thought the exact same thing.  Pretty dissapointed with that.

Thought the booing of Roly, was very poor form. Was pretty embarrassed by it

With you all on that one.

It was poor.  What's next, throwing tomatoes at Vinnie when Adelaide United are in town?

Actually, getting outplayed quite a bit these days

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

one_eyed_nik wrote:

Villanix wrote:

aitkenmike wrote:

Munk wrote:

im pretty over the booing of Roly -today of all days when we should be showing our class...

I thought the exact same thing.  Pretty dissapointed with that.

Thought the booing of Roly, was very poor form. Was pretty embarrassed by it

With you all on that one.

Wasn't too impressed with all that booing at Roly going on last night

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

I don't think there's anything wrong with booing an ex player, especially one you were very attached to who left the club. Remember the chant 'Smeltzy, what's the score' in that thumping of GCU??

Stuff like this adds colour to a game and if it helps to make an opposition player play poorly...why not!


VUW AFC - Victoria University Football for life

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

I didn't mind the booing, it was the idiot who kept blowing their whistle that kept coming through on the TV that did my head in!

Roly knows we as a fan base generally love him, thats why were gutted he left and that's why we boo when he returns.

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

When he took a corner and the "Who are ya?" went out, he started laughing  which was good. He knows most of us still like him.

Proud to have attended the first 175 Consecutive "Home" Wellington Phoenix "A League" Games !!

The Ruf, The Ruf, The Ruf is on Fire!!

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Correct me if I'm wrong, but the difference between Vinnie and Roly is that Vinnie was let go after a career as a loyal club man, whereas Roly gave off the impression that he was too good for us and stopped trying in his last season or two with us.


Ramming liberal dribble down your throat since 2009
This forum needs less angst and more Kate Bush threads



Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Doloras wrote:

Correct me if I'm wrong, but the difference between Vinnie and Roly is that Vinnie was let go after a career as a loyal club man, whereas Roly gave off the impression that he was too good for us and stopped trying in his last season or two with us.

it was his wife who wanted to leave. She thought Wellington was too small and quiet, plus wasn't a fan of seismic activity either. I always got the feeling Roly would've stayed if it wasn't for that. He got along with the squad really well and if I recall correctly he actually said he wouldn't leave until we won something. I know he didn't stick to that, but I reckon he mightve if his wife didn't want to move
Annual finals disappointment enthusiast.

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago · edited about 7 years ago · History

I have absolutely nothing against Roly. Booing him is fudgeing stupid; especially on a day like that where everyone is mourning. Whoever did it should've got a slap. 

Saying he "didn't try" in his last season is a load of crap; sure, he didn't play well - but no one did.

a.haak

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

I remember booing Jade North for a stupid dive at his own 16m box, that was funny.

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Remember all the people saying "but where will the goals come from", haha, we've just scored 11 goals in 2 games!

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Doloras wrote:

Correct me if I'm wrong, but the difference between Vinnie and Roly is that Vinnie was let go after a career as a loyal club man, whereas Roly gave off the impression that he was too good for us and stopped trying in his last season or two with us.

Vinnie was shark

yung thug

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Vinnie was limited, but not sharke. Can't fault his attitude - the NIX could have used more players like him over the last few years.

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

I think there's a difference between booing and having banter, ie "Who are ya" to Roly and "Smeltzy, what's the score".

Booing decisions or certain controversial plays is fine. But booing players or teams just for walking out or passing the ball is pretty dickish.

At the warriors game on Saturday afternoon, the fans seemed to give a polite golf clap when the Bulldogs ran out. I wondered if it was related to the different atmosphere at this weekends games. I actually quite liked it. 

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Sorry but I disagree. Booing an ex player is standard practice and very few exceptions are made for loyal/club men (eg Vinnie Lia).


VUW AFC - Victoria University Football for life

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

for crying out loud it’s part of the culture of football. Pros are not shrinking violets; can’t imagine any would get upset about a bit of booing from supporters of a previous club. They understand it’s not vicious or represents hatred. More PC gone mad.

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago · edited about 7 years ago · History

for crying out loud it’s part of the culture of football. Pros are not shrinking violets; can’t imagine any would get upset about a bit of booing from supporters of a previous club. They understand it’s not vicious or represents hatred. More PC gone mad.

'PC gone mad' - alright mate, jog on. We just don't think Bonevacia in particular deserves the treatment, and it's a bit fudgeing stupid doing it when football is completely secondary at the moment.

edit: went a bit angry, shouldn't of called anyone an idiot. 

a.haak

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

valeo wrote:

for crying out loud it’s part of the culture of football. Pros are not shrinking violets; can’t imagine any would get upset about a bit of booing from supporters of a previous club. They understand it’s not vicious or represents hatred. More PC gone mad.

'PC gone mad' - alright mate, jog on. We just don't think Bonevacia in particular deserves the treatment, and it's a bit fudgeing stupid doing it when football is completely secondary at the moment.

Also, only fudgeing idiots use the term 'PC gone mad'. So, you're a fudgeing idiot. Cheers.

So you want to govern who can and cant boo at games? Yep real YF mentality right there. 

Mr Positive

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Remember to be nice and play the ball, not the man, just as Bill and Ted says

I'm an optimistic pessimist. 
I'm positive things will go wrong.
Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Royz wrote:

valeo wrote:

for crying out loud it’s part of the culture of football. Pros are not shrinking violets; can’t imagine any would get upset about a bit of booing from supporters of a previous club. They understand it’s not vicious or represents hatred. More PC gone mad.

'PC gone mad' - alright mate, jog on. We just don't think Bonevacia in particular deserves the treatment, and it's a bit fudgeing stupid doing it when football is completely secondary at the moment.

Also, only fudgeing idiots use the term 'PC gone mad'. So, you're a fudgeing idiot. Cheers.

So you want to govern who can and cant boo at games? Yep real YF mentality right there. 

Nobody is proposing governing when people can and can't boo at games, they are saying they don't think Roly should have booed.

There's many examples from overseas of when a player leaves & plays against them but isn't booed, and is in fact welcomed back. Similarly there's many cases where a player declined to celebrate after scoring against a former club. Nobody governs that, and it's not 'PC gone mad', it's respect.

Are people saying that if in an imaginary world Durante went to play for Mariners next season they would boo him when came back to the stadium?

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago · edited about 7 years ago · History

Royz wrote:

So you want to govern who can and cant boo at games? Yep real YF mentality right there.

Hilarious. Two Australians having an argument over something neither of them control and then slagging the whole of Yellow Fever as if they have any clue about how the Fever zone works.

Fudge this fanbase is full of stupid cods these days.


Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

valeo wrote:

I have absolutely nothing against Roly. Booing him is fudgeing stupid; especially on a day like that where everyone is mourning. Whoever did it should've got a slap. 

Saying he "didn't try" in his last season is a load of crap; sure, he didn't play well - but no one did.

Love this logic. Brings up the fact that everyone is in mourning after the tragic, violent events of Friday and then proceeds to suggest violence towards those that booed Roly.

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago · edited about 7 years ago · History

Baiter wrote:

Royz wrote:

So you want to govern who can and cant boo at games? Yep real YF mentality right there.

Hilarious. Two Australians having an argument over something neither of them control and then slagging the whole of Yellow Fever as if they have any clue about how the Fever zone works.

Fudge this fanbase is full of stupid cods these days.

These days?

I'll have you know I've been a fan since day 1 and a stupid cod since long before that

Valley FC til I die?

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Colvinator wrote:

Royz wrote:

valeo wrote:

for crying out loud it’s part of the culture of football. Pros are not shrinking violets; can’t imagine any would get upset about a bit of booing from supporters of a previous club. They understand it’s not vicious or represents hatred. More PC gone mad.

'PC gone mad' - alright mate, jog on. We just don't think Bonevacia in particular deserves the treatment, and it's a bit fudgeing stupid doing it when football is completely secondary at the moment.

Also, only fudgeing idiots use the term 'PC gone mad'. So, you're a fudgeing idiot. Cheers.

So you want to govern who can and cant boo at games? Yep real YF mentality right there. 

Nobody is proposing governing when people can and can't boo at games, they are saying they don't think Roly should have booed.

There's many examples from overseas of when a player leaves & plays against them but isn't booed, and is in fact welcomed back. Similarly there's many cases where a player declined to celebrate after scoring against a former club. Nobody governs that, and it's not 'PC gone mad', it's respect.

Are people saying that if in an imaginary world Durante went to play for Mariners next season they would boo him when came back to the stadium?

No because of his long association with the club. But if they did he is smart enough to detect the almost certain emotion underpinning any booing that may occur and would immediately understand that no offence was intended . . . my guess is that he would crack a smile. To me it’s friggin obvious that the booing of Roly Bonnevacia was underpinned by a very different emotion to that which for example might underpin the noise supporters make when an opponent commits an horrendous foul on a member of the home team.

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

I don't think there's anything wrong with booing an ex player, especially one you were very attached to who left the club. Remember the chant 'Smeltzy, what's the score' in that thumping of GCU??

Stuff like this adds colour to a game and if it helps to make an opposition player play poorly...why not!

Sorry but they are nothing alike. Asking Smeltz what the score was and it being said in jest. Is nothing like the booing at Roly nearly every time he touched the ball none of which sounded much like it was being done in jest.

GET YOUR SHIRTS OFF FOR THE BOYS

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

Yakcall wrote:

Remember to be nice and play the ball, not the man, just as Bill and Ted says

We need more people like you working for Facebook, that platform is whack

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

number8 wrote:

I remember booing Jade North for a stupid dive at his own 16m box, that was funny.

Was this when he was playing for us? ;-)

Apparently I'm apathetic, but I couldn't care less.

"Being a Partick Thistle fan sets you apart. It means youre a free thinker. It also means your team has no money." Tim Luckhurst, The Independent, 4th December 2003

Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

valeo wrote:

for crying out loud it’s part of the culture of football. Pros are not shrinking violets; can’t imagine any would get upset about a bit of booing from supporters of a previous club. They understand it’s not vicious or represents hatred. More PC gone mad.

'PC gone mad' - alright mate, jog on. We just don't think Bonevacia in particular deserves the treatment, and it's a bit fudgeing stupid doing it when football is completely secondary at the moment.

Also, only fudgeing idiots use the term 'PC gone mad'. So, you're a fudgeing idiot. Cheers.

Let's try to be nice to each other, this level of vitriol is not warranted #resetourattitudes
Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

 it was (Roly's) wife who wanted to leave. She thought Wellington was too small and quiet, plus wasn't a fan of seismic activity either.

Thanks, I was not aware of that part of the story. Lots of WAGs seem to have a problem living in Wellington. No wonder Roly seemed unenthusiastic with that going on.


Ramming liberal dribble down your throat since 2009
This forum needs less angst and more Kate Bush threads



Permalink Permalink
about 7 years ago

If you think the booing was bad you wanna hear the amount of shark the guy behind me in the zone was talking. If you were a couple of rows behind the drums you’d know what I was talking about. 

Chelsea FC - Glasgow Rangers - Wellington Phoenix - Canterbury Dragons

Aspiring football coach:

Nomads United u14B 2016

Watch this space. 

Permalink Permalink