I think we absolutely cannot let Nathan go at this point. Even if we were to say get 1.5 million for him, it is highly unlikely we will find anyone in this transfer window to take his spot as attacking lynchpin. He is absolutely central to the system Ernie has got us playing, and I think there's a very high risk that any replacement would not fit into this system immediately. This is the season that we are closest to winning the league that we have ever been, and we don't want to compromise that by getting rid of our top scorer and maybe bringing someone else in who takes a couple of months to settle into the system. And I don't think we have anyone in the team right now who could step into Nathan's place.
If we have a great season, he scores a bag of goals, I'm sure there will be offers for him at the end of the season. He can invoke his buy-out clause and head overseas, we can (hopefully) have won the league or come close, and everybody's happy. So it does not make any sense to release him now.
Completely disagree re: we're being unreasonable. This is how negotiations work. They low ball us, we go much higher; then we meet in the middle. He's a player that is integral to our team and still under contract for another 1 1/2 years. If we let this club roll over us in regards to transfer fees, then we set a bad precedent going forward.
I agree with both valeo and with AMac.
Ernie did not just find a striker, he also got him to play to his system and for others to fit in around him. There's been a lot of work done by all concerned to get there, and I would like The Nix to reap some on-park benefit of this investment (let's win the damn league). While I perhaps sympathise with Burns thinking that he is denied a crack at a huge big pile of money being offered to him as salary by Shanghai, not many clubs were actively offering him that much when Ernie gave him a lifeline. Sorry, son, we bore the risk and we name the price.
To extend my argument, Burns is worth a lot more to us now than he would be a the end of this season, let alone next season. This is what we think the value of him to us is now - because this is how badly we want to win the league, to please the long-suffering Nix fans, and put some gate takings in our pocket (whatever's left after FFA takes it's cut).
Actually, getting outplayed quite a bit these days