Wellington Phoenix Men

Phoenix Transfer Speculation 2012/13

5729 replies · 274,865 views Locked
over 13 years ago

Colvinator wrote:

I will withdraw my support for the Phoenix for any period while David Beckham is playing. He may increase crowds, but if that is the reason for signing him, we could maybe sign Bono, who would probably increase crowds even more, and isn't much worse a footballer.



Boohoo. What a great supporter?????????????????????????

If you are old and wise you were probably young and stupid

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

tonya wrote:
 

"If it means playing away from Wellington, we will look at it.  

A cracker for any good will people may have.

A fan is a fan.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

yellowsite wrote:

tonya wrote:
 

"If it means playing away from Wellington, we will look at it.  

A cracker for any good will people may have.



I've kicked off some proper angst in the Angst thread.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Right.

A fan is a fan.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Jeff Vader wrote:
I'm surprised no one has really done that with ADP and he is having a field day. Surely coaches have woken up to that (or is he just too good)


Muscat. Round 1.

How's my driving? - Whine here

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

tonya wrote:

 

ex herald

We are extremely concerned,'' Dome said. "There's no doubt the crowds outside the first game with Del Piero have been poor. It's not sustainable. At the moment, Wellington is saying to us that football in the capital is not a sustainable business model.

"If it means playing away from Wellington, we will look at it. If it means more money to buy players, we will do that. It's all up for grabs.''

Can't believe Dome said this - don't they get it. Start winning and seriously challenge for top two. Crowds 10,000 plus easy. Wellington is saying to us that it will no longer accept a mediocre campaign, which includes a late run to scrape into the top 6. They want to win this thing, and with the exception of the opening game and last weekend, Herbert and his side have been mediocre. 

 

 

I know this is going to crank up some in the Nix angst circle but isn't there a case for making the Phoenix a NZ team rather than a Wellington side? The team could be based in Wellington but play say three times in Christchurch, three times in Auckland, once in Dunedin and the rest in Windy City.  This would ensure fans in any particular centre don't become indifferent. Crowds of only 6,000 odd at Westpac stadium are no good. You've had higher crowds in both CHCH and Auckland than in most regular season Wellington games. I think Auckland holds the record for a regular season game (20,000)??? There's a real novelty value that attracts fans when the team's only into town for a few games. The Warriors became the NZ Warriors and the Breakers are the NZ Breakers. So why not the NZ Phoenix? Tour the team around the country and fill it with NZ talent.

Rather than Beckham why not spend that sort of money and bring Nelsen over for a season - it would certainly shore up your defence?

 

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

The Warriors and Breakers play all their home games in Auckland?

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

So a guy from the knitting circle that says the phoenix single handedly destroy TW crowds, now wants to take the team around the country to do the same to all other ASBP crowds? Make your mind up.


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Jeff Vader wrote:

[/quote]If some one did come along and got an A-League team for Auckland, what would they need to do to get the support from the fans of Auckland City & Waitakere?
[/quote] With due respect to the Phoenix and the current environment, there is no way in hell ACFC fans will ever support an A League side. Its not in their interests too. If it was, they would be behind the Phoenix wholeheartedly

 

I think you'll find many ACFC supporters were also Kingz/Knights supporters in earlier times. Real football fans JV actually like attending football games. I'll happily watch other ASB Premiership games. You should try it one day.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Tegal wrote:

So a guy from the knitting circle that says the phoenix single handedly destroy TW crowds, now wants to take the team around the country to do the same to all other ASBP crowds? Make your mind up.

NZF indifference to its own national league and the lack of any promotion/tv coverage has hurt ASBP crowds. The Nix playing a couple of games in Auckland is not going to sap the support from ACFC. We have a very loyal fan base, so does Canterbury United and Hawkes Bay United. The rest of the ASBP teams attract very few spectators so it wouldn't be an issue. The same is not true, unfortunately, for Team Wellington, who have largely seen their fan base biodegrade over the years. The Phoenix hogging all the limelight in Wellington has clearly played a part in that.

Get the Phoenix out of town a bit more often and all those so-called Wellington football fans who only turn up when the planets are aligned might just pop down to Dave Farrington Park. Just a thought.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago · edited over 13 years ago · History

Do we really think that the FFA will aid us, a Kiwi team, in getting Beckham's signature?
Talk about being fair and equal all you want but I struggle to believe the FFA will help us over an opposing Aussie club.
Unless we really put some cash into it.
SELL THE HURRICANES!!


 

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

tonya wrote:

ex herald

We are extremely concerned,'' Dome said. "There's no doubt the crowds outside the first game with Del Piero have been poor. It's not sustainable. At the moment, Wellington is saying to us that football in the capital is not a sustainable business model.

"If it means playing away from Wellington, we will look at it. If it means more money to buy players, we will do that. It's all up for grabs.''

Can't believe Dome said this - don't they get it. Start winning and seriously challenge for top two. Crowds 10,000 plus easy. Wellington is saying to us that it will no longer accept a mediocre campaign, which includes a late run to scrape into the top 6. They want to win this thing, and with the exception of the opening game and last weekend, Herbert and his side have been mediocre. 



Completely agree.

Surely this is Wellington saying they will no longer accept horrible boring games such as those against Brisbane and CCM, 2 of our 3 home games this season?

We don't have a right back and we are crying out for a central midfielder at the very least (regardless of whether it's Beckham) and only NOW are they talking about spending some money on players?

If they could get Beckham they'd AT LEAST double crowds IMO.  However, it's what happens after that is important.  Back to the same old and we'll be here in a year's time saying the same things.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qe_B5CzbTJo - Caceres winning penalty v Perth - footage from the Fever Zone

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Trueblue wrote:

Tegal wrote:

So a guy from the knitting circle that says the phoenix single handedly destroy TW crowds, now wants to take the team around the country to do the same to all other ASBP crowds? Make your mind up.

NZF indifference to its own national league and the lack of any promotion/tv coverage has hurt ASBP crowds. The Nix playing a couple of games in Auckland is not going to sap the support from ACFC. We have a very loyal fan base, so does Canterbury United and Hawkes Bay United. The rest of the ASBP teams attract very few spectators so it wouldn't be an issue. The same is not true, unfortunately, for Team Wellington, who have largely seen their fan base biodegrade over the years. The Phoenix hogging all the limelight in Wellington has clearly played a part in that.

Get the Phoenix out of town a bit more often and all those so-called Wellington football fans who only turn up when the planets are aligned might just pop down to Dave Farrington Park. Just a thought.



Dave Farrington Park is a pain in the arse to get to, and the TW games are not that great any time I've seen them (bar that time Fifi scored an overhead kick).  That's why people don't go.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qe_B5CzbTJo - Caceres winning penalty v Perth - footage from the Fever Zone

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Steve-O wrote:

Trueblue wrote:

Tegal wrote:

So a guy from the knitting circle that says the phoenix single handedly destroy TW crowds, now wants to take the team around the country to do the same to all other ASBP crowds? Make your mind up.

NZF indifference to its own national league and the lack of any promotion/tv coverage has hurt ASBP crowds. The Nix playing a couple of games in Auckland is not going to sap the support from ACFC. We have a very loyal fan base, so does Canterbury United and Hawkes Bay United. The rest of the ASBP teams attract very few spectators so it wouldn't be an issue. The same is not true, unfortunately, for Team Wellington, who have largely seen their fan base biodegrade over the years. The Phoenix hogging all the limelight in Wellington has clearly played a part in that.

Get the Phoenix out of town a bit more often and all those so-called Wellington football fans who only turn up when the planets are aligned might just pop down to Dave Farrington Park. Just a thought.



Dave Farrington Park is a pain in the arse to get to, and the TW games are not that great any time I've seen them (bar that time Fifi scored an overhead kick).  That's why people don't go.

I think T_X had a good take on the difference between TW and the Nix games.  
We've been to a handful of games and it's always like a bit of a "chill out and enjoy the footy" day (and the occasional red card...Mr Sutherland).  Definitely not 90 mins 90 emotions, stuff.  It's a nice family day out, and I wouldn't even think of yelling out rude words, even to those blue lads from oop north.
And as I have posted before, if we hadn't been supporting the Nix, we'd never have even thought about going to watch TW.
BUT I do like their sausage sizzle (for true).

"Phoenix till they lose"

Posting 97% bollox, 8% lies and 3.658% genuine opinion. 

Genuine opinion: FTFFA

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Steve-O wrote:


We don't have a right back and we are crying out for a central midfielder at the very least (regardless of whether it's Beckham) and only NOW are they talking about spending some money on players?

If they could get Beckham they'd AT LEAST double crowds IMO.  However, it's what happens after that is important.  Back to the same old and we'll be here in a year's time saying the same things.

Can hardly blame Leo for crowds of 6,000. I reckon hes done bloody well. Maybe we actually try and win our home games and entertain the crowd would do better for the number? I mean its not the Premier League is it - go out there and play some entertaining football. There no relegation to worry about.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Steve-O wrote:

tonya wrote:

ex herald

We are extremely concerned,'' Dome said. "There's no doubt the crowds outside the first game with Del Piero have been poor. It's not sustainable. At the moment, Wellington is saying to us that football in the capital is not a sustainable business model.

"If it means playing away from Wellington, we will look at it. If it means more money to buy players, we will do that. It's all up for grabs.''

Can't believe Dome said this - don't they get it. Start winning and seriously challenge for top two. Crowds 10,000 plus easy. Wellington is saying to us that it will no longer accept a mediocre campaign, which includes a late run to scrape into the top 6. They want to win this thing, and with the exception of the opening game and last weekend, Herbert and his side have been mediocre. 



Completely agree.

Surely this is Wellington saying they will no longer accept horrible boring games such as those against Brisbane and CCM, 2 of our 3 home games this season?

We don't have a right back and we are crying out for a central midfielder at the very least (regardless of whether it's Beckham) and only NOW are they talking about spending some money on players?

If they could get Beckham they'd AT LEAST double crowds IMO.  However, it's what happens after that is important.  Back to the same old and we'll be here in a year's time saying the same things.

Exactly - surely before they start taking games elsewhere they should look at the onfield product and ask themselves some hard questions on the direction of the club

Normo's coming home

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

My two cents worth..Who ever gets Beckham  gets a three ring circus, pure and simple. In some ways a big distraction from the League and the game but other ways bringing a whole other level of attention. If there's a circus I'd like it to be OUR circus.

Won't sort the inadequacies of our current line up, could just distract us for a while and inspire some effort from the team  and bring in the hangers-on spectators and the "it" crowd ...." oh, we've always loved the Phoenix!"  ...while the spotlights shining bright.

More consistent performances, ( like Sunday's in Newcastle) will indeed bring the crowds back. More importantly, the whole relationship between the team, their owners, management and the fans who support them ought to be about accountability, passion, respect, and dedication,which builds and strengthens over time.Threats of taking matches elsewhere have no place in this arrangement.

 We the fans commit to be here when you're playing here..it really matters.We expect you the players to turn up for the game like it really matters too. 




  Improving,,on the up, a work in progress from Italiano and the Nix. Bring on the bathroom bling in '24! COYN!

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

asmodeus_82 wrote:

So grinds the rumor mill, breaking down harvested tweets into baseless speculation.


Maybe I'm not sober, but this seems quite poignant and reflective
Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Steve-O wrote:
Completely agree.

Surely this is Wellington saying they will no longer accept horrible boring games such as those against Brisbane and CCM, 2 of our 3 home games this season?

We don't have a right back and we are crying out for a central midfielder at the very least (regardless of whether it's Beckham) and only NOW are they talking about spending some money on players?

If they could get Beckham they'd AT LEAST double crowds IMO.  However, it's what happens after that is important.  Back to the same old and we'll be here in a year's time saying the same things.
 

GTFO, I've been critical of Leo in the past, but saying we don't have good crowds has anything to do with his performance at RB this season is borderline retarded.
He wasn't great in the MV game but otherwise he's been one of our best and most consistent players.
Beckham would draw crowds of course. 
Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

more talk of getting in another player to replace Pavlovic


Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago


From one of the lingering rumours of the off season, turns out Robert Earnshaw ended up in Tel Aviv. Did we know that already?

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/20397113

He doesn't seem the happiest, what with the place being bombed and all. Also, he's injured.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Trueblue wrote:

Tegal wrote:

So a guy from the knitting circle that says the phoenix single handedly destroy TW crowds, now wants to take the team around the country to do the same to all other ASBP crowds? Make your mind up.

NZF indifference to its own national league and the lack of any promotion/tv coverage has hurt ASBP crowds. The Nix playing a couple of games in Auckland is not going to sap the support from ACFC. We have a very loyal fan base, so does Canterbury United and Hawkes Bay United. The rest of the ASBP teams attract very few spectators so it wouldn't be an issue. The same is not true, unfortunately, for Team Wellington, who have largely seen their fan base biodegrade over the years. The Phoenix hogging all the limelight in Wellington has clearly played a part in that.

Get the Phoenix out of town a bit more often and all those so-called Wellington football fans who only turn up when the planets are aligned might just pop down to Dave Farrington Park. Just a thought.

I have to laugh. I'm regularly at Kiwitea and Fred Taylor


God you talk bollocks. The onfield product is horrible. The one time we get a regular league game on TV, it was insipid crap football - certainly nothing to ATTRACT fans to go watch. By reflection, your team of imports play a lot better but if its only one team, how does this help to grow the league, as you stated a couple of pages back? The TW v Canty game was completely fucking awful and backs the point that if you want fans (both for Phoenix and ASB games) make the product worth watching, not find a new location to play it at.

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

To further prove the theory, why did the Auckland based franchise get shit crowds for the HAL in the largest city in the country? Cause the on field product was crap. Yet your crowds stayed strong and consistent. Must have had a bastardising effect that HAL team.

And again to prove the theory, when the Phoenix came to town last year they got.... 20k? On field product, 3rd and final answer.

Whine about NZF and the marketing of the ASB league all you like. It's awful to watch (and run mickey mouse too if you can have a team of only 4 Kiwis) and much like the Black Caps, no one watches a shit product regardless where you play it or screen it.

Grumpy old bastard alert

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Jeff Vader wrote:

Trueblue wrote:

Tegal wrote:

So a guy from the knitting circle that says the phoenix single handedly destroy TW crowds, now wants to take the team around the country to do the same to all other ASBP crowds? Make your mind up.

NZF indifference to its own national league and the lack of any promotion/tv coverage has hurt ASBP crowds. The Nix playing a couple of games in Auckland is not going to sap the support from ACFC. We have a very loyal fan base, so does Canterbury United and Hawkes Bay United. The rest of the ASBP teams attract very few spectators so it wouldn't be an issue. The same is not true, unfortunately, for Team Wellington, who have largely seen their fan base biodegrade over the years. The Phoenix hogging all the limelight in Wellington has clearly played a part in that.

Get the Phoenix out of town a bit more often and all those so-called Wellington football fans who only turn up when the planets are aligned might just pop down to Dave Farrington Park. Just a thought.

I have to laugh. I'm regularly at Kiwitea and Fred Taylor


God you talk bollocks. The onfield product is horrible. The one time we get a regular league game on TV, it was insipid crap football - certainly nothing to ATTRACT fans to go watch. By reflection, your team of imports play a lot better but if its only one team, how does this help to grow the league, as you stated a couple of pages back? The TW v Canty game was completely fucking awful and backs the point that if you want fans (both for Phoenix and ASB games) make the product worth watching, not find a new location to play it at.

 

To call ASBP football "insipid crap" is pretty insulting to all the players involved and shows a complete lack of perspective. You seem to be too bitter and twisted to appreciate what's in front of you. I bet you're fun.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Trueblue wrote:
I know this is going to crank up some in the Nix angst circle but isn't there a case for making the Phoenix a NZ team rather than a Wellington side? The team could be based in Wellington but play say three times in Christchurch, three times in Auckland, once in Dunedin and the rest in Windy City.  This would ensure fans in any particular centre don't become indifferent. Crowds of only 6,000 odd at Westpac stadium are no good. You've had higher crowds in both CHCH and Auckland than in most regular season Wellington games. I think Auckland holds the record for a regular season game (20,000)??? There's a real novelty value that attracts fans when the team's only into town for a few games. The Warriors became the NZ Warriors and the Breakers are the NZ Breakers. So why not the NZ Phoenix? Tour the team around the country and fill it with NZ talent.

Rather than Beckham why not spend that sort of money and bring Nelsen over for a season - it would certainly shore up your defence?



What a brilliant idea! Yeah - lets make 6 more of our home games 'home away' games.

Then .. the owners can have the fun of:

1. Paying more for the use of a different stadium (surely no discount for only 3 games .. right?)
2. Paying to fly all of the players up to AKL / down to CHCH.
3. Paying for accommodation/transport etc. etc.
4. *Possibly* not having as many sponsors (which city do you play in?).
5. Maybe not having as many WLG based season ticket holders (seriously - 6 games a year at 'home home').
6. Halving the income from those WLG season ticket holders (I don't want to pay for 6 games 'away home')
7. 3 Game season Tickets in AKL / CHCH ... Why bother?
8. Not actually having a home advantage for 50% of your 'home' games.
9. Watching the crowds dissipate after the first awful game in AKL or CHCH
10. The 'away home' crowds having no connection to a team from 'Wellington' when it gets tough

Increasing the season ticket membership is the only way that the owners are going to consistently break even or, god forbid make a profit. Crowds are fickle and they always will be. Unless you have a reason to support a team that trumps anything else that's going on in your life, then guaranteeing punters will turn up to a game is at best a marginal likelihood. It's even less likely if they're not a team from your city.

The question then remains - how do you increase your core fan base (e.g: Season ticket holders) ... you sure as sh*t don't do that by taking half of your home games and playing them somewhere else. That's a Circus ... and a Circus only turns up once a year.

If it is a traveling Circus you're after then you should think long and hard about that.

AKL already f*(ked that up with the 'Oceania All Stars'



Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

I guess the truth hurts huh true blue, Vader is right though, the few TW games I've seen have been bloody aweful in comparison to the worst A-league games. The facilities are average the tactics are dull, and the skill level is pretty poor. If the league was of better quality then the fans would come, sadly the shite we get fed each week in the ASBP is not worth paying for.

Queenslander 3x a year.

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Jeff Vader wrote:

To further prove the theory, why did the Auckland based franchise get shit crowds for the HAL in the largest city in the country? Cause the on field product was crap. Yet your crowds stayed strong and consistent. Must have had a bastardising effect that HAL team.

And again to prove the theory, when the Phoenix came to town last year they got.... 20k? On field product, 3rd and final answer.

Whine about NZF and the marketing of the ASB league all you like. It's awful to watch (and run mickey mouse too if you can have a team of only 4 Kiwis) and much like the Black Caps, no one watches a shit product regardless where you play it or screen it.


also not a walk from a central bar district at North Shore- pain in the arse drive and you had to take a car. 20 k at Eden park with a lot of advertising, freebies and novelty value- lots of folk who wouldn't normally go to the football went cos it was the only show in town and to have a look see- sat next to a family who were talking about the Breakers at that game, but didn't know any of the phoenix players...


Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

playwithFire wrote:

more talk of getting in another player to replace Pavlovic

Wonder if they are looking local or someone from the state leagues.
Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

feel like we could use with someone a bit more proven than Boyd to come off the bench with a bit of xfactor. Also a chance for us to take a bit of a risk.. Knowing Ricki, the guy will have A-League experience.

So anyone pick out any half decent strikers in state league with a bit of histroy in the league?


Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

I'd like to see someone with a bit of strength in the air and presence in the box - even if they weren't a genuine goal scorer.  Must be able to play back to goal

Normo's coming home

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

james dean wrote:

I'd like to see someone with a bit of strength in the air and presence in the box - even if they weren't a genuine goal scorer.  Must be able to play back to goal


Someone like Billy Mehmet wouldve been good, dont know why Ricki didnt like him when he trialled with us
Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

james dean wrote:

I'd like to see someone with a bit of strength in the air and presence in the box - even if they weren't a genuine goal scorer.  Must be able to play back to goal



Chris Greenacre then?

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

A chap at the Jests might be keen - hasn't been paid for a month it seems.


"Phoenix till they lose"

Posting 97% bollox, 8% lies and 3.658% genuine opinion. 

Genuine opinion: FTFFA

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

james dean wrote:

I'd like to see someone with a bit of strength in the air and presence in the box - even if they weren't a genuine goal scorer.  Must be able to play back to goal

Chris Wood?


Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

playwithFire wrote:

james dean wrote:

I'd like to see someone with a bit of strength in the air and presence in the box - even if they weren't a genuine goal scorer.  Must be able to play back to goal

Chris Wood?
Chris Killen?

I think Smith showed against the Jets that he could provided most of what james dean is wanting, but did it a bit deeper than a striker would. He isn't a striker but playing just in behind the one man up front, he can do that role and also provide the late runs into the box.
Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

AJ13 wrote:

james dean wrote:

I'd like to see someone with a bit of strength in the air and presence in the box - even if they weren't a genuine goal scorer.  Must be able to play back to goal


Someone like Billy Mehmet wouldve been good, dont know why Ricki didnt like him when he trialled with us

Didn't meet our no cocks policy

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago · edited over 13 years ago · History

james dean wrote:

I'd like to see someone with a bit of strength in the air and presence in the box - even if they weren't a genuine goal scorer.  Must be able to play back to goal

 

hang on. Weren't you complaining about the product we are selling on the field? If so, then how does a target man improve that?

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

2ndBest wrote:

AJ13 wrote:

james dean wrote:

I'd like to see someone with a bit of strength in the air and presence in the box - even if they weren't a genuine goal scorer.  Must be able to play back to goal


Someone like Billy Mehmet wouldve been good, dont know why Ricki didnt like him when he trialled with us

Didn't meet our no cocks policy

Didn't we kind of throw that out the window with our mascot?


Allegedly

Permalink Permalink
over 13 years ago

Tegal wrote:

2ndBest wrote:

AJ13 wrote:

james dean wrote:
I'd like to see someone with a bit of strength in the air and presence in the box - even if they weren't a genuine goal scorer.  Must be able to play back to goal

Someone like Billy Mehmet wouldve been good, dont know why Ricki didnt like him when he trialled with us

Didn't meet our no cocks policy

Didn't we kind of throw that out the window with our mascot?

Sooo much this.

Permalink Permalink

This topic is locked.