Wellington Phoenix Men

vs Sydney FC, 7.30pm Sat

790 replies · 45,726 views
about 13 years ago

Tegal wrote:

I was thinking it was a very harsh foul to give us to begin with, then almost went into shock when saw the referee point to the spot. You honestly saw it and thought penalty straight away? 


Honestly? Yes. I was actually surprised to see everyone complaining about it.
Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Wasn't the ball a mile away? It really just looked like 2 players that had run into each other. One heading toward the ball (dura), the other running into an opposition player (culina). Not that I'm saying we should have had a foul either, just that if you did have to blow your whistle it would be for a nix freekick.


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Feverish wrote:

Bring Back Brown



Hell no.

Then we will have both him & Brockie standing round the halfway line doing nothing.
Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History

Hard News wrote:

 My recollection is that it had gone out of playing distance.


Playing distance is ill-defined in the LotG, but guess the question is, could Culina have got to the ball first, and I would hazard that a fair answer to that is yes.
The other side of it also is that any contact from Culina is arguably incidental as caused by the initial aerial challenge. As it was from Durante until he used his arm to get Culina out of the way.
Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

 Even the Fox Sports 'experts' agreed that it was NOT a penalty, and I agree.

If you are old and wise you were probably young and stupid

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Playing distance is not well defined but would be interpreted to be that the ball must be within the ability of the player to reach out and touch it with any part of his body that can legally play the ball.

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Jeff Vader wrote:

Playing distance is not well defined but would be interpreted to be that the ball must be within the ability of the player to reach out and touch it with any part of his body that can legally play the ball.


Not necessarily, as players are allowed to protect possession of the ball if it's going out and can't reach it in the way you describe.
But that's all moot as the situation to me appears as incidental contact until Durante's arm intervenes.
Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Just re-watched it on mysky. Durante heads the ball away and Culina goes into Durantes path gives the appearance of pushing Culina because his arm goes around him but he does not actually push him. The obstruction was the first and only offence

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

el grapadura wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

Playing distance is not well defined but would be interpreted to be that the ball must be within the ability of the player to reach out and touch it with any part of his body that can legally play the ball.


Not necessarily, as players are allowed to protect possession of the ball if it's going out and can't reach it in the way you describe.
But that's all moot as the situation to me appears as incidental contact until Durante's arm intervenes.
No thats called poor policing of the law. Do not confuse the two.

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History

In fact Culina even plants two feet and dives to sell it.

Edit: Well plants his right foot and pushes off of that anyway.

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Sunday Shootout just showed footage of Ricki chipping a drink bottle into the wall in the dressing room in frustration during halftime. He cares.


Yellow Fever - Misery loves company

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History

Indeed if anything Culina obstructed Dura. As I recall it he had recently headed the ball in the opposite direction of Culina's run and was moving in that direction. Crazy penalty to my mind. I would be pissed about it but really it didn't matter. 

Although without that penalty it might have only been a record matching drubbing instead of a record breaking one.... Son of a

"Yellow Fever are fantastic – I have to say that"

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

patrick478 wrote:

Sunday Shootout just showed footage of Ricki chipping a drink bottle into the wall in the dressing room in frustration during halftime. He cares.


Shame he didn't do it in the dug out so everyone knew he was pissed off. I have noticed even at our last home game, he only gets out of his seat to get a new water bottle. Other A League coaches spend most of their time standing and shouting out instructions.
Now a question for you all. Why is it when ever we cross the ball into the box, any Phoenix players near the area always run to the front post and no one goes to the back post?
 I would have thought our two foward's had worked it out between them, who was going to do what in a situation. But no, they still run to the near post - when they can be arsed to run, that is.
Proud to have attended the first 175 Consecutive "Home" Wellington Phoenix "A League" Games !!

The Ruf, The Ruf, The Ruf is on Fire!!

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

noticed that a number of times, brockie and Stein both fighting for the same spot. I would have thought with 3 up front it would be simple, Fenton/Ifill to one post Stein to the middle and Brockie to the other post. Surely Greenie is coaching this???

Queenslander 3x a year.

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Leggy wrote:

el grapadura wrote:

Tegal wrote:

I think the referee is quite lucky that the penalty decision has been forgotten about. Haven't seen a penalty decision that bad for a long time,that I can recall. A real shocker. 


Why? Thought it was pretty fair.



Never a penalty.

 

... in a million years

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History

Leggy wrote:

 Even the Fox Sports 'experts' agreed that it was NOT a penalty, and I agree.


Bozza showed his typical Sydney bias and said it was.
Anyone who thinks that is a penalty is either biased , like Bosnich, or knows nothing about football.

a.haak

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

valeo wrote:

Leggy wrote:

 Even the Fox Sports 'experts' agreed that it was NOT a penalty, and I agree.


Bozza showed his typical Sydney bias and said it was.
Anyone who thinks that is a penalty is either biased , like Bosnich, or knows nothing about football.

El Grap knows quite a lot about football.
I like tautologies because I like them.
Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Cosimo wrote:

valeo wrote:

Leggy wrote:

 Even the Fox Sports 'experts' agreed that it was NOT a penalty, and I agree.


Bozza showed his typical Sydney bias and said it was.
Anyone who thinks that is a penalty is either biased , like Bosnich, or knows nothing about football.

El Grap knows quite a lot about football.
^ This.

Yellow Fever - Misery loves company

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

patrick478 wrote:

Sunday Shootout just showed footage of Ricki chipping a drink bottle into the wall in the dressing room in frustration during halftime. He cares.


Of course he cares. He cares about his salary, and the reputation he has. 

ive got a song that wont take long, Adelaide are rubbish.. the second verse is same as the first.. ADELAIDE ARE RUBBISH

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History

patrick478 wrote:

Sunday Shootout just showed footage of Ricki chipping a drink bottle into the wall in the dressing room in frustration during halftime. He cares.


Ah, so it IS him who tells the players to keep chipping the ball rather than hitting it with some purpose.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qe_B5CzbTJo - Caceres winning penalty v Perth - footage from the Fever Zone

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Steve-O wrote:

patrick478 wrote:

Sunday Shootout just showed footage of Ricki chipping a drink bottle into the wall in the dressing room in frustration during halftime. He cares.


Ah, so it IS him who tells the players to keep chipping the ball rather than hitting it with some purpose.


First funny comment you've ever made

a.haak

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

 And a good one Stevo

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Thank you, I'm here all week.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qe_B5CzbTJo - Caceres winning penalty v Perth - footage from the Fever Zone

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

 something is surely wrong at the phoenix

The squad looks unmotivated/ poorly coached...

Both the reserves and the first team squad cannot compete... YOu have to start asking questions now

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Really? I've not noticed it. I thought we've been fine so far...

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Bring back daniel


Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

patrick478 wrote:

Sunday Shootout just showed footage of Ricki chipping a drink bottle into the wall in the dressing room in frustration during halftime. He cares.

Did it miss the wall and go out for a throw in?
Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

I'm more interested in if there was a Phoenix player there wanting to play it and it went to anywhere but him. Too long? Too short? High and loopy? C'mon details here...

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

 

C'mon Phoenix what's going on. Talk to your fans. Media bans are archaic. 

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

tonya wrote:

 

C'mon Phoenix what's going on. Talk to your fans. Media bans are archaic. 


meh. 

"Phoenix till they lose"

Posting 97% bollox, 8% lies and 3.658% genuine opinion. 

Genuine opinion: FTFFA

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Royal wrote:

patrick478 wrote:

Sunday Shootout just showed footage of Ricki chipping a drink bottle into the wall in the dressing room in frustration during halftime. He cares.

Did it miss the wall and go out for a throw in?


The bottle was going nowhere, just like the ball on the field.
You could see dressing room at half time in one of those dodgy streams, oh boy, the Nix players looked pretty sad, heads down.
"Thanx for all ur support for those asking my ankles all good!yesterday was one of the toughest days of my career but I promise wel bounce bk" -- Paul Ifill 
Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago · edited about 13 years ago · History

Junior82 wrote:

*giggles*

Firstly, to the international audience watching, whilst you might think you look like a clever and ironic bunch of wits, in actual fact you far more closely resemble a bunch of ignorant hicks.


Humour bypass much?

And what's with the pic of Ernie?




We're the WELLINGTON Phoenix

And this is our Home

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

patrick478 wrote:

Sunday Shootout just showed footage of Ricki chipping a drink bottle into the wall in the dressing room in frustration during halftime. He cares.

Audio had "have you lost your $@#$%%^ bottle u lot?...well here it is."

A small town in Europe........looking to bounce straight back up....well that aint going to happen

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

tonya wrote:

 

C'mon Phoenix what's going on. Talk to your fans. Media bans are archaic. 


And this is part of problem - all we are getting is apathy; no action.

a.haak

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

At the very least they should be apologising to the fans and offering to refund tickets for anyone in the away section out of the players team funds.  

Normo's coming home

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

Boro4eva wrote:

patrick478 wrote:

Sunday Shootout just showed footage of Ricki chipping a drink bottle into the wall in the dressing room in frustration during halftime. He cares.

Audio had "have you lost your $@#$%%^ bottle u lot?...well here it is."

Actually, he stared into the camera as he walked past it for about 4 seconds, and then turned around and smashed the bottle, looks like it was as the players were about to walk back out onto the field.

Yellow Fever - Misery loves company

Permalink Permalink
about 13 years ago

james dean wrote:

At the very least they should be apologising to the fans and offering to refund tickets for anyone in the away section out of the players team funds.  

why? they got an eight goal thriller

Founder

Permalink Permalink