Wellington Phoenix Men

The Great 2016/17 Coaching Saga

1493 replies · 413,907 views Locked
almost 9 years ago

Also, you'd be surprised how many Kenny Cunninghams there are in Ireland.


Ramming liberal dribble down your throat since 2009
This forum needs less angst and more Kate Bush threads



Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

Would Ramon & Ivan be a package deal?

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

dunnix wrote:

Would Ramon & Ivan be a package deal?

Only if we force Ivan out of retirement to run our midfield.

Yellow Fever - Misery loves company

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

Be good to know if he was even interested in the coaching job

Football: Tribulietx tip for Phoenix by Michael Burgess

I'd say the fact that Ivan's talking him up confirms he is. 

"At the end of the drive the lawmen arrive...

I'll take my chance because luck is on my side or something...

Her name is Rio, she don't need to understand...

Oh Rio, Rio, hear them shout across the land..."

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago
Can I just point out that Ramon's teams have not won the last two seasons. IMO this opens him up to the same criticism thrown at Ernie re lack of a plan B etc
Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago · edited almost 9 years ago · History

Maybe Ivan is talking up Ramon simply because he want's the ACFC head coach job?

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

Tyler wrote:
Can I just point out that Ramon's teams have not won the last two seasons. IMO this opens him up to the same criticism thrown at Ernie re lack of a plan B etc

Its been well commented that he does not coach his teams to have a plan B. They play a certain way and rely on scoring early and strangling possession. It when they have to chase the game (and to be fair its not that often) that they fall apart.

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

We're never going to get a flawless candidate though, because any coach that good won't be interested in the role. I think Ramon is capable of setting up his teams differently for different matches (CWC vs SSP for instance) but what he maybe isn't good at is adjusting tactics within a game if they aren't working. On the other hand, his general record and knowledge of the local game, and contacts for recruitment, all have to be big pluses in his favour.

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

Tyler wrote:
Can I just point out that Ramon's teams have not won the last two seasons.

You realise that ACFC have been Premiers for the last 4 seasons?

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

liberty_nz wrote:

Tyler wrote:
Can I just point out that Ramon's teams have not won the last two seasons.

You realise that ACFC have been Premiers for the last 4 seasons?

 

  Supporter For Ever - Keep The Faith - Foundation Member - Never Lets FAX Get In The Way Of A Good Yarn

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago · edited almost 9 years ago · History

Premiers - top of the league after regular season

Champions - winner of the finals series

Just plain wrong to say that ACFC haven't won anything. 

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

Also, not many a league coaches have plan b's

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago
I'm well aware of the history of the NZFC, I've been supporting TW for a long time. I'm just pointing out there was a lot of angst on this forum when we got in a hole this season. One of the criticisms was Ernie couldn't change things up when needed. If Ramon is steadfast to one formation well done but that doesn't cut it over a long season as we have just found out
Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

liberty_nz wrote:

Tyler wrote:
Can I just point out that Ramon's teams have not won the last two seasons.

You realise that ACFC have been Premiers for the last 4 seasons?

We are in New Zealand, and the winner of the league is the team who wins the grand final.

Yellow Fever - Misery loves company

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

Doloras wrote:

what we need is someone, with a lot of time on their hands, to hang out around nix hq on thorndon quay to see who turns up for an interview.

I thought it was on Vivian St?

Things might have changed, but when I lived in Welly, hanging out on Vivian St would lead to some surprising offers.

http://www.wellingtonphoenix.com/about/contact-us/95f2v8nyut6q1iegrubme96k6

Contact us

Street and Postal Address

Level 1, The Woolstore Design Centre

258-262 Thorndon Quay, Pipitea, Wellington

Phone: +64 4 802 4998

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

patrick478 wrote:

liberty_nz wrote:

Tyler wrote:
Can I just point out that Ramon's teams have not won the last two seasons.

You realise that ACFC have been Premiers for the last 4 seasons?

We are in New Zealand, and the winner of the league is the team who wins the grand final.

No there is a distinction between them. 

The winners of the league are called the Premiers and automatically qualify for the Oceania Champions League

The winners of the Grand Final are called the National Champions

Auckland City are the current premiers (and have been for 4 years in a row now)

Team Wellington are the National Champions (and have been for 2 years in a row now)

https://thejourneyfan.blogspot.co.nz/

New Zealand Football Media Association Website of the year 2015 & 2016

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

I'd be stoked if the Nix won the lid even if we didn't win the seat

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

So this is the coaching speculation thread?

A bit confused, from the thread title and the content here, but anyway:

Let's get Mark Rudan, then Fox Sports will stop slagging us off because he's their mate.

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

TreeFiddy wrote:

bennie99 wrote:

Ryan wrote:

Our biggest advantage is we have a monopoly on NZ players, the other clubs have a talent pool of 2.3 million each, we have a talent pool of almost 7 million to draw from. Because we're the only show in town the top NZ players should also be cheaper than the top Australians. 

We need to focus on developing NZ players and it's insane that we only started doing it a couple of years ago.

Problem is if they get to Marco or Kosta's level they just get 'poached' by the bigger clubs.  I think there's been a lot of academy development in the last 10 years in NZ, just not by the Nix.  The better players have bypassed the Nix and those like Rufer et al have been okish but not quite good enough to make an impact in the A league just yet. So I guess it's about developing enough young kiwi players and getting them up to A league standard that you aren't as impacted by the 'elite' young players not being with the Nix like the current situation.

Not always necessarily a bad thing especially given our financial constraints. If we could become a feeder club, yes it would be frustrating, but it would also mean that we could then reinvest that in our first team squad quality or even our own academy. It would also make us a more attractive destination for other youth players if they could see the potential to develop here. 

I agree with this but I thought Ryan was saying that we needed kiwi youth talent to be able to compete as a consistent top 6 side into the future as it's harder for us to get quality aussie players than most of the aussie clubs?

bling blang blah
Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

Ryan wrote:

Also, not many a league coaches have plan b's

Well Perth and Western Sydney were able to work through rough patches to end up going well by the end of the season so I assume they must have tweaked some stuff. Certainly City and Adelaide didn't appear to though.

bling blang blah
Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago · edited almost 9 years ago · History

bennie99 wrote:

TreeFiddy wrote:

bennie99 wrote:

Ryan wrote:

Our biggest advantage is we have a monopoly on NZ players, the other clubs have a talent pool of 2.3 million each, we have a talent pool of almost 7 million to draw from. Because we're the only show in town the top NZ players should also be cheaper than the top Australians. 

We need to focus on developing NZ players and it's insane that we only started doing it a couple of years ago.

Problem is if they get to Marco or Kosta's level they just get 'poached' by the bigger clubs.  I think there's been a lot of academy development in the last 10 years in NZ, just not by the Nix.  The better players have bypassed the Nix and those like Rufer et al have been okish but not quite good enough to make an impact in the A league just yet. So I guess it's about developing enough young kiwi players and getting them up to A league standard that you aren't as impacted by the 'elite' young players not being with the Nix like the current situation.

Not always necessarily a bad thing especially given our financial constraints. If we could become a feeder club, yes it would be frustrating, but it would also mean that we could then reinvest that in our first team squad quality or even our own academy. It would also make us a more attractive destination for other youth players if they could see the potential to develop here. 

I agree with this but I thought Ryan was saying that we needed kiwi youth talent to be able to compete as a consistent top 6 side into the future as it's harder for us to get quality aussie players than most of the aussie clubs?

Kind of, I wasn't saying it's hard for the Phoenix to get top Australian talent just that there is a lot of competition for it, if we just take population and ignore playing numbers then the A-League teams have a player catchment of 2.3 million per team. The Phoenix has a monopoly of 4.5 million + that 2.3 million that every team has.

It's not that it's any harder for the Phoenix to get top Australians, it's just that it's hard for every team. Whereas if we play our cards right we will get virtually no competition for the top NZ talent. 

Sure, the exceptional ones will go to get higher wages in Australian teams as foreigners, or will go overseas. But hopefully the club can profit from that. And that's no different from the smaller Australian clubs getting their players poached. In fact, there is an extra barrier that most Kiwis will be classed as foreigners in Australia so they have to be exceptional for that to happen and not a maybe.

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

Ryan wrote:

bennie99 wrote:

TreeFiddy wrote:

bennie99 wrote:

Ryan wrote:

Our biggest advantage is we have a monopoly on NZ players, the other clubs have a talent pool of 2.3 million each, we have a talent pool of almost 7 million to draw from. Because we're the only show in town the top NZ players should also be cheaper than the top Australians. 

We need to focus on developing NZ players and it's insane that we only started doing it a couple of years ago.

Problem is if they get to Marco or Kosta's level they just get 'poached' by the bigger clubs.  I think there's been a lot of academy development in the last 10 years in NZ, just not by the Nix.  The better players have bypassed the Nix and those like Rufer et al have been okish but not quite good enough to make an impact in the A league just yet. So I guess it's about developing enough young kiwi players and getting them up to A league standard that you aren't as impacted by the 'elite' young players not being with the Nix like the current situation.

Not always necessarily a bad thing especially given our financial constraints. If we could become a feeder club, yes it would be frustrating, but it would also mean that we could then reinvest that in our first team squad quality or even our own academy. It would also make us a more attractive destination for other youth players if they could see the potential to develop here. 

I agree with this but I thought Ryan was saying that we needed kiwi youth talent to be able to compete as a consistent top 6 side into the future as it's harder for us to get quality aussie players than most of the aussie clubs?

Kind of, I wasn't saying it's hard for the Phoenix to get top Australian talent just that there is a lot of competition for it, if we just take population and ignore playing numbers then the A-League teams have a player catchment of 2.3 million per team. The Phoenix has a monopoly of 4.5 million + that 2.3 million that every team has.

It's not that it's any harder for the Phoenix to get top Australians, it's just that it's hard for every team. Whereas if we play our cards right we will get virtually no competition for the top NZ talent. 

Sure, the exceptional ones will go to get higher wages in Australian teams as foreigners, or will go overseas. But hopefully the club can profit from that. And that's no different from the smaller Australian clubs getting their players poached. In fact, there is an extra barrier that most Kiwis will be classed as foreigners in Australia so they have to be exceptional for that to happen and not a maybe.

Correct, which is why they will be harder for us to lure back unless we become the best option they have left (meaning, they may have "peaked"). You could argue that Kosta is back with us, as was (briefly) Smeltz, but Marco Rojas or Storm Roux won't be, precisely for that reason.

Actually, getting outplayed quite a bit these days

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

Mainland FC wrote:

Ryan wrote:

bennie99 wrote:

TreeFiddy wrote:

bennie99 wrote:

Ryan wrote:

Our biggest advantage is we have a monopoly on NZ players, the other clubs have a talent pool of 2.3 million each, we have a talent pool of almost 7 million to draw from. Because we're the only show in town the top NZ players should also be cheaper than the top Australians. 

We need to focus on developing NZ players and it's insane that we only started doing it a couple of years ago.

Problem is if they get to Marco or Kosta's level they just get 'poached' by the bigger clubs.  I think there's been a lot of academy development in the last 10 years in NZ, just not by the Nix.  The better players have bypassed the Nix and those like Rufer et al have been okish but not quite good enough to make an impact in the A league just yet. So I guess it's about developing enough young kiwi players and getting them up to A league standard that you aren't as impacted by the 'elite' young players not being with the Nix like the current situation.

Not always necessarily a bad thing especially given our financial constraints. If we could become a feeder club, yes it would be frustrating, but it would also mean that we could then reinvest that in our first team squad quality or even our own academy. It would also make us a more attractive destination for other youth players if they could see the potential to develop here. 

I agree with this but I thought Ryan was saying that we needed kiwi youth talent to be able to compete as a consistent top 6 side into the future as it's harder for us to get quality aussie players than most of the aussie clubs?

Kind of, I wasn't saying it's hard for the Phoenix to get top Australian talent just that there is a lot of competition for it, if we just take population and ignore playing numbers then the A-League teams have a player catchment of 2.3 million per team. The Phoenix has a monopoly of 4.5 million + that 2.3 million that every team has.

It's not that it's any harder for the Phoenix to get top Australians, it's just that it's hard for every team. Whereas if we play our cards right we will get virtually no competition for the top NZ talent. 

Sure, the exceptional ones will go to get higher wages in Australian teams as foreigners, or will go overseas. But hopefully the club can profit from that. And that's no different from the smaller Australian clubs getting their players poached. In fact, there is an extra barrier that most Kiwis will be classed as foreigners in Australia so they have to be exceptional for that to happen and not a maybe.

Correct, which is why they will be harder for us to lure back unless we become the best option they have left (meaning, they may have "peaked"). You could argue that Kosta is back with us, as was (briefly) Smeltz, but Marco Rojas or Storm Roux won't be, precisely for that reason.

Storm Roux and Smeltz both hold Aussie citizenship....

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

what we need is someone, with a lot of time on their hands, to hang out around nix hq on thorndon quay to see who turns up for an interview.

bring back Horus. Isn't he the GOD of time?



Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

I call bullshark. Every time there's an A League manager job going names like this crop up, but they never actually get the role. 

The articles stem from a Val Migliaccio article about the Adelaide job. Of the A-League journos, he tends to have one of the lower hit rates.
Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

liberty_nz wrote:

Premiers - top of the league after regular season

Champions - winner of the finals series

Just plain wrong to say that ACFC haven't won anything. 

I'd be super stoked to be A-league premiers once for starters!



Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

I'd rather the incumbents, Ramon, Ryan, Jose, etc.

What style of football does psycho coach?

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

RR wrote:

I call bullshark. Every time there's an A League manager job going names like this crop up, but they never actually get the role. 

The articles stem from a Val Migliaccio article about the Adelaide job. Of the A-League journos, he tends to have one of the lower hit rates.

His son is a shark goalkeeper too.

Yellow Fever - Misery loves company

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

A manager with Premier League experience. Ambitious af.

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago · edited almost 9 years ago · History

Piney is tweeting it and Fox sports are also covering it. ? ??

Doing a bit of googling not only did he coach various age group teams but when he was manager of Man City in the PL he was also said to have relied on home grown talent rather than buying players and put a lot of attention on the academy system, so I can see why the Phoenix would be interested. 

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

Ryan wrote:

Piney is tweeting it and Fox sports are also covering it. ? ??

Doing a bit of googling not only did he coach various age group teams but when he was manager of Man City in the PL he was also said to have relied on home grown talent rather than buying players and put a lot of attention on the academy system, so I can see why the Phoenix would be interested. 

It's all smoke from the same fire - the Adelaide paper report.

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago · edited almost 9 years ago · History

A Tasman United board member told me he was an unsuccessful applicant for the Tasman United job - on cost on TU's part. I'd say there's a bit of fire here to go with the smoke.

Valley FC til I die?

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

And Phoenix saying it's bull according to Piney.

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

I would like to suggest the club needs a manager whom is a tactician and a disciplinarian or one whom gets in an assistant whom is one or the other. 

The players need to learn real fast that aiming for 6th is not an option. You want to be number 1 and a winner or bugger off if you want good wages just to play average. 

We are trying to keep ourselves in this league arnt we? Well if so, average and 6th are just not good enough or professional enough.

Proud to have attended the first 175 Consecutive "Home" Wellington Phoenix "A League" Games !!

The Ruf, The Ruf, The Ruf is on Fire!!

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

Doesn't really make sense that someone would be after a NZ Prem job (part-time at best) as an alternative to an A-League job.


Ramming liberal dribble down your throat since 2009
This forum needs less angst and more Kate Bush threads



Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago
Turned down by Tasman, didn't even get an interview at the Nix. Does Brooklyn Northern need a coach? (No offense to BNU.)

Ramming liberal dribble down your throat since 2009
This forum needs less angst and more Kate Bush threads



Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

Doloras wrote:

Turned down by Tasman, didn't even get an interview at the Nix. Does Brooklyn Northern need a coach? (No offense to BNU.)

Even Tasman did not like Pearce's coaching track record?  

At this rate we need to be careful we don't lose Des Buckingham to Notts Forest or to Man City.

Actually, getting outplayed quite a bit these days

Permalink Permalink
almost 9 years ago

Doloras wrote:

Doesn't really make sense that someone would be after a NZ Prem job (part-time at best) as an alternative to an A-League job.

The approach was before last season. TU only turned him down cos they couldn't come close to paying him.

Valley FC til I die?

Permalink Permalink

This topic is locked.